Merged Pearl Harbor: "Revisionists" vs. "Traditionalists"

Another bit of handwaving is the implication that orders from Tokyo to the strike force were updated frequently during the voyage, and that those orders had to be retransmitted to all of the smaller ships that lacked tall radio masts. First, there were no frequent changes in orders. Second, such information as might have been transmitted (including intelligence updates) would not have needed to have been passed on to those ships; the destroyers didn't need to know about the latest reports on the positions of ships in Pearl Harbor, for example.

Plus, they had signal lamps, signal flags and semaphore. Systems that have been in use for hundreds of years and are still used today (not so much the semaphore but I certainly used to be able to send and read quit fast.
 
Plus, they had signal lamps, signal flags and semaphore. Systems that have been in use for hundreds of years and are still used today (not so much the semaphore but I certainly used to be able to send and read quit fast.
The use of signal lights at night was severely restricted. You can see a flashing light a long way off at sea if conditions are right. That they went to this extreme to hopefully remain undetected points up even further the stupidity of the idea that they would transmit via radio.
 
Plus, they had signal lamps, signal flags and semaphore. Systems that have been in use for hundreds of years and are still used today (not so much the semaphore but I certainly used to be able to send and read quit fast.

In fairness to the OP, his argument is that foul weather during part of their journey prevented the use of these devices. However, he has provided no proof that the fleet transmitted anything.

For the rest, I hold that Kido Butai did not transmit.
 
We must keep in mind that this was in the days of manual typewriters. They had no word processors back then. So it's no surprise that, in each case, Grogan made it a point to specify that he was saying that the signals were coming from an area that was NW of Honolulu.

So Grogan describes the signals in extremely broad and vague terms as coming from, basically, the direction Japan itself was in, and from this you conclude he was tracking the specific position of the attack fleet?
 
Ah, but you see, the Japanese records are lying. For some unexplained reason.

For "some unexplained reason"? It's not unusual for the losers to spin tales after the fact to make themselves look better. That is at least one obvious motivation for making false statements.

The Japanese were caught lying repeatedly after the war--about spies in Hawaii, about Kido Butai records, about the task force receiving intel from spies in Hawaii, etc., etc. One more example: One Kido Butai sailor said they never encountered bad weather en route to Hawaii, but we know this is false, and at least one other sailor admitted they encountered horrific weather that caused the largest swells he'd ever seen.

It just seems a bit strange to cling to the Japanese claim of radio silence given the mass of credible testimony to the contrary.
 
Last edited:
In fairness to the OP, his argument is that foul weather during part of their journey prevented the use of these devices. However, he has provided no proof that the fleet transmitted anything.
He, of course, provides no evidence that the weather was severe enough to:
a. make lights impossible to use.
b. that a situation arose where the radio would have to be used.
c. that permission was given to use the radio in that case.
d. that Grogan actually picked up that transmission if it did occur.
For the rest, I hold that Kido Butai did not transmit.
The above scenario never happened. As the Kido Butai were traveling on a preset course any ship that got separated could find them again through the magic of navigation. One destroyer did get separated in the night and met up with force the next day. Without having to yell for help. It would have been a short-sword offense to have failed at seamanship so badly.
 
But Grogan specified, in very plain English, that by "NW by W" he meant NW of Hawaii


No, he clearly says on the second night out from LA the bearings he received came from NW by W of his position, which he interpreted to mean they were north and west of Honolulu. Then he said on the night of 2 Dec the bearings indicated the Kido Butai was NW by W from Honolulu, which is impossible.

--specifically, that the signals were coming from an area that was NW of Hawaii. Both times when he discussed the bearings, he made this as clear as English can state something. He was describing a location, not a direction of travel.


What a bizarre notion. An area NW of Hawaii must bear NW from Hawaii. An area NW of Hawaii is not due south from Hawaii.

But Jacobsen hides this fact from the reader by snipping out part of what Grogan said.


Jacobsen did not say or imply anything about a direction of travel. Where on Earth did you get that idea? Do you mean "compass bearing"? Because "direction of travel" means the direction a ship is traveling. No one with any maritime navigation experience would say "direction of travel" to refer to a bearing.

We must keep in mind that this was in the days of manual typewriters. They had no word processors back then. So it's no surprise that, in each case, Grogan made it a point to specify that he was saying that the signals were coming from an area that was NW of Honolulu.

Except he said "NW by W of Honolulu". Which was nowhere near the Kido Butai.

"NW by W" is not "NW".
 
OK, so now Bobby seems to think that all the allied forces did was ask some sailors if they transmitted or not, once the war was over.

Yeah...we wouldn't have looked at any of the ship logs, orders, records, etc. Nah, we'd just ask some people we still weren't keen on trusting and trust them. Sure.
 
...gee what happened to the Japanese naval signal men who were left behind to make others think the main fleet was in Japanese waters - they were transmitting during this time.....

Bob why don't you check the Japanese records?
 
The dates on that chart are Tokyo time; you have to subtract 19 hours to get Hawaii time, the time zone Grogan probably used.

That is the wrong chart projection to plot radio bearings. Radio waves propagate over the surface of the Earth as Great Circles; they have to be plotted on a gnomonic chart projection. Google Earth uses a gnomonic projection. See my charts here:http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=8683990&postcount=523 and here: http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=8684057&postcount=527

Matt,

Thanks for this information. I missed your pictures earlier in this thread, must have been on my phone at the time ... I did say I was no expert.:o
 
Well you can't trust those sneaky Japanese, nor anyone who was under that Commie FDR at any level, from cabinet level all the way down to the lowest private or seaman. They're all stooges or liars I tell ya!:rolleyes::rolleyes:

There was no Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor, it was a massive Psy-Op using smoke and paint bombs and American aircraft painted in Japanese colors.

Wake up sheeple!!


:duck:
 
For "some unexplained reason"? It's not unusual for the losers to spin tales after the fact to make themselves look better. That is at least one obvious motivation for making false statements.
Yep. Now, all you have to do is provide evidence of that motivation. Or, even better, evidence that the records were altered.

The Japanese were caught lying repeatedly after the war--about spies in Hawaii, about Kido Butai records, about the task force receiving intel from spies in Hawaii, etc., etc. One more example: One Kido Butai sailor said they never encountered bad weather en route to Hawaii, but we know this is false, and at least one other sailor admitted they encountered horrific weather that caused the largest swells he'd ever seen.
It's almost as if memories are subjective or something!

It just seems a bit strange to cling to the Japanese claim of radio silence given the mass of credible testimony to the contrary.
I love how, for all that, you don't specifically say that the claims that the task force didn't transmit are false. You spend weeks plucking up the courage to pretend to address the matter, waiting for an opening, and still can't quite pull it off.

Allow me to elaborate; there is no evidence in the Japanese records to indicate their ships transmitted. In fact, the evidence clearly shows them not transmitting. In lieu of evidence contradicting that, the most reasonable assumption is that they didn't transmit. And, no, saying "they may have had reasons to lie!1" is not evidence. Selectively interpreted testimony is not evidence, since we've already established you can't determine the course or location of a vessel, using directional readings, from another moving vessel.

First order evidence trumps your claims, and you know it.
 
He could have been picking up the Northwestern, Time Bandit, Wizard, or the Cornelia Marie.

Funny, that's what the people who were there said.

Or Maybe Grogan was picking up the USS Nimitz after it went thorugh the Time Warp.....:D


BTF's ability to ignore evidence that blows his Conspiracy Theory to heck is astounding.
 
The Japanese were caught lying repeatedly after the war--about spies in Hawaii, about Kido Butai records, about the task force receiving intel from spies in Hawaii, etc., etc.


[citations missing]


It just seems a bit strange to cling to the Japanese claim of radio silence given the mass of credible testimony to the contrary.


Therein perhaps lies the problem. Your definition of "credible" seems to be suspect. The Japanese accounts must be false. Grogan's account must be accurate. It seems to me it can be claimed just as easily that it's other way around—the Japanese are correct and Grogan is making stuff up.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom