Project for the New American Century

28th is obviously not aware of the results of the 2006 U.S. elections.

Where'd all that "star wars" missile-shield defense money go, 28th? That was the PNAC's main defense initiative, not more armor for Humvees.

I missed the portion in "Rebuilding America's Defenses" where the PNAC called for a U.S. overseas invasion and unimaginably expensive occupation/war against insurgents armed with RPGs and old artillery shells. High technology – the focus of the PNAC report – is not a defense against such enemies.

I did see the part of that paper that called for us to maintain our bases in Saudi Arabia. Oops, that didn't work out.

I did see the part of that paper that called on the air force to reduce its emphasis on tactical operations in favor of strategic and space operations. Oops.

I did see the part of that paper that called for the production and purchase of the the Comanche helicopter. Oops, that didn't work out.

I did see the part of that paper that called for the cancellation of the "roadblock" Joint Strike Fighter. That roadblock remains firmly in place, and as planned will be the most expensive military aircraft purchase in history. Rebuilding America's Defenses says that the needed changes in military technology cannot proceed if the JSF is built. Oops.

Those are just a few of the ways that the PNAC's plan hasn't worked out. The ground war in Iraq is, of course, by far the most significant.
 
28th is obviously not aware of the results of the 2006 U.S. elections.

Where'd all that "star wars" missile-shield defense money go, 28th? That was the PNAC's main defense initiative, not more armor for Humvees.

I missed the portion in "Rebuilding America's Defenses" where the PNAC called for a U.S. overseas invasion and unimaginably expensive occupation/war against insurgents armed with RPGs and old artillery shells. High technology – the focus of the PNAC report – is not a defense against such enemies.

I did see the part of that paper that called for us to maintain our bases in Saudi Arabia. Oops, that didn't work out.

I did see the part of that paper that called on the air force to reduce its emphasis on tactical operations in favor of strategic and space operations. Oops.

I did see the part of that paper that called for the production and purchase of the the Comanche helicopter. Oops, that didn't work out.

I did see the part of that paper that called for the cancellation of the "roadblock" Joint Strike Fighter. That roadblock remains firmly in place, and as planned will be the most expensive military aircraft purchase in history. Rebuilding America's Defenses says that the needed changes in military technology cannot proceed if the JSF is built. Oops.

Those are just a few of the ways that the PNAC's plan hasn't worked out. The ground war in Iraq is, of course, by far the most significant.

And, once again... you fail to see the big picture... opting instead to pick apart small details... this is a highly redundant debating pattern that all of you skeptics love to employ. The ole Bogged Down in the Details Syndrome.
 
Last edited:
And, once again... you fail to see the big picture... opting instead to pick apart small details... this is a highly redundant debating pattern that all of you skeptics love to employ.

Well, i´m sceptic, too. That´s why i consider both sides
of the issues. Anyway - what is your point of view, what
is the "big picture"? Dumping America´s reputation and
losing the elections? :confused:
 
And once again 28th, are you ever going to respond to the technical rebuttal of your "fires don't cause steel to fail" fancy or are you just going to run away - as usual?
 
And once again 28th, are you ever going to respond to the technical rebuttal of your "fires don't cause steel to fail" fancy or are you just going to run away - as usual?

I´m sorry but this is also completely off-topic, Architect.
You may like to ask him per PM? :)
 
And, once again... you fail to see the big picture... opting instead to pick apart small details... this is a highly redundant debating pattern that all of you skeptics love to employ. The ole Bogged Down in the Details Syndrome.
War with and and military occupation of Iraq, lost elections, no money for "star wars," and the procurement of an aircraft system that the PNAC says will prevent the needed technological changes from happening are small details?

This is a serious question: are you on drugs?
 
Nope, Oliver, I'm going to keep pursing this idiots lies and evasions so that the unwary are aware of just what a maroon he is. Sorry, but you will recall that it's what I promised to do waaay back in December.



ETA: Although I have to add that he's really doing a sterling job of discrediting himself these days....
 
War with and and military occupation of Iraq, lost elections, no money for "star wars," and the procurement of an aircraft system that the PNAC says will prevent the needed technological changes from happening are small details?

This is a serious question: are you on drugs?

Personally i think the Reagon "Star wars program" is a
completely different issue because the CT´ists are not
able to connect it to 9/11.
 
Nope, Oliver, I'm going to keep pursing this idiots lies and evasions so that the unwary are aware of just what a maroon he is. Sorry, but you will recall that it's what I promised to do waaay back in December.

ETA: Although I have to add that he's really doing a sterling job of discrediting himself these days....


I know how you feel - but we make no results if we
jump from issue to issue. Maybe we´re able to learn
something if we discuss one issue at a time. :)
 
28th doesn't discuss one issue properly at a time; he cherry picks quotes in a culpably reckless manner, puts anyone who beats him in an argument on ignore, and is now demonstrating anti-semitic tendencies which would be illegal in most of Europe. He's a clown.
 
Well, i´m sceptic, too. That´s why i consider both sides
of the issues. Anyway - what is your point of view, what
is the "big picture"? Dumping America´s reputation and
losing the elections? :confused:

Yes.... apparently you are a true skeptic... as you consider both sides... unlike these other pseudoskeptics, whose appeal to authority only allows them to see half of the picture.

Firstly, America is not run by America... it is run by these families who don't give a damn about America's reputation... they are using America and its resources the same way they used Germany and the USSR. The goal is a one world government with one currency... that is all controlled and manipulated by these central group of bankers.

First you had the European Union, and the Euro... and now we have the North American Union and the Amero... than the Pan American Union - and so on and so forth.
 
Yes.... apparently you are a true skeptic... as you consider both sides... unlike these other pseudoskeptics, whose appeal to authority only allows them to see half of the picture.

Firstly, America is not run by America... it is run by these families who don't give a damn about America's reputation... they are using America and its resources the same way they used Germany and the USSR. The goal is a one world government with one currency... that is all controlled and manipulated by these central group of bankers.

First you had the European Union, and the Euro... and now we have the North American Union and the Amero... than the Pan American Union - and so on and so forth.
'zat you, Jason? Welcome to the JREF forums. Please take your antipsychotic meds.
 
Yes.... apparently you are a true skeptic... as you consider both sides... unlike these other pseudoskeptics, whose appeal to authority only allows them to see half of the picture.

Oh, this might be a misinterpretation - i never met a
Bush-Bootlicker in here. The US-members are more
patriotic than the foreign members but as i said - never
met someone who does not question Bushs policy in
some way.

Firstly, America is not run by America... it is run by these families who don't give a damn about America's reputation... they are using America and its resources the same way they used Germany and the USSR. The goal is a one world government with one currency... that is all controlled and manipulated by these central group of bankers.

First you had the European Union, and the Euro... and now we have the North American Union and the Amero... than the Pan American Union - and so on and so forth.

The decision to invent an european-wide shared medium of
exchange was to stay on top of a worldwide race to survive
in terms of international rivalry. You have to consider that the
US-Dollar was pretty strong before the Euro.

Personally i don´t like it, too - but this is the way politics
works. Also america has to react to this development to
counter the strenght of the Euro. So to me it´s not the
intention to get a worldwide medium of exchange but to
counter the development. But i´m no expert within these
things. However - i see no relation to any conspiracy.

Concerning the ruling families in America: I´m also no expert
in american politics - you may ask the freaks within the
politics forum, i´m pretty sure they already thought
about it and are able to answer the questions about it:
(And yes, they don´t buy into Bush´s policy, too.)

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=6
 
Another fly in the ointment is the total absence of Democrats in PNAC. If both parties are in on it, why is (or was) PNAC all Republicans? The same could be said of Bohemian Grove and the Bilderbergs, where you don't find many Democrats. Don't they know they're in on the plan?

Conspiracy guys always say a group of elite families controls U.S. politics, but not a single historian in the world thinks so.
 
Last edited:
Another fly in the ointment is the total absence of Democrats in PNAC. If both parties are in on it, why is (or was) PNAC all Republicans? The same could be said of Bohemian Grove and the Bilderbergs, where you don't find many Democrats. Don't they know they're in on the plan? Reality rarely play along with the conspiracist paradigm.

Is there no article from the Democrats concerning the
PNAC plans? I mean someone should have said something
against it since it was published... :confused:
 
Is there no article from the Democrats concerning the
PNAC plans? I mean someone should have said something
against it since it was published... :confused:

I don't really see why.

The US is chock full of faux 'foundations' and 'corporations' set up by wealthy benefactors on both sides of the political spectrum who make a healthy living out of producing their own manifestos for the future direction of american life.

That it was signed by the good and the great of the Republican movement (oh and Dan Quayle) merely places it up on the shelf along with proclamations from the Heritage Foundation. And who pays any attention to them?
 
And, once again... you fail to see the big picture... opting instead to pick apart small details... this is a highly redundant debating pattern that all of you skeptics love to employ. The ole Bogged Down in the Details Syndrome.

In terms of picking out details, I've always thought it was a shame that CT only focuses on a few words of the long PNAC document. Even quoting the 'new pearl harbour' bit in the context of the paragraph it's in, this looks even less like a call for a false flag operation and it becomes more apparent that 9/11 didn't let PNAC get all that they wanted:

Further, the process of transformation,
even if it brings revolutionary change, is
likely to be a long one, absent some
catastrophic and catalyzing event – like a
new Pearl Harbor. Domestic politics and
industrial policy will shape the pace and
content of transformation as much as the
requirements of current missions. A
decision to suspend or terminate aircraft
carrier production, as recommended by this
report and as justified by the clear direction
of military technology, will cause great
upheaval. Likewise, systems entering
production today – the F-22 fighter, for
example – will be in service inventories for
decades to come. Wise management of this
process will consist in large measure of
figuring out the right moments to halt
production of current-paradigm weapons
and shift to radically new designs. The
expense associated with some programs can
make them roadblocks to the larger process
of transformation – the Joint Strike Fighter
program, at a total of approximately $200
billion, seems an unwise investment. Thus,
this report advocates a two-stage process of
change – transition and transformation –
over the coming decades.

If PNAC get the transformations they advocated (given the problems and failures in Iraq, among other issues, I doubt it) this will still take decades.

It's also a shame that PNAC (or, more often, one sentence from one PNAC document) is priveleged over a lot of other pre-9/11 debate around similar areas. Some RAND Corporation work, for example, is seems to bear much more directly on 9/11 than Rebuilding America's Defenses does.
 
And, once again... you fail to see the big picture... opting instead to pick apart small details... this is a highly redundant debating pattern that all of you skeptics love to employ. The ole Bogged Down in the Details Syndrome.

Translation: "Don't try to inject bothersome facts into my fantasy. My mind's permanently made up."
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom