Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
That was typical state department wording in a public information page and like I said, one can ignore things that aren't relevant like the militarized stuff. Yes, I said this was during Trump's 4 years

Just use these sources as part of the whole. There are sources claiming it was the lab and other sources saying it wasn't. We don't have a definitive answer, IMO. Though there is some good evidence coming out in this thread that it wasn't the lab.

If you don't buy any information coming from the US defense agencies, can you believe anything coming from China? There are issues with both.

What is there to believe? I want evidence.

What I don't trust is Trump-era propaganda, and frankly that webpage looks like it. The only claim that is vaguely interesting is the one about sick staff at Wuhan, but it isn't sourced, and you still haven't given any evidence about that. There is no reason to take it at face value. Give me a credible source on that, and then we can talk.

Not yet. There is the evidence posted elsewhere that through satellite images there was activity around the Wuhan hospital and an uptick of net searches for pneumonia and other related terms in August of 2019 suggesting COVID began spreading that month. The wet market was a super-spreader event but not the source.

Ah! So, is that now something we can look into?

I guess not.

So where is the evidence?

What are we left with?

Absolutely nothing!
 
lomiller said:
...you expected us to believe it was causing an increase in online searches.
I don't expect you or anyone else to believe anything. I'm also not opposed to posting rebuttal information myself. See post #76.

I do expect to not be dismissed with ad hominems (not you specifically) and to not have the debate hand-waved off, dismissing it as a CT before you've made much of an effort to see what the evidence is or what the ongoing discussion is.

I especially expect people to follow the discussion they inject themselves into and not comment about the flu coming before COVID when the discussion is about the cars in the hospital parking lots in August. OTOH, see post #76 since that particular piece of the debate has been resolved, at least to my satisfaction.
 
Here's an important point:

One of the supposedly compelling pieces of evidence is that the outbreak - or at least the emergence - of Covid-19 began in Wuhan when the idea is that it came from bats that dwell in caves in Yunnan Province. But that's like 100s of kilometres away! How is it possible that a coronavirus found in bats travelled 100s of kilometres!!!?!?!? How is it even possible?!?!

The theory then is that Wuhan Institute of Virology scientists to Yunnan, extracted the coronavirus from the bats, went back to Wuhan and let the virus escape because of shoddy protocols and then kept quiet about it because of "face" (*yawn*!)...

Except, why were they down in Yunnan in the first place? Well, because that is where SARS Cov1 was thought to have come from. So is that where SARS Cov1 emerged? No, it emerged in Guandong Province. But that's like 100s of kilometres away! How is it possible that a coronavirus found in bats travelled 100s of kilometres!!!?!?!? How is it even possible?!?!

Could it be that Guandong and Wuhan are both big cities and transport hubs, and that vast amounts of travellers and produce from all over China pass through there every day?

No! I want to ruminate instead on important questions of the concept of face. That's what scientists do after all...
 
To see why the Aug hospital parking lots and net searches is no longer being considered, see post #76, save yourselves some unnecessary stress.

Again trying to move the discussion forward. I cited this Nature article from 2015 a frew posts back: A SARS-like cluster of circulating bat coronaviruses shows potential for human emergence.

I don't pretend to understand some of the specifics in this paper but I understand the gist of this description of how the researchers are manipulating the coronaviruses they are working with.
Viruses, cells, in vitro infection and plaque assays.
Wild-type SARS-CoV (Urbani), mouse-adapted SARS-CoV (MA15) and chimeric SARS-like CoVs were cultured on Vero E6 cells (obtained from United States Army Medical Research Institute of Infectious Diseases), grown in Dulbecco's modified Eagle's medium (DMEM) (Gibco, CA) and 5% fetal clone serum (FCS) [details snipped] Human lungs for HAE cultures were procured under University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill Institutional Review Board–approved protocols. HAE cultures represent highly differentiated human airway epithelium containing ciliated and non-ciliated epithelial cells as well as goblet cells. The cultures are also grown on an air-liquid interface for several weeks before use, as previously described26. Briefly, cells were washed with PBS and inoculated with virus or mock-diluted in PBS for 40 min at 37 °C. After inoculation, cells were washed three times and fresh medium was added to signify time '0'. Three or more biological replicates were harvested at each described time point. No blinding was used in any sample collections nor were samples randomized. All virus cultivation was performed in a biosafety level (BSL) 3 laboratory with redundant fans in the biosafety cabinets, as described previously by our group2. All personnel wore powered air purifying respirators (Breathe Easy, 3M) with Tyvek suits, aprons and booties and were double-gloved.

On to the figures/charts.

Figure 1: SARS-like viruses replicate in human airway cells and produce in vivo pathogenesis.

Figure 3: Full-length SHC014-CoV replicates in human airways but lacks the virulence of epidemic SARS-CoV. (Similar to H5N1 which is still a potential flu pandemic threat.)

Figure 4: Emergence paradigms for coronaviruses.
Existing data support elements of all three paradigms.
1) bat to intermediate animal to humans
2) bat directly to humans
3) :
The data from chimeric SARS-like viruses argue that the quasi-species pools maintain multiple viruses capable of infecting human cells without the need for mutations (red circles). Although adaptations in secondary or human hosts may be required for epidemic emergence, ....

And an interesting addendum:
30 March 2020 Editors’ note, March 2020: We are aware that this article is being used as the basis for unverified theories that the novel coronavirus causing COVID-19 was engineered. There is no evidence that this is true; scientists believe that an animal is the most likely source of the coronavirus.

It depends on one's definition of "engineered". What these researchers demonstrated was how a human pandemic might occur and to do that they manipulated SARS-like coronaviruses.

They also note how carefully they maintained isolation when dealing with these dangerous viruses. What we don't know from this is was the Wuhan Institute just as careful?

Did the WHO look at those employees' and students' antibodies demonstrating no COVID 19 leaked. Yes, I am dismissing the Wuhan researchers claims without evidence backing those claims up that none of the viruses in their lab resembled the pandemic virus.

And what explains the coincidence that the initial outbreak was near the Wuhan lab? You know, "Of All The Gin Joints In All The Towns In All The World, She Walks Into Mine." There are thousands of wet markets in China. There are thousands of places people interact with animals where a species jump could occur. SARS 1 species jump was nowhere near Wuhan regardless the Institute was not there in 2003. Wuhan is nowhere near the bat caves.

I think that is the biggest question that needs an answer before we can rule out a lab accident.
 
Here's an important point:

One of the supposedly compelling pieces of evidence is that the outbreak - or at least the emergence - of Covid-19 began in Wuhan when the idea is that it came from bats that dwell in caves in Yunnan Province. But that's like 100s of kilometres away! How is it possible that a coronavirus found in bats travelled 100s of kilometres!!!?!?!? How is it even possible?!?!

The theory then is that Wuhan Institute of Virology scientists to Yunnan, extracted the coronavirus from the bats, went back to Wuhan and let the virus escape because of shoddy protocols and then kept quiet about it because of "face" (*yawn*!)...

Except, why were they down in Yunnan in the first place? Well, because that is where SARS Cov1 was thought to have come from. So is that where SARS Cov1 emerged? No, it emerged in Guandong Province. But that's like 100s of kilometres away! How is it possible that a coronavirus found in bats travelled 100s of kilometres!!!?!?!? How is it even possible?!?!

Could it be that Guandong and Wuhan are both big cities and transport hubs, and that vast amounts of travellers and produce from all over China pass through there every day?

No! I want to ruminate instead on important questions of the concept of face. That's what scientists do after all...

Of course it could be. The original SARS obviously traveled --and given the distance to the source was not a likely place for it start its' spread.

There are currently 113 cities in China with over 1 million people in the urban areas. It could have emerged anywhere, even outside of China, though it would be more likely in a closer city or one with some close 'supply' chain relation to the area. The difference with Wuhan is that we KNOW these SARS-related viruses went there, purposely, multiple times over many years, from persons having direct contact with the people, animals, and caves at the source. And so a theory that those travels contributed to the emergence there becomes more likely- however it happened. I am perplexed that it sounds so conspiratorial.

Going by just the 'main hub' train stations (of the 5500 they have), Yunnan to Guangdong is one main hub away. Wuhan looks like three hubs away.

https://flic.kr/p/2kEJpff https://www.flickr.com/photos/155114068@N02/
 
Last edited:
Of course it could be. The original SARS obviously traveled --and given the distance to the source was not a likely place for it start its' spread.

There are currently 113 cities in China with over 1 million people in the urban areas. It could have emerged anywhere, even outside of China, though it would be more likely in a closer city or one with some close 'supply' chain relation to the area. The difference with Wuhan is that we KNOW these SARS-related viruses went there, purposely, multiple times over many years, from persons having direct contact with the people, animals, and caves at the source. And so a theory that those travels contributed to the emergence there becomes more likely- however it happened. I am perplexed that it sounds so conspiratorial.

Going by just the 'main hub' train stations (of the 5500 they have), Yunnan to Guangdong is one main hub away. Wuhan looks like three hubs away.

[qimg]https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/50977770886_6cc1078dc4_z.jpg[/qimg]https://flic.kr/p/2kEJpff https://www.flickr.com/photos/155114068@N02/

But I think this misses another point. It seems only fairly recently have the researchers led by Shi Zhengli discovered that the original SARS came from Yunnan Province, and yet it turned up in Guanzhou City, so it clearly travelled far from its origin. This is the most important point. Where it emerges is not necessarily where it originates!

However, as I posted previously, the types of coronaviruses that share almost all of the genetic make-up of SARS Cov2 are found over wide areas of China, South-East Asia and even in Japan (probably elsewhere as well). We have no reason for thinking that the one that orginated in Yunnan is the one that has emerged as SARS Cov2. There could likely be several areas from which it broke out.

[Sorry, I meant to say that Guangzhou is the city in Guandong Province, and Wuhan is the city in Hubei Province.]
 
Did the WHO look at those employees' and students' antibodies demonstrating no COVID 19 leaked. Yes, I am dismissing the Wuhan researchers claims without evidence backing those claims up that none of the viruses in their lab resembled the pandemic virus.

That's not how this works!

You have made the claim that there were sick workers. The WHO said they found no evidence of that. Then you say, "I don't believe it!"

First, why don't you show evidence that there were sick workers at the lab!

And what explains the coincidence that the initial outbreak was near the Wuhan lab? You know, "Of All The Gin Joints In All The Towns In All The World, She Walks Into Mine." There are thousands of wet markets in China. There are thousands of places people interact with animals where a species jump could occur. SARS 1 species jump was nowhere near Wuhan regardless the Institute was not there in 2003. Wuhan is nowhere near the bat caves.
I think that is the biggest question that needs an answer before we can rule out a lab accident.

Yeah, and Guanzhou is nowhere near the bat caves either. So it couldn't have emerged there, by this line of reasoning.

Also, the Wuhan Institute did exist in 2003. It didn't have the BSL-4 lab until 2018, according to Wikpedia. So the idea is that now that the Institute has finally created a far more secure facility, now it escapes?
 
Which evidence is new? Bullet point descriptions would be fine.

Apparently what's new is:

  1. Look how close the Wuhan Institute of Virology is to Wuhan
  2. Then a bunch of debunked ****

ETA: Oh and the Chinese... well, you just can't trust them on anything because of the "face" thing. They're all liars!
 
Here's an important point:

One of the supposedly compelling pieces of evidence is that the outbreak - or at least the emergence - of Covid-19 began in Wuhan when the idea is that it came from bats that dwell in caves in Yunnan Province. But that's like 100s of kilometres away! How is it possible that a coronavirus found in bats travelled 100s of kilometres!!!?!?!? How is it even possible?!?!

The theory then is that Wuhan Institute of Virology scientists to Yunnan, extracted the coronavirus from the bats, went back to Wuhan and let the virus escape because of shoddy protocols and then kept quiet about it because of "face" (*yawn*!)...
That's a serious misunderstanding of the origin of SARS. And just what do you think they were doing with all these coronavirus strains in the Institute?

angrysoba said:
Except, why were they down in Yunnan in the first place? Well, because that is where SARS Cov1 was thought to have come from. So is that where SARS Cov1 emerged? No, it emerged in Guandong Province. But that's like 100s of kilometres away! How is it possible that a coronavirus found in bats travelled 100s of kilometres!!!?!?!? How is it even possible?!?!
Let's look at your hypothesis sans your incredulity sarcasm. And you really shouldn't dismiss the 'face saving' in the Chinese culture when there are so many papers written on how it makes medical research from China of uncertain value. But whatever...

Moving on: SARS 1 was traced to a wet market. SARS 2 was not traceable to the Wuhan (sea food) wet market it was initially thought to have originated in.

Hint: it's not about train stations or even population hubs. Surprisingly, we actually have a pretty good idea how SARS got to the Guangdong wet markets.

And don't forget, COVID has not been traced to any wet market so far. But I'll indulge the hypothesis anyway.

Molecular epidemiology, evolution and phylogeny of SARS coronavirus
Subsequently, SARS-related CoVs (SARSr-CoVs) were found in palm civets from live animal markets in Guangdong and in various horseshoe bat species, which were believed to be the ultimate reservoir of SARSr-CoV.
No such animal source was identified in Wuhan so far.

Overall, it is observed that the SARSr-CoV genomes from bats in Yunnan province of China possess the highest nucleotide identity to those from civets. ...

Our current model on the origin of SARS is that the human SARS-CoV that caused the epidemic in 2002/2003 was probably a result of multiple recombination events from a number of SARSr-CoV ancestors in different horseshoe bat species.
So recombination events in the bats. That was paradigm #3.

Also SARS was found in palm civet cats in the markets, but not in palm civet cats in the wild. The cats were infected from bats in the market where they were both for sale.
Were there bats for sale in the Wuhan market? I haven't checked yet. I'm waiting for the surprise. :)


Do they sell bats in the Wuhan Seafood Market?

That search turned up this oddity: Wiki: Huanan Seafood Wholesale Market
Phylogenetic analysis indicates that pangolins are a potential reservoir host rather than the intermediate host of SARS-CoV-2. While there is scientific consensus that bats are the ultimate source of coronaviruses, SARS-CoV-2 originated from a pangolin, jumped back to bats, and then jumped to humans, according to phylogenetic analysis.
I'm going to let someone else explore that rabbit hole.

Looks like there are over 100 wild animal species sold in that market.

Bats were initially suggested to be the source of the virus, although it remains unclear if bats were sold there.[28][29][30][31] ...

[30] Camero, Katie (6 February 2020). "Scientists Link China Coronavirus to Intersection of Humans and Wildlife". Wall Street Journal. ISSN 0099-9660. Retrieved 28 March 2020. Some researchers said bats weren't being sold at the Huanan market in Wuhan...The U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention and the World Health Organization said they couldn't confirm if bats were present at the market.

So patient zero didn't get infected in the Huanan market and it isn't even certain bats were sold there. [Bats and palm civet cats were sold in the markets where SARS originated and the palm civet cats are a documented source of SARS.]


We're back where we started, sort of. The market has been ruled out as the initial source. The wet markets are common all over China but the ones where bats and pangolins are most likely to be sold in the same market are in Southern China. You can probably find pangolins for sale in Wuhan but it is uncommon compared to other parts of China. And even if it were common, it's still a highly unlikely coincidence that the place this pangolin-human interface was, was in Wuhan. "Of all the gin joints" and all that.
 
Last edited:
But I think this misses another point. It seems only fairly recently have the researchers led by Shi Zhengli discovered that the original SARS came from Yunnan Province, and yet it turned up in Guanzhou City, so it clearly travelled far from its origin. This is the most important point. Where it emerges is not necessarily where it originates!

However, as I posted previously, the types of coronaviruses that share almost all of the genetic make-up of SARS Cov2 are found over wide areas of China, South-East Asia and even in Japan (probably elsewhere as well). We have no reason for thinking that the one that orginated in Yunnan is the one that has emerged as SARS Cov2. There could likely be several areas from which it broke out.

From what I have read, when looking at the whole genome, the closest related virus to SARS-CoV-2 continues to be RaTG13, collected from a cave in Yunnan.
I have not seen any conflicting research that proposes a closer 'whole genome' match. There could be, or might be in the future.

If you are aware of new data, let me know.
 
But I think this misses another point. It seems only fairly recently have the researchers led by Shi Zhengli discovered that the original SARS came from Yunnan Province, and yet it turned up in Guanzhou City, so it clearly travelled far from its origin. This is the most important point. Where it emerges is not necessarily where it originates!
See my last post, I'll let you catch up. And it wasn't recent. The source of SARS was discovered more than a decade ago.

However, as I posted previously, the types of coronaviruses that share almost all of the genetic make-up of SARS Cov2 are found over wide areas of China, South-East Asia and even in Japan (probably elsewhere as well). We have no reason for thinking that the one that orginated in Yunnan is the one that has emerged as SARS Cov2. There could likely be several areas from which it broke out. ...
I'm pretty sure your source did not say "share almost all of the genetic make-up of SARS Cov2" or if it did it's not a legit source.

But yeah, why did it happen in Wuhan if it could have happened anywhere?
 
Which evidence is new? Bullet point descriptions would be fine.

1) It did not originate in the sea food wet market

2) The concern over the highly unlikely coincidence it began in Wuhan now that we know more about the genome and potential animal sources.

3) The species transfer of SARS to people occurred after the palm civet cats and bats were commonly sold in wet markets together in southern China.

If we accept pangolins as the intermediary source, (maybe they initially traded virus back and forth between bats), one still has to explain why the outbreak would occur in Wuhan where the lab is.
 
Could you clarify: What wasn't where in 2003?
The Wuhan Institute of Virology in its present form:
In 2003, the Chinese academy of Sciences approved the construction of China's first biosafety level 4 (BSL–4) laboratory at the WIV. The construction of the WIV's National Bio-safety Laboratory was completed at a cost of 300 million yuan ($44 million) in collaboration with the French government's CIRI lab at the end of 2014.[2][4] The new laboratory building has 3000 m2 of BSL-4 space, and also 20 BSL-2 and two BSL-3 laboratories.[5]
In response to SARS a large part of the research was located in Wuhan. I'm not sure what's currently going on at the Beijing facility that also studied SARS at the time.

SARS did not emerge in Wuhan. Why would SARS 2 coincidentally emerge near the lab?
 
.....
SARS did not emerge in Wuhan. Why would SARS 2 coincidentally emerge near the lab?


I'm willing to say that WHO scientists know more about this than I -- or most other people -- ever could, and they have concluded that it's very unlikely that covid came from a Wuhan lab. China is a densely populated country in which people move freely from one giant city to another, usually by rail. It might not even have started in Wuhan. Why should it be a surprise that a disease could originate somewhere and travel elsewhere? Coincidences do happen.
https://www.cnn.com/2021/02/14/health/who-mission-china-intl/index.html
 
That's a serious misunderstanding of the origin of SARS. And just what do you think they were doing with all these coronavirus strains in the Institute?

Huh? What?

Let's look at your hypothesis sans your incredulity sarcasm. And you really shouldn't dismiss the 'face saving' in the Chinese culture when there are so many papers written on how it makes medical research from China of uncertain value. But whatever...

You posted a link to the Lancet that said nothing about face, and then one blog post written by some random laowai called China Mike that you said was a "paper" on the topic.

This is not evidence. It's an ac hoc narrative to support a hypothesis which I am not necessarily ruling out (although the WHO scientists who visited Wuhan are ruling it out, so I feel a little arrogant even allowing it to be an option for me), but want to see some actual support for.

Besides, what I really want you to do is post some support for your claim that scientists in Wuhan got sick.

I would be happy to see some independent and reputable source on this. That blog post is not even relevant, let alone reputable. The "fact sheet" from the Trump State Department (neither reputable nor independent) involves unsourced claims that you haven't even tried to substantiate.

Moving on: SARS 1 was traced to a wet market. SARS 2 was not traceable to the Wuhan (sea food) wet market it was initially thought to have originated in.

Hint: it's not about train stations or even population hubs. Surprisingly, we actually have a pretty good idea how SARS got to the Guangdong wet markets.

This is a false dichotomy. Who said it had to be the wet market or bust? Major transport hubs involve lots of people. There could be people travelling from all sorts of places, by rail or by air. They may be people who got infected and passed on the virus. Given that there are many asymptomatic carriers we simply don't know whether someone carried it into Wuhan after it had been circulating elsewhere in the country.

It seems that the scientists themselves are still considering the wet market:

What can you say now about the market and what you saw?

The market closed on the 31st of December or the 1st of January, and China C.D.C. sent a team in of scientists to try and find out what was going on. It was a very extensive study, swabbing every surface of this place. We knew early on that there were 500 samples collected, and there were many positives, and in that sampling were some animal carcasses, or meat. But there was not really much information publicly about what had been done. So we got all that information. And that, to me, was a real eye-opener.

They’d actually done over 900 swabs in the end, a huge amount of work. They had been through the sewage system. They’d been into the air ventilation shaft to look for bats. They’d caught animals around the market. They’d caught cats, stray cats, rats, they even caught one weasel. They’d sampled snakes. People had live snakes at the market, live turtles, live frogs.

Rabbits were there, rabbit carcasses. A farm with rabbits could have been really critical. There was talk about badgers, and in China, when they say badger, that means ferret badger. It’s a mustelid, related to weasels. Animals were coming into that market that could have carried the coronavirus. They could have been infected by bats somewhere else in China and brought it in. So that’s clue No. 1.

There were 10 stalls that sold wildlife. There were vendors from South China, including Yunnan Province, Guangxi Province and Guangdong Province. Yunnan Province is where the closest relative to SARS-CoV-2 is found in bats. Guangxi and Guangdong are where the pangolins were captured. They had close viruses.

You’ve got animals coming in to the market which are susceptible. Some of these are coming from places where we know the nearest relatives of the virus are found. So there’s the real red flag.

Now the Chinese group did swab those animals, and they were all negative, but it’s just one small group of animals in the freezer that were left behind. We don’t know what else was for sale there. So these two clues are really important.

Link

Anyway, the guy being interviewed suggests a number of possibilities including:

farm-meat being sent to market
human transmission from outside
wildlife farms

And he also raises the possibility of fur-farming, particularly given that mink has been known to be infected.

Another suggestion he raises is raccoon dogs

What is the next step?

For the animals chain, it’s straightforward. The suppliers are known. They know the farm name; they know the owner of the farm. You’ve got to go down to the farm and interview the farmer and the family. You’ve got to test them. You’ve got to test the community. You’ve got to go and look and see if there are any animals left at any farms nearby and see if they’ve got evidence of infection, and see if there is any cross-border movement. If the virus is in those southern border states, it’s possible that there’s been some movement across neighboring countries like Vietnam, Laos or Myanmar. We’re finding more and more related viruses now. There’s one in Japan and one in Cambodia, one in Thailand. For the human side, look for earlier cases, for clusters; look in blood banks for serum, if possible. Anything like this is going to be sensitive in China, and it’s going to take some persuasion and diplomacy and energy for them to do that because, to be honest, looking for the source of this virus within China is not a great, high priority I think for the Chinese government. Anywhere this virus is shown to emerge is a political issue. That’s one of the problems, and that is clear and obvious to anyone who has been looking at this.

Do you have a particular animal that you suspect right now as an intermediate link, more strongly than others?

It’s too up in the air. We don’t know if civets were on sale. We know they are very easily infected. We don’t know what the situation is with the mink farms in China or the other fur farms, like raccoon dogs, even though they’re normally farmed in a different part of China. That needs to be followed up on, too.
But if you were to say which pathway would you put the most weight on, I think the virus emerging either in Southeast Asia or Southern China from bats, getting into a domesticated wildlife farm. I’ve been to many of these, and they often have mixed species — civets, ferret badgers, raccoon dogs. Those animals would be able to get infected from bats.

Either the people that work there get infected and bring it in, or animals are shipped in, live or recently killed, that bring the virus into a market. Once it’s in a market — either Huanan or another one in Wuhan — you’ve got a dense population of people moving through those markets. And it’s going to be a real potential for an amplification.
 
The Wuhan Institute of Virology in its present form:In response to SARS a large part of the research was located in Wuhan. I'm not sure what's currently going on at the Beijing facility that also studied SARS at the time.

SARS did not emerge in Wuhan. Why would SARS 2 coincidentally emerge near the lab?

You missed that highlighted bit out as you said the Institute did not exist in 2003.
 
See my last post, I'll let you catch up. And it wasn't recent. The source of SARS was discovered more than a decade ago.

More than a decade ago?

What do you think 13 in RaTG13 stands for? It is the year the sample was collected - 2013.

I'm pretty sure your source did not say "share almost all of the genetic make-up of SARS Cov2" or if it did it's not a legit source.

But yeah, why did it happen in Wuhan if it could have happened anywhere?

If you say so...

Link

Here is a BBC write-up of the discovery:

Scientists say coronaviruses related to Sars-CoV-2 may be circulating in bats across many parts of Asia.

They have discovered a virus that is a close match to the virus that causes Covid-19 in bats at a wildlife sanctuary in eastern Thailand.

And they predict that similar coronaviruses may be present in bats across many Asian nations and regions.

The discovery extends the area in which related viruses have been found to a distance of 4,800km (2,983 miles).

And it gives clues to how Covid-19 might have emerged.

The researchers said sampling was limited, but they were confident that coronaviruses "with a high degree of genetic relatedness to Sars-CoV-2 are widely present in bats across many nations and regions in Asia".

The area includes Japan, China and Thailand, the researchers said in a report published in Nature Communications.

...

The virus, named RacCS203, is a close match to the genetic code of Sars-CoV-2 (with 91.5% similarity in their genomes).

It is also closely related to another coronavirus - called RmYN02 - which is found in bats in Yunnan, China (with 93.6% similarity to the genome of Sars-CoV-2).

Link
 
I'm willing to say that WHO scientists know more about this than I -- or most other people -- ever could, and they have concluded that it's very unlikely that covid came from a Wuhan lab. China is a densely populated country in which people move freely from one giant city to another, usually by rail. It might not even have started in Wuhan. Why should it be a surprise that a disease could originate somewhere and travel elsewhere? Coincidences do happen.
https://www.cnn.com/2021/02/14/health/who-mission-china-intl/index.html
Of course coincidences can happen. And sure the source might have been one person or a family bringing it to Wuhan.

But come on, is that a good enough explanation: it is remotely possible?

The problem is the WHO did not come back with an answer to the source of the pandemic. AFAIK, they ruled out the lab based on what the lab personnel told them.

I am not saying it came from a lab accident. I am saying I cannot rule that out at this point.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom