Merged Pearl Harbor: "Revisionists" vs. "Traditionalists"

Looking at the US Navy's allocation of shipping to the Atlantic and the Pacific we see for example, that in Leyte Gulf the USN committed around 30 carriers, a dozen battleships, two dozen cruisers and around 150 destroyers.

To Overlord, the USN (grudgingly) committed 3 battleships, 3 cruisers and around 40 destroyers.


The Pacific war was primarily a naval war—thousands of miles of ocean surrounding relatively small dots of land necessarily makes it a naval war thus requiring large naval forces. That should not come as any surprise. In Europe there were enormous numbers of land-based aircraft that could cover the Normandy beaches; in the Pacific, to have air cover typically meant using aircraft carriers, and lots of them, until the target island was captured. And lots of aircraft carriers means having to have a lot of supporting vessels.


On the 1st May 1944, the USN had 409 LST's on strength of which only 188 were committed to Overlord. Compare this to Siapan, a small island held by a force of 30,000 Japanese division and to which the USN dedicated (on the day before D Day) no fewer than fifteen battleships and 87 LST's.


In Europe there were large numbers of medium and heavy bombers that could pound targets in Normandy from bases relatively close by in Britain. In the Pacific that option didn't exist so naval gunfire had to be used instead (along with strikes by carrier-based aircraft).


Thats a strange definition of a checking force. To suggest that the Pacific theatre had no impact on the provision of shipping to the European theatre is just plain nonsense.


I think MG1942 meant for the first one to two years of the war, until U.S. naval strength was built up.


And no the US did not fight the war in the pacific almost on their own. There's the small matter of rather an awful lot of British, ANZAC, Indian, oh and also one of two Chinese who were also fighting the Japanese at the time.


Sure. But which nation's forces did the large majority of the work pushing the Japanese back? The United States. That fact does not diminish the efforts of others in the theatre, it just sets them into context of the overall forces deployed.
 
Last edited:
And no the US did not fight the war in the pacific almost on their own. There's the small matter of rather an awful lot of British, ANZAC, Indian, oh and also one of two Chinese who were also fighting the Japanese at the time.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_imphal At the time, the largest Japanese defeat of the war and one of the largest period.
You seem to be including the CBI theater with the Pacific theater. AFAIK the two are almost always considered separate theaters. Using this definition the U.S. certainly provided the vast majority of the materiel and manpower for the Pacific theater.
 
The idea that FDR felt that the damage would be minimal so he ordered no defensive preparations is somewhat ludicrous when you look at how the shorebased aircraft were deployed - in a tight formation in the centre of the airfield.

This method of protection is the preferred method of dealing with potential saboteurs, forcing them to cross large sections of open ground before the saboteurs get to the hgih value targets, but makes said targets the wet dream of any attacking aircraft, all bunched up in the open, vice dispersed and camouflaged.

Again, we're looking at a significant military asset that cannot be readily replaced (the aircraft). Allowing it to be rendered nearly combat ineffective for the purposes of getting into a war with one country, allegedly to allow you to go to war with that country's ally beggars belief.

Yes, the idea that you want to get into a war so bad that you allow some of the major assets you intend on fighting that war with be destroyed can only make sense to a mind devoid of logic.
 
You seem to be including the CBI theater with the Pacific theater. AFAIK the two are almost always considered separate theaters. Using this definition the U.S. certainly provided the vast majority of the materiel and manpower for the Pacific theater.

The US also provided a great deal of logistic support to the Commonwealth forced in the CBI. My grandfather was in the USAAF stationed in India, and he flew on a great many supply drop missions to the Chindits and the beseiged Kohima Garrison.

Gawdzilla must be taking a few days off from JREF.Otherwise he would have driven the OP screaming like a litte girl from this thread......
 
Last edited:
Gawdzilla must be taking a few days off from JREF.Otherwise he would have driven the OP screaming like a litte girl from this thread......


I'm eagerly awaiting him finding this thread. It'll be fun to watch, and I'll likely learn a few new things too. :)
 
I find that to be an extraordinary statement.

Looking at the US Navy's allocation of shipping to the Atlantic and the Pacific we see for example, that in Leyte Gulf the USN committed around 30 carriers, a dozen battleships, two dozen cruisers and around 150 destroyers.

To Overlord, the USN (grudgingly) committed 3 battleships, 3 cruisers and around 40 destroyers.

On the 1st May 1944, the USN had 409 LST's on strength of which only 188 were committed to Overlord. Compare this to Siapan, a small island held by a force of 30,000 Japanese division and to which the USN dedicated (on the day before D Day) no fewer than fifteen battleships and 87 LST's.

Thats a strange definition of a checking force. To suggest that the Pacific theatre had no impact on the provision of shipping to the European theatre is just plain nonsense.


When did the US have those ships in the Pacific? Atlantic Operations apart from some work along the US territiorial waters was by agreement a British theatre of operations. WHat would the 30 aircraft carriers have been used for? there was a place for Escort Carriers but they were a different beast to a Fleet Carrier. Shore based long range aircraft fitted with centimetric radar did more to destrou the U-Boats in the Bay of Biscay on their way out and back to base than the Convoy Escorts did.

What would they have done with more LSTs for Overlord? they had the ships they needed for the operation, why would they want more?

You mention 'Battleships' at Saipan. WHat are you classing as a Battleship? What would they ahve used 'Battleships' for in OVerlord? There were Battlships, Cruisers and Destroyers tasked with shore bombardment but as soon as the front moved inland they couldn't do anything to support shore operations anymore.

YOu do realise that 1944 is 3 years after Pearl Harbour and the strategic and logistic position had changed a whole lot. Increase in men and equipment meant that efforts in the Pacific could be expanded.
 
The claim that the Japanese task force maintained radio silence is demonstrably false. The fact that some scholars continue to insist on its validity says something about the nature of the Pearl Harbor debate. We have records--and in at least two cases copies--of messages that were sent by ships of the task force en route to Hawaii (Victor, The Pearl Harbor Myth, pp. 37-38; Timothy Wilford, "Watching the North Pacific: British and Commonwealth intelligence before Pearl Harbor," Intelligence and National Security, volume 17, number 4, pp. 147-153).

Furthermore, the task force's orders allowed for some communication among the ships. Yamamoto issued follow-up orders that allowed for a certain amount of radio traffic between ships of the task force (Victor, The Pearl Harbor Myth, pp. 37-38; Victor quotes the orders). The severe weather that the task force encountered would have mandated inter-fleet communication, as A. J. Barker pointed out (Pearl Harbor, p. 81).

Also, just because Kido Butai veterans later claimed that the task force maintained radio silence does not prove this was the case. Those same veterans made other claims that were proven false, such as their claims that the Japanese consulate in Hawaii provided no intelligence for the task force and that no written records survived. So it's curious that traditionalists put such stock in these men's claim of radio silence. Additionally, one admiral of the task force hinted that radio silence was not maintained after all, saying "To keep radio silence was easy to say, but not so easy to maintain."

Furthermore, the DF bearings obtained by the SS Lurline are additional proof that radio silence was not maintained. The bearings were taken by Leslie Grogan, an experienced radio operator on the ship. He took the bearings over the course of several days, which means they had a very reasonable degree of accuracy at the very least. One of the things that caught Grogan's attention was that the flotilla he was monitoring was using automatic rebroadcasts (aka "repeat-backs") at certain times. The only ships that would have repeatedly used repeat-backs in the North Pacific at that time were the vessels of the Kido Butai. Grogan discerned that the ships were trying to conceal their movements, and he concluded they intended to sneak up on Hawaii. Moreover, Grogan noted that the ships halted on 12/2, which is powerful evidence that he was tracking the Kido Butai--because we know that the task force stopped on 12/2 to refuel and to await final confirmation of orders.

Traditionalists have strained to explain the Lurline DF bearings. Wilford and Villa destroy the theories that Grogan heard Russian fishing ships or that he heard radio deception signals broadcast from Tokyo (Brian Villa and Timothy Wilford, “Warning at Pearl Harbor: Leslie Grogan and the Tracking of the Kido Butai,” The Northern Mariner, volume 11, number 2, pp. 1-17). No Russian fishing vessels would have been using automatic repeat-backs, and there is no way that signals broadcast from Tokyo would have yielded DF bearings that far east in the North Pacific.

As a former signals intelligence linguist who did direction finding in the field, I can add that the radio-deception explanation is wholly implausible, and anyone who knows anything about DFing knows this. Grogan took his bearings over the course of several days, which, given the size and speed of the task force, would have enabled him to essentially "triangulate" the location of the ships, which in turn would have ensured a degree of accuracy definitely within a reasonable margin of error. So it's not surprising that, as Wilford and Villa point out, Grogan's bearings substantially match the route that the task force traveled. This is further evidence that Grogan was tracking the task force. Needless to say, the Lurline DF bearings destroy the radio-silence claim.
 
Last edited:
I suggest from the OP's nickname,that his belief in Pearl Harbor Conspiracy theories has to do with a huge dislike for FDR because of politics....not unusual in the Pearl Harbor Conpsiracy community.
 
Sure. But which nation's forces did the large majority of the work pushing the Japanese back? The United States. That fact does not diminish the efforts of others in the theatre, it just sets them into context of the overall forces deployed.

Most of the British, Commonwealth and Indian Army efforts were in Burma and Malaya. They held down a considerable number of Japanes divisions and inflicted on them one of their largest defeats in the 4 month long Battles of Imphal and Kohima One of the actions in this campaign the so called 'Battle of the Tennis Court' was described by Mountbatten as "probably one of the greatest battles in history... naked unparalleled heroism... the British/Indian Thermopylae".

But it was largely a sideshow in the overall strategic picture contributing little to the final Japanese defeat. That was down to the Naval campaign that destroyed the Japanese Merchant Fleet and effectively blockaded them. Towards the end allied naval units were down to shooting up and sinking small fishing boats and Junks as all the ships of any size had been sunk.
 
The US also provided a great deal of logistic support to the Commonwealth forced in the CBI. My grandfather was in the USAAF stationed in India, and he flew on a great many supply drop missions to the Chindits and the beseiged Kohima Garrison.

Gawdzilla must be taking a few days off from JREF.Otherwise he would have driven the OP screaming like a litte girl from this thread......

At the sieges of both Kohima and Imphal, the Allies relied entirely on resupply from largely American aircraft. By the end of the battle the Allied air forces had flown 19,000 tons of supplies and 12,000 men into Kohima and Imphal, and flown out 13,000 casualties and 43,000 non-combatants. 89th Indian Infantry Brigade with all it's equipment and Mules was flown from one front to another in less than a week. AIr supply allowed encircled units to fight their way out of encirclement and those units that were besieged to keep fighting and hold out until relieved.
 
I suggest from the OP's nickname,that his belief in Pearl Harbor Conspiracy theories has to do with a huge dislike for FDR because of politics....not unusual in the Pearl Harbor Conpsiracy community.

So you think that I posit foul play in the Pearl Harbor case only or at least partly because I don't like FDR? It's actually much the reverse: The more I learn about FDR's handling of WW II, the more negatively I feel about him and his presidency.

I don't think much of Bill Clinton's personal morality, but I respect much of what he did as president and I reject the various conspiracy theories that accuse him of this or that crime.

Conversely, I think quite highly of Ronald Reagan, both as a president and a person, but that does not prevent me from agreeing that some of his actions regarding Iran and missiles for hostages were ill advised.

Critical thinking people separate their opinion of a politician from their analysis of accusations against him.

By the way, for the longest time I thought FDR did a good job with WW II, even though I disagreed with his domestic policies.
 
As a former signals intelligence linguist who did direction finding in the field, I can add that the radio-deception explanation is wholly implausible, and anyone who knows anything about DFing knows this. Grogan took his bearings over the course of several days, which, given the size and speed of the task force, would have enabled him to essentially "triangulate" the location of the ships, which in turn would have ensured a degree of accuracy definitely within a reasonable margin of error.

What? How does that work? One moving ship can't triangulate another moving radio source. All they can do is establish a bearing from their position to the transmitter. IF the transmitter is moving then the bearing moves. In the Atlantic the Anti Submarine Escorts used HF/DF that gave an automatic bearing, they then followed it to run down the U-Boat sending the signal but it needed several escorts gto get simultanious receipt to establish a position. RN Ships used the same HF/DF gear when I was in the Navy in the 80s with exactly the same 'Birdcage' Antenna and CRT in the Ops Room.. All that was different was the Valves had been replaced with solid state boards.
 
The claim that the Japanese task force maintained radio silence is demonstrably false. The fact that some scholars continue to insist on its validity says something about the nature of the Pearl Harbor debate. We have records--and in at least two cases copies--of messages that were sent by ships of the task force en route to Hawaii (Victor, The Pearl Harbor Myth, pp. 37-38; Timothy Wilford, "Watching the North Pacific: British and Commonwealth intelligence before Pearl Harbor," Intelligence and National Security, volume 17, number 4, pp. 147-153).

Furthermore, the task force's orders allowed for some communication among the ships. Yamamoto issued follow-up orders that allowed for a certain amount of radio traffic between ships of the task force (Victor, The Pearl Harbor Myth, pp. 37-38; Victor quotes the orders). The severe weather that the task force encountered would have mandated inter-fleet communication, as A. J. Barker pointed out (Pearl Harbor, p. 81).

Also, just because Kido Butai veterans later claimed that the task force maintained radio silence does not prove this was the case. Those same veterans made other claims that were proven false, such as their claims that the Japanese consulate in Hawaii provided no intelligence for the task force and that no written records survived. So it's curious that traditionalists put such stock in these men's claim of radio silence. Additionally, one admiral of the task force hinted that radio silence was not maintained after all, saying "To keep radio silence was easy to say, but not so easy to maintain."

Furthermore, the DF bearings obtained by the SS Lurline are additional proof that radio silence was not maintained. The bearings were taken by Leslie Grogan, an experienced radio operator on the ship. He took the bearings over the course of several days, which means they had a very reasonable degree of accuracy at the very least. One of the things that caught Grogan's attention was that the flotilla he was monitoring was using automatic rebroadcasts (aka "repeat-backs") at certain times. The only ships that would have repeatedly used repeat-backs in the North Pacific at that time were the vessels of the Kido Butai. Grogan discerned that the ships were trying to conceal their movements, and he concluded they intended to sneak up on Hawaii. Moreover, Grogan noted that the ships halted on 12/2, which is powerful evidence that he was tracking the Kido Butai--because we know that the task force stopped on 12/2 to refuel and to await final confirmation of orders.

Traditionalists have strained to explain the Lurline DF bearings. Wilford and Villa destroy the theories that Grogan heard Russian fishing ships or that he heard radio deception signals broadcast from Tokyo (Brian Villa and Timothy Wilford, “Warning at Pearl Harbor: Leslie Grogan and the Tracking of the Kido Butai,” The Northern Mariner, volume 11, number 2, pp. 1-17). No Russian fishing vessels would have been using automatic repeat-backs, and there is no way that signals broadcast from Tokyo would have yielded DF bearings that far east in the North Pacific.

As a former signals intelligence linguist who did direction finding in the field, I can add that the radio-deception explanation is wholly implausible, and anyone who knows anything about DFing knows this. Grogan took his bearings over the course of several days, which, given the size and speed of the task force, would have enabled him to essentially "triangulate" the location of the ships, which in turn would have ensured a degree of accuracy definitely within a reasonable margin of error. So it's not surprising that, as Wilford and Villa point out, Grogan's bearings substantially match the route that the task force traveled. This is further evidence that Grogan was tracking the task force. Needless to say, the Lurline DF bearings destroy the radio-silence claim.


Or they would if you could offer a citation that validated their content...
 
I am not a radio expert but doesn't triangulation require readings from 3 separate points and not three reading from the same point?

Also if both points (the radar and the contact) are moving over a period of three days wouldn't that negate the possibility of triangulation from only one moving source?:confused:
 
You can 'triangulate' with two bearings but if the contact is moving you need two recievers to do the fix at the same time. That's how the HF/DF set works it gives an instant bearing, two ships can 'triangulate' a moving transmitter even if it just radiates for a second or two.
 
Last edited:
You can 'triangulate' with two bearings but if the contact is moving you need two recievers to do the fix at the same time. That's how the HF/DF set works it gives an instant bearing, two ships can 'triangulate' a moving transmitter even if it just radiates for a second or two.

Ok. That makes sense. I was thinking along the lines of triangulating the epicenter of an earthquake. (or rather what I vaguely recall from high school)

So one ship moving can or can not triangulate another moving ship?
 
Last edited:
Ok. That makes sense. I was thinking along the lines of triangulating the epicenter of an earthquake.

So one ship moving can or can not triangulate another moving ship?

Can not. Think of it as lines on a map. One line (one ship) can give a bearing, but not a distance. Two lines can give two bearings and an intersection which signifies an approximate location. Three lines give you a much more accurate location.
 
As uke2se says but if the thing you are getting a bearing on is moving then you can't get it's position unless you have 2 bearings from different points at the same time.

Remember you are just hearing it's radio and using a directional antenna to get the strongest signal by rotating your antenna left and right. Automatic HF/DF systems use an array of antennas in a birdcage formation and some clever electronics to get the direction without having to move anything.
Radar on the other hand will give you a position fix by bouncing a radio signal off the target and recieving it back at your location. you only need one fix.
 
I get it. Thank you both.


So that makes bobtaftfan's post regarding the triangulation pretty much nonsense.
 
A few months ago, for the first time in my life, I became interested enough in the Pearl Harbor controversy to start doing some reading about it. Back in 2001, I read Robert Stinnett's book Day of Deceit, but I didn't understand half of what I read and had no interest in doing further reading on the subject.
Stinnett was a drooling idiot with ALZ who was obsessed with the alternate reality that was FDR let it happen on purpose (LIHOP).
When I started reading on the subject a couple months ago, I approached the matter with no emotional devotion or hardened commitment to any position. I quickly realized that some gigantic battle lines have been drawn and that the two sides rarely if ever engage in meaningful dialogue with each other--and usually yell at and past each other. Given that we're talking about an event that happened over 70 years ago, this seems rather surprising.
The dialog is difficult when conspiracy theorists don't read the material. For example, Stinnett didn't read the Hearings, so he though those "JN-25" messages in his book were intercepts. They were, in fact taken from the Hearings by Homer Wallin. The funny part is Stinnett cites Wallin, but didn't take the next logical step.
One thing that I find somewhat striking is the number of myths that continue to appear in scholarly writings on the topic. For example:

* "The Japanese fleet maintained radio silence from the time it set sail for Hawaii." We know this is a myth because we have copies of two messages that were sent by ships in the task force en route to Hawaii. What is especially odd is that the editors of one of the collections in which these messages appear repeat the radio-silence myth in their introduction to the collection (Donald M. Goldstein and Katherine V. Dillon, The Pearl Harbor Papers: Inside the Japanese Plans).
The Japanese confirmed they never transmitted. Go to Japan and call them liars if you wish.
* "FDR never saw the bomb plot messages." Lt. Commander Alwin Kramer delivered a copy of the first, and most important, bomb plot message to FDR on October 9, along with a summary of its contents and a notation that read “interesting message” (“Additional Views of Mr. Keefe,” JCC Pearl Harbor Report, p. 266-E). Incidentally, the summary read as follows:

"Tokyo directs special reports on ships in Pearl Harbor which is divided into five areas for the purpose of showing exact locations."​
And it's called the "bomb plot" by Americans. The Japanese pilots didn't need such things. They had a reconnaissance break-through in their planes called "glass". They could look through this "glass" and see the ships in the harbor. Some of the pilots were so good they could tell a battleship from a destroyer using this "glass".
* "The 14-part Japanese diplomatic cable was not a declaration of war, and did not even break off diplomatic relations. Beyond a recapitulation of Japanese complaints against the U.S., the United Kingdom, and the Netherlands, there doesn't seem to be any real point to the message at all." This one is especially baffling. The 14-part cable said that all hope of peace in the Pacific was lost and that the negotiations were terminated. The first instruction specified that the 14-part message had to be delivered to the American Secretary of State at exactly 1:00 p.m., Eastern time. The second instruction directed the Japanese ambassadors to destroy the remaining cipher machine and all codes and other classified documents at the embassy.

The 14-part message didn't declare war, it didn't break off diplomatic negotiations, it was not an ultimatum. If one is appalling ignorant of diplomatic forms one might miss these things.

As for the timing, what does that prove?
When Admiral Wilkinson read those messages (the morning of December 7), he urged Admiral Stark to call the Hawaiian commanders immediately. Colonel Bratton recognized the implication of the time of delivery immediately, as did General Miles. Secretary of the Navy Frank Knox said these messages "clearly indicated" a "surprise move of some kind." Secretary of War Henry Stimson likewise realized the messages indicated a "blow" would be struck that day. And on and on and on we could go.

And then the intell fairy came in and stamped "Pearl Harbor will be attacked at 1 pm" on their foreheads?
As you may have guessed by now, I have come down on the revisionist side. One of the first things that caused me to conclude that the Pearl Harbor attack involved foul play in Washington was the same thing that caught John Toland's eye: the actions of General Marshall and Admiral Stark on the morning of the attack. I find it impossible to believe that Marshall and Stark did not know exactly what they were doing. I find it impossible to believe that their utterly bizarre, incomprehensible actions that morning were merely "mistakes" or "bad judgment."

I offer you forty volumes of information Pearl Harbor. If you read it all you and I can have a conversation. http://www.ibiblio.org/pha/congress/
Of course, many of the books that reject the traditional Pearl Harbor story have some errors in them. But, on balance, I find them much more convincing and logical than traditionalist books.

Well, I'm impressed with the fact that you have read one book, a very badly written and highly inaccurate book, and you can make a serious decision like that. Reading Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone would make you a magician by those standards.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom