Project for the New American Century

"The history of the 20th century should have taught us that it is important to shape circumstances before crises emerge, and to meet threats before they become dire."

I'm only on the first page... and already I have another gem. What new defense strategy is the US employing globally... but the preemptive strike and/or invasion tactic. We saw it with Iraq, and now we will see it with Iran.

This fits perfectly with the founding principles of the PNAC.
 
Last edited:
Spin... you are weak... because you are scared to face the truth. Tell me what the Pearl Harbor line means... and I will respect you.

It means if we don't upgrade our military to a new smart high-tech paradigm, we are vulnerable to a situation where a foreign military can take advantage of us.
 
"The history of the 20th century should have taught us that it is important to shape circumstances before crises emerge, and to meet threats before they become dire."

I'm only on the first page... and already I have another gem. What new defense strategy is the US employing globally... but the preemptive strike and/or invasion strategy. We saw it with Iraq, and now we will see it with Iran.

This fits perfectly with the founding principles of the PNAC.

After all this discussion you had not read it before?
 
Anti and Fire... Give me your personal interpretations of the Pearl Harbor line... or suffer the shame and embarrassment of your shortcomings.
To preserve American military preeminence in the coming decades, the Department of Defense must move more aggressively to experiment with new technologies and operational concepts, and seek to exploit the emerging revolution in military affairs. Information technologies, in particular, are becoming more prevalent and significant components of modern military systems. These information technologies are having the same kind of transforming effects on military affairs as they are having in the larger world. The effectsof this military transformation will have profound implications for how wars are fought, what kinds of weapons will dominate the battlefield and, inevitably, which nations enjoy military preeminence.​

The United States enjoys every prospect of leading this transformation. Indeed, it was the improvements in capabilities acquired during the American defense buildup of the 1980s that hinted at and then confirmed, during Operation Desert Storm, that a revolution in military affairs was at hand. At the same time, the process of military transformation will present opportunities for America’s adversaries to develop new capabilities that in turn will create new challenges for U.S. military preeminence.​

Moreover, the Pentagon, constrained by limited budgets and pressing current missions, has seen funding for experimentation and transformation crowded out in recent years. Spending on military research and development has been reduced dramatically over the past decade. Indeed, during the mid-1980’s, when the Defense Department was in the midst of the Reagan buildup which was primarily an effort to expand existing forces and field traditional weapons systems, research spending represented 20 percent of total Pentagon budgets. By contrast, today’s research and development accounts total only 8 percent of defense spending. And even this reduced total is primarily for upgrades of current weapons. Without increased spending on basic research and development the United States will be unable to exploit the RMA and preserve its technological edge on future battlefields.​

Any serious effort at transformation must occur within the larger framework of U.S. national security strategy, military missions and defense budgets. The United States cannot simply declare a “strategic pause” while experimenting with new technologies and operational concepts. Nor can it choose to pursue a transformation strategy that would decouple American and allied interests.​

A transformation strategy that solely pursued capabilities for projecting force from the United States, for example, and sacrificed forward basing and presence, would be at odds with larger American policy goals and would trouble American allies. Further, the process of transformation, even if it brings revolutionary change, is likely to be a long one, absent some catastrophic and catalyzing event – like a new Pearl Harbor. Domestic politics and industrial policy will shape the pace and content of transformation as much as the requirements of current missions. A decision to suspend or terminate aircraft carrier production, as recommended by this report and as justified by the clear direction of military technology, will cause great upheaval. Likewise, systems entering production today – the F-22 fighter, for example – will be in service inventories for decades to come. Wise management of this process will consist in large measure of figuring out the right moments to halt production of current-paradigm weapons and shift to radically new designs. The expense associated with some programs can make them roadblocks to the larger process of transformation – the Joint Strike Fighter program, at a total of approximately $200 billion, seems an unwise investment. Thus, this report advocates a two-stage process of change – transition and transformation – over the coming decades.​

The passage is discussing the R&D of new technologies in the US military and how, barring some unforseen outside influence, the rate of this progress will be set out by politics and industry. The "Pearl Harbor" clause is nothing more than an example of one possible outside influence that could affect the rate of R&D. This is no different than if you were talking to your automotive insurance broker and (s)he said, "You're rates will continue to increase at only .5%/year, unless you have another accident like the one that occurred last year."​
​

​
​


​
 
Last edited:
Another fly in the ointment is the total absence of Democrats in PNAC. If both parties are in on it, why is (or was) PNAC all Republicans? The same could be said of Bohemian Grove and the Bilderbergs, where you don't find many Democrats. Don't they know they're in on the plan?

Conspiracy guys always say a group of elite families controls U.S. politics, but not a single historian in the world thinks so.
If I'm not mistaken, elite families have tried to control countries and policies throughout history. I believe they were called dynasties and reigns.
I don't think many were successful for very long, children and treachery being what they are.
Do you ever hear about Agustus Ceasar's family still being in control of Italy?
Or Alexander the Great?

History also has incidences where robber baron families like the Rockerfellers have tried to influence politics with thier money inorder to expander or secure thier business interest. But they meet with varying degrees of failure and success.

History has shown that no individual or group can hold or maintain control for a very long time. Look at the history of Rome. (they were the longest)

Some day the "almighty" USA will become a page in some future history book.

Heck maybe even the strangle hold of monetary gain may also come to pass.
 
"At present the United States faces no global rival. America’s grand strategy should aim to preserve and extend this advantageous position as far into the future as possible."

"The Defense Policy Guidance (DPG) drafted in the early months of 1992 provided a blueprint for maintaining U.S. preeminence, precluding the rise of a great power rival, and shaping the international security order in line with American principles and interests."

I don't think any of you have read this thing... because it's a perfect account of what the US is currently doing in the middle east. They are acting like world police... by purportedly spreading democracy, while simultaneously extending their global leadership and preeminence by preemptively meeting threats before they quote, "become dire."

You know like... we must invade Iran before something bad happens. It hasn't happened yet... but the US must act first.. to shape the circumstances before a crisis emerges.

I love the PNAC... can't wait to finish this thing... I want to see how this whole middle east fiasco turns out... I'm sure it's all in here!
 
"The history of the 20th century should have taught us that it is important to shape circumstances before crises emerge, and to meet threats before they become dire."

I'm only on the first page... and already I have another gem. What new defense strategy is the US employing globally... but the preemptive strike and/or invasion strategy. We saw it with Iraq, and now we will see it with Iran.

This fits perfectly with the founding principles of the PNAC.

Are you truly suggesting it is better for a nation to be reactive instead of proactive in handling potential threats to its citizenry and/or sovereigns?
 
Anti and Fire... Give me your personal interpretations of the Pearl Harbor line... or suffer the shame and embarrassment of your shortcomings.
Wow, this is a mission impossible!

I have no "personal interpretation" of the Pearl Harbor line. Just the boring standard interpretation of what the report actually says.
And this has already been explained by others, for example by Arkan_Wolfshade.

As for being embarrassed by my shortcomings: well, as everyone I suppose I have shortcomings. :o
However, I'm smarter than some others (:)) , so in general I don't post on forums about things I know almost nothing about. You won't see me pontificate about the exact mechanism of the collapse, about the inner working of FDR's, about the technicalities of remote control of airplanes, etc ...
So I will be less often embarrassed than, well, you know who, right? :)
 
Last edited:

The passage is discussing the R&D of new technologies in the US military and how, barring some unforseen outside influence, the rate of this progress will be set out by politics and industry. The "Pearl Harbor" clause is nothing more than an example of one possible outside influence that could affect the rate of R&D. This is no different than if you were talking to your automotive insurance broker and (s)he said, "You're rates will continue to increase at only .5%/year, unless you have another accident like the one that occurred last year."​

What kind of assbackward analogy is that? The insurance going up is a negative thing... the expedition of the R & D process is a positive thing.
 
28th,

You don't think it is at all dubious that you made up a firm conclusion about PNAC and Rebuilding America's Defenses before you had even read it yourself?
 
What kind of assbackward analogy is that? The insurance going up is a negative thing... the expedition of the R & D process is a positive thing.
It is analogous because it is predicting a trend and providing an example of a caveat that could make the trend prediction invalid. Whether the trend in the analogy is upwards or downwards is irrelevant.
 
At least he isn't making the typical truther claim that "Rebuilding Americas Defenses" specifically called for the invasion of Iraq and Afghanistan.
 
Last edited:
Are you truly suggesting it is better for a nation to be reactive instead of proactive in handling potential threats to its citizenry and/or sovereigns?

So you believe in thought police? Do you believe, that someone should be arrested before they even commit a crime... isn't that kind of a dangerous practice?
 
What kind of assbackward analogy is that? The insurance going up is a negative thing... the expedition of the R & D process is a positive thing.
higher rates is a positive for the insurance company

by your logic if the drive does have an accident this year then you would accuse the insurance agent of causing the accident, because they admitted to wanting to do it, lol
 
So you believe in thought police? Do you believe, that someone should be arrested before they even commit a crime... isn't that kind of a dangerous practice?
so if someone walked into a bank and pulled a gun youd wait until he shot someone to arrest him?

i agree there is such a thing as too proactive, but a strictly reactive policy is no good either
 
So you believe in thought police? Do you believe, that someone should be arrested before they even commit a crime... isn't that kind of a dangerous practice?
Policies in dealing with foreign powers and/or threats is not analogous to thought policing of its own citizenry.

ETA: Plus what defaultdotxbe said in post #98 of this thread.
 
So you believe in thought police? Do you believe, that someone should be arrested before they even commit a crime... isn't that kind of a dangerous practice?
Another lame analogy. We're not talking about jaywalking, dude.
Should the government step in and take action against an outside threat to its populace? Absolutely. Especially now that they've proven there is no atrocity too great for them to commit.
I don't want to wait until another 3000 innocent souls are killed. Obviously you do.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom