Project for the New American Century

"The history of the 20th century should have taught us that it is important to shape circumstances before crises emerge, and to meet threats before they become dire."

I'm only on the first page... and already I have another gem. What new defense strategy is the US employing globally... but the preemptive strike and/or invasion tactic. We saw it with Iraq, and now we will see it with Iran.

This fits perfectly with the founding principles of the PNAC.

The idea that the US should take the fight to the enemy is not a new one. It has been around since the mid-nineteenth century, when military strategists favored creating a strong navy that could take the fight anywhere on the globe. This way, wars would be fought overseas, rather than on US soil.

How is this different from the Bush Doctrine? It's not that different, really, but I think the drafters of this strategy had in mind something a little more provocative than a suspicion of weapons of mass destruction as an excuse to strike an enemy on the other side of the world.

Is is wrong to prefer to fight on someone else's soil, rather than on our own? Perhaps, but I think anyone would prefer to wreck someone else's country, given a choice. It's just a matter of what we would find acceptable as a triggering event before we would go to war in this manner. I think history will show that the triggering event of the Iraq war was pretty weak.
 
What the hell was vietnam if it wasn't an attempt to stop the spread of communism?

Pre-emptive action isn't new and what PNAC was proposing was hardly rocket science.

Given that the most recent wars the US has been involved in are contrary to the PNAC doctrine of technology over humans, it seems that the PNAC experiment has failed.
 
I´m guessing here but to me it sounds like the invasion in
Iraq had indeed something to do with simplifying negotiations
with Iraq and their Oil reserve.

My point is that there is more chaos than before the war.
And considering the popularity of the war, i guess that a
change in regime after the next elections will end the war,
leaving a completely chaotic iraqi government behind.
Nothing stable to reach their goals at all.

And america is at least not "very popular" over there. So
the Iraqis disagree with the americans even more as before
the invasion - i simply see no success in Iraq.

Australian ex-intelligence office, Andrew Wilkie, has a good summing up of the war.

The conflict obviously failed to achieve the original aim of reducing weapons of mass destruction and terrorism. So too it failed to achieve more recent justifications such as improving the humanitarian situation in Iraq and planting the seed of democracy in the Middle East. Nor has the war achieved the real reasons for its conduct, in particular to enhance United States power, control Iraq's oil, bolster Israel's security and bottle up Iran. Even the prospect for Iraq's fledgling Government is now parlous.

The stated reasons, and the real reasons. In all senses it is a failure.

http://www.theage.com.au/news/opinion/time-to-face-the-truth-mr-howard/2007/01/15/1168709664241.html
 
What the hell was vietnam if it wasn't an attempt to stop the spread of communism?

Pre-emptive action isn't new and what PNAC was proposing was hardly rocket science.

Given that the most recent wars the US has been involved in are contrary to the PNAC doctrine of technology over humans, it seems that the PNAC experiment has failed.

It was more about the hubris resulting from the fall of the USSR to lead some Americans to think it was all to do with them, and their innate superiority over all other political systems on the planet. PNAC was exactly what it claimed to be, a project to project their sense of American values over the whole world.
 
But the end of the cold war and the development of new IT meant that a different strategy was required and they set out in their document their proposals for what that strategy should be and how it should be implemented.

The only thing the woowoo's have with regard to the PNAC document is the 'pearl harbour' reference which got them all hot and bothered after 9/11.

But they were using that as an example of how change can be speeded up by an attack which is unpredicted and shows up the deficiencies in the strategic thinking up to that point.

But since PNAC was very much in favour of technology over boots on the ground, it is ironic that they are blamed for starting two wars which due to the assymetrical nature of the conflict has basically ended up with boots on the ground and alot of redundant high technology.

I think that the real irony of the Iraq war is that new IT has had little positive effect on the war overall direction of the war and may have had huge negative effects when it comes to decision making. Yes, we have more information on the state of the "battlespace" and this has positively effected our ability to engage and destroy the enemy, (US forces have had decisive victories in almost every engagement in which they have participated) but this glut of information has yet to provide dividends at anything above the tactical level. We are on our 6th change in strategy (quite a few would say tactics) at the moment and none of these descision have been accurate. In many cases IT can help you run your OODA loops faster, but a making accurate descisions in a deluge of data is very difficult. General Boyd observed about Vietnam that having Air, Sea and Land superiority does not win you the war, and it is truer today than ever.
 
This is straight from the horse's mouth people... Mr. PNAC himself. William Kristol. When publicly attacked, and accused of being involved in 9/11 the guy just smirks and smiles. Is that how you respond when someone just falsely accused you of actively participating in the killing of 3,000 innocent Americans? Well... is it?

It's how a polite person responds when a bunch of jackasses disrupt a public meeting, and the host of the meeting takes the lead in trying to quell the jackasses.

And even if he did flip out and tell off the jackasses, they'd still use the video of proof of his being "in on it", because, "Hey, must have touched a nerve, right? Why freak out so much over something that's not true?"

He knows that no matter what he says, it will be used against him, and so he decides to go for the havinf some class option, as everybody who isn't a CT loon will know what he's doing.
 
Okay... what is everyone objecting to now? You told me to go through the PNAC and read every page... and now I'm doing that and showing you how this document outlines the exact actions of current US military operations.

What do you want from me? Now, that I make points... you say that it's not even relevant to 9/11?
Your reading the PNAC report before commenting on it is only sensible. It's your constant insistence on deliberate misinterpretation and misrepresentation that I have a problem with.

You are a dishonest person. I hope you come to terms with that some day.

When you read,
ESTABLISH FOUR CORE MISSIONS for U.S. military forces:

• defend the American homeland;
• fight and decisively win multiple, simultaneous major theater wars;
• perform the “constabulary” duties associated with shaping the security environment in critical regions;
• transform U.S. forces to exploit the “revolution in military affairs;”
And you state,
Do you expect us to applaud your analytical skill?

When you read,
Further, the process of transformation, even if it brings revolutionary change, is likely to be a long one, absent some catastrophic and catalyzing event – like a new Pearl Harbor. Domestic politics and industrial policy will shape the pace and content of transformation as much as the requirements of current missions. A decision to suspend or terminate aircraft carrier production, as recommended by this report and as justified by the clear direction of military technology, will cause great upheaval. Likewise, systems entering production today – the F-22 fighter, for example – will be in service inventories for decades to come. Wise management of this process will consist in large measure of figuring out the right moments to halt production of current-paradigm weapons and shift to radically new designs. The expense associated with some programs can make them roadblocks to the larger process of transformation – the Joint Strike Fighter program, at a total of approximately $200 billion, seems an unwise investment. Thus, this report advocates a two-stage process of change – transition and transformation – over the coming decades.
And you interpret "some catastrophic and catalyzing event – like a new Pearl Harbor" as,
You are being dishonest.

Do you see that?
 
Your reading the PNAC report before commenting on it is only sensible. It's your constant insistence on deliberate misinterpretation and misrepresentation that I have a problem with.

You are a dishonest person. I hope you come to terms with that some day.

When you read,
And you state,
Do you expect us to applaud your analytical skill?

When you read,
And you interpret "some catastrophic and catalyzing event – like a new Pearl Harbor" as,
You are being dishonest.

Do you see that?

Is it dishonest to say that PNAC wanted to buildup America's defenses? Is it dishonest for me to say that? Is building up America's defenses something the PNAC wanted, yes or no?

Kristol reiterates in the video I linked to... that history shows, it's hard to get the support for a military buildup barring some catalyzing event like a Pearl Harbor, where the threat comes home. Does this mean that a Pearl Harbor-like event could help the PNAC in their desire to buildup America's defenses? Yes or no?

Regardless, if you say PNAC wanted a Pearl Harbor or not... was a catalyzing event like Pearl Harbor helpful to the PNAC in their goal of building up America's defense?

If as a direct result of this catalyzing event... the PNAC now had justification for increasing military spending i.e. to fight this new global threat of international terrorism... does that mean that 9/11 assisted them (whether they wanted 9/11 or not) in achieving their goal of a defense buildup? Yes or no?
 
Regardless, if you say PNAC wanted a Pearl Harbor or not... was a catalyzing event like Pearl Harbor helpful to the PNAC in their goal of building up America's defense?

It's gotta be, a comprehension issue. Right?
 
Is it dishonest to say that PNAC wanted to buildup America's defenses? Is it dishonest for me to say that? Is building up America's defenses something the PNAC wanted, yes or no?
You're doing it again. In post 167 I pointed out specific deliberate misrepresentations of yours. It's time for you to face your dishonesty. Please review those statements and revise them as necessary. If you do not do so, you are compounding dishonesty with stubbornness. That's no way for a rational person to behave.
 
Regardless, if you say PNAC wanted a Pearl Harbor or not... was a catalyzing event like Pearl Harbor helpful to the PNAC in their goal of building up America's defense?

If as a direct result of this catalyzing event... the PNAC now had justification for increasing military spending i.e. to fight this new global threat of international terrorism... does that mean that 9/11 assisted them (whether they wanted 9/11 or not) in achieving their goal of a defense buildup? Yes or no?

No....and......no.

It wasn't helpful to them, in implementing their desired type of build up, because the military build up we have seen isn't what they wanted.

Let's say that again for emphasis:

The military build up we have seen isn't what they wanted.

They thought such a "Pearl Harbor" event would help them. They were wrong.

Let's say that again for emphasis:

They were wrong!


Do you get it now?

And if the "Pearl Harbor" event they got was one they engineered, why did they allow the subsequent events to run so far out of their control? If they truly were as in charge as you seem to think, they wouldn't have.

So we can see, they didn't engineer 9/11. If they had, the response to 9/11 would have been very different.

QED.
 
You're doing it again. In post 167 I pointed out specific deliberate misrepresentations of yours. It's time for you to face your dishonesty. Please review those statements and revise them as necessary. If you do not do so, you are compounding dishonesty with stubbornness. That's no way for a rational person to behave.
Edited by Darat: 
Content in breach of Membership Agreement removed.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Is it dishonest to say that PNAC wanted to buildup America's defenses? Is it dishonest for me to say that? Is building up America's defenses something the PNAC wanted, yes or no?

Kristol reiterates in the video I linked to... that history shows, it's hard to get the support for a military buildup barring some catalyzing event like a Pearl Harbor, where the threat comes home. Does this mean that a Pearl Harbor-like event could help the PNAC in their desire to buildup America's defenses? Yes or no?

Regardless, if you say PNAC wanted a Pearl Harbor or not... was a catalyzing event like Pearl Harbor helpful to the PNAC in their goal of building up America's defense?

If as a direct result of this catalyzing event... the PNAC now had justification for increasing military spending i.e. to fight this new global threat of international terrorism... does that mean that 9/11 assisted them (whether they wanted 9/11 or not) in achieving their goal of a defense buildup? Yes or no?

I think in the case of Iraq they used WMD as the reason, the "Pearl Harbour" scenario was really just a fanciful one. "What if they attacked us with all those WMDs", "What if Saddam launched a WMD at us".
 
Edited by Darat: 
Content in breach of Membership Agreement removed.

I'm not sure what to make of this post. Obviously it's extremely inappropriate and doesn't belong in this (or any other) forum. But beyond that, it makes me question whether you are in control of your emotions, maturity, and rationality. If I can offer some free advice, I'd recommend you reconsider this whole internet debate thing, because writing stuff like this just isn't healthy.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Negativ... you disappoint me... for someone who apparently idolizes a maverick and innovative original like Zappa, you sure are one closed-minded, herd following individual.

9/11 is an inside job... I would bet my life and the life of everyone I know on it. It is fact... it's not a guess... or a wishful thought. I use to believe in the OS...but, I have since surveyed all of the evidence...and my 150 IQ, coupled with my spiritual enlightenment... leads me to the undeniable truth... and that is... elements within the USG were actively involved in the execution of 9/11. This is based in pure irrefutable fact... all you need do is turn off yer 48484848 tele and put down yer 484848484 beer and open yer 48484 474747474 mind a little.

I have nothing to gain from 9/11 being an inside job... I admit - it is a painful truth and I wish it weren't true... however, I must confront the truth regardless of how much it may inconvenience my life... for without the truth we are but ignorant pawns at the mercy of the machine.

And... I use to be one of these pawns... so don't feel so bad.

Wow man. You have almost convinced me!
 
Edited by Darat: 
Content in breach of Membership Agreement removed.
28th, do you see how irrationally you are behaving? Please seek help for your troubles.

If you're going to continue posting here, please address my critique of your statements in post 167.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Edited by Darat: 
Content in breach of Membership Agreement removed.

God damn it Im the evil metal dude, not Gravy! Look at my bands website! see! evidence!*


* I did not do this site. I do not like the design and layout! I think its too static and does not have enough dynamics for our stage show! check out the video!
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Australian ex-intelligence office, Andrew Wilkie, has a good summing up of the war.

The stated reasons, and the real reasons. In all senses it is a failure.

http://www.theage.com.au/news/opinion/time-to-face-the-truth-mr-howard/2007/01/15/1168709664241.html


Thank you for the interesting article, a_unique_person.
I can not imagine what blame it will be if there is a bad
end in and after this war. And Bushs comment didn´t
astound me:

Already Bush has said: "I've made it clear to the Prime Minister and Iraq's other leaders that America's commitment is not open-ended. If the Iraqi Government does not follow through on its promises, it will lose the support of the American people." In other words, if the US withdraws without victory then responsibility for that failure will lie, not with Americans, but with Iraqis.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom