Prostate Cancer Screening a Bad Idea!?

Summary...


The first study:
1410 men would need to be screened to prevent one death. For each death prevented, 48 people would need to be treated: and prostate cancer treatment has a high risk of very serious side effects like impotence and incontinence.

The second study:
found no difference in death rates between the two groups at all.
 
Fee-For-Service.

:duck:

Irrelevant.

:)

I had a DRE and a PSA as part of what? (Thursday before last)

My annual physical, so my doctor gets what?

Zero compensation for either sticking her finger in the pooper to probe my prostate, or having the lab draw my blood. She also got zero compensation for ordering my colonoscopy.

Do you ever get a new idea?
 
Not at all a delusion. I see my uroligist twice a year (I do have a bad prostate) and the first question he asks is always, "Are you happy with how you pee?" If I am, he does nothing more; if I'm not, he may run a test. At the last visit, I told him I was going to discontinue Flomax to see the effect and he was OK with that. Good doctors are out there - you just have to look.

That's some decision you're making there holler. :)
 
Oops, sorry, I was running late for work and no I didn't.
See posts #51 and #61
No sweat BJ, the info you have provided has been enough to make me decide not to have the test. Now, will my GP listen to me?:D
 
No sweat BJ, the info you have provided has been enough to make me decide not to have the test. Now, will my GP listen to me?:D

I hope the decision was your own, and not influenced by anything more than THE INFORMATION...and not an internet opinion, either mine or anyone elses.

TAM:)
 
I hope the decision was your own, and not influenced by anything more than THE INFORMATION...and not an internet opinion, either mine or anyone elses.

TAM:)

My concern here is the risk of overdiagnosis and the ensuing biopsy etc.
I had a vasectomy about 22 years ago, I don't know if this is relevant here, I just thought I state it.
I have not had any problems urinating, and the urine stream is strong and uninterupted although my wife complains that my aim is poor.
I do not need to shake more than three times after urination and I don't leak urine after I have zipped up.
These are the reasons I have decided to refuse the test.
If I was your patient, would you try to dissuade me from taking this decision?
 
If you were my patient, this is what I would say (assuming you are over 50)...

(Of course, articulation is a little easier on paper/computer, then in real life, but it would hopefully go something like the below)

-------------

Mr. Skwinty, you are over the age of 50, and as a result, you presently fall into the recommended screening guidelines for an annual DRE and PSA blood test. There is still a fair bit of controversy over the necessity of these tests/procedures. The reason for the controversy is due to the possibility of false positives (the test says you have cancer, but you do not) and false negatives (the test says you do not have cancer, but you do). Both false positives and false negatives occur in a small percentage of cases. There are also side effects / risks associated with procedures that might be suggested from the results of the DRE and PSA, so you must take this into account as well.

If you have the DRE and PSA done, and either comes back suspicious for Prostate CA (a nodule on your prostate or a PSA > 10) then I will be referring you to a Urologist for a follow up DRE, and based on his assessment, he may, or may not, recommend an ultrasound of your prostate. Based on that, a possible biopsy of your prostate may be recommended. The Urologist can inform you of the risks of that procedure when you visit him.

Most cases of prostate CA present WITHOUT urinary symptoms such as change to flow, etc...

If you decide not to have the tests done, then there will be no way of us screening you for early detection. Prostate Ca, in most cases, is a slow growing cancer, taking some times more than 10-15 years to metastasize to other areas of the body.

---------

From there, more might be said based on the questions/exchange.

TAM:)
 
Last edited:
T.A.M.,

With that information I think your patient is going to have the test. ;)
As a matter of of interest what percentage of your patients do have the test done?



On the other hand, Dr Ben Goldacre, would probably say something along these lines:

There are two recent clinical trials exploring this question:
The first study involved 160,000 men and concluded that:
1410 men would need to be screened with a PSA test to prevent 1 death. For each death prevented, 48 people would need to be treated: and prostate cancer treatment has a high risk of very serious side effects like impotence (1 in 4) and incontinence (1 in 20).
The second, involving 75,000 men, concluded that:
There was no difference in death rates between those who had the PSA test and those who did not have the PSA test.

If you gave your patients this up to date information, what percentage of them do you think would have the test now? ;)


you presently fall into the recommended screening guidelines for an annual DRE and PSA blood test.
As a matter off interest, have you ever looked into the reasons why they make these recommendations, which are given despite there being no evidence for them. Some of the colleges even admit that there is no evidence to support their recommendations.
(I wonder if they will revise their opinion in the light of these recent studies.)

regards,
BillyJoe
 
Is there anything to the notion that a lack of sexual activity increases the risk of prostate cancer? I have heard of this correlation, but wondered if decreased sexual activity was a cause or an effect or a coincidence?
 
BJ:

Most patients, in my experience, will get the test regardless of the "# to treat" to prevent death. Most patients hear "Cancer Screening" and say,

"Well of course I am going to get it done."

The other problem is that you may want to discuss not doing the tests with your patient, and that is fine, but I wager good money they are back in your office within the week, angry that you advised against doing a test that all of their friends had done by their doctors.

Does this make it right? of course not, but you try to convince the patient otherwise, and good luck not having them sue you if one of them ends up with the cancer.

I am not arguing that the evidence for screening is good...it isn't. As you and others have pointed out, the number to treat is high, and the unintended results of the treatment can be quite debilitating (incontinence, impotence). However, unless there is good evidence NOT to include the screening (Level D or E), the colleges will continue to include it, which means most docs will do it, which will place enormous pressure on those who wish not to.

Sucks really.

TAM:)

As an aside, I noticed neither of your quoted studies are evaluating the combination of DRE and PSA.
 
Is there anything to the notion that a lack of sexual activity increases the risk of prostate cancer? I have heard of this correlation, but wondered if decreased sexual activity was a cause or an effect or a coincidence?

I have seen no compelling data to indicate such. In general, it is believed that active use of the prostate (through sex, masterbation, etc...) is overall good for prostate health.

TAM:)
 
I have seen no compelling data to indicate such. In general, it is believed that active use of the prostate (through sex, masterbation, etc...) is overall good for prostate health.

TAM:)

OK, so there’s sex and masturbation. Could you elucidate on the “etc”.
 
Sorry, this WAS going to be a short reply...

T.A.M.,

That was a very good response, thanks.
I was thinking about what your response might be on my Sunday morning walk over the Dandenongs, and you seem to have covered all the issues.
A few little quibbles though.

Most patients, in my experience, will get the test regardless of the "# to treat" to prevent death. Most patients hear "Cancer Screening" and say, "Well of course I am going to get it done."

Two things:
I think you actually raise the question of the PSA test with your patients rather than wait for them to raise it with you. Is that right? In doing so, you are following the recommendations of your college to be proactively encouraging patients to have the test. As I mentioned before, the reverse applies in Australia. However, in Australia, the media has hijacked this issue and have done so for many years. One particular celebrity actually has his DRE done on camera whilst he tells all the males out there to have their prostate checked. So here it is probably the case that the patient, prompted by the media, goes to see his GP to have his prostate checked.
Secondly, I still think it's important the patient is told the facts in an easily digestible form even if they do all end up having the test. While reading what you tell your patients my eyes were glazing over, hey, let's just get it over with doc!

The other problem is that you may want to discuss not doing the tests with your patient, and that is fine, but I wager good money they are back in your office within the week, angry that you advised against doing a test that all of their friends had done by their doctors.
As I said, you read my mind.
Once the husband has been sent in by the wife after seeing the media promptings, he's not going to leave till he has it done.

Does this make it right? of course not, but you try to convince the patient otherwise, and good luck not having them sue you if one of them ends up with the cancer.
Again, you read my mind.
Yes, even your college is against you here.
(Is does puzzle me that they make the recommendation though whilst admitting the evidence is not there)

I am not arguing that the evidence for screening is good...it isn't. As you and others have pointed out, the number to treat is high, and the unintended results of the treatment can be quite debilitating (incontinence, impotence). However, unless there is good evidence NOT to include the screening (Level D or E), the colleges will continue to include it, which means most docs will do it, which will place enormous pressure on those who wish not to.
In Australia, the college of GPs do not recommend it, but the specialist college does. But really it's all driven by the media. And there's also a little subversive activity by pharmaceutical companies via sponsorship of the patient advocate organisation, "The Prostate Cancer Foundation of Australia" (inapropriately named in my opinion), and sponsorship of CME activities, and financial support of Urologists who push the view that prostate cancer can be cured with surgery despite the lack of evidence.
I guess it also seems reasonable on the part of patients to assume that diagnosing prostate cancer early and treating it early would increase your chances of survival.

As an aside, I noticed neither of your quoted studies are evaluating the combination of DRE and PSA.
You are right. And I think someone pointed that out before. I wonder if anyone has done a study to see how more effective PSA plus DRE is compared with just PSA. And I'm wondering if the outcome would be any different. My first past test suggests to me that it wouldn't, but I might revisit this at some stage.

regards,
BillyJoe
 
Last edited:
<snip>

Two things:
I think you actually raise the question of the PSA test with your patients rather than wait for them to raise it with you. Is that right? In doing so, you are following the recommendations of your college to be proactively encouraging patients to have the test. As I mentioned before, the reverse applies in Australia. However, in Australia, the media has hijacked this issue and have done so for many years. One particular celebrity actually has his DRE done on camera whilst he tells all the males out there to have their prostate checked. So here it is probably the case that the patient, prompted by the media, goes to see his GP to have his prostate checked.
Secondly, I still think it's important the patient is told the facts in an easily digestible form even if they do all end up having the test. While reading what you tell your patients my eyes were glazing over, hey, let's just get it over with doc!

1. As I said, in a real life interview/patient encounter, I would be less formal, more off the cuff, and try to shorten my explanation to the bare essentials.

2. It is a tough issue. Going against the recommendation not only of your own college, but that of the Urlogist's college, puts you not only in the minority, and hence you will get flack from many patients, as they hear of all of their friends getting the tests, but also gives you little leg to stand on should you be sued.

As I said, you read my mind.
Once the husband has been sent in by the wife after seeing the media promptings, he's not going to leave till he has it done.

Again, you read my mind.
Yes, even your college is against you here.
(Is does puzzle me that they make the recommendation though whilst admitting the evidence is not there)

I suspect they recommend it because there are more factors at play then just the utility of the test from a strict medical pov.

One caveot. The present guidelines (PDF),

http://www.topalbertadoctors.org/PDF/complete set/Prostate Cancer/prostate_cancer_guideline.pdf

Do not DIRECTLY recommend PSA as routine screening (though they do for high risk, select groups, etc...), but they recommend "Discussing" it with men who express an interest in it.

I suppose in that regard, I am a little strong handed in suggesting it to my patients, but rather, perhaps, "discussing" it with them...lol In a perfect world...

In Australia, the college of GPs do not recommend it, but the specialist college does. But really it's all driven by the media. And there's also a little subversive activity by pharmaceutical companies via sponsorship of the patient advocate organisation, "The Prostate Cancer Foundation of Australia" (inapropriately named in my opinion), and sponsorship of CME activities, and financial support of Urologists who push the view that prostate cancer can be cured with surgery despite the lack of evidence.
I guess it also seems reasonable on the part of patients to assume that diagnosing prostate cancer early and treating it early would increase your chances of survival.

I am not sure about the Pharmaceutical involvement, although I see none visible from my end, i suppose at the specialist end their might be some. You are correct about the media.

The media is the reason why, despite little evidence to back it up, women in my practice will not here tell of even the suggestion of HRT (a new kettle of fish I do not wish to get into here).

You are right. And I think someone pointed that out before. I wonder if anyone has done a study to see how more effective PSA plus DRE is compared with just PSA. And I'm wondering if the outcome would be any different. My first past test suggests to me that it wouldn't, but I might revisit this at some stage.

regards,
BillyJoe

From the same guidelines above, the recommendation seems to be a PSA done if a DRE results in an abnormal finding...if that helps.

This very topic, and the obvious lengthy discussion you could have with your patients, runs right into the other discussion we were having on the forum...that of Fee For Service, versus Salaried. Very few FFS GPs will have the time to discuss the Prostate Screening Guidelines with their patients. You can see above that the number of issues, and decisions, would easily dwarf a 10-15 minute visit to the GP, especially if the end result, results in wanting a DRE performed.

TAM:)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom