Prostate Cancer Screening a Bad Idea!?

My doctor recommended a PSA test just yesterday, and she will draw blood on Monday for a PSA and for glucose average.
I am 55 and have not had a PSA before although I had PRE about 7 years ago.
Will this PSA test be of value to me?
If you have a cancer growing in your prostate, definitely. If not, no it won't be.:)
 
Fee-For-Service.

:duck:

I'll throw more than a tomato at you in a minute;)

I performed rectal exams on all of my male patients over 50y when I was a salaried physician.

The insinuation that my decision to perform rectal exams on patients would be money driven is insulting...again.

TAM
 
I don't understand the "harm" part. Except for the cost (and that is a legitimate concern), there is no harm at all in my knowing my PSA. I get it as part of the same bloodletting that I go through several times a year for other tests. If my PSA is high, then I can discuss with my urologist whether a biopsy is warranted. If we decide yes, than again I can think about whether surgery is in the cards.

Were I such a sheep that I would blindly follow the doctor's recommendation, then the story would be different, but one of the first questions I always ask a new doctor is whether I am allowed to ask questions and participate in the choice of treatment.

The "harm" issue relates to unneeded procedures such as TRUS +/- Biopsy, etc... The Biopsy is not without its possible complications.

The other issue is a false sense of security when the tests are "normal" because they are vulnerable to false negatives.

I can only tell you what the typical procedure is in my clinic.

A male patient over the age of 50 will be ADVISED to have an annual PSA and DRE done. If either of these come back abnormal, they are sent to a urologist for a second assessment. From there, the Urologist will decide what to do. If the PSA is less than 4, typically observation is all that is needed. If there is a definite prostate nodule, typically a TRUS is done, and based on what that reveals, a bx.

TAM:)
 
That depends on the type of tumor:

There is a valid point here (surprisingly...:D)

The biggest issue with prostate CA is that most cases occur in the elderly, and most cases are of a slow growing nature. The general rule of thumb is that if you are age>70 you will likely die of something else before the Prostate Cancer will kill you.

Unfortunately, there is a subtype of Prostate Cancer which effects younger men, and a subtype that is a very aggressive form of the disease. It is for these reasons that the screening proponents yell so loudly. The trouble is, to distinguish between the two, you need to get pathology specimens (Biopsies), and in so doing, you are inadvertently going to perform Biopsies on people who will have the slow growing version.

TAM:)
 
I'll throw more than a tomato at you in a minute;)

I performed rectal exams on all of my male patients over 50y when I was a salaried physician.

The insinuation that my decision to perform rectal exams on patients would be money driven is insulting...again.

TAM

So you weren't making money hand over fist from the tests then?

:eye-poppi
 
The "harm" issue relates to unneeded procedures such as TRUS +/- Biopsy, etc... The Biopsy is not without its possible complications.

The other issue is a false sense of security when the tests are "normal" because they are vulnerable to false negatives.

I can only tell you what the typical procedure is in my clinic.

A male patient over the age of 50 will be ADVISED to have an annual PSA and DRE done. If either of these come back abnormal, they are sent to a urologist for a second assessment. From there, the Urologist will decide what to do. If the PSA is less than 4, typically observation is all that is needed. If there is a definite prostate nodule, typically a TRUS is done, and based on what that reveals, a bx.

TAM:)

But, that's my point. My urologist does not decide diddly. We decide. I own my body and I own the consequences of bad decisions.
 
My doctor recommended a PSA test just yesterday, and she will draw blood on Monday for a PSA and for glucose average.
I am 55 and have not had a PSA before although I had PRE about 7 years ago.
Will this PSA test be of value to me?

It appears not.

The insinuation that my decision to perform rectal exams on patients would be money driven is insulting...again.

TAM

I think you'll find Ivor was having a dig at Yanks getting the exam for fun rather than casting aspersions at doctors, but I'll let him confirm.
 
I hope this helps..

I don't understand the "harm" part...there is no harm at all in my knowing my PSA.

If your PSA level is high enough to suggest that you might have prostate cancer, the next step is to consider a biopsy of the prostate. If you decide not to have a biopsy, you are left with the uneasy feeling that you might still have prostate cancer. That is a harm. If you do have the biopsy, you have a 1 in a 100 chance of septicaemia which will result in your admission to hospital for intravenous antibiotics. That is a harm. If the biopsy result is negative, you have had a biopsy with no benefit compared with if you didn't have the PSA in the first place. If your biopsy is positive, you are now living with prostate cancer. If there is no evidence that treating prostate cancer is going to decrease your chances of survival, living with the knowledge you have prostate cancer is a harm. If you decide against treatment of the prostate cancer, you are living with the knowledge that you have prostate cancer and have left it untreated and, even though you know that there is no evidence that treatment will make any difference, that is a harm. If you do have the prostate cancer treated, you may end up with impotence and incontinence. That is a harm, especially if it turns out the treatment will have made no difference to the outcome. And this is true even if you have no complications whatsoever.

If my PSA is high, then I can discuss with my urologist whether a biopsy is warranted. If we decide yes, than again I can think about whether surgery is in the cards.

You need to think about this BEFORE you have your PSA.
(see above)

Were I such a sheep that I would blindly follow the doctor's recommendation, then the story would be different,

Whose recommendation would you rather blindly follow? :D

but one of the first questions I always ask a new doctor is whether I am allowed to ask questions and participate in the choice of treatment

I am sorry, but your participation in the decision is just an illusion and no amount of political correctness can change that fact. ;)


regards,
BillyJoe
 
Most Americans of my age seem to have this sort of exam as a routine annual event, whereas it seems rare in Britain. I just wonder what part of that is a training recommendation and what is just cultural reluctance on the part of both doctor and patient.

The Australian and British colleges do not recommnend it BECAUSE there is no evidence of benefit.
The American college recommnends it DESPITE the lack of evidence.
Take your pick.

BJ
 
The Australian and British colleges do not recommnend it BECAUSE there is no evidence of benefit.
The American college recommnends it DESPITE the lack of evidence.
Take your pick.

BJ

and Canada is somewhere in between. I personally recommend both, but I do explain to my patients the pros and cons.

TAM:)
 
I can only tell you what the typical procedure is in my clinic.

A male patient over the age of 50 will be ADVISED to have an annual PSA and DRE done. If either of these come back abnormal, they are sent to a urologist for a second assessment. From there, the Urologist will decide what to do. If the PSA is less than 4, typically observation is all that is needed. If there is a definite prostate nodule, typically a TRUS is done, and based on what that reveals, a bx.

TAM:)

Your clinic obviously follows the American way of doing things. :D
 
I hope you enjoy your delusion :)

Not at all a delusion. I see my uroligist twice a year (I do have a bad prostate) and the first question he asks is always, "Are you happy with how you pee?" If I am, he does nothing more; if I'm not, he may run a test. At the last visit, I told him I was going to discontinue Flomax to see the effect and he was OK with that. Good doctors are out there - you just have to look.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom