Arkan_Wolfshade
Philosopher
- Joined
- Jan 18, 2006
- Messages
- 7,154
Well, let's see, what was Pearl Harbor?
Pearl Harbor was a military attack, by a foreign nation's military, against a US military installation that occurred while US allies were in armed conflict against the attacker's allies.
What were the effects of Pearl Harbor?
Gave the US the needed nudge to enter WWII both from a political standpoint and a popular support angle.
Entering the war did bolster the military support from Washington and bolstered the economy, but there was a significant ramp-up time.
Why would PNAC reference Pearl Harbor in their discussion of what the future direction of the armed forces and the related R&D?
A fear of history repeating itself. Realizing that history has shown that nations become lax in the military focus during long duration times of peace they feared that R&D and change within the armed forces would creep along and, if another event like Pearl Harbor occurred, we would once again be playing catch-up to be able to retaliate, and take the fight to the enemy.
How does 9/11 compare to Pearl Harbor?
There were no existing engagements that the US allies were involved in at the time of the attacks that we could/would have been drawn in to.
The attack was not launched by a foreign nation.
The attack was not carried out by a foreign nation's military.
The US has attempted to take the war to the enemy's soil, but since the enemy is not a sovereign power, these attempts have had limited success.
The R&D and organization that was pursued prior to the attack, and emphasized after the attack has not been successful in dealing with a non-convential OpFor.
WWII was supported, to my understanding, by the general populace for the four years after the US entered the war has not repeated itself in the six years since 9/11.
28th, you are basing your entire argument on a caveat mentioned by a committee in a chapter discussing the expected trend of armed forces R&D and organization, in a document discussing recommendations for how the US should fund its military. Not only that, but you are suggesting that the US carried out an operation based upon this caveat within 18 months of the report being finalized.
You are chasing fairies at the bottom of the garden in an attempt to either justifiy your preconceived notions, or as a means to attack one suggested policy that has been recommended to the federal gov't.
Pearl Harbor was a military attack, by a foreign nation's military, against a US military installation that occurred while US allies were in armed conflict against the attacker's allies.
What were the effects of Pearl Harbor?
Gave the US the needed nudge to enter WWII both from a political standpoint and a popular support angle.
Entering the war did bolster the military support from Washington and bolstered the economy, but there was a significant ramp-up time.
Why would PNAC reference Pearl Harbor in their discussion of what the future direction of the armed forces and the related R&D?
A fear of history repeating itself. Realizing that history has shown that nations become lax in the military focus during long duration times of peace they feared that R&D and change within the armed forces would creep along and, if another event like Pearl Harbor occurred, we would once again be playing catch-up to be able to retaliate, and take the fight to the enemy.
How does 9/11 compare to Pearl Harbor?
There were no existing engagements that the US allies were involved in at the time of the attacks that we could/would have been drawn in to.
The attack was not launched by a foreign nation.
The attack was not carried out by a foreign nation's military.
The US has attempted to take the war to the enemy's soil, but since the enemy is not a sovereign power, these attempts have had limited success.
The R&D and organization that was pursued prior to the attack, and emphasized after the attack has not been successful in dealing with a non-convential OpFor.
WWII was supported, to my understanding, by the general populace for the four years after the US entered the war has not repeated itself in the six years since 9/11.
28th, you are basing your entire argument on a caveat mentioned by a committee in a chapter discussing the expected trend of armed forces R&D and organization, in a document discussing recommendations for how the US should fund its military. Not only that, but you are suggesting that the US carried out an operation based upon this caveat within 18 months of the report being finalized.
You are chasing fairies at the bottom of the garden in an attempt to either justifiy your preconceived notions, or as a means to attack one suggested policy that has been recommended to the federal gov't.
