Project for the New American Century

28th,

You don't think it is at all dubious that you made up a firm conclusion about PNAC and Rebuilding America's Defenses before you had even read it yourself?
Yep.

Here's what he wrote about PNAC on 23 december:

Hey OSist...most of you agree that the Bush administration is exploiting the deaths of 3000 innocent Americans for its own political agenda...namely expanding the military so that the American Empire can effectively invade and steal whatever country it wants...as was laid out in the PNAC.

And, how the USG can and has killed innocent women and children within its own country (Waco) and without retribution. And, how the USG has a long history of targeting and killing innocent civilians in other countries during times of war...so what's up?

OSist: Oh come on now...sure, Bush is a pretty bad dude, of course, he's lied to the American people about 1 million times...of course, he's overseen a military that has killed hundreds of thousands of innocent Iraqi civilians (but, that's what democracy is all about) of course, he's now on record as saying that the Iraq invasion had nothing to do with the war on terror...of course, there are official documents coming out, that state the USG knew Saddam had no MD's before they invaded...of course, Bush proclaimed right after he got into office, that he was hell bent on invading Iraq....of course, it makes perfect sense that after 9/11 the US would leave their borders wide open and all but abandon an operation to catch the man responsible for 9/11 - so that the US could go play world police by spreading democracy (killing innocent women and children...while inciting a civil war so that the US can have an excuse to setup up permanent military bases) in the middle-east...of course, the USG has the power to kill anyone - innocent or not, in the US or abroad - and without repercussions...but, you really think Bush or the USG would kill its own people to exploit them for their own political agendas?

Oh come on now...that's just crazy talk. Of course, the PNAC hinted at the fact that its members needed a New Pearl Harbor in order to gain the support of the American people to expand the military and invade other countries without reasonable cause...but that's just pure coincidence. Especially, since PNAC members...don't hold any key positions in the USG. If they did...than maybe, I could see your point a little...

Someone go find me a word that means 'naive' to the tenth power. Why do you all accept everything at face value? Why do you assume that the world...and everything in it...is exactly how it appears on the surface? And to question this facade...automatically indicts one with crimes of insanity.

CTist are screaming, "The WORLD is ROUND!" And OSist, are like, "You fruitcake...what would make you think a crazy thing like that? I can see the world with my own two eyes...and I can assure you, it's flat."
(bolding mine)

Like most woowoo's, he is just recycling nonsense he finds on conspiracy-sites, without ever checking anything!
 
Yes.... apparently you are a true skeptic... as you consider both sides... unlike these other pseudoskeptics, whose appeal to authority only allows them to see half of the picture.

Firstly, America is not run by America... it is run by these families who don't give a damn about America's reputation... they are using America and its resources the same way they used Germany and the USSR. The goal is a one world government with one currency... that is all controlled and manipulated by these central group of bankers.

First you had the European Union, and the Euro... and now we have the North American Union and the Amero... than the Pan American Union - and so on and so forth.

I hate to tell you this but globalization is an inevitability. The world has just become to dependent on foriegn trade to go back. It would be devistating to our economy if we go isolationist. Even notoriously xenophobic China has realized the neccesity of globalization.

There's a delegation of Chinese businessmen and officials being paraded way down here in South Texas to bring thier factories and businesses down here.

BTW, who are these families? Are they families that own businesses? You do do know that the historical foundation of the United States was about business and merchants and land owners? That the whole American revolution was about money? (i.e. Taxation and property)

The rich have always had the power throughout history because they had the resources. The French revolution just repalced one set of rich people with another set of rich people.
The Rockerfellers actually saved the US on more than one occasion from financial ruin.

It's even true to day, The only difference is that just about anybody can become rich if they get luck or play thier cards right.
Look at Bill Gates. Do you know how much power this guy can wield? 90% of the worlds computers run his software and do you know how dependent we are on computers now days?

And what power do we the small people hold? Yep that's right. money. The power of the market place. We determine which companies live or die by our patronage. The only problem is that the middleclass and poor people are notoriously disorganized.

But anyhoo. Welcome to the new world.
 
Negativ... you disappoint me... for someone who apparently idolizes a maverick and innovative original like Zappa, you sure are one closed-minded, herd following individual.

9/11 is an inside job... I would bet my life and the life of everyone I know on it. It is fact... it's not a guess... or a wishful thought. I use to believe in the OS...but, I have since surveyed all of the evidence...and my 150 IQ, coupled with my spiritual enlightenment... leads me to the undeniable truth... and that is... elements within the USG were actively involved in the execution of 9/11. This is based in pure irrefutable fact... all you need do is turn off yer 48484848 tele and put down yer 484848484 beer and open yer 48484 474747474 mind a little.

I have nothing to gain from 9/11 being an inside job... I admit - it is a painful truth and I wish it weren't true... however, I must confront the truth regardless of how much it may inconvenience my life... for without the truth we are but ignorant pawns at the mercy of the machine.

And... I use to be one of these pawns... so don't feel so bad.

You seem to bet your life on things with little or no evidence. Do you play the lotto quite a bit?
 
"Leaked before it had been formally approved, the document was criticized as an effort by “cold warriors” to keep defense spending high and cuts in forces small despite the collapse of the Soviet Union; not surprisingly, it was subsequently buried by the new administration."

Has anyone seen the documentary, "The Power of Nightmares," where it talks about how Rumsfeld and the other neocons created these imaginary threats from the USSR in the 70's, by saying the Soviets had weaponry that couldn't be detected, but that the US was positive they had these weapons... or something like that... it's bizarre, you need to watch this documentary if you haven't already seen it.

Anyway, this line from the PNAC... is also referenced in The Power of Nightmares, where they talk about the need to create a new boogeyman i.e. OBL - to generate another crisis or global threat to replace the fall of the USSR, so that the neocons could keep defense spending high. See, they admit that defense spending was declining after the demise of the USSR...

Now... you tell me - what year did the American public first become aware of OBL as a global threat (terrorist) if not in the early 90's right after the fall of the USSR? Coincidence? Apparently, they used OBL to fight the Soviets and then after the Soviets were gone... they used OBL as this new boogeyman... so that they could maintain high defense spending... in order to fight this new external threat.

The Power of Nightmares Part 2:

http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=-7930933565201168

The Power of Nightmares Part 3:

http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=-3649090417189127240
 
High profile external threats:
Al Qaeda
North Korea
Iraq (pre-invasion)
Iran

The problem is, you are looking for motives without looking for evidence to show the motive has been acted upon in the manner you feel it has.

Additionally, you search for motives is clearly biased. One could argue that a foreign power, such as N. Korea, could launch a false flag operation, under the guise of Al Qaeda, to direct attention away from their weapons research. That you only look at the US as a possible source reveals your bias.
 
Sigh... you people have so bought into this whole fear campaign. God, this is so disconcerting... I can't believe you all think it's okay to overthrow countries who have never posed a threat to the US, and who continue to pose no threat to the US... all because the US scares you into believing that these countries will attack if you don't attack them first...

SINCE WHEN has any country ever had to be so proactive in its defenses? Sounds more like imperialism masked as defense...coated in good-will...to me. My god... the absurdity of this whole premise, is just so far off the chart...

The only reason you are all buying into this whole charade is because of 9/11... and the fact that you saw/experienced what you thought was a real-life attack on your homeland and on your people. Without this image in your head... America's actions in the middle east would seem absolutely ridiculous to you... as they should.

You have been bound in this pit of fear... where you will support any action by the US, so long as you think it prevents future 9/11's and/or protects you from the boogeyman.

Now... do you see the motivation behind 9/11? They got EXACTLY WHAT THEY WERE LOOKING FOR... cart blanche from the American people to attack any and everyone... who the USG wants to eliminate for their own political gain.
 
Last edited:
I use to believe in the OS...but, I have since surveyed all of the evidence...and my 150 IQ, coupled with my spiritual enlightenment... leads me to the undeniable truth...

So, by surveying, you mean not actually looking at the evidence (such as the PNAC Report), but just forming opinions on what you think it says from what other people say about it?

Or is surveying basing your conclusions on things that don't exist? Like thermite devices that could cut vertical steel columns.

If your 150 IQ and your "spiritual enlightenment" leads you to these kinds of undeniable truths, then I hope you've left a trail of bread crumbs so you can find your way back to reality.
 
Sigh... you people have so bought into this whole fear campaign. God, this is so disconcerting... I can't believe you all think it's okay to overthrow countries who have never posed a threat to the US, and who continue to pose no threat to the US... all because the US scares you into believing that this country will attack if you don't attack it first...

SINCE WHEN has any country ever had to be so proactive in its defenses? Sounds more like imperialism masked as defense...coated in good-will...to me. My god... the absurdity of this whole premise, is just so far off the chart...

The only reason you are all buying into it is because of 9/11... and the fact that you saw what you thought was a real-life attack on your homeland and on your people. Without this image in your head... American's actions in the middle east would seem so absolutely ridiculous to you... as they should.

You have been bound in this pit of fear... where you will support any action by the US, so long as you think it prevents future 9/11's and/or protects you from the boogeyman.

Now... do you see the motivation behind 9/11? They got EXACTLY WHAT THEY WERE LOOKING FOR... cart blanche from the American people to attack any and everyone... who the USG wants to eliminate for their own political gain.

Your political opinion about US policy is not evidence of an inside job of 9/11.

ETA: To clarify; you are using circular logic even at this level of discussion.
 
Sigh... you people have so bought into this whole fear campaign.


I find statements like these from truthers to be extremely ironic.

A group of people who fear some faceless non existant entity accusing others of buying into fear.
 
Sigh... you people have so bought into this whole fear campaign. God, this is so disconcerting... I can't believe you all think it's okay to overthrow countries who have never posed a threat to the US, and who continue to pose no threat to the US... all because the US scares you into believing that this country will attack if you don't attack it first...

SINCE WHEN has any country ever had to be so proactive in its defenses? Sounds more like imperialism masked as defense...coated in good-will...to me. My god... the absurdity of this whole premise, is just so far off the chart...

The only reason you are all buying into this whole charade is because of 9/11... and the fact that you saw/experienced what you thought was a real-life attack on your homeland and on your people. Without this image in your head... America's actions in the middle east would seem so absolutely ridiculous to you... as they should.

You have been bound in this pit of fear... where you will support any action by the US, so long as you think it prevents future 9/11's and/or protects you from the boogeyman.

Now... do you see the motivation behind 9/11? They got EXACTLY WHAT THEY WERE LOOKING FOR... cart blanche from the American people to attack any and everyone... who the USG wants to eliminate for their own political gain.

Another emotional screed by the master of histrionics, distorter of history, and ignorer of facts.
 
I am more interested in why you feel the need to state your interpretation as fact. Why are you afraid of the actual facts?
 
Is anyone... getting anything out of my analysis of the PNAC... or should I just stop and save everyone the headache?
 
Is anyone... getting anything out of my analysis of the PNAC... or should I just stop and save everyone the headache?

If it means you will actually read it, go ahead. Of course, comprehension is another issue, but we'll let you try to read it first.
 
So, by surveying, you mean not actually looking at the evidence (such as the PNAC Report), but just forming opinions on what you think it says from what other people say about it?

Have you read all 10,000 pages of the NIST? Has any of you? The case of mine has been rested... now shudap!
 
Have you read all 10,000 pages of the NIST? Has any of you?
No, I haven't read the NIST. I haven't made any claims based on it. You have. Like the existence of a thermite device that cuts vertical steel beams.

And we were talking about the PNAC report here. Which it appears that you've now just started reading long after numerous posts giving your interpretations of what it said.

The case of mine has been rested... now shudap!

What the heck does that mean? 150 IQ?
 
Have you read all 10,000 pages of the NIST? Has any of you? The case of mine has been rested... now shudap!

I have read or skimmed most of it, in fact. Granted I skipped over large sections after reading the intro/conclusion bits because it was in more detail than I required for my own personal edification. I do, however, know all of the major conclusions in the work, and I know where to find their methodology if I need more detail, or wish to question their results.

How much have you read?
 
Have you read all 10,000 pages of the NIST? Has any of you? The case of mine has been rested... now shudap!
Not all 10,000 pages, no.
However, like many people here I have read the main report (see here). I also downloaded the whole set of files (from here), and use these to check specific details.

You absolutely must read at least the main report.
It is well-written, and even a lay-person (like myself) can understand most of it.
 
Your political opinion about US policy is not evidence of an inside job of 9/11.

Actually, this documentary, 'The Power of Nightmares," was made by the BBC. You don't get any more mainstream media than the BBC. So are you saying that the BBC consists of a bunch of whacked out CTist, because they believe that OBL and al Qaeda are fake boogeymen, who the US invented in order to create a crisis that would insure high defense spending? Well, do you?

Also, if OBL is the one purportedly behind 9/11...and we prove that OBL is not what he really appears to be... well, then - yes, my dear friend... that does go along way towards debunking the OS.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom