Religion's value questioned

Christians seem to be rather fond of sacrifices and tests of loyalty, don't they?


In the city of Godham: i.e. in the Old Testament.


And in the New Testament, i.e. in Jesusville:
"If anyone comes to me and does not hate his father and mother, his wife and children, his brothers and sisters—yes, even his own life—he cannot be my disciple. Luke 14:26" &
Jesus would simply have been emphasising that following him would mean committing oneself to putting doing that before loyalty to others, so if the two conflicted, it would come first.



And finally in Jonestown: "When the time came when we should have dropped dead, Rev. Jones explained that the poison was not real and that we had just been through a loyalty test."
 
Last edited:
Brief Summary: The book opens with a scene in heaven where Satan comes to accuse Job before God. He insists Job only serves God because God protects him and seeks God’s permission to test Job’s faith and loyalty. God grants His permission, only within certain boundaries. Why do the righteous suffer? This is the question raised after Job loses his family, his wealth, and his health. Job's three friends Eliphaz, Bildad and Zophar, come to “comfort” him and to discuss his crushing series of tragedies. They insist his suffering is punishment for sin in his life. Job, though, remains devoted to God through all of this and contends that his life has not been one of sin. A fourth man, Elihu, tells Job he needs to humble himself and submit to God's use of trials to purify his life. Finally, Job questions God Himself and learns valuable lessons about the sovereignty of God and his need to totally trust in the Lord. Job is then restored to health, happiness and prosperity beyond his earlier state. http://www.gotquestions.org/Book-of-Job.html
As we know from history, health, happiness and prosperity are the usual outcome when we "totally trust" in someone ...
 
Nobody's claimed that religion has no evolutionary value: Read Steve Kowit's article about the Mass-Suicide of the Xhosahttp://findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_kmske/is_1_11/ai_n29108024/?tag=content;col1http://findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_kmske/is_1_11/ai_n29108024/?tag=content;col1, in English or in Danish.
Cynics might even argue that a stunt like the one pulled by the American reverend Jim Jones several years ago in Guyana would be worthy of a Darwin award.

Dann, Dann, oh how you have sacrificed your professed principles! What a coincidence it is that less than a week ago, I found a horrible thread about a woman who died while doing something that wasn't a sensible thing to do at all, and you protested the callousness of the person who found it amusing and had proposed she should get a Darwin award. You said,

Darwin??! Or some @$$holes at a radio station who took advantage of a woman who happened to want to please her children, but did not have quite enough money
to do so!
This cynical "Darwin" argument is getting more and more stupid!

Apparently indignant that the woman should have been spoken of by the OP with such a lack of compassion, you go on to illustrate why she deserved it by quoting from the article:

the "Hold Your Wee for a Wii" contest in which KDND 107.9 promised a Nintendo Wii video game system for the winner.

"She said to one of our supervisors that she was on her way home and her head was hurting her real bad," said Laura Rios, one of Strange's co-workers at
Radiological Associates of Sacramento. "She was crying, and that was the last that anyone had heard from her."
(...)
"I was talking to her and she was a nice lady," Ybarra said. "She was telling me about her family and her three kids and how she was doing it for her kids."

But are you now doing the same thing yourself? You link to examples of where many women as well as children die this time. Is your point that those so sucked into a harmful religious belief they all die deserve a Darwin Award?? Why the difference in your attitude?

Does your hatred of religion really make so much difference to the amount of compassion you think people deserve? Aren't human beings still human beings deserving of compassion no matter what belief system they've been sucked into following?

It's disturbing the way sentiments that appear to be borne out of compassion can in fact come very much secondary to ideology, even ideology that professes to be promoting their welfare. I've been reading a depressing book called Behind the Forbidden Door by some Italian bloke - See it on Amazon. It's about China, and was written in the early 1980s. He talks quite a lot about China's history.

The author says a lot of peasants fought for the Communists in the 1940s when they were trying to overthrow the establishment, because the Communists promised them that they would take the land away from oppressive landlords and let them own it themselves. A lot of landlords had exploited the workers and famines had resulted.

Landlords were driven away. And at first, peasants were allowed to own their own land so they were happy. But then:

In the late 1950s, Mao Zedung put into operation his ideal of an egalitarian state. All private property was forbidden. Garden plots and livestock were confiscated from peasants. They were no longer allowed to hold markets to sell or buy things. They weren't even allowed to plant some vegetables for themselves along the side of a canal. Everything would belong to the state. They became detached from the land! Each one worked for communes of about 50 thousand members, one day perhaps helping to build a dike, the next day on a road, and the next in an iron-smelting plant. In return for their work, they'd be guaranteed food and clothing, education, and some other things.

But it didn't work out as planned. In fact, this policy, designed to make everyone equal, was disastrous! Output of grain, pork and sugar fell to the levels it had been at ten years earlier. Millions of people were plunged into famine, and many died.

In the early 1960s, they were allowed private plots to grow what they liked on again, and they called them "life saving plots". But this was short-lived, because when the Cultural Revolution started, Mao's "leftist" ideology was put into force again, and private plots were no longer allowed, again with disastrous consequences.

At the time the author wrote the book, many communes had been abolished and peasants were allowed to own their own land, and output of crops had increased a lot. People could remark on how much better cared-for the private plots were than the publicly-owned land was. The abolition of the commune system brought big problems though, since at least when all food belonged to the commune, people who didn't work, like old people, got a share. But grain production certainly rose afterwards. The private plots were a lot more productive than the others.

It was perhaps partly selfishness that led to the decline in productivity when everything was publicly owned - people wouldn't feel as motivated to work on land they might not see again or which other people might not work hard on so they didn't know if their efforts would pay off, as they would on land where they knew they'd have a definite percentage of what was produced, and where they could actually witness the results of their work in progress.

But the point is that even when it had been discovered that Mao's ideology was leading to disaster, the same ideology, purported to be all about the promotion of human welfare but in reality causing disaster, was still implemented as the policy. What makes people put an ideology that professes to be all about human well-being above human well-being itself when it proves to be harming it? What makes people consider human welfare as so much less important than an ideal they hold, such as the abolition of religion for the good of the people?

Those articles seem interesting though. Shame the first one's ten pages long, although the pages are short. I'll get to reading all of it though in the end.
 
Christians seem to be rather fond of sacrifices and tests of loyalty, don't they?


In the city of Godham: i.e. in the Old Testament.


And in the New Testament, i.e. in Jesusville:
"If anyone comes to me and does not hate his father and mother, his wife and children, his brothers and sisters—yes, even his own life—he cannot be my disciple. Luke 14:26" &



And finally in Jonestown: "When the time came when we should have dropped dead, Rev. Jones explained that the poison was not real and that we had just been through a loyalty test."

And just what was there in Jesus words about following him that urged people to die for him? Remember this was the same Jesus who said, "When you're persecuted in one town, flee to another".

Jesus' words about putting him before family can be put in context and shown to mean something very different from what you're inferring they mean. You'll see if you read the whole of Luke chapter 14 yourself. Jesus is making a point in the next verses about counting the cost of following him before you even bother to start. Hence Jesus' illustration immediately after the verse about putting him before parents of someone building a tower and having to stop after he laid the foundations because he didn't have enough material to build it, and just being laughed at, because he didn't count the cost of building it before he started. The illustrations Jesus gives before the verse are of people basically making excuses for not wanting to follow him - divided loyalties.

As for your Job example, you seem to have really missed the point of the book. The amount of complaining it says Job did about God proves it isn't a parable to teach loyalty to God no matter what! His complaining starts quite near the beginning, and goes on persistently through many chapters. It's probably a parable that teaches a far more profound message than that.

Here's what it's more likely to be:

The Book of Job is an important counter-balance to faulty assumptions that might be made through reading too much into the rest of the Old Testament, since most of the Old Testament is about God's punishment on societies for sins such as violence and oppression of the poor, but some might think it's saying tragedy is always a punishment for sin, rather than sometimes having nothing to do with it. The Old Testament doesn't say that every instance of such suffering would be a punishment from God, and it doesn't address the reasons for the suffering of individuals. However, it may have been easy for anyone to assume it meant that when individuals suffered tragedy, they were being punished for something by God, so it was their fault. It may be for this reason that the New Testament tells us the disciples of Jesus asked him when they saw a man who'd been blind from birth, "Who sinned, this man or his parents, that he was born blind?" They might have got ideas like that from the Old Testament. The Book of Job is an essential corrective to this mistaken belief, since it's about how suffering can happen to the best of us for no obvious reason.

If it wasn't for the Book of Job, a terrible stigma could have grown up against people who suffered tragedy, because other people might have mistakenly thought the Bible shows that they must be suffering as a result of God's punishment. Thus, the Book of Job could have prevented mental torment of many who might otherwise have suffered the effects of judgmentalism by such people on top of the tragedies they were already suffering.
 
Hey Dann, look at this!! I know I suggested I wouldn't post again if you didn't, but this is just too good to miss! :)

Just when it seemed the reputation of Christianity was so far-gone it would never again be able to struggle to its feet and drag itself haltingly out of the mud, Yippy! Someone pops up to save the day! Here we have Christianity showing the good side it's supposed to. Here's a link to another thread on here: An Interview with a Former KKK Leader.

... Ahem, before everyone reading this faints in shock or flies into a rage and rushes to reply with a bellowing tirade of outraged indignation for my offensive audacity, no, I'm not suggesting the KKK is the good side of Christianity. :) Here's what I'm saying:

The former KKK leader talks about how he and his Klan followers threatened a certain preacher. I looked up a bit more about the preacher in Wikipedia and it turns out he was active in the civil rights movement and a friend of Martin Luther King. The Ku Klux Klan leader said he and his gang threatened him in the 1980s. He said the preacher responded by being nice to him and using humour. I found an article about him that I link to in that thread, that says his attitude towards black people changed as a result, and he now even works with a group to combat racism. It's yet another inspirational story.

... And I read that he's become a clergyman as well. Sorry Dann, it seems I've collected yet another gangster-gone-good story. :D

(I nearly managed to do a bit of cheek-turning myself in the religion forum a few weeks ago, inspired by remembering something someone I presume is an atheist said/did in a conversation I had with them and others when I first got here; but unfortunately my temper got the better of me. ... Still, some of the results were entertaining, and possibly instructive in a round-about way, although probably best not repeated, although they have to be two of my best posts. :D Kind of relevant though, funnily enough.)

Anyway, the interview with the former KKK leader is linked to in the thread about him - it's an audio interview on YouTube, but it's only short. Definitely worth a listen for anyone interested. The chicken-kissing episode might be especially of note to some. :)
 
Part of alcohol recovery has to do with how much the alcoholic actually wants to recover. In a book about recovery from agoraphobia, (Freedom from Agoraphobia by Mark Eisenstadt), the author even goes so far as to say he once worked for six months as the doctor on an alcohol dependency ward, and some of the patients explained what they called "bottoming out". They said that was when an alcoholic had reached the point when drinking just cost too much to go on doing it so they'd stop. They said it was as if a decision made itself in them - something happened that finally made them decide they couldn't go on like that. The patients said for some alcoholics, it would take a lot more to get to that point than for others. For some, the point they made the firm decision to stop drinking would be when they'd lost their wives and kids, their jobs and their homes, and they found themselves sitting in freezing doorways drinking alcohol out of a bottle in a paper bag. On the next level up, some wouldn't stop drinking till they'd lost all that but had also had physical problems that had left them needing emergency treatment and had nearly killed them. The patients said for others, they wouldn't stop drinking this side of the grave.

The author said the patients also told him that if a man hadn't reached the point where the costs of drinking were just too high for him to carry on, then no matter how much part of him wanted to stop, and no matter how well-intentioned anyone who tried to help him was, he couldn't be helped.

The author says he thinks that's why Alcoholics' Anonymous has the concept of a higher power that can help people who are otherwise helpless to give up drinking themselves.

---------


But perhaps some good approaches just hadn't been tried with them that would have worked on some. Motivational counselling might go quite some way to changing the mind-sets of some of those people - talking them into being convinced that giving up will actually have benefits they really want, rather than simply being something they have to deny themselves. This might be one reason why religion can work for some - it can give them the promise of a new hopeful start in life, as well as a new set of things in their lives they can enjoy, which make up to some extent for the loss of drink in their lives so they're not just faced with a big void. ...

Perhaps Alcoholics' Anonymous would be more successful if it had a more positive, motivational ethos. I read in a book once about someone who toured lots of support groups in America, like AA ones, and she found that in most of them, people would just immerse themselves in self-pity, telling stories about their painful pasts. She said the only exception to this was a group of Cambodian women who'd newly arrived in America from the "killing fields", where they'd witnessed and been victims of horrifying scenes of murder and violence and had fled to America where they had to get used to a lot of new things. Unlike in the other "self-help" groups, they spent little time discussing their traumatic pasts, but they spent most of the time helping each other learn practical things that could help them in their everyday lives - more English phrases, the local bus system, and other such things. They joked and laughed a lot. Only once, when a news story of a similar massacre in another country came on the radio, did they become quiet and sad and talk a bit about their past experiences; but then they quickly moved back to searching for solutions rather than dwelling on problems.

It may be that more people who go to Alcoholics' Anonymous would succeed in giving up drinking if the groups focused on the future and ways of making life more fulfilling that made giving up drinking seem more enticing, rather than dwelling on misery and feeling helpless.

I only have second-hand information about what Alcoholics' Anonymous is like so I can't be sure I've represented them fairly. But still:

I came across this interesting article a few days ago that seems to support those ideas, though the research was only done with a small group: A Brief Intervention That Works For Drivers Who Persist In Driving While Intoxicated

... Brown and his colleagues divided 184 male and female recidivists with drinking problems and not currently engaged in DWI intervention into two groups:
92 (86 men, 6 women) received a 30-minute BMI session [brief motivational interviewing], a brief but powerful psychosocial intervention where the client was encouraged to review personal reasons for change; 92 (79 men, 13 women) received a 30-minute "control" intervention, where the client received information about the hazards of excessive drinking related to health and DWI. Outcomes measured at six- and 12-month follow-ups included percent of risky drinking days in the preceding 6 months, biomarkers of alcohol abuse, and alcohol abuse-related behaviors. "The drivers we studied may be among the most dangerous drivers, what some authorities call 'hardcore drunk drivers,'" said Brown. "We figured that an intervention tailored to their specifications would have to be very brief, something that could be applied opportunistically, say at the time of a court appearance. Our results indicated that BMI, compared to the control procedure, was superior in reducing by around 30 percent the number of risky drinking days for up to a year after receiving the intervention. A risky drinking day is when an individual drank enough on a given day that he or she would probably be impaired if they were to drive shortly after."

As for why the BMI intervention was more effective than the control intervention, Lapham responded: "We all have inner conflicts, but these conflicts between how we act and how we would like to be are sometimes not obvious to us," she said. "BMI techniques expose these conflicts and allow the person to be more aware of how their harmful alcohol use is at odds with their self image; in other words, how their behavior sabotages their own personal goals for the future. Some interventions try to lead the person into setting goals developed by the therapist, whereas BMI allows the person to fashion his or her own agenda: uncover their own reasons, and motivations, for changing, and set their own goals."

So I wonder if Alcoholics' Anonymous would be more effective if they changed their approach to one more like that, instead of one where people are indoctrinated into seeing themselves as powerless over the drinking problem and needing a higher power to help them over it.

I'm not suggesting past problems shouldn't be discussed. I'm just saying it might be more productive if the focus was on creating a more fulfilling future.
 
Last edited:
So I wonder if Alcoholics' Anonymous would be more effective if they changed their approach to one more like that, instead of one where people are indoctrinated into seeing themselves as powerless over the drinking problem and needing a higher power to help them over it.

I think about this quite often and readily agree that AA would be worthwhile if using completely different method. Nothing makes me angrier than the promotion of human weakness.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom