Corsair 115
Penultimate Amazing
- Joined
- Apr 18, 2007
- Messages
- 14,519
Looking at the US Navy's allocation of shipping to the Atlantic and the Pacific we see for example, that in Leyte Gulf the USN committed around 30 carriers, a dozen battleships, two dozen cruisers and around 150 destroyers.
To Overlord, the USN (grudgingly) committed 3 battleships, 3 cruisers and around 40 destroyers.
The Pacific war was primarily a naval war—thousands of miles of ocean surrounding relatively small dots of land necessarily makes it a naval war thus requiring large naval forces. That should not come as any surprise. In Europe there were enormous numbers of land-based aircraft that could cover the Normandy beaches; in the Pacific, to have air cover typically meant using aircraft carriers, and lots of them, until the target island was captured. And lots of aircraft carriers means having to have a lot of supporting vessels.
On the 1st May 1944, the USN had 409 LST's on strength of which only 188 were committed to Overlord. Compare this to Siapan, a small island held by a force of 30,000 Japanese division and to which the USN dedicated (on the day before D Day) no fewer than fifteen battleships and 87 LST's.
In Europe there were large numbers of medium and heavy bombers that could pound targets in Normandy from bases relatively close by in Britain. In the Pacific that option didn't exist so naval gunfire had to be used instead (along with strikes by carrier-based aircraft).
Thats a strange definition of a checking force. To suggest that the Pacific theatre had no impact on the provision of shipping to the European theatre is just plain nonsense.
I think MG1942 meant for the first one to two years of the war, until U.S. naval strength was built up.
And no the US did not fight the war in the pacific almost on their own. There's the small matter of rather an awful lot of British, ANZAC, Indian, oh and also one of two Chinese who were also fighting the Japanese at the time.
Sure. But which nation's forces did the large majority of the work pushing the Japanese back? The United States. That fact does not diminish the efforts of others in the theatre, it just sets them into context of the overall forces deployed.
Last edited: