Please help with the "Wall of Harm"

From Bermuda. Dentist (why is it always dentists??) Dr. Amenemhat Waset Amen-Re Tamerry - formerly known as Clark Godwin - and his wife Maatkai Hatsheput Tamerry killed their 10 month old daughter A'maya with extreme vegetarianism. They were convicted of manslaughter in 2004 and recently the conviction was quashed on appeal. But the baby's still dead.

http://www.royalgazette.com/siftology.royalgazette/Search/results.jsp

http://bermudasun.bm/Main.asp?SectionID=24&ArticleID=33062

snip
The trial in 2004 had heard that, instead of providing the baby girl with balanced nutrition and proper medical care, the couple relied on Irish Sea Moss in conformity to their vegetarian lifestyle.

She lost weight dramatically over the last months of her life and died suffering from major organic deterioration.
 
Last edited:
Great cases, brett and dog, thanks!

I have one or two others where people tried to feed newborns a vegetarian/vegan diet with catastrophic effects, I may have to add a category for that one.
 
I tried to post this idea before, but I must have missed the submit button.


How about a "Close Calls" page? Stories like:

Jane Doe's psychic friend told her that the chest pains she was experiencing were do to an imbalance in her chi. If she'd meditate and experience acupuncture, it would go away. After three weeks of this therapy, Jane's condition got worse. She decided to go to a board-certified doctor. After doing some scans, it was discovered that she had an arrythmia. The surgery was successful and is credited with saving her life.
 
I tried to post this idea before, but I must have missed the submit button.


How about a "Close Calls" page? Stories like:

Jane Doe's psychic friend told her that the chest pains she was experiencing were do to an imbalance in her chi. If she'd meditate and experience acupuncture, it would go away. After three weeks of this therapy, Jane's condition got worse. She decided to go to a board-certified doctor. After doing some scans, it was discovered that she had an arrythmia. The surgery was successful and is credited with saving her life.


If skeptics made Chick Tracts this would be the plot of like 90 of them.
 
Death of nurse by ear candle:
http://www.akjusticecommission.com/uploaded_documents/Tundra_Drums_02-03-05.pdf

Story starts on front page and continues on page 18. Could not find the Anchorage Daily News article on it. When this happened, the newspaper had a quote from someone at the state fire marshalls office supporting ear candling. I called the office (a former cow-orker worked there) and complained about state officials supporting the use of illegal medical devices.

-David
 
How about a "Close Calls" page? Stories like:

I agree, in fact there are already some stories like that in there. In general I used the term "delayed treatment", which is definitely a harm. Look on the scientific studies page, there are several on this very topic, since some illnesses are only curable if caught early.

Death of nurse by ear candle

That is a good one, I never would have found that one via Google. Thanks!

--Tim Farley
 
Last edited:
That is a good one, I never would have found that one via Google. Thanks!

--Tim Farley


I could not find the other articles on the web sites of the news agencies that originated them, but I did quote the text of a KTUU.com article in an email I sent at the time. I know posting large portions of an article is usually a no-no, but there does not seem to be an option with this one. It does not appear to be on the 'net any more and it's so full of win that I really can't chop it up much:

(bolding, other than the title, is mine)
(originaly located at
http://www.ktuu.com/CMS/templates/master.asp?articleid=11389&zoneid=4)

Ear candle may have sparked fatal fire in Bethel
Wednesday, February 2, 2005 - by Sean Doogan​

Anchorage, Alaska
- An ear candle could have been the cause of last Thursday's fatal apartment fire in Bethel. The Jan. 27 blaze injured four and killed Bethel nurse Ardean Selby.​

The cause has not yet officially been determined, but fire officials say 60-year-old Selby could have been using an ear candle when the fire started. But what is an ear candle?

Edited by chillzero: 
Editing for breach of copyright
 
Last edited by a moderator:
New stories expire quickly

I know posting large portions of an article is usually a no-no, but there does not seem to be an option with this one. It does not appear to be on the 'net any more and it's so full of win...

Yes, the quick expiration of articles on news websites is a problem I've already noticed, and I've only been working on this for a couple months. It underscores the value of this database in capturing these cases before they are lost down the "memory hole". I use the Internet Wayback Machine for some links, but they don't cover the whole web.

I think I'm gonna have to start archiving articles for the site just in case. It seems like a common practice on the web, if you go to Rick Ross's cult site or any of the Scientology sites, they often post the entire text of long-expired news stories. Yes, I know technically this is a violation of copyright, but what I'm saying is the news services don't seem to be too strident about policing this. Anyone have any experience otherwise?


Case in point. Dog, do you have a copy of this story? It says the story is archived when I go here.

Thanks again, everyone, and keep sending stuff in.
 
Last edited:
Site updated

I've updated the site with almost all of the cases you guys submitted, plus a few more I stumbled across. Thanks, everyone, and keep it up. We're now up to 2,405 people killed, 17,641 injured and over $52,586,248 in economic damages.

Every link now has a title, so you can hover over the outbound links to see what the source is. Please report any broken links or if you can find one that is better than one I have for a given case.

I've added a couple of categories to cover recently added cases.

Please keep looking for cases you know about that I may have missed, and especially cases that reflect forms of woo that are currently unrepresented.

As I said I'm very busy with work this week, so I won't get a chance to incorporate the many great design ideas until sometime next week. (I probably spent too much time on this just today alone).

My current hope is to get it cleaned up, add a FAQ and some more neutral explanatory text, and move it to its own domain before TAM 5.5. That way we can all talk about it at the conference and think about what we want to do with it moving forward.

--Tim Farley
 
Another thing to consider is having a paper archive. Maybe not physically, but scanned and OCR'ed from local or national papers along with the web snapshots. You don't even have to make them public, short excerpts and attributions are fine for that kind of cites, and completely legal, IIRC.

This is a lot of work, though, and you'd need a network of people willing to send the local stuff in.

ETA: The point is to have the full documentation handy if anyone asks. Oh, and aren't court papers copyright-free?
 
Last edited:
Great work, Krelnik!

I don't know the man's name, but I've heard of a case where, as a result of belief in witchcraft, a man got turned into a newt.

He got better though, so I do not know if it would be a good candidate for the Wall...
 
Case in point. Dog, do you have a copy of this story? It says the story is archived when I go here.

Ah, I had sent you a search string which doesn't seem to be picked up on the link. The thing is there isn't really one comprehensive story; the coverage was more along the lines of various updates (it was quite big news over here). In any case, try:

http://www.royalgazette.com/siftolo...le.jsp?sectionId=60&articleId=7d2830e30030033

http://www.royalgazette.com/siftolo...le.jsp?sectionId=60&articleId=7d46c8e30030009

http://www.royalgazette.com/siftolo...le.jsp?sectionId=60&articleId=7d4648e30030011

http://www.royalgazette.com/siftolo...le.jsp?sectionId=60&articleId=7d7373330030000

These seem to have the most info on what happened. If you want to have a look at the other stories, press the "search articles" button (top left of any story) and type "Tamerry" - this brings up all the articles.
 
krelnik, this is fantastic! I'd like to link to it from my blog, but I figured I'd better warn you first. I have a decent sized audience -- not enough to slam your server -- but if it gets picked up by reddit, Digg, or slashdot, you could get hit pretty hard. Does Mindspring cap your bandwidth?
 
krelnik, this is fantastic! I'd like to link to it from my blog, but I figured I'd better warn you first.

Can you hold off on that for a week or two? I'm gonna move it to a proper domain and make it look prettier, at that point I'll want everyone to link to it.

Thanks!

ETA:
I added that link into the db, its not up on the site yet though.
 
Last edited:
What about the elderly New Hampshire couple who refused to pay their taxes, and ended up in a months-long standoff with government agents? It turned out that they'd set up lethal booby-traps around their property, and had prepared to resist violently when arrested. Luckily, U.S. marshals managed to surprise them and make the arrest without incident, and both are now serving sentences for tax evasion, with other charges pending.

I cannot for the life of me remember their names, however, which makes finding references somewhat problematic...

Another suggestion - for each category, have multiple reference links to descriptions of the practice, including Wikipedia. Since Wikipedia tries to maintain neutrality in their articles, it should be less offputting to believers than openly skeptical sites. If it can be done without causing clutter, perhaps putting the damage totals for each category next to the category link, along with a link to a descriptive site (new window/tab) - might make it more eye-catching.
 
What about the elderly New Hampshire couple who refused to pay their taxes, and ended up in a months-long standoff with government agents? It turned out that they'd set up lethal booby-traps around their property, and had prepared to resist violently when arrested. Luckily, U.S. marshals managed to surprise them and make the arrest without incident, and both are now serving sentences for tax evasion, with other charges pending.

I cannot for the life of me remember their names, however, which makes finding references somewhat problematic...

(snip).

Edward and Elaine Brown of Plainfiled, N.H., taken into custody on October 4, 2007.
 
Scientology

Read this Larry King transcript of an interview two former long-term Scientologists, Michael Pattinson and Tory Christman:

CHRISTMAN: In Scientology, you have to pay for just about everything. They have a few free things to try to rope people in, but basically you pay for everything. It starts very inexpensive and builds rapidly into thousands, hundreds-of-thousands of dollars.

COOPER: Michael, you say you've spent, what? How much money?

PATTINSON: Approximately half-a-million dollars.

CHRISTMAN: Well, I know -- Yes, I would say $200,000, at least, was our inheritance we spent and more.
 
I have a decent sized audience -- not enough to slam your server -- but if it gets picked up by reddit, Digg, or slashdot, you could get hit pretty hard.
BA, not sure if I've ever mentioned it, but I have gotten more external page requests originating from your site (1,311,307) than from any other.

If I haven't said it before - thanks!
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom