Project for the New American Century

No. They said they wanted THAT military buildup (the one they wrote about), not THIS military buildup (the one we got). The one we got killed any hope of them getting the one they wanted.

This point has been raised several times on this thread. Take some time to let it sink in.

Yea... I know - all you great minds... think this is your debunking, right? Look... we're not even debating whether or not a New Pearl Harbor... could have given PNAC what they wanted... that's not the point.

PNAC had a belief which they clearly articulated in the document, "Rebuilding America's Defense," in which - they claim that a New Pearl Harbor would speed up the transformation they were looking for. PNAC is not a group of psychics, who can predict the future... it doesn't even matter if they were wrong after the fact. (and, I don't even agree that they were wrong... I'm saying this for the sake of argument)

The fact is... pre 9/11 - the PNAC thought a 9/11 event would speed up the transformation they wanted to see... whether or not they were right about it speeding up this transformation is a moot point.

In their eyes and in their own words...they clearly stated a belief (pre 9/11) that gives them a motive to perpetrate 9/11... and that is the point.
 
Last edited:
That's why it is so important that the PNAC actually admits... that a catastrophe would actually expedite(make it easier) for them to realize the transformation they want to see for American in the New Century.
But not just any ol' catastrophe. One which would catalyze American opinion around their goals. This does not include a low-tech attack carried out by terrorist moles that took advantage of holes in civilian security procedures.

To justify shifting spending to their high-tech, lightning strike, air & space dominance type vision for the military, the catalyzing event would have to be something like the dictator of a nuclear-armed rogue nation successfully launching an ICBM within range of the North American continent.
 
Last edited:
Firstly, when I said my "interruption" of the Pearl Harbor line... that probably wasn't the best choice of words. I wasn't interrupting anything... I was merely rewording what they said... reframing it, if you will... so you could see what they were implying. Have you ever heard the expression... "it goes without saying."

They say they want this military buildup. Actually... even more than that, they are actively seeking this military buildup. They are "lobbying" for this military buildup. We know that... then they proceed to tell us what needs to happen in order for this military buildup to take place. They tell us, that the transformation they want to see will take a long time, barring some Pearl Harbor-like event.

The point is made... The Vice President and Secretary of Defense of the United States of America... were part of a thinktank, that has a document which says... that a Pearl Harbor-like event will aid them in achieving this transformation of a military buildup, that they want to see implemented in the New Century.

If you write out a document that details your retirement plan... and you basically describe everything you will have to do i.e. bust yer bum for 40 years, put away 10% a month, sacrifice the quality of your life for a future payout, etc. but then go on to say...of course, this is gonna be a life long mission, that will take 40 years to realize, barring any unforeseen events... like me hitting the lottery.

Well... you really don't need to say in your plan... word for word. "Oh God, I WANT to hit the lottery, so I don't have to do all this other 3445." It just goes without saying.

See, the problem with you left-brain radicals... is that you always need everything spelled out for you word for word....in a straight line...otherwise, you can't piece two and two together... which really hinders your ability to access a situation. I know... it's not always a good thing to draw conclusions... but when we're talking about something as simple as saying... we know you want A, and you also say, that in order for you to get A you will either have to grind it out over several years or decades unless B happens - well, it's a pretty simple connecting of the dots from A to B. And, actually...this formula is based in science... it's called, the path of least resistance. :p

The main point... is that PNAC admits a New Pearl Harbor would benefit them. See, again... no they don't word it like that... but that is exactly what they are saying. They want a military buildup... and if this event happens, it will aid their cause to get this military buildup.

Whether or not... they actually say... OH PLEASE DEAR GOD, WE WANT 3,000 PEOPLE TO DIE.... is moot. The point is that we know a massive catastrophe like 9/11 would actually be beneficial to PNAC... so this gives us a motive... and that's really the only thing PNAC should be used for. It outlines why an event like 9/11 could benefit Cheney and Rumsfeld (among others) in achieving their goal for A New American Century.

Here's a tip. When you need to write this much ^ to explain how your "fact" is indeed a fact. It's not. It's an interpretation.

Your interpretation is not fact. Not matter how much you rationalize it. PNAC never said what you claimed they said. Never. Not once. You, essentially, lied. If you said "It appears that...", or "It's clear to me that...", then you'd be being honest. To claim that it is indeed factual is a lie. It is not factual.

This is the problem with your movement. You constantly misrepresent what was said because you need for others to view the world the way you view it. You refuse to allow for any other interpretations. You view your interpretations as the only valid ones and therefore factual. At it's core, it's based on intellectual dishonesty. You are proving this yourself by trying to rationalize this lie you've been peddling for several pages.

PNAC never said what you claim they said.
 
Firstly, when I said my "interruption" of the Pearl Harbor line... that probably wasn't the best choice of words. I wasn't interrupting anything... I was merely rewording what they said... reframing it, if you will... so you could see what they were implying. Have you ever heard the expression... "it goes without saying."

I believe that is the definition of "quoting out of context", "quote mining" and "leading the reader" all tied up in one brief explination.

And you seem quite unashamed of it.
 
In their eyes and in their own words...they clearly stated a belief (pre 9/11) that gives them a motive to perpetrate 9/11... and that is the point.

You need more than motive to prove beyond reasonable doubt that someone was responsible for an event.

PNAC:
You claim they have a Motive (UNDER SERIOUS DEBATE WHETHER THIS MOTIVE IS VALID)

al Qaeda:
Motive
Confessions
Evidence linking Hijackers to Leader of al Qaeda
9/11 Commission report detailing pre-9/11 al Qaeda activity
Past activity with similar traits such as the 1993 bombing
Record of Terrorism
And that's only the tip of the ice berg.

So...
 
Oh and let's not forget the Moussaoui trail :)

[SIZE=-1]http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zacarias_Moussaoui[/SIZE]
 
I'm sure 28th will say that the PNAC is not what their plan was, who would give away their exact plans in public?... They must have disguised their plan so that they wouldn't give away too much of it, except that new Pearl Harbor thing...

:boggled:
 
But not just any ol' catastrophe. One which would catalyze American opinion around their goals. This does not include a low-tech attack carried out by terrorist moles that took advantage of holes in civilian security procedures.

To justify shifting spending to their high-tech, lightning strike, air & space dominance type vision for the military, the catalyzing event would have to be something like the dictator of a nuclear-armed rogue nation successfully launching an ICBM within range of the North American continent. (emphasis 28IQ)

Pure opinion and speculation... and it goes against what PNAC believed... which is all that really matters, since we're talking about their motive.

"The fact is... pre 9/11 - the PNAC thought a 9/11 event would speed of the transformation they wanted to see... whether or not they were right about it speeding up this transformation is a moot point."

PNAC... obviously knew the type of transformation they wanted... and they are the ones who said, that a catalyzing event, like a New Pearl Harbor... would expedite the transformation they were seeking.

And, please don't say 9/11 isn't a catastrophe or a catalyzing event. The Pearl Harbor attack is the only thing comparable to the 9/11 attack. Just because they weren't identical doesn't mean anything...

9/11 was a surprise attack from an outside threat that killed thousands of innocent Americans on American soil. Period.
 
*snip*You (and all the other CTist) have so far not provided ANY EVIDENCE to prove this.*snip*


@28th: I guess she is right in this point. Even if PNAC's plan
was to perform 9/11 - praying this quote out of context to
new people within the Movement, is pretty much like lying.

But at least it is Anti-Gov Propaganda and therefore an
attempt to brainwash people, especially young ones.

And don´t get me wrong here - i would love to see that
it was in inside job. I would make a hidden video during
the executions and spread it all over the net - with the
latest HipHop music, promised.

I guess im just more sceptic than you - i'm not trying
to collect only the little pieces of evidence against the
Idiots within the Gubmint, but also the aspects that
proves these pieces wrong or unlikely. And i usually
find my conclusions >between< these two sides of
an issue.
 
Last edited:
So basically, no matter what would have happened, they would have been guilty of it, since they mentioned an "attack" in the PNAC?
 
"The fact is... pre 9/11 - the PNAC thought a 9/11 event would speed of the transformation they wanted to see... whether or not they were right about it speeding up this transformation is a moot point."
This is a lie, pure and simple.

A 9/11 event in no way helps PNAC's agenda.
This has been explained a number of times already. Just read the PNAC-report. You know, read it, read what THEY WRITE, not what is in your head.

ETA: see Pardalis post above.
 
Whether or not... they actually say... OH PLEASE DEAR GOD, WE WANT 3,000 PEOPLE TO DIE.... is moot. The point is that we know a massive catastrophe like 9/11 would actually be beneficial to PNAC... so this gives us a motive... and that's really the only thing PNAC should be used for. It outlines why an event like 9/11 could benefit Cheney and Rumsfeld (among others) in achieving their goal for A New American Century.

So then why has so many military projects been canceled? The RAH-66 Comanche,(canceled after 9/11) the Ospry, The strategic missle defense plan just to name a few)

Why has the president having so much trouble pushing more troops into Iraq?

The main reason why so many high tech military plans were cancelled after 9/11 was that the the govt. knew the nature of our enemies had changed. After the fall of the Soviet Union, no enemy country had technology advanced enough to justify the money being spent advanced technology fighters and other systems.
Especially when our enemies could highjack an airplane and ram it into a building.
Now why would a conspiring government cancel all those projects if the Middle East threat was not real?

Leasons like the Little Bighorn, the Zulu wars, the Korean war, the Vietnam war showed that a less techicaly advanced army could kick a more technically advanced army's a$$ under the right conditions.

PNAC was rendered usless when 9/11 happened because our enemy is not a technically advanced organization. They are essentially geurilla warriors fighting more with guile, and resourcefullness than money and high technology.
 
Last edited:
I think I have 3 simple statements we can use to counter the claims of the woowoo's with regard to PNAC:

1. The PNAC Document doesn't say what you think it says

2. Even if it did say what you think it says, why say it in public and then do it in secret?

3. The PNAC Document doesn't say what you think it says

This is an open source rebuttal.
 
Here's a tip. When you need to write this much ^ to explain how your "fact" is indeed a fact. It's not. It's an interpretation.

Your interpretation is not fact. Not matter how much you rationalize it. PNAC never said what you claimed they said. Never. Not once. You, essentially, lied. If you said "It appears that...", or "It's clear to me that...", then you'd be being honest. To claim that it is indeed factual is a lie. It is not factual.

This is the problem with your movement. You constantly misrepresent what was said because you need for others to view the world the way you view it. You refuse to allow for any other interpretations. You view your interpretations as the only valid ones and therefore factual. At it's core, it's based on intellectual dishonesty. You are proving this yourself by trying to rationalize this lie you've been peddling for several pages.

PNAC never said what you claim they said.

You people are your own worse enemy... why don't you stop being so fastidious about the words I'm using... and see the undeniable point I have made over the course of 10+ posts.

Stop trying to pick apart my every word, and just - LOOK AT THE BIG PICTURE PLEASE.

Maybe, I shouldn't have said, "PNAC SAID A NEW PEARL HARBOR WOULD BENEFIT THEM," to you left-b's, because I guess that confuses you. Even though... the PNAC did SAY without all the words... that a New Pearl Harbor would benefit them. Unless... you don't think expediting someone's goals from years/decades to a day is beneficial.
 
If this were to continue it could lead one to suspect a certain element of dishonesty in 28th's position.
 
And, please don't say 9/11 isn't a catastrophe or a catalyzing event.
9/11 was a catastrophe. 9/11 was a catalyzing event. Obviously. But if your MOTIVE was to catalyze Americans towards a goal of high-tech military buildup against a high-tech threat, then you have NO MOTIVE for creating a false flag op designed to look like a low-tech threat that your high-tech goals would be useless against.

9/11 catalyzed Americans around buttoning up localized (non-military) defenses at home, ferreting out groups of independent men bent on doing us harm, and targeting the nations that harbored them.
The Pearl Harbor attack is the only thing comparable to the 9/11 attack. Just because they weren't identical doesn't mean anything...

9/11 was a surprise attack from an outside threat that killed thousands of innocent Americans on American soil. Period.
I'm glad to hear you acknowledge this.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom