Project for the New American Century

Actually, this documentary, 'The Power of Nightmares," was made by the BBC. You don't get any more mainstream media than the BBC. So are you saying that the BBC consists of a bunch of whacked out CTist, because they believe that OBL and al Qaeda are fake boogeymen, who the US invented in order to create a crisis that would insure high defense spending? Well, do you?
Strawman. I clearly stated, "Your political opinion about US policy is not evidence of an inside job of 9/11." I labeled no one holding such an opinion. I maligned no one holding such an opinion. I merely said that opinions are not evidence.

Also, if OBL is the one purportedly behind 9/11...and we prove that OBL is not what he really appears to be... well, then - yes, my dear friend... that does go along way towards debunking the OS.
And how, exactly, would the US's exaggeration of the threat Al Qaeda posed relate to whether or not they carried out the attack? If I state that your chances of winning the lottery are 1:100, you hit the lottery, and then it turns out the odds were actually 1:1000, does that mean the lottery was rigged? No. Again, you are misapplying your interpretation of motive as being evidence of guilt.
 
Actually, this documentary, 'The Power of Nightmares," was made by the BBC. You don't get any more mainstream media than the BBC. So are you saying that the BBC consists of a bunch of whacked out CTist, because they believe that OBL and al Qaeda are fake boogeymen, who the US invented in order to create a crisis that would insure high defense spending? Well, do you?

Also, if OBL is the one purportedly behind 9/11...and we prove that OBL is not what he really appears to be... well, then - yes, my dear friend... that does go along way towards debunking the OS.

Adam Curtis made the film. He works for the BBC, he is not the BBC. That in no way implies that the BBC consists of a bunch of whacked out CTists. There are other reasons for that. ;-)

What is it that OBL is not what he appears to be?

And whether or not he planned the attack doesn't debunk anything about how the towers came down or how a plane crashed into the Pentagon or in Shanksville.
 
Adam Curtis made the film. He works for the BBC, he is not the BBC. That in no way implies that the BBC consists of a bunch of whacked out CTists. There are other reasons for that. ;-)

What is it that OBL is not what he appears to be?

And whether or not he planned the attack doesn't debunk anything about how the towers came down or how a plane crashed into the Pentagon or in Shanksville.
[nitpick] Osama was not the major planner, he just green-lighted the project[/nitpick]
 
[nitpick] Osama was not the major planner, he just green-lighted the project[/nitpick]
You're too quick for me.

Was just going to edit that to say "Whether OBL had anything to do with...".

ETA: And unlike 28K, I'll leave my error and remediation for all to see.
 
Last edited:
Actually, this documentary, 'The Power of Nightmares," was made by the BBC. You don't get any more mainstream media than the BBC. So are you saying that the BBC consists of a bunch of whacked out CTist, because they believe that OBL and al Qaeda are fake boogeymen, who the US invented in order to create a crisis that would insure high defense spending? Well, do you?

Also, if OBL is the one purportedly behind 9/11...and we prove that OBL is not what he really appears to be... well, then - yes, my dear friend... that does go along way towards debunking the OS.

We had a discussion about the "Power of Nightmares":

BBC says Al Qaida is fake:
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=66748

I would suggest to discuss the issue in this on-topic thread. :)
 
Is anyone... getting anything out of my analysis of the PNAC... or should I just stop and save everyone the headache?

It is the worse I have seen. Go ahead prove me right by drifting off in to more insane rant. You are back; thought you quit; you should have quit.

I thought you were just ignorant on the facts, but you may be crazy.
 
Actually, this documentary, 'The Power of Nightmares," was made by the BBC. You don't get any more mainstream media than the BBC. So are you saying that the BBC consists of a bunch of whacked out CTist, because they believe that OBL and al Qaeda are fake boogeymen, who the US invented in order to create a crisis that would insure high defense spending? Well, do you?

Also, if OBL is the one purportedly behind 9/11...and we prove that OBL is not what he really appears to be... well, then - yes, my dear friend... that does go along way towards debunking the OS.

First off, the BBC as a whole doesn't have an opinion and makes programmes across a wide range of views - The Power of Nightmares is just one of these.

Secondly, the documentary does not assert that Islamist terrorists don't exist. The basic thesis is that both Bin Laden and the Neocons both have a vested interest in exaggerating the power and threat of Al Qaeda and that they've both done this.

Here are some questions from the BBC website, with answers from the producer Adam Curtis:

"Are you saying that there is no threat?"

No, the series did not say this. It was very clear in arguing that although there is a serious threat of terrorism from some radical Islamists, the nightmare vision of a uniquely powerful hidden organisation waiting to strike our societies is an illusion.

As the films showed, wherever one looks for this "al-Qaeda" organisation - from the mountains of Afghanistan to the "sleeper cells" in America - the British and Americans are pursuing a fantasy. The bombs in Madrid and Bali showed clearly the seriousness of the threat - but they are not evidence of a new and overwhelming threat unlike any we have experienced before. And above all they do not - in the words of the British government - "threaten the life of the nation". That is simply untrue.

"OK, so al-Qaeda does not exist as a highly organised and structured group. But it is a terrifically powerful ideology, which makes it even more dangerous."

No - the extreme Islamist ideas are dangerous, as Madrid, Bali and 11 September showed, but to portray them as a terrifying new viral form of terrorism is also part of the politics of fear.

Blair and Bush in the shadow of Osama Bin Laden
The Power of Nightmares re-defined the terrorist threat
If one looks at the history of the Islamist movement and its ideas it is clear that its high point came in the late 80s when it seemed on the verge of success across the Muslim world.

But then in the 1990s Islamism failed dramatically in its attempts to create revolutions because the ideas failed to inspire the masses. They did not appeal to the majority of people.

The attacks on 11 September were not the expression of a confident and growing movement, they were acts of desperation by a small group frustrated by their failure which they blamed on the power of America. It is also important to realise that many within the Islamist movement were against this strategy.

Also, it's clear the Curtis has no truck with conspiracy theories:

"Do you believe it possible that the American Neo-Cons engineered the 9/11 atrocity as a catalyst for their program?"

Cliff Babbs, Daventry


No.
"Are you saying it's a conspiracy?"

No. The use of fear in contemporary politics is not the result of a conspiracy, the politicians have stumbled on it. In a populist, consumerist age where they found their authority and legitimacy declining dramatically they have simply discovered in the "war on terror" a way of restoring their authority by promising to protect us from something that only they can see.

I don't think it will last. Already senior parts of the Establishment are beginning to question the very basis of the politicians' argument - that "al-Qaeda" is a threat like no other which "threatens the life of the nation".

In the recent House of Lords ruling which said that the indefinite detention of foreign nationals without trial was illegal, one of the Law Lords - Lord Hoffman - publicly challenged the government's justification.

He said: "This is a nation which has been tested in adversity, which has survived physical destruction and catastrophic loss of life.

"I do not underestimate the ability of fanatical groups of terrorists to kill and destroy, but they do not threaten the life of the nation.

"Whether we would survive Hitler hung in the balance, but there is no doubt that we shall survive al-Qaeda.

"The Spanish people have not said that what happened in Madrid, hideous crime as it was, threatened the life of their nation. Their legendary pride would not allow it.

"Terrorist violence, serious as it is, does not threaten our institutions of government or our existence as a civil community."

The full Q&A is here:
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/programmes/4202741.stm
 
"At present the United States faces no global rival. America’s grand strategy should aim to preserve and extend this advantageous position as far into the future as possible."

"The Defense Policy Guidance (DPG) drafted in the early months of 1992 provided a blueprint for maintaining U.S. preeminence, precluding the rise of a great power rival, and shaping the international security order in line with American principles and interests."

I don't think any of you have read this thing... because it's a perfect account of what the US is currently doing in the middle east. They are acting like world police... by purportedly spreading democracy, while simultaneously extending their global leadership and preeminence by preemptively meeting threats before they quote, "become dire."

You know like... we must invade Iran before something bad happens. It hasn't happened yet... but the US must act first.. to shape the circumstances before a crisis emerges.

I love the PNAC... can't wait to finish this thing... I want to see how this whole middle east fiasco turns out... I'm sure it's all in here!

Please could you give your opinion on exactly what American Middle East policy should be, I am just curious as to what role , if any role you would have the US play in the Middle East.

Before you reply , please read.

http://www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/jsource/myths/mf21.html
 
You're too quick for me.

Was just going to edit that to say "Whether OBL had anything to do with...".

ETA: And unlike 28K, I'll leave my error and remediation for all to see.
It's a moot distinction anyway. Same as nitpicking over whether a given idea was Himmler's or Hitler's.
 
“We can either sustain the [armed] forces we require and remain in a position to help shape things for the better, or we can throw that advantage away. [But] that would only hasten the day when we face greater threats, at higher costs and further risk to American lives.” -Secretary Cheney PNAC pg.9

Fear mongering at its finest... hey, can you blame the guy... he's just trying to make some extra bucks to help knock out the rent.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fear_Mongering

"Fear mongering is the use of fear to leverage the opinions and actions of others towards some end. The object of fear is exaggerated; those the fear is directed toward are kept aware of it on a constant basis.

Fear of terrorism born from the September 11th attacks has been arguably exploited by incumbent politicians to maintain their control of the house, senate, and executive branch of the government."
 
“We can either sustain the [armed] forces we require and remain in a position to help shape things for the better, or we can throw that advantage away. [But] that would only hasten the day when we face greater threats, at higher costs and further risk to American lives.” -Secretary Cheney PNAC pg.9

Fear mongering at its finest... hey, can you blame the guy... he's just trying to make some extra bucks to help knock out the rent.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fear_Mongering

"Fear mongering is the use of fear to leverage the opinions and actions of others towards some end. The object of fear is exaggerated; those the fear is directed toward are kept aware of it on a constant basis.

Fear of terrorism born from the September 11th attacks has been arguably exploited by incumbent politicians to maintain their control of the house, senate, and executive branch of the government."

Since this has devolved into a politics and policy discussion, could it, perchance, be moved to the Politics subforum?
 
Since this has devolved into a politics and policy discussion, could it, perchance, be moved to the Politics subforum?

I guess no one cares about PNAC beside the CT´ists.
To me it sounds still on topic beside the BBC Docu that
is about "Fear mongering"...

ETA: ...and already discussed here.
 
Fear of terrorism born from the September 11th attacks has been arguably exploited by incumbent politicians to maintain their control of the house, senate, and executive branch of the government."

Your mom should let you read more! You are paying attention!

Your politcal expertise is the same as your physics.
 
I guess no one cares about PNAC beside the CT´ists.
To me it sounds still on topic beside the BBC Docu that
is about "Fear mongering"...

ETA: ...and already discussed here.
It's a twofold issue. First off, it's putting the cart before the horse. Secondly, 28th's post seem to clearly be disagreeing with the policy suggestions put forth in PNAC. Neither of which add value to the discussion of evidence of an inside job.

Let me throw out an example.

John and Jane Doe are married. John increases his life insurance policy. Two months later he dies of a heart attack. Jane takes the insurance money and moves to Aruba. Now, the increased payout of the policy could be viewed as a motive, by Jane, to murder John. However, unless there is some other evidence to suggest that John's heart attack was anything other than natural there is no need to pursue a homicide investigation where Jane is the primary suspect.

Another example, Clue. Every one of the suspects in the movie had motive and opportunity. It took other physical evidence to determine what actually happened.

Additionally, PNAC is questionable in its usefulness in such a discussion because who would be the people carrying out the acts?
The elected gov't?
Some shadow gov't?
A foreign power that has infiltrated the gov't?
Alex Jones?
IPUs?
etc
 
From PNAC pg.11:

ESTABLISH FOUR CORE MISSIONS for U.S. military forces:

• defend the American homeland;
• fight and decisively win multiple, simultaneous major theater wars;
• perform the “constabulary” duties associated with shaping the security environment in critical regions;
• transform U.S. forces to exploit the “revolution in military affairs;”

MAJOR THEATER WAR (MTW) – US military operations to deter and defeat large-scale aggression by a state or coalition that threatens an ally or the stability of a region. Involves joint and potentially combined military operations that project, apply, and sustain substantial US combat and combat support forces for high-intensity/high-end conflict

1. Designed to shroud the other three missions under the guise of homeland security... when they are really imperialistic operations cloaked as good-will, peace keeping missions.

2. Okay... so Iraq was the first MTW... Iran will be number 2... Who comes after that... North Korea?

3. That's constabulary as in Team America: World Police... and critical regions, as in the middle east.

4. There they go with this transformation talk again... I need to continue reading to see if any of this stuff starts piecing itself together.

PNAC pg.12:

EXPLOIT THE “REVOLUTION IN MILITARY AFFAIRS” to insure the long-term superiority of
U.S. conventional forces. Establish a two-stage transformation process which

• maximizes the value of current weapons systems through the application of advanced
technologies, and,

• produces more profound improvements in military capabilities, encourages competition
between single services and joint-service experimentation efforts.

INCREASE DEFENSE SPENDING gradually to a minimum level of 3.5 to 3.8 percent of gross
domestic product, adding $15 billion to $20 billion to total defense spending annually.

"Fulfilling these requirements (all bulletins listed above) is essential if America is to retain its militarily dominant status for the coming decades."

So the PNAC wants simultaneous major theater wars, increased defense spending, to act as world police in critical regions, and to transform US forces by producing new advancements and technologies in weaponry. Okay... so how many of these have they achieved so far? If they invade Iran or another country... they have the simultaneous MTWs... they're already playing world police in Iraq... the defense budget has increased since 9/11. And, I'm not sure how much new technologies they have developed or worked on since 9/11, although I'm sure that goal was on a longer time line, since you don't produce new breakthroughs overnight.

Okay... so, I think it's safe to say that once the US evades a 2nd country... the PNAC will have accomplished all of these goals. Go Go PNAC! High-Five!
 
Last edited:
From PNAC pg.11:

ESTABLISH FOUR CORE MISSIONS for U.S. military forces:

• defend the American homeland;
• fight and decisively win multiple, simultaneous major theater wars;
• perform the “constabulary” duties associated with shaping the security environment in critical regions;
• transform U.S. forces to exploit the “revolution in military affairs;”

MAJOR THEATER WAR (MTW) – US military operations to deter and defeat large-scale aggression by a state or coalition that threatens an ally or the stability of a region. Involves joint and potentially combined military operations that project, apply, and sustain substantial US combat and combat support forces for high-intensity/high-end conflict

1. Designed to shroud the other three missions under the guise of homeland security... when they are really imperialistic operations cloaked as good-will, peace keeping missions.

2. Okay... so Iraq was the first MTW... Iran will be number 2... Who comes after that... North Korea?

3. That's constabulary as in Team America: World Police... and critical regions, as in the middle east.

4. There they go with this transformation talk again... I need to continue reading to see if any of this stuff starts piecing itself together.
We are fully aware that you take issue with a pro-hawk, proactive policy by the US. However, this is doing nothing to support your assertions and you appear to be ignoring criticisms of this line of inquiry.
 
It's a twofold issue. First off, it's putting the cart before the horse. Secondly, 28th's post seem to clearly be disagreeing with the policy suggestions put forth in PNAC. Neither of which add value to the discussion of evidence of an inside job.

Let me throw out an example.

John and Jane Doe are married. John increases his life insurance policy. Two months later he dies of a heart attack. Jane takes the insurance money and moves to Aruba. Now, the increased payout of the policy could be viewed as a motive, by Jane, to murder John. However, unless there is some other evidence to suggest that John's heart attack was anything other than natural there is no need to pursue a homicide investigation where Jane is the primary suspect.

Another example, Clue. Every one of the suspects in the movie had motive and opportunity. It took other physical evidence to determine what actually happened.

Additionally, PNAC is questionable in its usefulness in such a discussion because who would be the people carrying out the acts?
The elected gov't?
Some shadow gov't?
A foreign power that has infiltrated the gov't?
Alex Jones?
IPUs?
etc

Personally i hoped that some other CT´ists would discuss
the issue, too - since it seems to be such a mistery and
smoking gun for them. I agree - to quote just one or two
sentences of the whole report is pretty out of context.

Maybe they know something we can not see - or, what
seems to be more likely - there is nothing behind the
PNAC urban legend.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom