Merged Pearl Harbor: "Revisionists" vs. "Traditionalists"

Yes, I know that for most of the war, Europe got the lion's share of men, material, and attention. But the Pacific campaign required ships, planes, and men.


So did the European theatre. Ships were needed to safeguard convoys, and aircraft were needed to combat the Luftwaffe.
 
So did the European theatre. Ships were needed to safeguard convoys, and aircraft were needed to combat the Luftwaffe.

And the men and material that wouldn't have been needed in the Pacific could have gone there too. I'm assuming a quicker victory in the Pacific due to the Japanese losses in the attempt to attack Pearl. With much of the fleet hit (and the American fleet intact), Yamamoto can't give the Japanese the 6 months of freedom in the Pacific that he thought he could.
 
And the men and material that wouldn't have been needed in the Pacific could have gone there too. I'm assuming a quicker victory in the Pacific due to the Japanese losses in the attempt to attack Pearl. With much of the fleet hit (and the American fleet intact), Yamamoto can't give the Japanese the 6 months of freedom in the Pacific that he thought he could.

No it just doesn't work. The US deployed no more than a checking force in the Pacific. The victories the US enjoyed at Coral Sea and Midway where dominated by luck, not overwhelming force or resources.

Even of the Japanese win both battles, not much really changes, only the timing
 
I don't know anything about these documents are communist spies in the White House. I know a lot about the Japanese colonial empire. The whole idea that Pearl Harbor needs some kind of conspiracy to explain it seems strangely out of line with the facts of Japanese history. As I have said elsewhere,
Actually, this whole issue of Pearl Harbor sounds strange to me. The Japanese pioneered surprise attack at Port Arthur
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Port_Arthur
At about 0028 on 9 February 1904, the first four Japanese destroyers approached the port of Port Arthur without being observed, and launched a torpedo attack against the Pallada and and the Retvizan.

It was a standard Japanese military strategy by the time of Pearl Harbor. They didn't need the US government to help them come up with the idea of killing people when they weren't looking.

But look at this. What was supposed to be a schooling of another one of the lost generation has become instead a fireside chat with the 'big boys' of the JREF. Our new found buddy here is no doubt telling his Truther friends about how he has been successful.

Just give the guy a push and let him float out to sea. But then even WTC Dust was given her fair share of JREF hospitality, so what the ****.

and then,

History tells us that
A major cause of the Russo-Japanese War was the lease of Port Arthur to Russia by the weak Qing government of China

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_Sino-Japanese_War
and don't forget that Japan had a long standing interesting in Korea
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Imo_Incident
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gapsin_Coup
or that the Japanese shot up a lot of the civilians in Port Arthur
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Port_Arthur_massacre_(China)

Or even that Western reception of the surprise attack was very positive
(sorry, no Wiki on this one, but you can read http://www.amazon.com/Japans-First-Modern-War-Strategic/dp/0312122772)

My point is that nothing that the Japanese are accused of doing later on is any surprise given the record of their early military conflicts. And that includes Pearl Harbor.

While I can understand that a bunch of silly white boys who never heard of Port Arthur 'til they read my post might be sucked in by all the false flag-911 talk, it's just boring after a while. It would be a lot more fun if we started talking about the New World Order and their chemtrail attacks or how Obama is the anti-Christ and he's going to take away all your guns. Now these are some real 911 topics. How about that black (disparaging name for homosexual men) in the White House blowing up the Super Bowl and declaring martial law?
http://www.nuclearbible.com/
 
...
2. FDR could not risk trying to meet the oncoming Japanese task force because Japanese spies on Oahu would have noticed and reported the deployment preparations, which in turn would have led the Japanese to call off the attack. We know that the Japanese were going to call off the attack if they lost the element of surprise. FDR would have logically assumed this to be the case, which provides a logical explanation for the "vacant sea" order that Washington issued for the North Pacific (this cleared a path for the Japanese task force).
...

They did report them absent. I repeat: They did report them absent.

Not making much sense there, bobtaftfan.
 
The idea that FDR felt that the damage would be minimal so he ordered no defensive preparations is somewhat ludicrous when you look at how the shorebased aircraft were deployed - in a tight formation in the centre of the airfield.

This method of protection is the preferred method of dealing with potential saboteurs, forcing them to cross large sections of open ground before the saboteurs get to the hgih value targets, but makes said targets the wet dream of any attacking aircraft, all bunched up in the open, vice dispersed and camouflaged.

Again, we're looking at a significant military asset that cannot be readily replaced (the aircraft). Allowing it to be rendered nearly combat ineffective for the purposes of getting into a war with one country, allegedly to allow you to go to war with that country's ally beggars belief.
 
1. Marshall led FDR to believe that the damage from an air attack on Pearl Harbor would be minimal. So FDR thought he could allow a surprise attack to occur at very little cost. He was stunned when he heard how much damage had been done.

Why would he conclude this? FDR was very interested in naval power, and was well aware (as were the Japanese) of the raid on the Regia Marina at Taranto Harbor that was launched by the Royal Navy just a year prior to Pearl Harbor. Just twenty antiquated aircraft launched from a single aircraft carrier destroyed one battleship and severely damaged two others. This one attack swung the balance in favor of the British Mediterranean Fleet.
 
No it just doesn't work. The US deployed no more than a checking force in the Pacific. <snip>

I find that to be an extraordinary statement.

Looking at the US Navy's allocation of shipping to the Atlantic and the Pacific we see for example, that in Leyte Gulf the USN committed around 30 carriers, a dozen battleships, two dozen cruisers and around 150 destroyers.

To Overlord, the USN (grudgingly) committed 3 battleships, 3 cruisers and around 40 destroyers.

On the 1st May 1944, the USN had 409 LST's on strength of which only 188 were committed to Overlord. Compare this to Siapan, a small island held by a force of 30,000 Japanese division and to which the USN dedicated (on the day before D Day) no fewer than fifteen battleships and 87 LST's.

Thats a strange definition of a checking force. To suggest that the Pacific theatre had no impact on the provision of shipping to the European theatre is just plain nonsense.
 
As an actual professional historian let me just say, if a student turned in this "theory" as a term paper it would earn a big, fat, huge, glowing red F. What a steaming pile. Not to mention it's an appalling slander of General Marshall.
 
Last edited:
I find that to be an extraordinary statement.

Looking at the US Navy's allocation of shipping to the Atlantic and the Pacific we see for example, that in Leyte Gulf the USN committed around 30 carriers, a dozen battleships, two dozen cruisers and around 150 destroyers.

To Overlord, the USN (grudgingly) committed 3 battleships, 3 cruisers and around 40 destroyers.

On the 1st May 1944, the USN had 409 LST's on strength of which only 188 were committed to Overlord. Compare this to Siapan, a small island held by a force of 30,000 Japanese division and to which the USN dedicated (on the day before D Day) no fewer than fifteen battleships and 87 LST's.

Thats a strange definition of a checking force. To suggest that the Pacific theatre had no impact on the provision of shipping to the European theatre is just plain nonsense.

Seriously Hubert, you want to go there - How about you show me available forces in May 42 and May 43? Once the US calmed down, got there ducks in a row it was clear the Japanese had over extended and the US could out produce them in war material to a frightening level.

We only need to look at the casualty rates. Only 1 in 4 was killed in the Pacific during the entire war, a theater where the US had to almost fight the war on their own.
 
As an actual professional historian let me just say, if a student turned in this "theory" as a term paper it would earn a big, fat, huge, glowing red F. What a steaming pile. Not to mention it's an appalling slander of General Marshall.

Shrill :D
 
Seriously Hubert, you want to go there - How about you show me available forces in May 42 and May 43? Once the US calmed down, got there ducks in a row it was clear the Japanese had over extended and the US could out produce them in war material to a frightening level.

We only need to look at the casualty rates. Only 1 in 4 was killed in the Pacific during the entire war, a theater where the US had to almost fight the war on their own.

I dont have them to hand. You claimed the US only put out a holding force to repudiate the claim that the Pacific theatre was a not inconsequential drain on allied maritime resources.

Perhaps you should provide some data to back up your assertion.

And no we do not only have to look at the casualty rates because we are talking about maritime resources here not overall resources.

And no the US did not fight the war in the pacific almost on their own. There's the small matter of rather an awful lot of British, ANZAC, Indian, oh and also one of two Chinese who were also fighting the Japanese at the time.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_imphal At the time, the largest Japanese defeat of the war and one of the largest period.
 
You're demanding data for someone else to back up their assertion when you can't even back up yours.
 
You do realize FDR wanted the US in a war with Germany. The US did everything it could to provoke Germany. It didn’t work, so they provoked Japan and got their desired result.

By the brilliant tactic of crossing their fingers and hoping Hitler would declare war on them even though his treaty with Japan put him under no such obligation?
 
You're demanding data for someone else to back up their assertion when you can't even back up yours.

Its commonly accepted in these here JREF forums that the burden of proof lies with the person who makes an assertion in the first place.

I have provided some data to back up my position.

Now lets hear from the other side.

Fair?
 
Even if this idea was true the Japanese were still an aggressive military committing horrible acts of genocide that needed to be destroyed.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom