Possibility of proving that God maker of everything exists.

The questions are:
1. Is it possible to prove to an atheist that God maker of everything exists?

2. And is it possible for himself to prove to himself that God maker of everything exists?
​

​



Before anything else we have to -- that is you anyone and everyone who answer yes to 1 and yes to 2 -- determine whether an atheist has the capability for cognitive certainty.


That means that he is intelligent and also psychologically receptive to proof for the attainment of certainty.


How do we determine that an atheist is intelligent and is psychologically receptive to proof?






Yrreg

Yrreg, the shifter of goal posts.

Sorry, try the evidence for a created universe.
 
The questions are:
1. Is it possible to prove to an atheist that God maker of everything exists?

2. And is it possible for himself to prove to himself that God maker of everything exists?
​

​








There is a very simple way to prove that an atheist can be intelligent and can be psychologically receptive to proof of the certainty of God's existence.

Would you anyone and everyone who answer yes to 1 and yes to 2 be interested in knowing what is that very simple way to show that an atheist can be intelligent and can be psychologically receptive to proof of God's existence?

Tell me then what is that simple way?






Yrreg


Yregg the gilder of new goal posts.
 
There is no call for the unacceptable language.


If you see any unacceptable language from my part, just report me to the moderators or administrators.


You still have not come to the simple way by which one can see that the atheist can be intelligent and can be psychologically receptive to the proof of the existence of God.


I gave you a hint and you failed to see it -- in the message previous to this present one.





Yrreg


Yrreg espouses the Mystery of the Gilded Goal Post.
 
The questions are:
1. Is it possible to prove to an atheist that God maker of everything exists?

2. And is it possible for himself to prove to himself that God maker of everything exists?
​

​


These questions bring up an ascendant question, namely:

Who will judge whether:

1. It has been proven to an atheist that God maker of everything exists.

2. An atheist has in effect proven to himself that God exists, but he refuses to admit the proof by an oral or written assent to the truth of God's existence.

​



You can lead a horse to water, but you can't make it drink.








Yrreg

Yrreg, the maker of the nested gilded goal posts.
Atheists deny god and thereby prove god.
 
@ Foster: I don't think it's fair that people keep assigning a gender to God. It is my idea that God somewhat transcends gender, and it is only a convenient convention that depicted God as male. I think it would be more fair if God looked like ... this.
View attachment 14667 View attachment 14668

Think of all the college aged males who'd start coming .... to church! :p

Freya rocks!
 
1. Yes, give them a copy of Snow White to read
2. Yes, on condition that they have read Snow White and know how to use a mirror
 
Is God being defined simply as a first cause of existence? (That's what it looks like, like the Deists' watchmaker god.)

Or are you referring to a god that controls and sees even when a sparrow falls.
 
Is God being defined simply as a first cause of existence? (That's what it looks like, like the Deists' watchmaker god.)

Or are you referring to a god that controls and sees even when a sparrow falls.

Gerry tried the "Spinoza's God" thing. Then he hoped no one would notice as he pole vaulted from there to the the god of Catholicism.
 
Is God being defined simply as a first cause of existence? (That's what it looks like, like the Deists' watchmaker god.)

Or are you referring to a god that controls and sees even when a sparrow falls.

I define God as the maker of everything, everything man knows that is.
Do you give your god any other properties?
Let us first get clear that God is the maker of everything, afterwards we can proceed to discuss the properties of God.

He wants to lure atheists into agreeing that there is a maker of everything and call it God, then he'll trot out the "HA HA GOTCHA" that Foster is referring to.
 
Can't help yourself, can you Gerry?

Who will judge whether:

1. It has been proven to an atheist that God maker of everything exists.

An Atheist.

2. An atheist has in effect proven to himself that God exists, but he refuses to admit the proof by an oral or written assent to the truth of God's existence.

Not you.
 
God is the maker of everything and He does not have to make Himself.

[...]

However, as I said before, "maker of everything" is an inadequate definition [of God]. For example, it would mean that he created himself. In order for him to do that, he would have to prove a paradox.

[...]


God is the maker of everything and He does not have to make Himself.

Why? Because it is not necessary to do so since He is already God the maker of everything.
Edited by Tricky: 
Rule 11 portions removed.

There are several threads for the general discussion of atheism. This one asks specific questions. Please stick to the discussion of those questions.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Tricky
 
Last edited by a moderator:
God is the maker of everything and He does not have to make Himself.

Why? Because it is not necessary to do so since He is already God the maker of everything.
If god requires no maker, why does the universe?
 
God is the maker of everything and He does not have to make Himself.

Why? Because it is not necessary to do so since He is already God the maker of everything.


Why is it not necessary? If you are simply building the why into your definition, why is it wrong to build the why into the definition of everything and simply omit the god part?
 
I like to ask atheists here:


1. Is it possible to prove to an atheist that God maker of everything exists?


2. And is it possible for himself to prove to himself that God maker of everything exists?
​




Yrreg


1. An unknown. If there is a God or Gods his/her/its/their nature may be unprovable and therefore proof in a scientific sense is unattainable. If it is attainable it certainly hasn't been achieved yet.

2. Or indeed does not exist. See 1. Given the failure to date it would suggest that it would be a rather long and fruitless task. That doesn't mean someone should not try but they would have to be motivated to do so. Most, I would suggest, would have other things to do.

Of course anyone can take a step of faith and skip over the proof bit. Once on the other side proof is irrelevant because one believes. One can choose to believe in any number of deities and of course millions do.
 
yrreg's questions answered

1. Is it possible to prove to an atheist that God maker of everything exists?


Yes, by presenting sufficient evidence in support of the claim.


2. Is it possible for [the atheist] to prove to himself that God maker of everything exists?


Yes, by the atheist discovering or otherwise obtaining sufficient evidence in support of the claim.


Those who answer yes to 1 and 2, shall we work together on the how?


I have answered "yes" to 1 & 2 and I have also listed the "how," or at least one possible "how." Do you wish to work further on this together?


How do we determine that an atheist is intelligent and is psychologically receptive to proof?


I would imagine an intelligence test or psychological evaluation that was designed for humans would also work for atheists, although I am unfamiliar with any tests that specifically evaluate psychological receptivity to proof.


Would you anyone and everyone who answer yes to 1 and yes to 2 be interested in knowing what is that very simple way to show that an atheist can be intelligent and can be psychologically receptive to proof of God's existence?


Yes, I would be interested in knowing your very simple way to show that an atheist can be intelligent and can be psychologically receptive to proof of God's existence.


Who will judge whether: It has been proven to an atheist that God maker of everything exists.


First, only the atheist himself can judge whether or not he accepts the statement "God, maker of everything, exists" as being true.

Second, if you are using the phrase "proven to an atheist" in some other way, it is unclear to me what you intended to ask.


Who will judge whether: An atheist has in effect proven to himself that God exists, but he refuses to admit the proof by an oral or written assent to the truth of God's existence.


Only the atheist himself can judge whether or not he accepts the statement "God, maker of everything, exists" as being true but if he does, and is unwilling to disclose it, then to all others it would be no different than if he did not accept the statement as being true. I don't see how anyone can judge whether or not this is what the atheist in question has done unless there is evidence other than his oral or written attestation, such as someone catching him in the act of worshiping God or sacrificing animals to God, or some other visible display of belief.
 
God is the maker of everything and He does not have to make Himself.
Right. So he has no attributes, no omnipotence, no omnipresence, no ability to answer prayers or send sinners to hell. You certainly can't be a Christian, sounds more like a Buddhist to me.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom