Religion's value questioned

Hilarious! Next testimony?

Dann, it's time you learned a Very, Very important lesson:

Do Not ...

That is, Do Not provoke me early in the morning. If anyone provokes me in the morning, I'm more likely to respond with irritation than I am later in the day; the later in the day it is, the more likely I am to respond playfully.

Thus, you should strategically time your provocations to coincide with the time I'm less likely to be irritated.

This is the Word of Baby Nemesis.

However, since you didn't know that, just this once, I'll give you a concession and Not be irritated with you this morning.

In fact, I will respond by doing you the blessed favour of acceding to your request.

You want more Christian testimonies? Excellent! You are learning fast. You are clearly becoming a blessed disciple of Jesus, even though you will for appearances' sake, naturally want to keep up your facade of atheism on the board, even with great protests against Christianity so it seems convincing. :D

Unfortunately, I haven't prepared any more testimonies where I have analysed them to see what elements some atheist psychologists and sociologists could use to give them ideas on research they could do into the kinds of things that can attract delinquents to become Christians and give up harmful lifestyles so they can devise secular substitutes, as I did in the post here that you apparently found hilarious, but you can have some unanalysed Christian testimonies:

Here are a few testimonies of ex-street gang members. I haven't even read them myself or browsed the site, but it could be interesting. This is how the site presents itself:

This blog is part of Street Gang Style, a site aimed at giving expression to gang and ex gang members and showing the love of Jesus Christ to gang members.

Besides testimonies, it contains articles about various aspects of gangs, and various things that can be done to stop people getting involved, and so on.

Perhaps you'd actually prefer people to remain in violent gangs than to become Christians? Do you think Christianity is just so evil that gangs are the lesser of two evils? Or are gangs just that little bit worse?

Still, since you have so obligingly requested more Christian testimonies, perhaps you would also like me to post Bible quotes again as well? Excellent! Thank you for allowing me this platform. Here we go again. :) I posted these before, but they're so good, I'm going to post them again.

These are all instructions meant mainly for Christians. They illustrate just why gangsters and the like might decide that being a Christian involves the responsibility to give up violence and so on:

What The Bible Says About Violence, Anger, Jealousy, Arguments, And Living In Peace With Each Other.
What The Bible Says About Love And Caring.
What The Bible Says About Honesty And The Love Of Money.
A Short Story About Tackling Prejudice, And What The Bible Says About Despising People, Judging By Appearances, And God's Mercy.
What The Bible Says About Drunkenness and Why It's Wrong.
What The Bible Says About Lies, Gossip, Quarrelling, Insulting Language And Dirty Jokes.
What The Bible Says About Sex And Marriage.
What The Bible Says About Lustful And Nasty Thoughts.
What The Bible Says About Avoiding Sin And Loving One Another, God's Mercy, And The Return Of Jesus Christ.
What The Bible Says About The Life-Changing Power Of The Holy Spirit.
 
Now she's even giving lessons?! Including thou-shalt-nots!

Well, her Christian testimonies are getting more and more hilarious. However, it would be much easier for everybody if she simply posted the link to the whole bloody thing and let people search for whatever theme they might find interesting. If anybody here actually does find anything interesting in the bible, that is. Spamming us repeatedly with the stuff seems a little exaggerated.

I have no idea which timezone she's in, by the way, and I don't care.
 
Dann, you're such a kill-joy!

Still continuing with your Mr Bean act - blundering around missing points wherever you go? ... You are doing it deliberately, aren't you? ... Aren't you?

But perhaps you could just inform us as to exactly what is so hilarious about testimonies of people who gave up being violent to others in their community when they found some kind of fulfilment in Christianity. It's strange you should find those so funny, and yet apparently be so humour-impaired as to not notice the humour in your opponents' posts. Still: Is it hilarious that anyone would want to give up violence? Hilarious that it took the inspiration of Christianity to motivate them to do it? - in which case, just what is so funny? - "Ha! Those wimpy gang members! Fancy hard men needing an emotional crutch before they could stop being violent!" - is that it? Well, I'd say that was very mildly amusing but certainly not hilarious. What an interesting sense of humour you have! Or was it something else?

And it should have been obvious what time zone I'm in - it would have been obvious to anyone giving it a bit of thought that if you post in the morning, and then someone jokes about how it's inadvisable to post in the morning, it just might be that they're living in a similar time zone to you. :)

You know, it's funny that since I advised you not to respond to me if you don't want me to post in this thread any more, you seem to have taken it into your head that what I said will still apply if you refer to me in the third person, - i.e. not responding directly to me. Do you really have such a literalistic mind-set? It would appear so from a lot of what you say.

Still, it's fun to be literal sometimes, hence my own literal response to your request for another Christian testimony. It's foolish indeed to accuse me of spamming when all I'm doing is acceding to your request, perhaps with a bit of embellishment. All I'm doing is making the case that religion can sometimes prove valuable, as per the thread title and in opposition to your position. The fact that you consistently refuse to critique my position but just protest about opposition to your point of view even being put forward suggests you have an intolerance of dissent, typical of Communists, if what I quoted earlier about Communists is to be believed. It's a pity you didn't state at the beginning of this thread that you weren't prepared to tolerate opposition to your views. Then we would have known where we stood.

But here's something else, Mr "Haha, what a load of wimps those gang members are, feeling the need to turn to Christianity before they can shake off their violent lifestyle" Dann the masterfully self-sufficient:

Do you feel that way about all self-help attempts? What if it's not Christianity they turn to but a psychological self-help regime? Couldn't it be argued that they were still using an unhealthy emotional crutch, if, for instance, they started practising relaxation techniques every day and doing other such things?

And since you suggest I should post a main link to what I want to post, here's one: :) Free Self-Help to Recover From Some Life-Damaging Problems.

This self-help series currently covers several things, including:

•*Depression
•*Marriage difficulties
•*Parenting
•*Bullying and teasing
•*Anger problems
•*Unemployment
•*Addiction
•*Anxiety problems like worry, phobias, panic and obsessive-compulsive disorder
•*The aftermath of some traumatic experiences
•*Life-threatening illness
•*Self-harm, like eating disorders and self-injury
•*Grief and loneliness
•*Losing weight

Now it may be that several recommendations in there haven't been meticulously scientifically tested. But if they work for a lot of people, must those people be deprived of them? And what's the difference between the emotional help they might get from such things as those, and any emotional renewal and fulfilment they might gain by becoming Christians? Should one be tolerated and not the other, or should they both be prohibited?

Go on, laugh at some of those articles if you think things like gang members turning from violence and people feeling healed of emotional pain by taking on a new lifestyle is hilarious. The concepts are similar - adopting a new lifestyle that gives you new optimism about life, new self-worth and so on. Yes, funny isn't it. :rolleyes:

But again, this time, perhaps you could enlighten us all by explaining exactly why you find the idea of people doing such things hilarious? Or if it isn't that but some other aspect of things that's hilarious, perhaps you could explain that? No one's going to know why you find testimonies of gang members giving up violence "hilarious" otherwise.
 
Since Babe Nem appears to be so fond of her imaginary martyrdom, i.e. the idea that any contradiction to her boring, repetitive testimonies constitutes "intolerance of dissent, typical of Communists", I'll restrict myself to repetition, too.
I just don't need to take up as much space as her torrent of words:
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=5098794#post5098794
It's almost a pity that she's given up the torrent of smilies. At least they added some colour to her posts ...
Even the entertainment value of her straw-man tactics becomes a little dull when you've seen them more than once:
"Ha! Those wimpy gang members! Fancy hard men needing an emotional crutch before they could stop being violent!" - but they seem to play an essential part in establishing the self-righteous attitude of a true servant of the Lord.

PS I did not notice till now that Babe Nem replaced all the links she used to have in her sigline to posts in this forum by posts to her own website. I guess that is preferable if you suffer from dissent intolerance.
 
Last edited:
Sorry, but all your Bible quotations, Christian testimonies and other anecdotal evidence just don't cut it against actual research:
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=46293
http://www.randi.org/jr/200510/102105herbs.html#14
http://moses.creighton.edu/JRS/pdf/2005-11.pdf

Thanks for the links, dann.
From the third link:
There is evidence that
within the U.S. strong disparities in religious belief versus acceptance of evolution are correlated
with similarly varying rates of societal dysfunction, the strongly theistic, anti-evolution south and
mid-west having markedly worse homicide, mortality, STD, youth pregnancy, marital and
related problems than the northeast where societal conditions, secularization, and acceptance of
evolution approach European norms (Aral and Holmes; Beeghley, Doyle, 2002). It is the
responsibility of the research community to address controversial issues and provide the
information that the citizens of democracies need to chart their future courses.

I see this is dated 2002.
What's the latest on the subject?
 
Dann,

Your behaviour provides a good lesson in how it's impossible and extremely unwise to judge by appearances/first impressions. When I first came across a few of your posts, I thought, "Hey, here's an enlightened, more compassionate atheist than some on the board, one who understands why people might be attracted to religion, one who thinks it shouldn't be hastily eliminated, but allowed to die a comfortable relaxed death when conditions in the world improve enough that people no longer feel the need for it; one who chides skeptics for ridiculing religious people and thinks a better attitude is 'benign indifference' to religion."

But you've certainly shown your true colours since, haven't you! You find testimonies of people giving up violently hurting people "hilarious". The laughter continues all the way through how one of them talks about how his mother threw him out of the house when he was only eight years old and he grew up fearful and lonely and bitter. Still your laughter continues as he talks about how his gang would commit violence and murder. Your laughter continues as he talks about how he gave up criminality. Yes, never mind how many people could have got hurt who didn't because he was turned away from a life of violence, the whole thing's a big joke to you.

This, appropriately enough, reminds me of the Communism paradox: On the face of it, the desire for a classless society, the concern for people's happiness, a yearning for an improvement in people's living conditions, and an attitude that seems understanding of why they might resort to religious belief, all seem to be indicators of a compassionate mind-set that wants the best for people. How is it, then, that it tends to result in the deaths of millions and millions? The compassion, it seems, is only skin-deep. How can it take such a very secondary place to ideology? When implementing the policies that kill so many people, where is the compassion of those who seemed only to want the people's good? What is the point of the whole thing if it doesn't result in their good?

You're very fond of the accusation of "straw man" (as well as rather more ridiculous ones). The point is that I pointed out in my last post that I had been reduced to guessing about your motives for findding the stories about gangsters giving up violence and so sparing many people who would have been hurt otherwise "hilarious". It is illogical and unintelligent to dismiss such guesses as "straw men". Your arguing style is frankly terrible. You make vague hints about things and silly accusations and expect us to understand your side of the argument just from those, it seems. It's been a long long time since you actually explained your position on anything here clearly, apart from in a few minor things. I suggest you try doing so from now on if you want to make yourself understood.

By the way, you do realise that that Ruthlesscriticism article on what it is to be a Christian was in fact not a representation of reality but a gross and ridiculous caricature, don't you? That is why I found it worthy of no more than making a parody of. Perhaps one in 2 million Christians is genuinely like that. But I can't imagine that many more are! Think about it: Were the Christians you grew up around all like that? If you're honest with yourself, I'll be surprised if you can say yes. If you can, and you're honest with yourself, I'll be surprised if you won't agree that you must have been brought up in a strange fringe set of extremists.

The figures on the correlations between crime/unwanted pregnancies/other types of societal dysfunction and Christian belief have a similar superficial tone to the compassion a first impression of mine credited you with. If you look behind the statistics, and ask yourself whether these people are following New Testament teaching as Christians are instructed to do, which would obviously stop them doing all such things, the answer will clearly be that a lot of them are not. So bringing up such a matter is an utter irrelevance to the issue of gangsters who turn to Christianity, want to follow it devoutly and so in fact do begin to follow it.

It's my belief that Christianity is likely to be in a much healthier state in societies where it is a minority religion, and so a Christian is more likely to have chosen it for themselves and thus will investigate what it actually means to follow Christianity, rather than having been born and raised in it, thinking they're a Christian because they were born into it, but not necessarily having much interest in following its precepts. The very point of me quoting Bible verses was to illustrate this very point - it seems people are not following the Christianity they profess to believe in! Far better that such people learn critical thinking skills and reject Christianity and learn to make discerning decisions about their lives than that they continue in unethical behaviour and thoughtlessness. Far better that Christianity is a minority religion surrounded by atheist critics than that it is the dominant belief and its accountability is compromised because it's so powerful and traditional that no one's asking questions. Far better to have thoughtful reflective atheism than to have mindless conformity to a religion. For one thing, it will likely show a higher education standard.

And now, Dann, I'm going to phrase this in simpler terms than I did before so perhaps you'll understand it better. I hope you heed the advice:

If you do not want me to continue responding to your posts, do not respond to mine. Your responses simply provide momentum for the conversation to continue. Stop responding, and the conversation you appear to dislike so much will naturally peter out. That is simply the law of cause-and-effect in operation.
 
I see this is dated 2002.
What's the latest on the subject?

Are you familiar with Phil Zuckermann's book from October 2008, Society without God: What the Least Religious Nations Can Tell Us About Contentment, which I mentioned in another thread?
It is about Scandinavia, not about the USA, but its theme is the relationship between religion and ”life expectancy, child welfare, literacy, schooling, economic equality, standard of living”.
 
Are you familiar with Phil Zuckermann's book from October 2008, Society without God: What the Least Religious Nations Can Tell Us About Contentment, which I mentioned in another thread?
It is about Scandinavia, not about the USA, but its theme is the relationship between religion and ”life expectancy, child welfare, literacy, schooling, economic equality, standard of living”.

You entirely credit the lack of religion for that then? Nothing to do with your left-wing politics? :D Nothing to do with pre-existing conditions of, and an ethos that promotes, greater social equality, a better educated public, a government that actually looks after its people better in terms of providing healthcare and welfare benefits, and other social factors?

Here's an interesting discussion on another forum where atheists are discussing whether the statistics that would seem to indicate that there are a very low proportion of atheists in American prisons are actually valid. Refreshingly, there's no chest-thumping about atheists being better or anything - it seems to be an honest, frank and objective discussion.
 
Are you familiar with Phil Zuckermann's book from October 2008, Society without God: What the Least Religious Nations Can Tell Us About Contentment, which I mentioned in another thread?
It is about Scandinavia, not about the USA, but its theme is the relationship between religion and ”life expectancy, child welfare, literacy, schooling, economic equality, standard of living”.

Thanks for the heads up, dann.
I'll look into those links this evening.
 
Sounds like an interesting read. A prohibitively expensive one for most people though, it seems.

I had a look to see what the Amazon.co.uk page on it said.

... This fascinating approach directly counters the claims of outspoken, conservative American Christians who argue that a society without God would be hell on earth. It is crucial, Zuckerman believes, for Americans to know that "society without God is not only possible, but it can be quite civil and pleasant."

Shocking! Really?

What, so there are people in America who think a godless society would inevitably make things much worse than they already are in America? Those must have been the people he was writing for!

Actually I remember hearing a song by the Christian artist Carman a while ago about how America was going to the dogs because it was becoming godless. I've found the lyrics.

The song claims:

America is now number one in teen pregnancy and violent crime, number one in illiteracy, drug use, and divorce. Everyday a new holocaust of 5,000 unborn die, while pornography floods our streets like open sewers. America's dead and dying hand is on the threshold of the Church ...

Wow, America is even becoming necrotic?! And to think he's unabashed enough about it to proclaim it to a world audience. ;)

Still, serious problems, clearly!

Part of the chorus goes:

The only hope, for America, is Jesus. The only hope, for our country, is Him.

It never occurred to me to take that literally enough to assume he must be saying,

And now to our politicians: Don't bother tightening gun control - without God, the effort will be futile! Don't bother implementing inner-city regeneration projects - without God, they won't achieve a thing! Don't bother trying to improve standards of education - more godliness is the answer to the mammoth illiteracy problem we have!

And so on. In fact, I don't believe for a moment he was really saying that. :D

It's a long song as it is; but perhaps he could have explained his position more clearly by being less hyperbolic and turning it into a two-hour treatise, going into detail about all the other things that could help solve the problem:

Chorus: We need more godliness; and we need healthcare reform! We need better drug rehabilitation facilities! easily-accessible parenting courses and marriage preparation classes! More rehabilitation efforts in prisons through education and empathy-building and whatever else has been found to work!

It could go on like that for some time. I expect he could think up a decent melody to sing that to. What an awesome song that would have been!

It would have had to have a whole album all to itself!

Could there really be people in America who think it's a simple matter of godliness vs godlessness, and that atheists wouldn't have any interest in social reform, or that social reform wouldn't work because the only thing that would is more godliness, or that social reform isn't necessary because anyone less fortunate can surely sort themselves out if only they put their minds to it so the only problem is making them more motivated to do that, and the only way to do that is making them more godly? Or do they think the only problems America currently has are abortion levels, sexual immorality and too many women in the workplace, and that Christian leaders are more likely to be anti-abortion and anti-teenage sex, so they'll try to mend the only things that ail society, whereas atheist leaders would let the young and everyone else run riot and so bring on a whole load of new social problems? Or what, I wonder.

Surely there can't be that many people who think that simplisticly.

... Oh hang on, didn't I have a conversation a bit like this when I first came here, and it ended up linking to a scary website of quotes from people most likely to feel that way whose views didn't actually make sense? Oh yeah. ... Never mind then; no more questions.
 
Are you familiar with Phil Zuckermann's book from October 2008, Society without God: What the Least Religious Nations Can Tell Us About Contentment, which I mentioned in another thread?
It is about Scandinavia, not about the USA, but its theme is the relationship between religion and ”life expectancy, child welfare, literacy, schooling, economic equality, standard of living”.


Thanks again for the links, dann.
From what I was able to see, they look like interesting reports and I'm looking forward to seeing what kinds of conclusions can be drawn from them.
 
Thanks again for the links, dann.
From what I was able to see, they look like interesting reports and I'm looking forward to seeing what kinds of conclusions can be drawn from them.

After highlighting them so much, I hope you're going to give us an outline of what you discover about their conclusions, and how valid you judge them to be, and the reasons why.

For more information, See this post from a thread of my own:

... "Democracy, middle-class security and a scientific outlook constitute a triple threat to faith so powerful that across the first world it is inflicting severe damage upon popular religiosity, except where economic tribullations perpetuate the dysfunction milieu that popular religion must enjoy if it is to thrive."
"Across the first world, lower income inequality correlates with lower religiosity."
"With its low taxes, relatively high rate of poverty and huge disparity between incomes of the poor and rich, the United States displays greater income disparity than any other industrialized democracy."
"It is no coincidence that religiosity is low in every first-world nation with universal health coverage and high in the only one without it."
"Religion, then, has proved able to thrive only in populations where living conditions are sufficiently defective to cause the majority to resort to petitioning speculative supernatural power for aid." ...

I suspect you have most of your answers. There aren't many people who are going to be scared of the after-life any more when they can look forward to a long life ahead of them because mortality is low below a fairly old age. There aren't many people who are going to be that fervent about praying for help when it's often readily available in the form of free medical care, welfare benefits and the like. There aren't that many people who will retain a devout belief in the supernatural when they've received a scientific education sophisticated enough to make them question things there isn't absolute proof for. When people are generally content with life, and when there are a lot of entertaining and interesting things going on in their lives, they'll often tend to become apathetic about religion.
 
Thanks for the link.
Here's the source for the quotation in the previous post.

From this month's "Free Inquiry
"The Big Religion Questions Finally Solved"/ by Gregory S. Paul

What caught my interest was yet another source cited in that same thread:

http://www.firstthings.com/article/2008/08/003-rapture-and-renewal-in-latin-america-37

Rapture and Renewal in Latin America

This kind of participation, however, is a delicate plant. It can bring about serious and bitter intra-faith divisions (there are four Evangelical political parties in Guatemala, three in Colombia). And it can even have a self-defeating result. President Serrano's fall in Guatemala in 1993 and a botched Evangelical insertion into Peruvian politics with President Alberto Fujimori have given renewed strength to the “politics is of the devil” mentality.

I'm looking forward to reading more on the subject.
 
Last edited:
The article is 12 years old, and much has happened in Latin America - in particular to Alberto Fujimori. (I don't think that he is one of Babe Nem's gangsters persuaded by Christianity to mend his ways.)
 
The article is 12 years old, and much has happened in Latin America - in particular to Alberto Fujimori. (I don't think that he is one of Babe Nem's gangsters persuaded by Christianity to mend his ways.)

Whoops. You were doing so well for a few days at disciplining yourself not to provoke me into responding to you. Now you've made a slip. Try not to let it happen again if you don't want me responding again.

The point of the article, Dann, was not to give a commentary on the activities of various politicians in South America, but to analyse the pros and cons of Christianity that has an apocalyptic bent coming to poorer neighbourhoods. Unlike your rabid hatred, the article manages to analyse the matter in an objective way, putting forward both the advantages and the disadvantages. Advantages in terms of various social improvements people have been motivated to make, and disadvantages in terms of various social problems that have been created. Hooray for willingness to analyse both pros and cons!

So you're still chortling over the testimonies of gangsters who gave up hurting and killing others when they became Christians? Still finding them "Hilarious!"? Still totally missing the point about how utterly absurd it is to scoff at a story of someone turning away from violence because they just didn't do it the way research says violence is reduced in a society, as if you can scold someone eating honey to soothe a sore throat in a healthcare-deprived area by saying, "No, you fool, honey doesn't work that well; what works is a universal healthcare system where the government uses taxes to finance readily-accessible healthcare for all which is free at the point of use. That is what improves the healthcare of a country, and when we've all campaigned hard for decades, perhaps this government will introduce such a system and you'll see!"?

That's hardly going to help the person with the sore throat then and there, is it!

But I expect you're still chortling at that post of mine with the stories in it that said atheists might get some valuable pointers to secular research from Christian testimonies about how people gave up harmful lifestyles and why they found Christianity motivated them to do so. Here's what your attitude seems to be like - here are quotes from my post and an illustration of what you have suggested your response is:

I say in this post

Earlier I linked to the testimony of a former gang boss who gave up his violent ways when he became a Christian.
Here are some ways in which his testimony illustrates that such testimonies could be used to gain insights into ways such people's lives could be changed in secular ways:

He first gives a bit of information about his life story. He blames his behaviour partly on ill-treatment and rejection by his family:

Code:
At home I was totally left out and sent away by my mother. She had called me the “devil’ son”. I never believed that she would get rid of me. The lifestyle and the situation we lived in really had an effect. The feeling of being left out was so terrible for me! It hurt inside and I was fully torn apart. I
was a very lonely BOY on the streets. ...

Since the day when I was 8 years old and my mother threw me out I have rejected everyone who has even tried to show me love. If my mother did not love me I could not expect that any strangers could love me. That’s why I became such a bad man on the streets.

"Hilarious!" shouts Dann.

... It has in fact been found that part of what motivates many teenagers to join gangs is wanting a sense of belonging, to feel as if they're in a family-type group of supportive friends. So one possible solution would be to try to get individuals thought to be at risk of getting involved in gangs and crime and drugs etc. into alternative activities where they'll be mixing with a group of people they'll hopefully make friends with, who have different goals - who are optimistic that they're going places in life, who enjoy harmless activities, and who might make up a solid friendship network for a boy introduced to them.

"Hilarious!" bellows Dann.

The former gang leader also says:

Code:
I never would have thought that Jesus could change my life so completely whatever I have done with my hands and have seen with my eyes. I could never have thought it would be possible that it could be so nice to have a personal 
loving relationship with him so that we can feel so secure and protected and don’t have to fear anything.

Um, surely he's using hyperbole there. Nevertheless, it seems that something he values in his life is security, protection and freedom from fear, along with the feeling of being loved. In a group of supportive friends who regularly do healthy activities, he'd be more likely to get near-equivalents of such
things. But also, such considerations could be taken into account by counsellors/therapists when exploring a delinquent teen's reasons for their misbehaviour with them, and possible solutions could be worked out in collaboration with people like probation officers and community leaders. Here's an example:

"Hilarious!" roars Dann.

There's a book called Solution-Focused Therapy with Children by Matthew Selekman, which contains a story about a ten-year-old boy, who seemed advanced for his age and was hanging around with boys who were involved with gangs, and had been shoplifting for a few years, stealing computer toys. He was also disobedient to his parents and teachers. His parents were at their wits' end and brought him for therapy with the author of the book.

"Hilarious!" yells Dann.

It turned out that in his particular case, that he was being bullied to steal for the older boys, who had told him not to stop or they'd "kick his ass". His parents had had no idea of this. The boy said he'd been scared he'd be caught stealing, and about what the gang would do to him if he stopped.

"Hilarious!" Dann guffaws into his glass.

The therapist and the family met with the boy's probation officer and the school social worker. The probation officer offered to intervene with the older boys on the boy's behalf, and the social worker offered to help out with some means of support and protection.

Another person meeting with the group was the family's church pastor, who offered to get the boy in touch with a certain community leader who was respected by the gangs, who also coached a basketball team the boy could join. The boy was excited about that, since he loved basketball.

"Hilarious!" scoffs Dann.

Some psychologists assert that everyone has certain emotional needs, and recommend that therapists always have conversations with their clients about whether those needs are being met in their lives, no matter what they presented as the problems that had brought them to therapy. According to ... those needs include:

Code:
• the need for security (a stable home life and safe territory to live in); 
• the need for intimacy and friendship; 
• the need to give and receive attention; 
• the need for a sense of autonomy and control; 
• the need to feel connected to others and be part of a wider community; 
• the need to feel competent which comes from successful learning and effectively applying skills (the antidote to ‘low self-esteem’); 
• the need for privacy (to reflect on and consolidate our experiences); 
• and the need to be ‘stretched’ in what we do, from which comes our sense that life is meaningful.

When some of those needs are identified to be lacking, steps can be taken to find ways of improving the person's life with them so those needs are met.

Obviously that won't work for everyone. Some people will be too far-gone to be expected to change just because their environment is changed. Christian testimonies can also give useful insights into that - illustrations of what works and what doesn't for some people.

"Hilarious!" titters Dann.

The testimony also says:

Code:
I wanted to know where this Jesus came from. He [David Wilkerson]began to explain this. Anyone who has read the stories in the New Testament will know what a fascinating person Jesus was and still is today. David started off by talking about him as a human version of God, how he had worked so many miracles which could only happen through the holy power of God. On the other hand he suffered like a person - like Nicky Cruz. However he was only filled with the love of salvation. He always wanted to help and despite this the preacher said: "The human race crucified him!" They were so cruel to him. They did not just want to hurt him but also humiliate him; and then I began to think about how he had felt.

The preacher’s words had hit me hard! He had painted a wonderful picture of Jesus for me.

I had understood how he was ignored and thrown out. I also realised that the people wanted to crucify him; and I could still here my mother’s voice: "You are not my son. I don’t love you. You are the son of Satan!"

I could also hear the voice of society: "Shut him away, kill him, he is sick. He will never amount to anything, he’s too dangerous. The only hope for him is the electric chair!" - Ignored and abandoned! Yes, I knew how Jesus had felt! However there was a big difference between him and me: He was the pure son of God and had sacrificed himself for others.

Nicky Cruz was different! I was a sinner, yes, I was in the clutches of sin and chained by evil.

So he's been faced with the inspirational story of someone who only wanted to help others, and yet was ill-treated and crucified, and yet he's told that this inspirational figure still wants to lovingly change the lives of people other people have rejected - most of them for good reason.

An atheist sociologist/psychologist might be inspired by such testimonies to turn their minds to thinking about how people could be given inspiration on the same theme in secular ways, which they might at least find moving enough so it helps motivate them to change.

For instance, here are a couple of examples of inspirational stories about people who dedicated their lives to trying to improve the lives of prisoners or people on the fringes of the law, and got heavily criticised for it by some, and even threatened with physical attack, and yet they continued to campaign for improvements in other people's welfare.

"Hilarious!" shrieks Dann.

And so on.

I appreciate the styles of those who, even if they seriously disagree with me, take a more insightful and explanatory approach.
 
Last edited:
The article is 12 years old, and much has happened in Latin America - in particular to Alberto Fujimori. (I don't think that he is one of Babe Nem's gangsters persuaded by Christianity to mend his ways.)

Do you have any updates on the pentacostal movement and its influence in South America, dann?
 
I don’t know if Pentecostalism in Latin America is still on the rise in the new millennium. What I’ve been able to find, however, may explain Babe Nem’s affinity for the movement: the combination of Christian testimonies and self-help philosophy, which you also find in the links in Diana Holbourn's links in her sig line.

It would be fair and more precise not to associate the term "neo-Pentecostals" with the Pentecostal movement; perhaps "New Religious Movements" would be more correct. Secondly, there are marked theological differences, even though in matters of ritual there might be common points of emphasis. These New Religious Movements construct their message from a theological perspective that assures converts their lives will improve radically on the material level. This approach has been called the "theology of prosperity".
http://overcomingviolence.org/en/ab...rica/ecumenical-history-of-latin-america.html

This one from a Pentecostal website illustrates the necessity pointed out by Marx in the link I posted earlier in this thread: “The criticism of religion is, therefore, in embryo, the criticism of that vale of tears of which religion is the halo.”
The Pentecostal movement in Latin America has furnished the people with hope in the midst of their suffering.

Some Latin American families have already testified about the Pentecostal movement’s effect on their families. http://www.pctii.org/cyberj/cyberj11/nolivos.html
I.e. mere education that doesn’t abolish the abject poverty of these people will have no effect on their religious sentiments.

This assessment from The Christian Science Monitor sounds very probable:
Pentecostals across the region, most of whom considered themselves Catholics before, say they converted in order to tackle their problems, for a sense of community, or simply because Pentecostalism offered something that the rituals of the Catholic mass did not. Most Pentecostal services today are rollicking events that include 10-piece bands, movie screens, and emotional testimonials – a reflection of society's preferences. It's what Luis Lugo, director of the Pew Forum on Religion & Public Life, calls "bringing the fiesta spirit to church."
Pentecostals have been particularly skilled at reaching out to the region's poor, providing answers to the overwhelming problems their poverty provokes each day. The Catholic answer, in the 1960s, came in the form of "liberation theology," a Marxist-tinged approach to addressing the needs of the oppressed. It had enthusiastic supporters across Latin America, but soon got wrapped up in cold war politics. Religious scholars often quip: "Liberation theology opted for the poor, and the poor opted for Pentecostalism."
"A lot of these folks are marginalized in their own societies, and here come the Pentecostals. They are not just meeting their spiritual needs," says Mr. Lugo, "they are providing them with an outlet for their own leadership. They provide a sense of empowerment, which no doubt has to be very attractive to people when nobody else [pays attention to] them."


I don’t know if this little gem is the reason why Babe Nem is so upset by a quotation mentioning Alberto Fujimori:
Usually those parties and groupings are supported (by the penecostals) which are expected to create conditions which will be favourable to Pentecostal mission and reduce the privileges of the Catholic churches that discriminate against them. So, Alberto Fujimori gained a big proportion of the Pentecostal vote by promising them religious freedom. (62) This development has gone furthest in Brazil as research by P. Freston reveals. (63) After the end of the military dictatorship, a large Pentecostal church put its own candidates forward for the first election to the constitutional assembly without, however, forming its own political party. (64) It is worth noting that, apart from political decisions that directly affected their churches, these Pentecostal deputies did not, as might have been expected, reveal right wing or neo-liberal tendencies. According to a trades union analysis of voting on "questions of interest to workers", the Pentecostals showed a rather centre-left tendency: they scored higher than the established Protestant churches and slightly higher than the average for the parliament. (65) Moreover, the only Protestant deputy for the leftwing Labour Party (PT) was a Pentecostal woman.

However, there is also the possibility of polarization within the Pentecostal movement. This was clearly observable in Chile under the Pinochet dictatorship. On the one hand, in the leadership of the biggest Pentecostal church (the Iglesia Metodista Pentecostal) a so-called pastors' council was founded to support the military junta, which it described as "the answer to the prayers of all believers who consider Marxism to be the highest expression of the Satanic forces of darkness". (66) This council, claiming to speak for all Protestants, conducted an annual thanksgiving service for the regime in the cathedral of the Methodist Pentecostal church; it negotiated for an improvement in the legal status of Protestants and for special state concessions. (67) On the other hand, there is evidence that Pentecostals as a whole certainly did not show a special preference for the Pinochet regime. (68)
http://goliath.ecnext.com/coms2/gi_0199-1758127/The-Pentecostal-movement-and-basic.html
 
Dann said:
I don’t know if Pentecostalism in Latin America is still on the rise in the new millennium. What I’ve been able to find, however, may explain Babe Nem’s affinity for the movement: the combination of Christian testimonies and self-help philosophy, which you also find in the links in Diana Holbourn's links in her sig line....

What, Pentecostalism has an affinity with self-help of the type linked to in my signature? Well there's a thing! But there aren't any Christian testimonies linked to in the links linked to in that. :)

It's nice of you to advertise my signature. :p

I bet people like Joe Griffin and Ivan Tyrrell, Michele Weiner Davis, Thomas J. Harbin, Jim Stringham and David R. Workman didn't know their names were being affiliated with the pentecostal movement though! I'm talking, as you will naturally know, of the authors of the books used as source material for some of the self-help articles linked to in my signature. I'm not entirely sure they'll all be pleased to realise they're part of the movement. :p

So Dann, let's go through the self-help articles linked to in my signature:

Learning to Control Anger that's a pentecostal concern, is it? They're big on that? :D Oh good.

Overcoming Depression and Worry - the Pentecostals are mightily good at that as well?

Protecting Yourself From Being Teased At School - so if your children are being teased, a good strategy will be to send them to the Pentecostals? :)

Conquering Any Kind of Addiction or Craving - everything in that article and the others would be endorsed by the leading Pentecostals of the world, would it? Hey, Pentecostalism must be a fantastic movement! Yep, I must get into it more.

Actually there are a number of other articles in that self-help series which sadly wouldn't fit in my signature, but I presume you'll be able to tell us if the leading Pentecostals of the world endorse them:

Cutting Down Verbal Abuse from Work Colleagues

Yes, they'll be able to help you do that? What a fantastic movement the Pentecostal movement must be!

Healing a Marriage After an Affair

So the Pentecostals are the people to go to if you want to do that, are they, and they'll use the types of self-help in that article? Fantastic! Well, for a rabid anti-Christian militant atheist, you're certainly doing a good job of advertising them! Excellent! :)

How Life Can Improve For People With Anorexia

They're all for helping people with that, are they? Fantastic! Like I said, for a rabid anti-Christian atheist, you're certainly doing a good job of advertising them. Would you now like to tell us exactly where people go for their services? Will any old Pentecostal church do, or are there special Pentecostal therapists who take people through all the steps those articles say will be helpful?

Reducing the Effects of a Life-Threatening Illness

Wow, interesting. Like almost all the rest of the articles in that series, there's no religious content in that at all. One would have thought that since it's so closely affiliated with the Pentecostals, there would at least be something about praying and the laying on of hands. Not a bit of it! Why does their self-help typically contain so little religious content?

Saving a Marriage When a Loved One Wants Divorce

Again, amazingly, no praying in that at all. And that's the kind of therapy you'll get if you go to the Pentecostals? Marvellous! Atheists need have no qualms about queuing up outside Pentecostal churches then to find out more about this non-religious self-help?

Getting More Sex in Marriage

Blimey, the Pentecostals are getting raunchy now! Still no religious content in sight though, bizarrely. Not even a word of prayer for help.

Stopping Worry Ruining Your Life

Awww, how nice of them to be concerned about that. But again, a bit mystifying that there's not one mention of God in there, especially given Bible verses instructing people to give all their worries to God. Is Pentecostal self-help always this devoid of religious content? Do they see the two as being entirely separate for some reason? Why is that?

Recovering from Social Phobia

And how sweet! They'll even help you with that! And again, no religion in sight! Wow! Why don't they integrate God into their self-help?

... Or did you mean a different kind of self-help? What kind?

Dann said:
Code:
It would be fair and more precise not to associate the term "neo-Pentecostals" with the Pentecostal movement; perhaps "New Religious Movements" would be more correct. Secondly, there are marked theological differences, even though in matters of ritual there might be common points of emphasis. These New Religious Movements construct their message from a theological perspective that assures converts their lives will improve radically on the material level.
This approach has been called the "theology of prosperity".

the Prosperity Gospel doesn't seem to be self-help, if you were suggesting that, as this testimony and article can illustrate nicely:

I Received Death Threats From a Prosperity Teacher!
The Gospel of Health and Prosperity.
 
Hi, dann, thanks for the information and the links.
Obviously SA is huge and no analysis of tendencies towards secularisation and its influence can really cover the entire continent.
I found this
Fr. Jose Oscar Beozzo, who directs the Center for Evangelizing Services and Popular Education in São Paulo, told NCR May 10 that between 1980 and 2000, the percentage of the Brazilian population that identifies itself as “Protestant,” with most of that number being Pentecostal, rose from 12 to 17 percent. Over the same period, Beozzo said, the percentage who say they have no religious affiliation went from 0.7 percent to 7.3 percent, a ten-fold increase. Those numbers, he said, come from Brazil’s state-run Institute of Geography and Statistics.

“This is the infinitely more important movement in the Brazilian religious situation,” Beozzo said.

The decline in religious affiliation is unevenly distributed across Brazil, he said. In rural areas, relatively small percentages have abandoned religion, while the total rises in urban zones such as Rio de Janiero, where Beozzo said it’s 15 percent.

What’s especially noteworthy about this phenomenon, which Beozzo said is still growing, is that it’s not really a sign of “secularization” in the classic Western sense, though he said one can find elements of secularization on university campuses and in more middle- and upper-class segments of urban society in Brazil.

For the first time, he said, increasing numbers of Brazilian poor are simply saying that they no longer have any faith.

here
http://209.85.229.132/search?q=cach...+religion&cd=9&hl=en&ct=clnk&gl=es&lr=lang_en

It will be interesting to see where this actually takes the country or if it has any meaningful impact on the country's developement.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom