One of the (myriad) rasons why I left my job after we were taken over by a big pushy American outfit was their insistence on trying to push pointless "screening" testing for pets on the unsuspecting animal owners. Moral blackmail was heavily in evidence (for example sending out anaesthetic request form pro-formas to practices that included the requirement for a signature to confirm that the owner was rejecting the recommendation for this useless testing).
An Arts graduate was heavy on the line that "but isn't it worth it, just to be sure?", and when I pointed out that no way did those tests provide certainty about anything, she switched to "but isn't it worth it, even if we only pick up one in a million? It's worth it for that one, surely?" Attempts to point out the counterbalance of all the upset caused by the inevitable false alarms, and the cost of the whole thing, simply weren't understood. Well, of course the cost of the whole thing was a big plus in her mind - because it was her company, the one pushing the tests, who would be getting all the money.
In the end, I was told to shut up because the interestes of the shareholders were paramount over the interests of the pets or their owners. That's about when I left.
What really bugs me is that many of my professional colleagues have bought into this crap, see it as a moneymaker for themselves too, and then criticise me for arguing against it. Right, the word of a specialist in the subject, who is arguing against her own financial self-interest, is trumped by the word of an Arts graduate who is aguing from her own financial self-interest.
Sorry, I'll stop ranting now. But you know, the whole screeing concept isn't as straightforward as it may often appear.
Rolfe.