Religion's value questioned

Pakeha said:
Code:
Fr. Jose Oscar Beozzo, who directs the Center for Evangelizing Services and Popular Education in São Paulo, told NCR May 10 that between 1980 and 2000, the percentage of the Brazilian population that identifies itself as “Protestant,” with most of that number being Pentecostal, rose from 12 to 17 percent. Over the same period, Beozzo said, the percentage who say they have no religious affiliation went from 0.7 percent to 7.3 percent, a ten-fold increase. ...

Now that could be a good sign of what's going on in society, because it could indicate that more Brazilians are experiencing the higher standard of living, including access to better healthcare, and the higher education levels that tend to be a precursor to abandonment of faith. It may be that the fact that most of those who've abandoned their faith live in urban areas is significant, because people are more likely to have access to healthcare facilities there, as well as the cosmopolitan influences that might make them think more about their traditions. But Brazil is apparently one of the countries with the biggest wealth inequality in the world. People apparently live like Westerners not too far from people living in abject poverty in the slums. For a big increase in abandonment of religion to happen, wealth inequalities will probably have to be reduced to the point where a large percentage of the country has Western living standards.

On the other hand, the figures could partly reflect the large number of immigrants Brazil apparently tends to have, many of them Western.

The Christianity in Brazil has tended to be in reality a mixture of Christianity and spirit worship of various kinds that comes from the traditions of the Africans that were brought there as slaves, natives to Brazil before the Portuguese arrived, and European folk beliefs. See this article, for instance. For some reason, the statistics differ a little from the ones you've found, but the truth probably lies somewhere within that region:

Eighty-nine percent of Brazilians are Roman Catholic. Other Brazilians subscribe to various forms of Protestantism. There are also very small Islamic and Jewish communities in the country. Many Brazilians who subscribe to one of the mainline religions also practice other religious traditions, including Spiritism, Candomblé, Macumba, Umbanda, or Santería. These religious practices are informed by Christianity and traditional African and Amerindian religious ceremonies.

Hopefully if they're giving up religion it means they're giving up those practices too, rather than keeping them and just giving up mainstream religion. Perhaps a mixture of both is going on. Rejecting spirit worship would at least mean they weren't open to being defrauded by people claiming to be psychic any more, and may mean their standards of living are improving. It seems many still look to spirits for the protection modernisation would give them with greater technology and healthcare:

Two other major Brazilian festivals are Carnaval, a huge, nationwide, annual celebration that takes place the week before Lent, and Festa do Iemenja, a solemn ceremony held on New Year's Eve. The Festa do Iemenja, dedicated to the "Queen of the Sea," is a major rite in Rio de Janeiro and Bahia. Flowers, perfumes, fruits, and even jewelry are tossed into the sea to please the mother of the waters and gain her protection for a new year.
 
Last edited:
It will be interesting to see where this actually takes the country or if it has any meaningful impact on the country's development.

It is no surprise that "one can find elements of secularization on university campuses and in more middle- and upper-class segments of urban society in Brazil". Atheism is a luxury that is not easily available to everybody, but only to those who do not need to believe because they are not in control of their lives and their other needs aren't satisfied.

That "increasing numbers of Brazilian poor" are losing their religion could be due to their faith in Lula, i.e. he may, with or without cause, have made them believe that it is possible to improve conditions of life in a secular manner.

I notice that BN does not approve of ”spirit worship” but seems to subscribe to the traditional Christian distinction between the Holy Spirit and all the other inferior spirits. Maybe she hasn’t found any testimonies from worshippers of Candomblé or Santeria. In Cuba the latter more or less replaced the former in the bad times since 1990 – in spite of universal healthcare.

It is a little peculiar to notice her apparent belief in the "the protection (!) modernisation (!) would give them with greater (!) technology" - as if the capitalist introduction of "greater technology" is not often the precursor of unemployment and thus uncertain conditions of life and the need to believe.

The lack of ”spirit worship” in Denmark, by the way, does not seem to make people less ”open to being defrauded by people claiming to be psychic”. Cuban Elegguá or Yemaya worshippers aren’t any worse than than Danish Christians in this respect, I think, but they lack the religious intolerance of Christians (and their music is so much better!).
 
Dann said:
I notice that BN does not approve of ”spirit worship” but seems to subscribe to the traditional Christian distinction between the Holy Spirit and all the other inferior spirits. Maybe she hasn’t found any testimonies from worshippers of Candomblé or Santeria. In Cuba the latter more or less replaced the former in the bad times since 1990 – in spite of universal healthcare.

It is a little peculiar to notice her apparent belief in the "the protection (!) modernisation (!) would give them with greater (!) technology" - as if the capitalist introduction of "greater technology" is not often the precursor of unemployment and thus uncertain conditions of life and the need to believe.

Poor Dann, you just can't resist goading me into responding to you, can you. :) No matter how many "ass-whoopings" you take - crikey, I'm beginning to learn how to speak like a local of this place now! - anyway, no matter how many you let yourself in for, you still just keep coming back for more! Perhaps that's because you seem to manage to anaesthetize yourself from them, probably by not reading them. It seems lots of people are though. Since this thread has become lless civilised, it's recieved hundreds of hits! Masses more than it ever used to get. Obviously people like a good flame war. :) If only you could be more creative in your flaming though! You'd be more impressive if you could produce a real clever zinger, instead of the lame attempts at mockery you've been using up until now!

If I considered you a worthy opponent, I'd give you a sensible answer to your comments. Unfortunately, I have discovered that you are not one, and thus you are not worth engaging in serious debate or giving thoughtful explanations to.

In fact, so disgruntled have I been with your poor performance, both on the flaming and on the debating fronts, that I even felt obliged to complain about you to a curmudgeonly rambunctious militant old atheist from Scotland I debated with for some time before I came here. He used to annoy me sometimes, but I compared him rather favourably with you in my post to him about you, because he did at least put forward arguments that had some quality of intelligence about them, as well as his posts sometimes having a compassionate feel, which had rather more of an authentic feel about them than your comments, that can seem compassionate on the surface but turn out to be inflexible dogmatism upon familiarisation. Here's the thread he started that I complained about you in: Could Noah's Flood have happened? Science says so. ... Are you straining every fibre of your intellect to try to work out how in the world a rabid militant atheist could possibly start a thread with a title like that? You'll have to go there if you want to find out. (It could be something to do with fish hooks, of course.) You will see fully demonstrated if you go there, the utter difference in the quality of argument put forward by you and him. The quality of his is just so much more intelligent!

I call myself Meme Virus on that forum. My post about you is post 8. In fact, it's the last one in the thread. Admittedly, I should have been more charitable in the language I used about you. If only I'd have been following the instructions of Jesus, that great ubermoderator of the world, who said it was against the rules of the Christian Membership Agreement and a terrible thing to use language like that to describe someone, then I wouldn't have used it. Unfortunately, due to a lapse in my powers of self-discipline, I disobeyed the great ubermoderator, and did use it. You see, you'll be able to tell right there that there are advantages in having people look up to that great ubermoderator after all. You will perhaps realise upon personally encountering the consequences for you yourself of disobedience to him that Your wish to have him banished from the thoughts of all mankind is misguided.

Unfortunately, Jesus the Great Ubermoderator said nothing about going off-topic on Internet forums, and thus I was not inhibited from doing so on that one, and my post to Mr Militant Atheist about you had nothing to do with Noah's Flood. But never mind; they aren't so strict there, and there were several other posts there that were on-topic. Perhaps Jesus the Great Ubermoderator didn't mind people going off-topic on Internet forums too much, and thus he didn't mention it. Or perhaps his failure to do so is proof that those who dismiss him as an irrelevance or someone who in reality had no special powers of prophecy are correct. :)

Or perhaps he didn't mention it because no one knew what Internet forums were then so they wouldn't have understood a word he said. :)

Anyway, if anyone actually wants to know my answers to the points Dann made about my attitude - I'm sure he doesn't himself but is just attempting to savour a "gotcha" moment - then just ask me. There are in fact answers to both of the points he made in my quote from him at the beginning of this post that may be extremely obvious to anyone who's been following what I've said in this thread. He obviously hasn't. :)
 
Thanks for the insights about Brazil.
An interesting reference to the Flood story in that link posted in the previous post, though I don't understand what it has to do with the topic of this thread.
 
Well, BM is not too concerned about derailing threads - in this forum or in others, apparently.
 
Not so: I have an extremely relevant point to make, and here it is:

As I was saying, my old belligerent militant atheist sparring partner's attitude was so much more intelligent and empathetic towards people's suffering than yours. Admittedly, when he erupted into a flame, his intelligence and compassion faded away instantly like a cake in the clutches of a greedy child! But when he was on form, his style was just so, so much more thoughtful and compassionate than yours! Unfortunately paranoid and bigoted, he believed religion to be an entirely dangerous phenomenon that was only followed by irrational brain-impaired people. Yet if you'd asked him what religion's value was on a good day, he might have tried to give a thoughtful answer that was prepared to admit it wasn't entirely a terrible thing.

He might, for instance, have said that although he didn't believe religion had any value in itself, it could be valuable to work with people within the framework of their spiritual beliefs. For instance, he claimed to be a doctor who'd worked for a while in Africa. He said when he was doing that, he didn't tell the local spiritual healer-types around him that their medicine was quackery and his was vastly superior. He said he called his own medicine a form of magic so he'd be using concepts they'd understand, and he tried to recruit them to work alongside him in delivering it. (Or something like that - I can't remember the exact details of what he said now.)

(I know some African doctors would disagree with that approach, not believing witch-doctor types should be trained to practice modern medicine because they might mix it with the kinds of strange things they used to do).

But it may be that even my old belligerent militant atheist debate combatant, in a similar way to the way he said he thought the services of those African healer-types could be turned to good use, would agree that Christianity was making a valuable contribution when he read about gangsters and other criminals who found new motivation to give up violent lifestyles because they found Christianity to be inspiring.

And if even he could do that, what does it say about you that all you do is mock the idea in a repulsive and feebly stupid display of lack of empathy? There's just a massive difference in class between you and him!

If you tried to put your brains to work more, you could have done what seems to me to be obvious for someone holding your viewpoint and seized the opportunity to proclaim that the testimonies were more proof of Marx's assertion that people believe in religion because conditions in society aren't ideal. You could have merrily argued that in an ideal society, where not only poverty itself but also violence and other kinds of crime were much reduced because of superior living conditions, people wouldn't feel the need to find inspiration in Christianity. Thus you could have argued that the testimonies were just illustrative of a step on the way to progress. You could have argued that such conversions might be necessary now because societies aren't ideal; but when they are, such conversions will no longer be necessary.

If Marx was somehow resurrected and I was arguing with him, rather than his pale shadow of a representative in the form of you, he might have said something quite similar to that, and greeted what I said with more favour than the likes of some of his followers like you have. Perhaps he would have been more open-minded, and would prove his ideas to be more complex than the mere attempts to wave the issues away and brush them under the carpet that you have greeted the stories with. Perhaps he would have reprimanded you for your callous simplistic protests, and urged you to listen to him and take a more thoughtful view like him.
 
Oh how cool is that!! I've just discovered Dann's edited the tags for this thread, or ordered someone else to, and lo and behold, he seems to be advertising the self-help series I link to parts of in my signature, or something else on the website they're on that he hasn't actually had the thought to mention, for he obviously looked at one or more of the articles and found the name of the author at the top.

The new tags for this thread:

Baby Nemesis, Christian zealots, Diana Holbourn, opium of the people, value of religion

How sweet of him to mention my name in the new tags, implying that this thread's now all about Me! :p

Now why he mentions Christian zealots is something only known to him. But look at this!

Here are links to the self-help articles he seems to want this thread to be all about now, even though they have nothing to do with religion. Still I will bemusedly oblige him by doing what he could be hinting he wants, and elaborate on what they're about:

Overcoming Depression and Worry

By Diana Holbourn

The Main Contents

1. The Causes of Depression
• When the Brain Doesn't Seem to Work
• Why Depressed People can Wake Up So Tired and Unmotivated
• The Problems with the Kinds of Worries Depressed People Tend to Have
• Getting a More Refreshing Sleep

2. Relaxation Exercises

3. Stopping Ourselves Worrying and Thinking the Worst

4. Finding Things to Amuse us

5. When Things Remind us of Bad Things in the Past
• How to Turn Fear of Failure into Anticipation of Success

6. Handling Other People's Negative Criticisms of us

7. How Some Drugs, Food, Exercise and Alcohol can Affect our Mood
• Some Prescription Drugs can Cause Depression
• Exercise Can Help Lift the Mood
• Food that Can Help Lift the Mood
• Alcohol Can Make Depression Worse

8. What to Do when Grieving Causes Depression

9. Getting Emotional Needs Met
• The Emotional Needs we Have
• Working Out What Needs Aren't Being Met
• Changing Things Little by Little

10. Encouraging Ourselves by Thinking about Past Achievements

11. For Anyone who Wants to Withdraw from Anti-Depressants

12. What to Do when we Start to Feel Down Again After we've Recovered from Depression

(I'd like to point out that by saying "we", the author isn't referring to herself, as the introduction makes clear. Yet another of the evening's conundrums, along with the one about why Dann apparently wants this stuff promoted even though it doesn't relate to the thread topic! :p ... Well, if he put the name in the tags for a different reason, he should have explained what the reason was. He really isn't good at explaining himself!

Anyway, on to article two - the second one I link to in my signature. I'd like to thank Dann once again for hinting that he wants this stuff promoted, even though it will cause one great bout of thread drift:

Improving a Marriage Instead of Getting a Divorce

By Diana Holbourn

The Main Contents

1. Blaming, Holding Grudges and Forgiving
• One or Two Things That Can Make Forgiving Easier
• A Few Qualities of Genuine and Fake Forgiveness
• Ways of Going About Forgiving

2. Some Ways of Controlling Anger
• The Importance of Not Burying Anger
• Talking Over the Real Problem Rather Than Arguing Over Lots of Other Things Instead
• The Importance of Listening to Explanations of Things Before Expressing Anger
• The Importance of Standing Up for Oneself

3. Communication Difficulties
• Preventing Conflict Because of Misunderstandings By Giving More Explanation of Motives
• Being Straightforward About What You Want Rather Than Hinting At Things
• Making Positive Suggestions Rather Than Complaints
• The Way Things are Phrased Can Make a Big Difference
• The Importance of Listening Properly
• Pros and Cons of Communicating Important Things By Writing a Letter

4. Thoughts on Having Read That

Isn't Dann nice to be hinting in the very tags of this thread that he wants all this stuff promoted!

So here's the third article I link to in my signature:

Protecting Yourself From Being Teased At School

By Diana Holbourn

The Main Contents

1. Some Reasons Children Tease
• Bearing a Grudge
• Teasing to be Admired or to Get Attention
• Teasing For Fun
• Not Being Able to Handle Anger Properly
• Teasing Because It's Thought to be Normal
• Fear of Differences
• Some Teasers Are Copying Other People
• Sometimes Teasers Don't Understand the Words They Use
• Being Teased About Something That's Easy to Change

2. Ways We Can Stop the Teasing Making us Feel So Bad
• One or Two Ways People Being Teased Can Feel Better About Themselves
• Not Feeling Helpless About the Teasing Problem
• Not Assuming We're Being Teased Because Something's Wrong With Us
• Teasers Can Control Their Feelings Too
• Becoming Good at Not Taking Things Personally
• If we Get Teased Because We're Better Than the Teaser at Something
• Being Nice to Ourselves
• Trying Not to Let the Bullying Make us Think Our Whole Life's Messed Up
• If We're Upset That People Don't Like Us
• Other Ways of Lifting the Mood
• It's Much Better to Feel Angry Than Hurt
• How We Can Use Anger to Help us Get What We Want
• Not Letting Resentment Ruin Our Day

3. Things We Can Do About the Nasty Things Teasers Say, to Stop Them
• Thinking About What the Teasers are Saying Differently So It's Not So Upsetting
• Asking Ourselves Whether the Tease is True
• Asking Ourselves Whose Opinion Counts, the Teaser's or Ours
• Thinking Nice Thoughts About Ourselves
• Thinking Calming and Reassuring Thoughts When We're Being Teased
• Rehearsing Reacting to Teasers
• Ignoring the Tease
• Expressing Our Feelings to the Teaser
• Using Our Imagination to Stop Teasing Bothering Us So Much
• Acting as if There's Something Good About Being Teased
• Stopping the Teaser In Their Tracks By Agreeing With The Facts of What They Say
• Acting as if we Just Don't Care About What the Teaser Says
• A Way of Answering Questions Meant to Make Fun of Us
• Complimenting the Teaser
• Using Humour
• If a Teaser Begins to Get Nasty

4. Stopping Ourselves Feeling So Worried and Scared About Being Teased
• Making it Easier to Face Up to People Who Tease Us
• Imagining Ourselves as Being Brave and Strong
• One Way we can Stop Worrying so Much

5. Telling Other People About the Teasing if it's Too Much for us to Cope With on Our Own

(Again, when the author says "we", she doesn't really mean "we".) :D

And now to another article - once again I'd like to thank Dann for changing the tags of this thread to seemingly loudly hint that he wants this stuff promoted:

Coping with Unemployment

By Diana Holbourn

The Main Contents

1. Encouraging and Pampering Ourselves When we First Lose a Job
• Even if we Think Unemployment Will Last Forever, It Shouldn't
• We Can Unashamedly Pamper Ourselves the First Few Days of Unemployment

2. Thinking of Unemployment as a Full-Time Job
3. Encouraging Ourselves
4. Building Up a Daily Routine
5. Making Sure We're Sleeping Well
• Reasons We Might Not be Sleeping Well

6. The Importance of Exercise
7. Being Careful Not to Over-Eat
8. Dealing With Finances
• Borrowing From Friends and Family

9. Doing Things we Never Got Around to Before
10. Making the place more cheerful to Look At
11. Telling the Children About the Job Loss
12. Teaching the Children Healthy Attitudes and Being There for Them
13. Family Time Together
14. Making Time to Find a Job
15. If We Have to Move Back In With Parents for a While
16. Making Sure We Don't Start to Feel Isolated
17. Not Being Embarrassed to Tell the Truth About Our Unemployment
18. Making Sure We Have Things to Laugh About
19. Being Around Positive People
20. Creating Our Own Support Group
21. Doing Kind Things For Others
22. Birthday Presents and Other Gifts
23. Doing Any Old Job for Now
24. Learning New Job Skills
25. Helping Ourselves Feel More Energetic
26. The Problem of Being Over-Qualified for Jobs
27. Relaxation
28. Going Away For a Break
29. Free Fun Activities
30. Fun That Doesn't Cost Much
31. Shopping
32. Getting Anxious About Starting a Week of Job Searching

(Again, the "we" doesn't really mean "we" ... well, you get the picture.) :D Or at least you will if you read one of the articles.

And now on to the fifth article in my signature - thank you once again, Dann, for implying that not only this post but the entire thread should be about this stuff, by putting the author's name in the thread tags:

Conquering Any Kind of Addiction or Craving

By Diana Holbourn

The Main Contents

1. Encouraging Ourselves and Thinking About Our Skills
• Looking Forward to the Future

2. The Reason People Are Vulnerable to Addiction
• Withdrawal Symptoms

3. How We Need to Get Our Emotional Needs Met to Keep Addiction Away
• Addiction Means Something's Missing In Our Lives
• Eating Disorders Are Addictions Too
• Addiction to Smoking

4. How People Can Be Very Motivated to Give Up Addictions When Their Needs Are Being Met
• Examples of How Addictions Can Become Unattractive When Emotional Needs Are Being Met
• The Morphine Experiment
• The Vietnam Veterans
• Natural Recovery From Addiction
• Inaccurate Beliefs That Can Stand in the Way of Addictions Being Shaken Off

5. Giving Up Addictions by Increasing Pleasure, Not Enduring Suffering
• Why Withdrawal Symptoms Don't All Have to be Nasty
• Not Feeling Discouraged If We've Tried to Break Free From Addiction Before Unsuccessfully

6. What Causes Cravings, And How Knowing That Can Help Overcome Them
• Things That Go On in the Brain When a Craving Comes On
• An Example of What Happens in the Brain When Someone's Trying to Resist a Craving for Smoking

7. How Addiction Fools Us
• Other Things We Can Forget About Our Addiction When We Get the Craving For It
• The Woman Who Was Pleasantly Surprised the Day She Went Out and Didn't Drink
• The Idea of Staying Addicted to Keep Friends

8. The Way to Cure Addiction

9. What Has to Happen For Us to Be Able to Break Free From Addiction
• The Emotional Needs Everyone Needs to Have Fulfilled

10. Thinking Through What Addiction Really Does For Us, or Does to Harm Us

11. Working Out Which of Our Needs Isn't Being Met and What We Can Do About It
• The Woman Who Was Addicted to Shopping

12. Planning Whether to Cut Down Our Addiction or Stop Altogether

13. Working Out How to Revamp our Lives to Get Unmet Needs Met
• Improving Our Social Lives
• Being Creative About Meeting Unmet Needs
• The Cocaine User who Quickly Stopped
• The Man With the Gambling Problem who Quickly Stopped
• Sorting Out Unmet Needs That Are More Difficult to Meet, Bit By Bit

14. Using Relaxation Techniques to Calm Down and Feel Better
• Using Relaxation to Combat Addiction

15. Changing Our Expectations of What Our Addiction Will Do for Us
• How it Might Work With Someone Trying to Cut Down Their Coffee Drinking
• An Example About Giving Up Smoking
• Alcohol

16. Reminding Ourselves of What We Can Use to Help Us Overcome Addiction

17. Things That Can Trigger Off a Craving For Our Addiction

18. Using Our Imagination to Break the Power of Addiction
• Thinking About the Bad Things About the Addiction First
• The Harmful Effects of Cannabis
• The Harmful Effects of Smoking
• Imagining the Good Things About Being Free of Addiction

19. Planning Things We Can Do When We're Really Tempted By Our Addiction

20. Improving Our Physical Health

21. Not Letting Relapses Get Us Down But Picking Ourselves Up Again

And on to the last article linked to in my signature:

Learning to Control Anger

By Diana Holbourn

The Main Contents

1. Making Ourselves Happier
• Starting to Make Changes in our Lives
• Imagining What Life With Much Less Anger Could be Like
• What Might Happen When We Begin to Change for the Better
• Changing the Way we Think of Ourselves

2. Thinking About Things That Used to Make us Angry Differently
• How we Can be Fooled Into Becoming More Angry Than We Should and More Quickly
• Changing Our Thinking Style
• An Example of How We Can Ruin Our Days and Put People Off Us Just Because of Our Thinking Style

3. Dealing With Things That Make Us Angry In Different Ways So They Don't Make Us So Angry
• Things That Don't Cure Anger Problems
• An Example of Why Angry Outbursts Don't Solve Problems
• Responding to Awkward Questions People Ask to Make Us Uncomfortable
• Using Swear Words
• Speaking Up to Get our Needs Met
• Feeling More Worthwhile As People

4. Violence
• Violence Against Children
• Ways of Avoiding Violence When We Feel as If We're Building Up to It

5. Anger in Family Relationships
• Improving Relationships With Our Wives/Partners
• Sex
• Preventing Our Children Growing Up With Anger Problems
• What Can Give Children Anger Problems
• How We Can Change Things If Our Children or Others We Know Have Anger Problems

6. A Few Tips for the Future

Well that was good. Shall we have one more short one for good measure, even though my signature doesn't link to this one? Yeah let's.

Cutting Down Verbal Abuse from Work Colleagues

By Diana Holbourn

The Main Contents

1. Trying to Deflect the Bully's Personal Attacks
• Some Reasons Why Bullies Bully
• Diverting the Bully from Making Personal Attacks by Bringing the Discussion Back to the Issues
• Confusing or Diverting the Bully's Attention by Asking an Unexpected Question
• Working Off the Anger
• Trying to Bore the Bully into Silence
• Why it's Best Not to Respond to a Bully in Kind

2. Dealing with Heckling in Meetings
3. Trying to Encourage the Bully to Get a Life
4. Calming Angry Impulses and Learning to be More Relaxed Around the Bully
5. Threatening to Report the Bully to Management and Others if Nothing Else Works

Hey, let's just have one more:

Helping a Husband or Wife Over Depression

By Diana Holbourn

The Main Contents

1. Reminiscences

2. The Causes of Depression
• Medications and Illnesses That Can Cause Depression
• Eating and Drinking Healthily Can Help Keep Depression Away
• Exercise Can Help Lift Depression
• Psychological Causes of Depression

3. Ways of Trying to Persuade a Spouse to Get Treatment for Depression

4. Dealing With the Depressed Partner's Hurtful Attitude
• If the Depressed Partner's Blaming You for All Their Misery
• Try Not to Take the Depressed Partner's Accusations Personally

5. Techniques a Spouse Can Try to Help Lift Their Marriage Partner's Depression If They Don't Want Treatment
• Suggesting Enjoyable Activities Known to Lift Depression
• Getting Someone Else to Speak to the Depressed Spouse
• Take Special Notice of the Times the Spouse Isn't Depressed
• Looking After Your Own Needs for Enjoyment in Life

6. Conclusion

Hey, shall we just link to the index of all the self-help articles in case anyone wants to see what else there is, for good measure? Yes, here it is: Free Self-Help to Recover From Some Life-Damaging Problems.

And I didn't think Dann liked me enough to want me to promote the things in my signature. :p

If he hints at wanting me to promote them some more, I'll link to more of the self-help articles and quote their contents lists, ... unless, of course, he actually gets around to explaining why he changed the tags of this thread to include the name of the articles' author, and the reason turns out to be different. It is quite possible it could be, but just vaguely hinting won't reveal that to us. He'll need to do more.
 
If Marx was somehow resurrected and I was arguing with him, rather than his pale shadow of a representative in the form of you, he might have said something quite similar to that, and greeted what I said with more favour than the likes of some of his followers like you have. Perhaps he would have been more open-minded,

Na, he wouldn't, but I'm sure that you'd be able to interpret him as if he backed up your Christian self-help philosophy.
That's so easy to do when you don't understand what he says and need somebody to translate it for you.
 
Spam, or hilarious spam?

More BN/Diana Holbourn spamming. No surprise there.

Wow, no matter how I try to encourage Dann to reveal just why he changed the tags of this thread to have the names Baby Nemesis and Diana Holbourn in them, he just will not do so! No matter how much I guess, he will not give me even a clue as to what the real reason is. ... Unless he's hinting that he's decided I've linked to just too many things put together by this Diana Holbourn fella ... I mean gal, and he changed the tags in a rare outburst of the ability to use irony, thinking that's what this thread had become all about. As if! I have my doubts that that was the reason, since his sense of humour doesn't seem to be that well-developed; but if he did, it's just another indication that he doesn't seem to have the ability or inclination to attack the actual arguments being put forward, but only the modus operandi of the one putting them forward! It's a poor show, and it's difficult to remain engaged in discussing the issues oneself if he doesn't want to discuss anything he disagrees with but just expresses offence or feeble mockery at it! Perhaps he also thinks Diana Holbourn is the author of everything I've linked to in this entire thread. :D

So Dann, besides dismissing that self-help material I linked to in my previous post, which could actually prove extremely useful for some people to read, as mere "spam", did you also think it was "hilarious", just as you found stories of damaged gangsters giving up violence "hilarious"?

Maybe you did. I'll quote a few stories from some of those self-help articles I quoted the contents lists from in my last post - a story each from some of the ones I link to in my signature, and you tell me whether you find them just as amusing as thoughts of people murdering and maiming and then giving up such lifestyles when they become inspired by Christianity. Tell me Dann, are these stories just spam, or "hilarious" spam?:

(Remember that when they say "we" and "us", they don't really mean "we" and "us".) :D

From the article Overcoming Depression and Worry

By Diana Holbourn

It [a self-help book] says we should set goals for ourselves, to change our lives little bit by little bit, not too ambitiously so things might not work out and we just get more depressed, but in little stages that we're fairly confident we can achieve. But the goals should be things that help us work towards putting pleasure and meaning back in our lives. ...

It says that our goals should be concrete rather than vague, because if they're too vague, we won't know how to work out steps to work towards achieving them. So, for instance, they couldn't be things like, "I want to be happier", or, "I want to be less of a burden to others". It says that if those are the only types of things we can think of at first, we can work out how to turn them into goals we can think through how to achieve if we ask ourselves to imagine what it would be like if we were happier or less of a burden, what we'd be doing differently. So we could ask ourselves questions like:

•*"If I woke up in the morning and wasn't depressed any more, what, realistically, might have changed?
•*What would be the first sign that things were different?
•*What would I be doing differently when I got up?
•*How would things be different as I went through the day?
•*What would I be doing to contribute to making them so different?
•*What would other people notice me doing differently?"

It says that one man who asked himself how his day would start off differently had been deeply depressed after he'd had to retire early from work because of a back injury. He said that if things were different, ideally, he'd get up in time to have breakfast with the children before they went to school, and ask his wife about her day. He said that even though he couldn't work long hours, he'd still be able to do some practical things around the house and garden. This gave him ideas about what his life could be like, and then he set three goals for himself to work towards getting there:

He said he'd set his alarm clock early enough to get up in time for breakfast with his children, no matter how he'd slept;
he'd ask his wife at least three questions during the day about how her day was going or what she planned to do with the rest of it;
and he'd decide on a DIY task that needed doing in the house, and do it.

Doing DIY tasks gave him even more to discuss with his wife, and he needed to go out to buy materials, and soon, he was more involved with life again, and feeling better, feeling as if there was meaning in his life again. Because he was focusing his attention outwards onto things rather than spending all his time thinking about how upsetting he thought life was for him as he had before, his sleep improved, because he didn't need to spend so much of it discharging
excess emotion. So he was more refreshed in the mornings, and so his mood improved a lot.

Is that "spam", Dann, or "hilarious" spam?

From the article Improving a Marriage Instead of Getting a Divorce

By Diana Holbourn

She says she realises that another way she used to mess up the communication between [herself and her husband] was that she used to hint at things rather than being direct about what she wanted, almost hoping her husband would read her mind. She would often feel hurt because he didn't take her hints. ...

She says another time she was upset with him because he didn't understand that when she hinted at something she really meant that she wanted something was in a shop when she was looking at spatulas. She found one she liked and said, "Oh look, there's one of those nice spatulas I've been wanting" But after she looked at the price, she said, "But it's so expensive!" She was hoping he'd tell her not to worry about the price, and buy it for her, saying she was worth it. He, on the other hand, thought she'd decided not to get it after all. So they walked away, but she felt hurt and angry because she thought he was so thoughtless.

She sulked for a little while, and then she complained. He was totally amazed, not having realised she wanted it. Then she realised she hadn't said she wanted him to buy it for her. She'd expected him to just know. He was very happy to buy it. She would have spared them both some hassle if she'd said what she wanted in the first place.

So she advises people to be direct about what they'd like their spouses to do for them.

Is that "spam", Dann, or "hilarious" spam? It's a pity if you just dismiss it, since you could certainly learn from stories like that to improve your own communication technique.

From the article Protecting Yourself From Being Teased At School

By Diana Holbourn

The book says some teasers just don't think about the feelings of the person being teased, and when they find out how upset it makes them, they feel sorry for what they did and stop. ...

Anyway, it says in this book that there was a girl whose mother was ill and had to spend lots of time in hospital who had to go and stay with foster parents for a while. Two girls in her class teased her about it. She was already upset that her mum was ill, and the teasing made her more upset. She wrote down her feelings about how upset and scared she was about what would happen to her mum in a diary. And she wrote about how the teasers teased her, and how upset she was about that, and which lessons every day they teased her in and what other times of day they did, and how many times a day.

She plucked up the courage to tell her headmistress about the teasing, and showed her the diary. The headmistress called the two girls who'd been doing the teasing into her office, and read them some of it. They were shocked at what impact their teasing had had. They hadn't thought about how the girl they'd been teasing might feel. They were ashamed of themselves.

They stopped teasing the girl straightaway, and her classmates became a lot more caring towards her after that, and they were pleased when her mum was well enough to come home.

Is that "spam", Dann, or "hilarious" spam?

From the article Conquering Any Kind of Addiction or Craving

By Diana Holbourn

It tells the story of a woman who was involved in the running of her husband's business; but when it expanded, her husband employed someone to do the job they'd both done part of together, and went abroad a lot to promote the business. His wife wasn't working after that, and she didn't have any children, so she spent a lot of time on her own with not much to do. She became a compulsive shopper, buying large amounts of designer clothes, most of which she didn't even wear. In fact, she didn't even want to bother hanging them up half the time. But the bills became huge. And yet she still felt the need to go to shops that sold expensive designer clothes.

But when she sat down to work out what emotional needs weren't being met in her life, she realised it wasn't the clothes she was really after when she went shopping. She realised that she went because she wanted the buzz from the attention the shop assistants gave her. They were elegant women who were knowledgeable about fashion, and she loved to have them focusing their attention entirely on her, admiring her choices and deciding what suited her best.

Then she realised that she was very lonely and had lost her sense of purpose in life once she'd stopped working for her husband's business. She realised she'd get her purpose in life back and feel much better about herself if she learned some skills and did some activities that were really worthy of approval.

So she broadened her social life, so she wasn't so dependent on having her husband around for company, and she started fundraising for a local charity, partly by using her knowledge of fashion to arrange fun fashion shows.

Is that "spam", Dann, or "hilarious" spam?

From the article Learning to Control Anger

By Diana Holbourn

I heard about someone who said she learned early in her marriage about how much better the results can be when you ask for change rather than complaining about what's wrong, when one day she wanted to ask her husband if he'd go out at weekends more with her. She said he worked hard during the week, so he just liked to relax at home at weekends, whereas she wanted to be more active.

So one day, she sat him down and said she was fed up that they didn't go out much and that all he wanted to do at weekends was to hang around the house. He'd go out to dinner occasionally, but not much more than that, and she thought it wasn't very exciting. When she told him that, he started defending himself and it turned into an argument, until After a while, she said in a loud voice that she didn't understand what all the fuss was about, since all she wanted them to do was to go into the city every four to six weeks and do something out of the ordinary.

He said, "That's fine. Why didn't you just say so?"

She was surprised that he was so willing to do what she wanted, and wondered why he'd made such a fuss at first; but then she realised that she'd annoyed him by condemning him for his perfectly justifiable behaviour in wanting to relax at weekends, while she was criticizing his behaviour because she was trying to justify asking for what she wanted, when she didn't need to justify it. She just needed to ask for a small change.

She said that after that, she would always try to just ask for what she wanted, rather than stating all the reasons why she was unhappy at not getting it.

Is that "spam", Dann, or "hilarious" spam?

Given that you seem to consider anything that is even directly on-topic to be spam if you merely disagree with it, rather than putting up good arguments against the issues, and given your hasty dismissals of things as hilarious and spam, no matter how productive they could prove, I don't have any hope that you'll display any hint of empathy and have a more constructive attitude to these, even to the extent of suggesting they go in a different thread. ... Still, some people might like them. ;)
 
Yes, BM seems to like her own DH spam. She is probably the only one who reads it.
 
Yes, BM seems to like her own DH spam. She is probably the only one who reads it.

Don't be so sure about that, Dann. After all, didn't I just say the other day that this thread's getting masses of hits now it's degenerated into a train wreck of a thing? Nearly a thousand in a few weeks! I bet they're not all after reading your feeble put-downs. :D

So the stories in my last post were just spam then, not "hilarious" spam? OK, I'm curious to know just what turns something from spam into hilarity in your mind. The extra ingredient in what you consider hilarity that didn't appear in my recent stories was that of people turning away from violence; or could it be the fact they found Christianity inspiring enough to motivate them to turn away from it? Perhaps it's your Viking genes that would make you find hilarity in the idea that someone could actually want to turn from violence, or give up good old Odin worship to follow another God? :D No?

... Are you a secret Odinist who's just been pretending to be an atheist all this time? :D

I could perhaps find out which factor induces your hilarity by a process of elimination. Here are two stories of kids who gave up or reduced their aggressive behaviour, but didn't become Christians. If you don't find these hilarious, I will assume it must have been the Christian aspect you found amusing.

Here are the stories, again from self-help articles by that Diana Holbourn who continually pops up in this thread like a jack-in-a-box with ADHD:

From the article called Parenting Difficult Teenagers

Just a minor example: (I hope that fact doesn't confound my experiment! - it is just possible it's only the idea of people turning from major violence that sets off Dann's hilarity juices.)

A woman brought her son to see the therapist who wrote the book for therapists I've been reading, because he was throwing temper tantrums where he'd break
anything he could get his hands on, not obeying her rules, and fighting with his eight-year-old sister. The therapist asked the woman if she'd noticed
any progress in solving the problem between the time she'd booked the appointment with him and the time she'd brought him to it, and she said she had.
She said in the weeks before the appointment, they'd stopped having battles about making his bed and putting his toys away, and he'd stopped destroying
things during his temper tantrums. She said she thought she'd helped to improve things by being more patient with him and yelling less. She'd found that
what really helped was avoiding the power struggles they'd had before. She said she used to "try and win the battles" by screaming at him and taking everything
away, but that had only made things worse.

She said she also took him out for pizza and a movie when he'd had a good week.

The boy said he thought his mum not yelling was what helped him to behave better, and he was loving the pizza and movies. She said she'd like him to make
further progress by not fighting with his sister any more. He seemed keen to try, since he liked the idea of going out for pizza so much.

Things improved from there. In the next week, he only fought with his sister once, and had no temper tantrums.

And now just one more example to complete the experiment.

From an article called How Schools Can Reduce Bullying

The book by the school counsellor says that in one school he worked at, the headmistress monitored levels of aggression in the children, and
noticed they were at their worst during the weeks when teachers were busy marking exams so they had less time to talk with students and listen to them
telling them things about their home life or whatever. She asked non-classroom staff to spend more time on the playgrounds and at lunch times showing an
interest in the lives of the children during those times, and aggression levels fell to usual levels.

Come on, was that hilarious like the story of the gang boss who was so moved by the thought of Jesus caring for him that he gave up terrorising his neighbourhood was, or was it just spam?

And would you be so kind as to elaborate a little on what made the stories either hilarity or spam, so as to eliminate confusion caused by confounding factors like the seriousness or lack of severity of the violence? Thank you.
 
I've come to realise I owe Dann a slight apology. ... Oh, not much of one; a teeny tiny one. But one nevertheless. :)

The realisation struck me when no sooner had I finished pulvarising him in this thread, than on some kind of foolish ill-begotten whim, I descended right down into the dark spooky underground halls of the religion forum and joined a dreadful thread! I think it would be a hundred times better to live in a society where everyone in the entire place was indifferent to religion than it would be to live in one where the predominant view was similar to some of the views and attitudes expressed in there, on both sides!

This religion thread's so much better than some of the threads in the religion forum. Even at its worst it was. The content's so much more positive, because it's mainly about what has, or could, improve society, rather than a boorish rush to attack and put down and misrepresent the views of others for years, apparently for no good reason. I didn't realise how comparatively good this thread was before.

Here's an issue that's both related to what I discussed with people there, and related to this thread topic:

There are even atheists who think fear of divine punishment is good. :) Maybe religion is the answer claims atheist scientist

Lord May, the president of the British Science Association, said religion may have helped protect human society from itself in the past and it may be needed again.

Speaking on the eve of the association’s annual conference, the committed atheist said he was worried the world was on a “calamitous trajectory” brought on by its failure to co-ordinate measures against global warming.

He said that no country was prepared to take the lead and a “punisher” was needed to make sure the rules of co-operation were not broken.

The former Government chief scientific advisor said in the past that was God and it might be time again for religion to fill the gap. ...

He said in the past a belief in a god, or gods, that punish the unrighteous may have been part of the mechanism of evolution that maintains co-operation in a dog-eat-dog world. ...

Yay, what did I say earlier in this thread! :D Even an atheist scientist agrees. :)

Of course, that wouldn't mean people should gratuitously have their noses rubbed in the idea of punishment. And there might well be better solutions to feet-dragging over world problems.

I hope I can put that here without the "How dare you say such a terrible thing you hate-promoting scum" brigade crawling up from the depths and coming here to play. I'll have to put them on ignore if they do.

Anyway, as to the thing I said I needed to give Dann a tiny apology for: The thing is that although they paled into insignificance in my mind compared to the behaviour of a small minority of anti-theists, or I'd have explained something about what they were, some of the views expressed on the Christian side in the spooky thread I mentioned first were rather disturbing and seemed much, much closer to Dann's Ruthlesscriticism article supposedly describing what a Christian and Christian faith is than I'd ever dreamed could be possible. I called that article a "gross and ridiculous caricature" of what a Christian is. Now I realise there might be at least a few more Christians around like that than I thought, so I've realised it was merely a gross and offensive generalisation. ... See, that's not quite as bad as what I called it before, is it? ... Or is it? :dc_biggrin:

Anyway, in the context of this thread, the thought of gangsters turning away from violence to become Christians, only to adopt views like the ones Dann's article attributed to Christians, is indeed disturbing! I never thought for a minute that anything like that might have happened when the gangsters and criminals in those stories changed their ways. But I suppose it's always possible. :yikes: Perhaps that's what Dann was envisaging. I sincerely hope that wasn't what happened to them. Now that would be a bit scary!

I suspect they didn't go like that though. In any case, what I was suggesting was that secular therapists and sociologists might be able to think of and use secular versions of things that can attract such people to Christianity as some of the variety of tools they use, to help such people and thus society in non-religious ways, rather than that we necessarily need more of the same as what turned the lives of the gangsters and criminals with those Christian testimonies around, although that might be nice as well, ... provided it doesn't make them go like the Christians described in that article, of course. :)
 
John Stewart and Barbara Ehrenreich in an exchange of words about her latest book, Brightsided:

- If Jesus makes you stop drinking, isn’t that okay?
- No, I never think that delusion is okay!
 
What about conflicting ethical issues though? For example, imagine you know of a preacher who's managed to influence several dozen gangsters to give up violence, because they were so inspired when they heard about Jesus that they wanted to follow him and do what they believed he wanted, and you hear this preacher's coming to your town and that several gangsters are going to see him. Do you try to persuade them not to go because you hate the thought of them being deluded, or do you hope they will become deluded if it means they'll give up their violence, seeing their delusion as unfortunate in a way, but a good thing in the circumstances, because it'll stop them terrorising others? Bear in mind that there might well be other ways of persuading them to give up their violence, but it might take some time before the authorities manage it, if they ever do, so there's a possible chance they'll be inspired to give it up long before they ever would otherwise.
 
What about conflicting ethical issues though? For example, imagine you know of a preacher who's managed to influence several dozen gangsters to give up violence, because they were so inspired when they heard about Jesus that they wanted to follow him and do what they believed he wanted, and you hear this preacher's coming to your town and that several gangsters are going to see him. Do you try to persuade them not to go because you hate the thought of them being deluded, or do you hope they will become deluded if it means they'll give up their violence, seeing their delusion as unfortunate in a way, but a good thing in the circumstances, because it'll stop them terrorising others? Bear in mind that there might well be other ways of persuading them to give up their violence, but it might take some time before the authorities manage it, if they ever do, so there's a possible chance they'll be inspired to give it up long before they ever would otherwise.

If believing helps them, that's great. I would let them do it. Can't really see any reason to prevent it. But maybe later I would try to show them how religion isn't necessary for morality. If they don't want to listen then, then leave 'em be, because they're fine as-is.
 
imagine you know of a preacher who's managed to influence several dozen gangsters to give up violence, because they were so inspired when they heard about Jesus that they wanted to follow him and do what they believed he wanted, and you hear this preacher's coming to your town and that several gangsters are going to see him. Do you try to persuade them not to go because you hate the thought of them being deluded, or do you hope they will become deluded if it means they'll give up their violence, seeing their delusion as unfortunate in a way, but a good thing in the circumstances, because it'll stop them terrorising others?

Not even Hallmark would be able to make up delusions as treacle-sweet as those fabricated by BN. It makes you wonder why this fact doesn't make her realize how silly this kind of daydreaming is. It is for children, it is for children.
I don't know you, Pure_Argent, but I'm surprised that anybody is able to buy into this nonsense.

PS "Knowing is so much sweeter than wanting and believing."
- cgordon
 
Last edited:
Not even Hallmark would be able to make up delusions as treacle-sweet as those fabricated by BN. It makes you wonder why this fact doesn't make her realize how silly this kind of daydreaming is. It is for children, it is for children.
I don't know you, Pure_Argent, but I'm surprised that anybody is able to buy into this nonsense.

PS "Knowing is so much sweeter than wanting and believing."
- cgordon

I agree that the situation is highly unlikely, and even slightly ludicrous for its sheer inanity. For the most part, I tend to disagree strongly with Baby Nemesis. But yeah, I think that if turning to religion stops someone from committing crimes, then their turning to religion could be a good thing. This doesn't mean that I think that this situation is likely to turn up any time soon.

ETA: And when I say "disagree strongly", I mean very strongly. Most of our... discussions... tend to end up in AAH, because neither of us can stand the other.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom