Please help with the "Wall of Harm"

There is a thread that I started in the CT forum (actually njslim and I started threads on the same subject at the same time that were merged) that relates to an article about a book written by Damian Thompson entitled "Counterknowledge" that points out the tactics used by CTers and the damage that can result from the acceptance of lies as fact, not just individually, but on entire cultures and populations.
I found it interesting because it takes aim at the Loose Change bunch, but it also cites examples of CTs in the medical and health fields that have caused harm or prevented help to entire populations:

The fingerprints of the alternative medicine lobby are all over the worst British health scare of recent years, in which thousands of parents denied their children the MMR triple vaccine against measles, mumps and rubella following the dissemination of flawed data linking it to autism. In that case, distrust of orthodox medicine increased the danger of a measles epidemic.

But that is nothing compared to the impact of medical counterknowledge in underdeveloped countries. In northern Nigeria, Islamic leaders have issued a fatwa declaring the polio vaccine to be a US conspiracy to sterilise Muslims: polio has returned to the area, and pilgrims have carried it to Mecca and Yemen. In January 2007, the parents of 24,000 children in Pakistan refused to let health workers vaccinate their children because radical mullahs had told them the same idiotic story.

These incidents cannot be dismissed as examples of medieval superstition: these people are not rejecting life-saving vaccines because they reject modern medicine, but because their leaders are spouting Islamic takes on Western conspiracy theories. Counterknowledge, with its ingrained hostility towards a political, intellectual and scientific elite, appeals to anti-American, anti-Western sentiment in the developing world.

This might be a good book to cite in any references and examples of publications you might list.

Edit: Here is a link to the book on Amazon.com:
http://www.amazon.com/Counterknowledge-Damian-Thompson/dp/1843546752/
 
Last edited:
Thanks, folks, for all the tips. Keep them coming. I think I captured all of them, but I do still have a small backlog of URLs from other sources that I need to read & get into the db.

Just as an update, I'm super busy at work this week, but I'm gonna get a domain registered for this and launch it just before TAM 5.5. I'll post the URL when it is live.

A question on that: the pages all say "What's the harm", which seems like the skeptical "meme" for this sort of thing, and therefore good Google bait.

Should I just call the site "What's The Harm?" and forget the "wall" stuff?

My thought is that "wall of harm", while perhaps useful as imagery for skeptics, is not that helpful when trying to attract believers.
 
Another question: replacement for "hysteria"

As we move toward launch, I'm also trying to clean up some of the verbiage to make sure it is very neutral. It occurs to me that a few of my topic names don't seem very neutral:

Metal toxicity hysteria
Satanic ritual abuse hysteria
Apocalypse hysteria
Y2K hysteria

(Yes, I realize I should probably combine those last two).

It occurs to me that a believer, seeing the word "hysteria" in those, might be put off.

Can anyone think of a better way to word this? These are categories so they have to be relatively short to fit in page titles and URLs.
 
Should I just call the site "What's The Harm?" and forget the "wall" stuff?

My thought is that "wall of harm", while perhaps useful as imagery for skeptics, is not that helpful when trying to attract believers.

Yeah. Keep it neutral - and then pelt'em with damning facts.

As we move toward launch, I'm also trying to clean up some of the verbiage to make sure it is very neutral. It occurs to me that a few of my topic names don't seem very neutral:

Metal toxicity hysteria
Satanic ritual abuse hysteria
Apocalypse hysteria
Y2K hysteria

(Yes, I realize I should probably combine those last two).

It occurs to me that a believer, seeing the word "hysteria" in those, might be put off.

Can anyone think of a better way to word this? These are categories so they have to be relatively short to fit in page titles and URLs.

"Scares". People don't mind being called scared, but they don't like to be called hysterics.

And yes, Y2K should be under Apocalypse. ;)
 
I think this is a very cool idea and you've done a great job setting it up. I think this site has the potential to do a lot of good. May I repeat the suggestion, made earlier, that the word "woo" on the main page is replaced with "believer" or some other, woo-friendlier term? This site could appeal strongly to "woo" types, too, most of who will not have heard of the term "woo," - many do try to think critically but are unaware that so much negative, objective (even if anecdotal) evidence is available. Great to have it gathered in one place like this!
 
...would the hysteria surrounding roleplaying games, specifically Dungeons and Dragons, be considered?

That's good outside-the-box thinking. I really do like including categories that are not among the traditional skeptical topics. For instance I have one for "internet misinformation". This helps drive home the point of how generically useful critical thinking is.

I read that whole Wikipedia article, though, and it seemed like all the cases where people actually got harmed (suicides and the like) were, on reflection, caused by other underlying caused and only superficially blamed on D&D. Who in there would you call a victim?
 
A question on that: the pages all say "What's the harm", which seems like the skeptical "meme" for this sort of thing, and therefore good Google bait.

Should I just call the site "What's The Harm?" and forget the "wall" stuff?

My thought is that "wall of harm", while perhaps useful as imagery for skeptics, is not that helpful when trying to attract believers.

As a European, I would not immediately get the wall reference. If properly presented, I could probably get the concept anyway, but I think "What's the harm" is better. Just my two (euro)cents.

Oh, and a great thing about Snopes is the thorough research and the "state lights" - true, false, undetermined. If you had the manpower to do something similar, ranging from a rating of the documentation to full articles, that would be great. That's probably wishful thinking, though.
 
That's good outside-the-box thinking. I really do like including categories that are not among the traditional skeptical topics. For instance I have one for "internet misinformation". This helps drive home the point of how generically useful critical thinking is.

I read that whole Wikipedia article, though, and it seemed like all the cases where people actually got harmed (suicides and the like) were, on reflection, caused by other underlying caused and only superficially blamed on D&D. Who in there would you call a victim?


Which is my main question. That I'm aware of there have been no deaths directly attributed to a roleplaying game and the hobby, but there have been some overblown media surrounding it.

Since you are going to TAM 5.5, you might want to talk with Stackpole. Being the media muckity-muck at GAMA, he might some better insight to some documented stories. I know for a fact he authored a paper on the Pulling story.
 
It suddenly occurs to me to wonder whether the Christian Scientist section is appropriate. Unlike the other medicine-compromising woo, Christian Scientists don't (AFAIK) claim that their doing nothing is more effective than doing something - they know the risks, and choose to refrain from using medicine for religious reasons. The same would apply to Jehova's Witnesses, and other religions that simply prohibit one or more forms of treatment. Generally, these people are aware of the risk, but choose to continue with their practices for spiritual reasons. I don't think that telling them something they already know is going to convince them to change/abandon their religion, and it risks alienating them before they can read about other, more insidious woo.

Pretty much every religion is, directly or indirectly, responsible for numerous deaths. Scientology is a good target, because they actually claim to have a superior treatment. They specifically oppose scientifically proven treatments in favor of their woo, to the detriment of their believers. The cultlike controlling aspects of Jehova's Witnesses are certainly fair game, but I don't see any point to harping on people making poor medical decisions for spiritual reasons. If you're going to do that, you might as well start looking into complications from circumcision, which would risk alienating much larger religious segments.

Overall, I'd go after cultlike practices and practices and beliefs that can be scientifically demonstrated to be woo - since spiritual side-effects cannot be scientifically investigated, practices that are considered a physical sacrifice for spiritual gain can't really be proven as woo.

What do other posters think about this?
 
It suddenly occurs to me to wonder whether the Christian Scientist section is appropriate. Unlike the other medicine-compromising woo, Christian Scientists don't (AFAIK) claim that their doing nothing is more effective than doing something - they know the risks, and choose to refrain from using medicine for religious reasons. The same would apply to Jehova's Witnesses....

Overall, I'd go after cultlike practices and practices and beliefs that can be scientifically demonstrated to be woo - since spiritual side-effects cannot be scientifically investigated, practices that are considered a physical sacrifice for spiritual gain can't really be proven as woo.

That is an interesting point that I had not thought about.

I am very aware of the possibility of alienating religious people. While I am an agnostic/atheist myself, I feel that trying to convince people to abandon religion is (in many cases) an insurmountable problem. As a skeptic my personal choice is to avoid that battle and concentrate on more immediately winnable ones. (That's just my personal choice, and I'm not saying anyone is wrong to choose otherwise).

To play Devil's Advocate for a bit, there was a study in Pediatrics that showed that 80% of child deaths in Christian Scientist (and similar) households are from medical conditions that are 90% curable. It seems like even a religious person might be swayed by that.

On the Jehovah's front, the thing that always stands out to me is the fact that the church formerly prohibited organ transplants, and then reversed themselves in a later ruling. (Of course, what use is allowing transplants if you don't allow transfusions? Is it even possible to transplant anything other than maybe a cornea without a transfusion?) They've also reversed themselves on vaccinations. If I were a JW, I'd be wondering: when is the reversal on transfusions coming, and is it going to be soon enough to save my kid?
 
I found a small typo on the Quackery page in the Liam Williams-Holloway story.

Also, on this sort of web site I prefer the links to open in separate windows so I can click on them, but keep reading the page I'm on, but that may be just me.
 
Possibly of use...



http://www.newstalkzb.co.nz/newsdetail1.asp?storyID=130711

Quake predictions rattle nerves in Gisborne

16/01/2008 10:24:02

A rumour of more earthquakes to come in Gisborne is sending shock waves through the community, and causing headaches for officials.

An American woman claims to have foreseen the region's 6.8 magnitude quake in December, and believes another is on its way. The psychic predicted a magnitude 8 earthquake for last Wednesday.

Gisborne District Council civil defence officer Richard Steele says when it did not happen, the dates and times started changing. He says a few people have fled in fear and the emergency phone systems have been flooded with calls.
 
Krelnik,

Excellent idea. I must have missed this sticky up until now. It looks like you're doing a smashing job! If there's anything I can do at any point I'd only be too happy to assist. I'll definitely keep it in mind if I remember anything, though.

Athon
 
On the Jehovah's front, the thing that always stands out to me is the fact that the church formerly prohibited organ transplants, and then reversed themselves in a later ruling. (Of course, what use is allowing transplants if you don't allow transfusions?
I may be wrong in this, but don't they allow transfusions of your own blood? So a person can have blood taken in the weeks leading up to the operation, which will then be used as the transfusion blood during the operation?
 
A couple of ideas that occurred to me today:

1) For each entry, have a set of links at the bottom to the categories that include that entry. This would more clearly show what woo is involved in each case.

2) Maybe put together graphs that show a breakdown of deaths, injuries, and money lost by category. This would admittedly be a bit difficult due to overlap, but if you could find some way to deal with that, it would be interesting to see. The biggest problem I could see with it would be that it would give the (probably mistaken) impression that the graphs were representative of damage caused by woo in general, rather than just that which you've been able to find documentation of.

3) If you do include Wikipedia links (as suggested in a previous post), perhaps they should be given a different icon, or always placed at the beginning/end of the set of information links. Given that most of your info links are from various scattered sources, it would look good to have a consistently-referenced source, even if it's as unofficial as Wikipedia. Just make sure you don't link any Wikipedia pages you've edited (at least not without warning that you've edited the page), as that would give the mistaken impression of potential dishonesty.
 
I'd go with "What's the Harm?" When I glance at "Wall of Harm", I usually parse it as "Wall of Ham", and it makes me hungry.
 
I may be wrong in this, but don't they allow transfusions of your own blood? So a person can have blood taken in the weeks leading up to the operation, which will then be used as the transfusion blood during the operation?

Krelnik slaps his forehead and says, "Doh!"

You're right as usual, Robert!
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom