Project for the New American Century

9/11 wasn't a new Pearl Harbor

I think we're all giving the CTists (28th included) too much credit by not challenging the idea the 9/11 was a new Pearl Harbor.

9/11 was a terrorist attack, launched against basically civilian targets from inside the US. Pearl Harbor was a military attack by the armed forces of a sovereign nation, launched from outside of the US, targeting a US military installation.

PNAC's concern was that the US would be vulnerable to attack by the military of another nation if they didn't keep their defence technologies up to date - they're worry was that the nation would be forced to do this in response to an attack. Their message is that the possibility of another Pearl Harbor should be extinguished by following their proposals. In no way are they suggesting that they want the US to be attacked - this is precisely the scenario they are trying to avoid.

What they didn't consider at all was that the US could be attacked by terrorist action from within their own borders. Because this is what happened, 9/11 has, if anything, made their recommendations less likely to happen. What use is a missile defence shield against suicide bombers?
 
Last edited:
28th

Can you please explain how you marry your claim that the USG want Iraq to be embroiled in civil war, and yet at the same time they want a free flow of oil.

If the USG wanted a free flow of oil they should have kept Saddam in power, and removed sanctions. They could have kept a steady flow of oil that way. Hell they ignored Saddam's human rights abuse and genocide for decades, until kuwait.

Right now oil production is massively down from the peak when Saddam was in power, and I cannot understand your logic on this matter. If they needed a new Pearl Habour, and Afganistan isn't won by any stretch of the imagination why bother with Iraq?
 
Yes... yes I am... and the irregular modulation in this man's vocal tonality (2:50-3:10) his avoidness of eye contact (2:50-3:10) and fidgeting with hands (2:50-3:10) are all signs of someone who is obviously lying.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8ov8nJ1lOa8

With people acting that rude to a man who voluntarily organized a speech - why wouldn't he be nervous.

They are signs of someone who is nervous. Understandably so with people acting like that. You guys need to grow up. If someone's talking to you - shut the [rule8] up and listen. If you become hostile with your aggressive questions what do you expect?

The assistant is saying "wait to the end" and all he's getting is "OMFG WTC7 WTC7 WTC7 WTC7 WTC7 WTC7!".
 
Also notice the number of cuts in the video.

When the guy (around 2:30) asks "So 9/11 was pretty good for PNAC" or something similar, they cut out his answer!
 
Edited by Darat: 
Content in breach of Membership Agreement removed.
"Your karma is coming down on you." --Charles Manson (said to reporter Theo Wilson during his murder trial)
"Oh, shut up, Charlie." --Theo Wilson
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Regardless, if you say PNAC wanted a Pearl Harbor or not... was a catalyzing event like Pearl Harbor helpful to the PNAC in their goal of building up America's defense?

This is just the point. It doesn't matter what you say, or what I say. You claimed that PNAC said they wanted it. PNAC never said that. You seem to be finally admitting that, now. You are finally starting to understand how dishonest it is to state your interpretation of the events as the factual representation of what happened.
 
28th

Can you please explain how you marry your claim that the USG want Iraq to be embroiled in civil war, and yet at the same time they want a free flow of oil.

If the USG wanted a free flow of oil they should have kept Saddam in power, and removed sanctions. They could have kept a steady flow of oil that way. Hell they ignored Saddam's human rights abuse and genocide for decades, until kuwait.

Right now oil production is massively down from the peak when Saddam was in power, and I cannot understand your logic on this matter. If they needed a new Pearl Habour, and Afganistan isn't won by any stretch of the imagination why bother with Iraq?
Actually one opinion is that their goal is to stop the free flow of oil to drive up prices, makes sense but I doubt it's the sole goal of the War, but... it certainly gets the oil companies on your side.
 
Actually one opinion is that their goal is to stop the free flow of oil to drive up prices, makes sense but I doubt it's the sole goal of the War, but... it certainly gets the oil companies on your side.

At the same time as screwing over your economy, the industries that depend on oil and the voters (pretty much all of whom drive cars).

Low oil prices are much more n US interests than high ones.
 
You are finally starting to understand how dishonest it is to state your interpretation of the events as the factual representation of what happened.

I doubt that; it's a fundamental thought process of a conspiracy theorist. How on Earth could somebody stay a CT if they stopped using opinion as fact?
 
At the same time as screwing over your economy, the industries that depend on oil and the voters (pretty much all of whom drive cars).

Low oil prices are much more n US interests than high ones.
But not the Oil companies, I think it's a far more complex issue than one simple company/industry getting what they want. The war is a result of LOTS of people and their influence all getting what they want. Including what we're being told. No single reason often brought up by CT'ers is the sole reason for the war, it's considerably more complex and not waged for the sole benefit of the US, Oil Companies, Bush, Weapons manufacturers or anyone. They each get good and bad things out of it, it's not a simple issue.
 
This is just the point. It doesn't matter what you say, or what I say. You claimed that PNAC said they wanted it. PNAC never said that. You seem to be finally admitting that, now. You are finally starting to understand how dishonest it is to state your interpretation of the events as the factual representation of what happened.

Firstly, when I said my "interruption" of the Pearl Harbor line... that probably wasn't the best choice of words. I wasn't interrupting anything... I was merely rewording what they said... reframing it, if you will... so you could see what they were implying. Have you ever heard the expression... "it goes without saying."

They say they want this military buildup. Actually... even more than that, they are actively seeking this military buildup. They are "lobbying" for this military buildup. We know that... then they proceed to tell us what needs to happen in order for this military buildup to take place. They tell us, that the transformation they want to see will take a long time, barring some Pearl Harbor-like event.

The point is made... The Vice President and Secretary of Defense of the United States of America... were part of a thinktank, that has a document which says... that a Pearl Harbor-like event will aid them in achieving this transformation of a military buildup, that they want to see implemented in the New Century.

If you write out a document that details your retirement plan... and you basically describe everything you will have to do i.e. bust yer bum for 40 years, put away 10% a month, sacrifice the quality of your life for a future payout, etc. but then go on to say...of course, this is gonna be a life long mission, that will take 40 years to realize, barring any unforeseen events... like me hitting the lottery.

Well... you really don't need to say in your plan... word for word. "Oh God, I WANT to hit the lottery, so I don't have to do all this other 3445." It just goes without saying.

See, the problem with you left-brain radicals... is that you always need everything spelled out for you word for word....in a straight line...otherwise, you can't piece two and two together... which really hinders your ability to access a situation. I know... it's not always a good thing to draw conclusions... but when we're talking about something as simple as saying... we know you want A, and you also say, that in order for you to get A you will either have to grind it out over several years or decades unless B happens - well, it's a pretty simple connecting of the dots from A to B. And, actually...this formula is based in science... it's called, the path of least resistance. :p

The main point... is that PNAC admits a New Pearl Harbor would benefit them. See, again... no they don't word it like that... but that is exactly what they are saying. They want a military buildup... and if this event happens, it will aid their cause to get this military buildup.

Whether or not... they actually say... OH PLEASE DEAR GOD, WE WANT 3,000 PEOPLE TO DIE.... is moot. The point is that we know a massive catastrophe like 9/11 would actually be beneficial to PNAC... so this gives us a motive... and that's really the only thing PNAC should be used for. It outlines why an event like 9/11 could benefit Cheney and Rumsfeld (among others) in achieving their goal for A New American Century.
 
Last edited:
:words:
The main point... is that PNAC admits a New Pearl Harbor would benefit them. See, again... no they don't word it like that... but that is exactly what they are saying. They want a military buildup... and if this event happens, it will aid their cause to get this military buildup.
Yesterday I asked you to read the PNAC-report.
Now I must ask you to understand it.

Whether or not... they actually say... OH PLEASE DEAR GOD, WE WANT 3,000 PEOPLE TO DIE.... is moot. The point is that we know a massive catastrophe like 9/11 would actually be beneficial to PNAC... so this gives us a motive... and that's really the only thing PNAC should be used for. It outlines why an event like 9/11 could benefit Cheney and Rumsfeld (among others) in achieving their goal for A New American Century.
The attacks of 9/11 were in no way beneficial to PNAC's agenda.
And even if they were (which they were not), still it wouldn't prove that 9/11 was an inside job.

You (and all the other CTist) have so far not provided ANY EVIDENCE to prove this. All you do is take silly arguments, baseless interpretations, outright lies, cook them in a bath of ignorance and prejudice, and then claim that 9/11 was an inside job. No rational person will fall for this nonsense!
 
Last edited:
If you write out a document that details your retirement plan... and you basically describe everything you will have to do i.e. bust yer bum for 40 years, put away 10% a month, sacrifice the quality of your life for a future payout, etc. but then go on to say...of course, this is gonna be a life long mission, that will take 40 years to realize, barring any unforeseen events... like me hitting the lottery.

Well... you really don't need to say in your plan... word for word. "Oh God, I WANT to hit the lottery, so I don't have to do all this other 3445." It just goes without saying.
you seem to be implying that as long as the ends are the same all means to that end are equally desirable

so working and saving for 40 years is as good as winning the lottery is as good as your wife dying and you collecting life insurance, right?
 
They say they want this military buildup.
No. They said they wanted THAT military buildup (the one they wrote about), not THIS military buildup (the one we got). The one we got killed any hope of them getting the one they wanted.

This point has been raised several times on this thread. Take some time to let it sink in.
 
you seem to be implying that as long as the ends are the same all means to that end are equally desirable

so working and saving for 40 years is as good as winning the lottery is as good as your wife dying and you collecting life insurance, right?

No... yer not paying attention. All means to this end...are NOT equal... some require 40 years of hard work... and some only take ONE DAY... or ONE MINUTE of one day... or ONE HOUR of one day.

Path of least resistance. If you had a choice... which one would you select? See... the confusing part.. is that - how often can a catastrophe (thousands of innocent people dying) actually aid a good honest person in achieving their goals... it almost goes against common logic.

That's why it is so important that the PNAC actually admits... that a catastrophe would actually expedite(make it easier) for them to realize the transformation they want to see for American in the New Century.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom