Prostate Cancer Screening a Bad Idea!?

The triumph of The Anecdote. :cool:

2 billion christians can't be wrong!

NPR (US National Public Radio) had a story about this, the conclusion, it was a treat 50 to save one sort of option.

That appears to be the issue.

In my kind of language, you're betting a pellet of some radioactive **** up your arse on a 50:1 chance of dying.

Interesting version of Pascal's Wager - he would've taken the pellet.
 
My GP is a not unattractive lady.
She has never offered and I have not asked.

She does seem very keen that I should take statins though.

One wonders whether GPs would be more proactive in prostate examination if the Latex glove manufacturers gave them more freebies?
 
Well given all the "freebies" that Pfizer and others give me, go straight to those who cannot afford the meds, and have no insurance, I suppose I could start giving out free latex gloves with their Lipitor samples (if such a push by the latex glove company occurs).

TAM:D
 
But as noted above, it's only an anecdote, like mine - I chose to not trust the odds, I beat that cancer.


But you have still missed the point.

How do you know you have beaten the cancer?
How do you know how it would have turned out without the surgery?
How do you know what morbidity or mortality you would have suffered without surgery compared with surgery?

BJ
 
My GP is a not unattractive lady.
She has never offered and I have not asked.

That, most likely, is because that's what her college recommends.
There is insufficient evidence to recommend DRE and PSA so the colleges don't recommend it and therefore she doesn't recommend it to you.
However, if you ask her, and if she is a good physician, she will discuss with you the pros and cons of the procedures and leave it to you to decide whether you will have it done or not - because that is what the college recommends based on the lack of evidence for its value.

I hope all this is starting to make sense for everyone. :)

BillyJoe
 
Last edited:
But you have still missed the point.

How do you know you have beaten the cancer?
How do you know how it would have turned out without the surgery?
How do you know what morbidity or mortality you would have suffered without surgery compared with surgery?

BJ
Sorry thought I made it clear - I take a psa blood test (this is what I did not add) every six months - no p cancer cells in it for four years. Once the cancer breaks through the capsule, cancer cells start moving through the body and lodge in other places where they can start new cancers - I was under 6 months from that max (the Dr. - evidently thinking I was more nervous than I actually was told me the first time I saw him after the surgery that it had been close but not yet a problem. It was four visits - each time when he would casually say where it had been it got closer. Finally told me one of the two had been in but not broken through the capsule. Because of choosing surgery, I appear to have no chance of cancer from that batch. When they first found cancer cells (due to my reg. doctors suggestion to have checked) the urologist/surgeon said I could easily wait for five years with under 20% chance anything would occur before then. Had I done that I would very likely not be with us (80% chance). Like I said and another first, just an anecdote - but, at the end of my anecdote, I'm one of the ones who the odds were actually very against but because I went with the very safe choice at each point I'm still here. I like it here.

I hear you on the anecdote point, but I like the end of it I am on in this situation.:):):):)
 
Out of curiosity.
I'm 54. I moved GP about five years ago from one 4-5 person practice to another.
Not one of those doctors that I've seen has ever suggested a prostate exam, though proactive mens' health care seems to be a big thing these days.
Maybe as BJ says they simply think it's not worth it, but I seriously wonder if there's simply a reluctance to carry out a test that can't be fun for either party, whereas there's no similar reluctance to dole out statins? (A surprisingly high number of people I know aged over 45 has been put on these things in the last year. Billyjoe will tell me this is anecdotal of course, which means it's not happening.)
 
Wasn't the publication all about PSA? I know having a blood sample taken isn't top of everybody's fun list, but it's not that bad.

Rolfe.
 
Funnily enough, once on statins, my GP wants blood tests every 3 months.
I'm a regular blood donor. Blood tests don't bother me in the least. But the bloods are done by the surgery nurse, not by the GP.
Having a mother of two stick her finger where the sun don't shine would bother me a bit. I just wonder how much it bothers her and her colleagues.
Seriously- some tests are easier / less unpleasant than others. Are doctors statistically likely to use them more , or use the unpleasant ones less than optimal?
I dunno, but it seems a reasonable question.

Possibly less reasonable is the question - and how much are NHS trusts paid for blood tests?
Given your comments about the vet tests, this one seems worth asking too.
 
Last edited:
Out of curiosity.
I'm 54. I moved GP about five years ago from one 4-5 person practice to another. Not one of those doctors that I've seen has ever suggested a prostate exam, though proactive mens' health care seems to be a big thing these days.
Maybe as BJ says they simply think it's not worth it,

Yes, the evidence is that it is not worth doing a DRE and PSA. The colleges therefore do not recommend to GPs that these procedures be done but, if the patient asks, they suggest GPs discus the pros and cons and let the patient make the decision. Interestingly the specialist colleges (Urology) do recommend it even though they agree there is insufficient evidence to support the activity. This is probably why the public gets a mixed message.

but I seriously wonder if there's simply a reluctance to carry out a test that can't be fun for either party,

I cannot see how this could be the case when the colleges recommend against this and yet patients are being diagnosed with non-symptomatic prostate cancer every day.

whereas there's no similar reluctance to dole out statins? (A surprisingly high number of people I know aged over 45 has been put on these things in the last year. Billyjoe will tell me this is anecdotal of course, which means it's not happening.)

I think the figures support your anecdotal evidence in this case. :)
You are off topic though. ;)

BJ
 
Wasn't the publication all about PSA? I know having a blood sample taken isn't top of everybody's fun list, but it's not that bad.

Yes, it is about the PSA test, but DRE goes hand in...um...hand with the PSA test.
 
Sorry thought I made it clear - I take a psa blood test (this is what I did not add) every six months - no p cancer cells in it for four years. Once the cancer breaks through the capsule, cancer cells start moving through the body and lodge in other places where they can start new cancers - I was under 6 months from that max (the Dr. - evidently thinking I was more nervous than I actually was told me the first time I saw him after the surgery that it had been close but not yet a problem. It was four visits - each time when he would casually say where it had been it got closer. Finally told me one of the two had been in but not broken through the capsule. Because of choosing surgery, I appear to have no chance of cancer from that batch. When they first found cancer cells (due to my reg. doctors suggestion to have checked) the urologist/surgeon said I could easily wait for five years with under 20% chance anything would occur before then. Had I done that I would very likely not be with us (80% chance). Like I said and another first, just an anecdote - but, at the end of my anecdote, I'm one of the ones who the odds were actually very against but because I went with the very safe choice at each point I'm still here. I like it here.

I hear you on the anecdote point, but I like the end of it I am on in this situation.:):):):)


I still think you missed the point. :o


Edited to add:
My father died of pneumonia due to lung cancer, but he was diagnosed with prostate cancer some months before that. So I have given the question of prostate cancer screening considerable thought. I feel I can't do better than follow the college's recommendation. If they change their opinion after this extra bit of evidence - which I doubt - I will take a deep beath and....
 
Last edited:
I don't understand the "harm" part. Except for the cost (and that is a legitimate concern), there is no harm at all in my knowing my PSA. I get it as part of the same bloodletting that I go through several times a year for other tests. If my PSA is high, then I can discuss with my urologist whether a biopsy is warranted. If we decide yes, than again I can think about whether surgery is in the cards.

Were I such a sheep that I would blindly follow the doctor's recommendation, then the story would be different, but one of the first questions I always ask a new doctor is whether I am allowed to ask questions and participate in the choice of treatment.
 
You are off topic though ;)

BJ

OK dat be true, but the drift from blood test to DRE was started before I chimed in, and the question of what tests meds prefer to perform seems related.

There also seems (and this IS anecdotal) to be big national variation in the DRE test. Most Americans of my age seem to have this sort of exam as a routine annual event, whereas it seems rare in Britain. I just wonder what part of that is a training recommendation and what is just cultural reluctance on the part of both doctor and patient.
 
OK dat be true, but the drift from blood test to DRE was started before I chimed in, and the question of what tests meds prefer to perform seems related.

There also seems (and this IS anecdotal) to be big national variation in the DRE test. Most Americans of my age seem to have this sort of exam as a routine annual event, whereas it seems rare in Britain. I just wonder what part of that is a training recommendation and what is just cultural reluctance on the part of both doctor and patient.

Fee-For-Service.

:duck:
 
My doctor recommended a PSA test just yesterday, and she will draw blood on Monday for a PSA and for glucose average.
I am 55 and have not had a PSA before although I had PRE about 7 years ago.
Will this PSA test be of value to me?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom