Prostate Cancer Screening a Bad Idea!?

The Atheist

Psychopath
Joined
Jul 3, 2006
Messages
38,190
Now, I know a bloke who gets his prostate checked once a week, but for most of us, it's been a PSA test, followed by a biopsy if it's abnormal.

It seems that this may all be in vain, and actually costing a lot of men a lot of pain and discomofrt they needn't have.

The case certainly isn't closed, but the study of 250,000 men across multiple countries seems pretty solid.
 
No, the US data implies it is, the European implies not/less so. As a person who had it found by that and found ithe tumors were almost through the capsule when it was removed (through the capsule would have been A Very Bad Thing) I am in favor of them. To each his own, though.
 
As a person who had it found by that and found ithe tumors were almost through the capsule when it was removed (through the capsule would have been A Very Bad Thing) I am in favor of them. To each his own, though.


The triumph of The Anecdote. :cool:
 
The evidence does not support DRE and PSA according to the RACGP in Australia who therefore do not recommend screening for prostate cancer to GPs. Some prominent Urologists, a well known parmaceutical company via their sponsorship of a prostate awareness group, the Prostate Cancer Foundation of Australia, and the media seem to believe otherwise. They apparently do not believe in evidence though.
 
In Canada, there does not seem to be a 100% uniform consensus, however, most of us will suggest to our patients an annual DRE (Digital Rectal Exam) and PSA from age 50-70. We start younger if there is a 1st degree relative with a history of Prostate CA. In that case, we start the annual screening when the patient is 10 years younger than the relative was when they were diagnosed.

TAM:)

Edit:

Here is a great little page with a summary of study evidence for various Cancer screenings.

http://www.phac-aspc.gc.ca/publicat/cdic-mcc/19-3/e_e.html

TAM:)
 
Last edited:
The issue as already mentioned by Dr. Yaffle is that PSA/prostate screening is not very specific so it has a tendency of picking up false positives in a large population. The balance between detecting disease early vs. false tests leading unnecesary testing and anxiety is often the subjective component.
 
I think the real issue is this:

With both cancers [breast and prostate], researchers say they badly need a way to distinguish tumors that would be deadly without treatment from those that would not.

ETA: Beaten to it!
 
NPR (US National Public Radio) had a story about this, the conclusion, it was a treat 50 to save one sort of option.

The doctor they interviewed said that the PSA should be checked again after an interval, it it was rising then a biopsy might be warranted. Then further monitoring unless the 'Gleason' of the biopsy was super positive.

They also said that the age and other factors (other conditions) needed to be considered as well, in that often other condistions would killl the patient first.

But NPR is a well known source of socialist and left wing biased reporting. ( ;) )
 
One of the (myriad) rasons why I left my job after we were taken over by a big pushy American outfit was their insistence on trying to push pointless "screening" testing for pets on the unsuspecting animal owners. Moral blackmail was heavily in evidence (for example sending out anaesthetic request form pro-formas to practices that included the requirement for a signature to confirm that the owner was rejecting the recommendation for this useless testing).

An Arts graduate was heavy on the line that "but isn't it worth it, just to be sure?", and when I pointed out that no way did those tests provide certainty about anything, she switched to "but isn't it worth it, even if we only pick up one in a million? It's worth it for that one, surely?" Attempts to point out the counterbalance of all the upset caused by the inevitable false alarms, and the cost of the whole thing, simply weren't understood. Well, of course the cost of the whole thing was a big plus in her mind - because it was her company, the one pushing the tests, who would be getting all the money.

In the end, I was told to shut up because the interestes of the shareholders were paramount over the interests of the pets or their owners. That's about when I left.

What really bugs me is that many of my professional colleagues have bought into this crap, see it as a moneymaker for themselves too, and then criticise me for arguing against it. Right, the word of a specialist in the subject, who is arguing against her own financial self-interest, is trumped by the word of an Arts graduate who is aguing from her own financial self-interest.

Sorry, I'll stop ranting now. But you know, the whole screeing concept isn't as straightforward as it may often appear.

Rolfe.
 
Sorry, I'll stop ranting now. But you know, the whole screeing concept isn't as straightforward as it may often appear.

Rolfe.

Amen, and Prostate CA is one of the murkiest of the lot.

TAM:)
 
You do realize that rectal exams for prostate cancer is as effective as voodoo?:o

Actually, I know a professional dominatrix who had a regular client she used to anally "fist." One session, she noticed that his prostate did not feel as it normally did, and told him he should see his doctor at once.

It was indeed prostate cancer, and an aggressive sort. And he was dead within the year.
 
Actually, I know a professional dominatrix who had a regular client she used to anally "fist." One session, she noticed that his prostate did not feel as it normally did, and told him he should see his doctor at once.

It was indeed prostate cancer, and an aggressive sort. And he was dead within the year.
And still so many people think fisting is a bad thing.........

It's good to find a professional that attuned to what they are doing!

But as noted above, it's only an anecdote, like mine - I chose to not trust the odds, I beat that cancer.
 
Actually, I know a professional dominatrix who had a regular client she used to anally "fist." One session, she noticed that his prostate did not feel as it normally did, and told him he should see his doctor at once.

It was indeed prostate cancer, and an aggressive sort. And he was dead within the year.

It's posts like this that put the 'E' in JREF.:D

Anyone know what the adverts at the top of the page for visitors who are not logged-in are?
 
One of the (myriad) rasons why I left my job after we were taken over by a big pushy American outfit was their insistence on trying to push pointless "screening" testing for pets on the unsuspecting animal owners.

That would be like pushy doctors pushing expensive prostate cancer drugs like Elityran or Casodex when "patients" don't really need them, because the doctors are "rewarded" by big pushy pharmaceutical companies :eek:

I'm sure these things belong in fiction :D
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom