Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
There is the evidence posted elsewhere that through satellite images there was activity around the Wuhan hospital and an uptick of net searches for pneumonia and other related terms in August of 2019 suggesting COVID began spreading that month.

An uptick in the number of searches for pneumonia right at the start of flu season isn't exactly a remarkable occurrence.

That's not to say there was no connection at all to Covid-19. Most estimates I've seen say it started circulating is a Septemberish time frame.

This doesn't change the fact that market was the epicenter making it the most likely place for the jump to humans to have occurred. It would have had to have been spreading in and around and away from the market for a couple months before there 1000 infections, with 20-30 hospitalizations and a handful of deaths. It's in the third month that you'd see a real explosion of cases.

We know local officials dropped the ball and delayed identifying the outbreak by up to a month. Identifying the outbreak and mid Dec and isolating the virus in late Dec pushes the first case back to late August or early September. This leaves lots of time for it to spread elsewhere but would still have most of the early cases having some connection to the market.
 
A few things while a have some time now since this thread was is response to my 'conspiracy' about the outbreak being related to scientists traveling to the 'bat caves' area (likely Yunnan) and returning to Wuhan.
And given the collaboration of the team, not all of the members go back to work in the lab.

I posted a link back to an NPR article back in April (pub in Feb '20)

New Research: Bats Harbor Hundreds Of Coronaviruses, And Spillovers Aren't Rare
https://www.npr.org/sections/goatsa...ds-of-coronaviruses-and-spillovers-arent-rare

So the researchers started taking blood samples from villagers in China who lived near some of the bat caves they'd been studying.

Hongying Li is an ecologist with EcoHealth Alliance. She says there were any number of ways these people seemed at risk of inadvertently coming into contact with bat saliva, urine or poop.

Each time, says Li, "we found coronaviruses that had already spilled over into the human population."
These were multiple mini-outbreaks that had gone undetected.


Olival says this discovery was a huge red flag: "The signal is there that these SARS-related viruses were jumping into people even if they weren't causing any noticeable disease."
Indeed, people might have even had symptoms, but health authorities simply never picked up on it.

Though these viruses are not exactly Covid-19 (or at least no proof of it), there were hundreds of variants residing there at any given time. Also note that no intermediary animal was required for these infections to be passed to villagers from bats.

Scientists had thought spillovers were rare — that bat coronaviruses weren't generally capable of infecting humans, so it took complicated steps.
"What we showed was that SARS-related viruses in these bat populations have the potential to go directly into human cells and do not need that extra mutational step [of] infecting another host."
 
Last edited:
There is the evidence posted elsewhere that through satellite images there was activity around the Wuhan hospital and an uptick of net searches for pneumonia and other related terms in August of 2019 suggesting COVID began spreading that month. The wet market was a super-spreader event but not the source.

Like lomiller, I dismissed that idea when it was first mooted, and I still do.

There was a spike in searches for "flu symptoms and diarrhea at the start of the influenza and norovirus seasons, around September.

Hmmm.

Satellite images, which may or may not be correct, showed full carparks in August/September as well.

To buy the idea that Covid was circulating widely enough to impact both searches and hospitals by September would require the disease to have stopped replicating for two months, despite no measures being taken.
 
This has been achieved to a relatively high degree. It's possible there are still some missing steps, but what we already know is more than enough to say it's unlikely it would have been in a lab in the first place.
I don't see how you can say that.

Covid-19 is very much a new virus. How would a lab even get hold of it before it started circulating? It's a very infectious virus that can infect many different animal species. I don't find it credible that it was just sitting around waiting for a laboratory to pick it up and study. It's infectious enough that it would have begun circulating widely among animals almost the moment it came into existence and found it's way into humans shortly after. If it were not so infectious than the "escaped from a lab" story wouldn't make sense either.
What the heck do you think the lab is studying, how to make bat soup?

A lot of these genetic changes that allow a species jump are not that involved. What does matter is if the changes allow the pathogen to easily enter and reproduce in the human body (usually respiratory track). A poor match might mean the individual gets infected but doesn't shed enough virus to sustain human to human spread. The lab was looking at what changes are needed to make these viruses adapted to humans.

They did similar research with the HPAI H5N1 virus and found it only needed two more mutations to become adapted to the human respiratory track.

Just jogged my memory, when the H5N1 human infections did occur, they were deep in the lung, fewer viruses shed from these cells. But the upper airway was a different matter. Viral replication in these cells would likely mean more viral shedding. There are papers on this but it's getting too far OT.
 
Last edited:
An uptick in the number of searches for pneumonia right at the start of flu season isn't exactly a remarkable occurrence.
Flu season in the northern hemisphere typically starts in Dec, not Aug.

That's not to say there was no connection at all to Covid-19. Most estimates I've seen say it started circulating is a Septemberish time frame.
No. They've found blood specimens with antibodies that document cases at least as far back as Aug.


This doesn't change the fact that market was the epicenter making it the most likely place for the jump to humans to have occurred. It would have had to have been spreading in and around and away from the market for a couple months before there 1000 infections, with 20-30 hospitalizations and a handful of deaths. It's in the third month that you'd see a real explosion of cases.
The wet market in Wuhan has already been ruled out as the place the virus originally jumped species.

We know local officials dropped the ball and delayed identifying the outbreak by up to a month. Identifying the outbreak and mid Dec and isolating the virus in late Dec pushes the first case back to late August or early September. This leaves lots of time for it to spread elsewhere but would still have most of the early cases having some connection to the market.
The problem with this hypothesis is that there were many cases with no connection to the market, even remotely.
 
Like lomiller, I dismissed that idea when it was first mooted, and I still do.

There was a spike in searches for "flu symptoms and diarrhea at the start of the influenza and norovirus seasons, around September.
And you make the same mistake with this confirmation biased assumption. Flu season in the northern hemisphere rarely starts before Dec. The 2009 variant was an exception, but we did not have an exception in 2019.


Satellite images, which may or may not be correct, showed full carparks in August/September as well.

To buy the idea that Covid was circulating widely enough to impact both searches and hospitals by September would require the disease to have stopped replicating for two months, despite no measures being taken.
You are welcome to support this rebuttal with a source.

And stopped replicating for 2 months? I don't think it did but even if it had, we also had a lull for no good reason between the first and second waves.

SARS circulated for several months in Guangdong before breaking out into the world. HIV circulated for years (or at least many months) in rural West Central Africa before it broke out into the rest of Africa and then to the world. This is not an argument for the origin being in Sept.
 
Last edited:
And stopped replicating for 2 months? I don't think it did but even if it had, we also had a lull for no good reason between the first and second waves.

SARS circulated for several months in Guangdong before breaking out into the world. HIV circulated for years (or at least many months) in rural West Central Africa before it broke out into the rest of Africa and then to the world. This is not an argument for the origin being in Sept.

Agree. This sort of argument also assumes the variant and how contagious or serious the illness becomes remains stable from when it first enters a human population and that infections also remain stable throughout seasons.
Well, we know that is not true.

If it just hit some small rural village near the source without many hosts or much ability to travel, then we likely never hear of them, unless you follow the research that found infections/antibodies in people there.

But what happens when it hits a larger, denser population with many more hosts? Is it not reasonable to think it has much more opportunity to mutate over time into a more virulent form? And doesn't that usually take many weeks or months?

After all, this is what we have seen happen in different locations globally.
 
Last edited:
And you make the same mistake with this confirmation biased assumption. Flu season in the northern hemisphere rarely starts before Dec. The 2009 variant was an exception, but we did not have an exception in 2019.

Oh, that is pure gold. You call me out for making assumptions, while making an enormously erroneous one yourself.

In southern China, influenza is prevalent throughout the year; it has a clear peak in the summer and a less pronounced peak in the winter.

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3321959/

(Shoulda checked before assuming China reflects what happens in USA)

You are welcome to support this rebuttal with a source.

Like the one I just posted that shows your response to be factually incorrect?

Sure. Consider it done.

And stopped replicating for 2 months?

Have you been asleep for the whole pandemic? It has exponential spread and if hospitals were full of Covid in August/September, most of the population would have been infected by January.

I don't think it did but even if it had, we also had a lull for no good reason between the first and second waves.

Utter nonsense. You had a minor drop (nothing like a lull) after introduction of extreme measures in NY, which held the pandemic up until it took hold elsewhere. Numbers didn't start rising again for four whole months. Even then, the reduction in USA was all of about 20%, and if you don't think Covid is at least somewhat seasonal, you haven't been watching, and it was the middle of summer.

In Wuhan, no measures were taken until January, and the numbers do not support an earlier outbreak at all.

SARS circulated for several months in Guangdong before breaking out into the world. HIV circulated for years (or at least many months) in rural West Central Africa before it broke out into the rest of Africa and then to the world. This is not an argument for the origin being in Sept.

That's not even a goalpost shift - you're trying to change the entire game by talking about entirely different diseases, one of which is impossible to catch for most people. The other infected all of 8000 cases worldwide.
 
From your link:
Whereas a regular winter pattern is noted for northern China (similar to that in most parts of the Northern Hemisphere)

Wuhan is far enough north that flu season is consistent with the northern hemisphere:

Seasonal influenza activity in young children before the COVID‐19 outbreak in Wuhan, China
we also found a peak of influenza A in early January, coinciding with the start of the COVID‐19 outbreak. It is interesting to note that the winter peak of seasonal influenza in Wuhan appeared in early January 2020, nearly one month earlier than those in 2017–2018 and 2018–2019.

Tag, you're it.
 
From your link:

Wuhan is far enough north that flu season is consistent with the northern hemisphere:

Incorrect.

Holy crap, even though I gave you the instructions, you still failed.

Let's unpack it so you don't get it wrong yet again.

The link clearly states:

For influenza surveillance purposes, mainland China was divided into northern and southern parts, basically following the Qinling Mountain range in the west and the Huai River in the east.

Wuhan is south of Huai. Here's a handy map so you can't possibly go wrong this time:

https://www.semanticscholar.org/pap...6bc5bacb30fbefd8bbc0b44d56c247e00676/figure/1


Sure.

You are terrible at this, and you'd save yourself an enormous amount of embarrassment if you tried reading the link more carefully next time.

From the link...

The prominent influenza peaks in the winter in the north and summer in the south were clear for adults and for children (Figure, panel A); the level of ILI was 3–5× for children.

Children aren't even relevant - the link gives you the child and adult data separately, and even then you missed it. Southern China has a peak in August. The data is all there.

The end.
 
So you think adults get flu at a different time of year than the kids? :boggled:

If anything, adults get flu later as it spreads in schools then to adults from their kids.

My link was specifically about influenza IN WUHAN. To repeat:
we also found a peak of influenza A in early January, coinciding with the start of the COVID‐19 outbreak. It is interesting to note that the winter peak of seasonal influenza in Wuhan appeared in early January 2020, nearly one month earlier than those in 2017–2018 and 2018–2019.
From the graph, influenza positive cultures in the two previous years don't match the summary and I'm not sure why that is, but regardless it is the 2019-2020 season that we are discussing.

It did not peak in Aug-Sept and was not responsible for the increased activity in the Wuhan hospitals or for the related net searches.

And from the charts, there is little flu activity in from July to Nov in 2019. And from the text:
The retrospective laboratory tests in the specimens from these ILI patients to January 2020 showed that an outbreak of seasonal influenza attacked the ≤30 age group in October–November 2019,
Still not Aug-Sept.

:rolleyes:


Interesting side note from the graph, the 2018-19 and 2019-20 flu seasons are back to normal, peaking Jan to Mar. That is the same flu season we see here in the US with the earliest cases showing up in Dec. In the 2017-18 seasons things are different. After the 2009 variant flu, the flu seasons were irregular for several years after that here as well.
 
Last edited:
What the heck do you think the lab is studying, how to make bat soup?

Covid-19 isn’t a bat virus anymore. It’s spike doesn’t attach well to the receptors in bats so at best it’s minimally infections to bats. It’s unlikely that it could even spread from bat to bat. Someone studying bat viruses is very unlikely to encounter Covid-19.

They did similar research with the HPAI H5N1 virus and found it only needed two more mutations to become adapted to the human respiratory track.

The spike structure that allows Covid-19 to infect humans is completely different than it’s bat predecessor. It’s certainly NOT just one or two mutations. The bat virus

The lab was looking at what changes are needed to make these viruses adapted to humans.

This fails for the same reason “it was created in a lab” conspiracy theories fail.
Essentially you are suggesting that someone took pieces from 2 random viruses, neither of which was thought to be able to infect humans, in the hopes that the result would somehow be able to infect humans. This isn’t how human researchers work, it IS characteristic of how of how recombination in RNA viruses works in the wild to occasionally produce something entirely new that can spread jump species easily.
 
Summary of bat Coronaviruses in China (Pub Mar 2019)
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6466186/

Published many months before the outbreak.

It is generally believed that bat-borne CoVs will re-emerge to cause the next disease outbreak. In this regard, China is a likely hotspot. The challenge is to predict when and where, so that we can try our best to prevent such outbreaks.

It was strongly suggested that SARS-CoV most likely originated from Yunnan Rhinolophus bats via recombination events among existing SARSr-CoVs.
...
(on SARS-related viruses)
The S protein in certain strains is capable of using human ACE2 as a receptor and thus poses a direct threat to humans [69]. Interestingly, all the SARSr-CoVs that are capable of using human ACE2 were found in R. sinicus in Yunnan Province
..
These studies revealed that various SARSr-CoVs capable of using human ACE2 are still circulating among bats in China, highlighting the possibly of another SARS-like disease outbreak. Certain areas in Yunnan Province are hotspots for spillover. To support this hypothesis, we provide serological evidence of bat SARSr-CoV infection in humans in Yunnan Province where no prior exposure to SARS-CoV was recorded
 
My link was specifically about influenza IN WUHAN.

Your own link shows a clear uptick in Influenza BEFOR Covid-19 hits. It also shows the premature end to flu season due to social distancing required to combat Covid-19. If, as you speculate Covid-19 was circulating in Aug, the spike in Covid cases would have been much sooner because it’s more infectious than the Flu and case counts increase much more rapidly. Furthermore flu tends to all but disappear when people are responding to Covid and that didn’t happen until Jan.

It did not peak in Aug-Sept and was not responsible for the increased activity in the Wuhan hospitals or for the related net searches.


You are telling us this metric as an early response indictor for Covid, but then saying it can be the Flu because the Flu season Doesn’t peak at that time. Why would it be a leading indicator for one but not the other? If it’s a valid metric it should start to rise as soon a flu cases start to rise, which occurs much sooner than when the peak case loads occur.
 
Covid-19 isn’t a bat virus anymore. It’s spike doesn’t attach well to the receptors in bats so at best it’s minimally infections to bats. It’s unlikely that it could even spread from bat to bat. Someone studying bat viruses is very unlikely to encounter Covid-19.

The spike structure that allows Covid-19 to infect humans is completely different than it’s bat predecessor. It’s certainly NOT just one or two mutations. The bat virus

This fails for the same reason “it was created in a lab” conspiracy theories fail.
Essentially you are suggesting that someone took pieces from 2 random viruses, neither of which was thought to be able to infect humans, in the hopes that the result would somehow be able to infect humans. This isn’t how human researchers work, it IS characteristic of how of how recombination in RNA viruses works in the wild to occasionally produce something entirely new that can spread jump species easily.
So many false assumptions here about what I know and what I'm thinking.

I know all about the middle animal in the chain (bat-animal x-human) and why it is thought the mutations have to go through that middle animal before adapting to humans.

I said bat soup sarcastically because a wide collection of coronaviruses were obtained in the field by the researchers in the Wuhan Institute. That is what they are studying.

No CT is needed and frankly, trying to dismiss a viable possibility of a lab accident as a CT is so typical of this forum. People are so quick to label something as a CT after new evidence surfaces if they first went with the CT. Unfortunately it doesn't move the discussion forward.

And if you look at sherkeu's link above, it is about more than one coronavirus species being found in the people around the caves in China suggesting it is possible that a direct infection from bats can occur, no pangolin intermediary necessary. Maybe you missed this sentence:
To support this hypothesis, we provide serological evidence of bat SARSr-CoV infection in humans in Yunnan Province where no prior exposure to SARS-CoV was recorded
If it is at all like the influenza virus, people close to infected birds get infected but the virus is not in an efficient state, thus no sustained human to human transmission occurred. But it is worth noting that those needed mutations could occur in a human as easily as in the intermediary animal.

The point is the Wuhan lab was studying multiple strains of bat coronaviruses.

Nature 2015: A SARS-like cluster of circulating bat coronaviruses shows potential for human emergence
Affiliations: ...
Key Laboratory of Special Pathogens and Biosafety, Wuhan Institute of Virology, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Wuhan, China

Xing-Yi Ge & Zhengli-Li Shi
Not a big deal, just saying this is the kind of research that was going on in Wuhan.


As for the flu peaking before COVID in 2019, that has nothing to do with the conversation. The issue was, is the spike in cars in Wuhan hospital parking lots explained by natural flu season?
Flu did not peak in Aug in Wuhan. :rolleyes:

Now that that is cleared up, you'll all be happy to see the BBC rebuttal to the satellite and search engine evidence: Coronavirus: Fact-checking claims it might have started in August 2019


Moving on.

Evidence against it being a lab leak:
The WHO and the top researcher in the Wuhan Institute says it was not.
There no genomic evidence it was a manufactured virus, something one would expect to see. (No one here is claiming purposefully manufactured.)​

The evidence for it being a lab leak:
The initial outbreak was in Wuhan which is hundreds of miles from the bat caves.
China is known to cover things like this up.
If it was a lab leak the researcher would be fired or maybe worse, IOW the lab people have sufficient motive to lie.​

There are probably more on those lists, I'll add them as we go.
 
I know all about the middle animal in the chain (bat-animal x-human) and why it is thought the mutations have to go through that middle animal before adapting to humans.
Recombination not mutation.
I said bat soup sarcastically because a wide collection of coronaviruses were obtained in the field by the researchers in the Wuhan Institute. That is what they are studying.
Again, Covid-19 doesn’t readily infect bats, so “studying bats” is not a satisfactory explanation for why it would be in the lab in the first place.
No CT is needed and frankly, trying to dismiss a viable possibility of a lab accident as a CT is so typical of this forum. People are so quick to label something as a CT after new evidence surfaces if they first went with the CT. Unfortunately it doesn't move the discussion forward.

I said it fails for the same reason as the CT, but when you suggest scientists modified the bat virus “to see what would make it infectious to humans” you are tilting well into CT territory. The fact remains that this isn’t how human researchers work, but it is how recombination events work.
And if you look at sherkeu's link above, it is about more than one coronavirus species being found in the people around the caves in China suggesting it is possible that a direct infection from bats can occur, no pangolin intermediary necessary. Maybe you missed this sentence:If it is at all like the influenza virus, people close to infected birds get infected but the virus is not in an efficient state, thus no sustained human to human transmission occurred. But it is worth noting that those needed mutations could occur in a human as easily as in the intermediary animal.

Again. Recombination not mutation. The spike from the Pangolin virus efficiently attaches to human ACE-2 receptors, so it’s infectious to humans right out of the gate. The same link also suggest something very similar happened with SARS, but with the spike protein coming from another bat virus. SARS was also infectious to humans right form the start.
Flu did not peak in Aug in Wuhan.
Neither did Covid, yet you expected us to believe it was causing an increase in online searches.
As for the flu peaking before COVID in 2019, that has nothing to do with the conversation.
Covid spreads more rapidly the Flu. There is no credible way it could have started spreading sooner and peaked later.
The evidence for it being a lab leak:
The initial outbreak was in Wuhan which is hundreds of miles from the bat caves.

Again, not an issued because Covid-19 isn’t infectious to bats.
China is known to cover things like this up.
If it was a lab leak the researcher would be fired or maybe worse, IOW the lab people have sufficient motive to lie

That’s not evidence for anything.
 
Really? That has not been clearly established. It remains an hypothesis.

NIH: COVID-19: Time to exonerate the pangolin from the transmission of SARS-CoV-2 to humans

I'll let you read it yourself.

I read it the other day and didn't find it compelling. they offer no explanation for why the spike protein so closely resembles the one found in the Pangolin virus and they handwave away the evidence for the what that spike protein can and can't attach to. Subsequent finding that the Pangolin virus can directly infect humans directly contradicts their claim that spike protein cannot.
 
@lomiller: No it is not all recombination. That is playing a role with COVID, but it is not the only thing going on.


How do you know COVID 19 can't reinfect bats?

It hasn't been found yet but it also hasn't been ruled out. Researchers are still looking.

Phys org news Jan 2021: Is COVID-19 infecting wild animals? We're testing species from bats to seals to find out


@everyone else:
If you aren't aware the Chinese cover things up for political reasons and to 'save face' I recommend you do more reading on the subject. Start with the ophthalmologist who was told to keep quiet before he himself died from COVID?


Then go here: The Lancet 2015 editorial: China's medical research integrity questioned.


This is what happened with SARS back in 2003:

RFI (request for information):
Date: 10 Feb 2003
From: Stephen O. Cunnion, MD, PhD, MPH <[email protected]>

This morning I received this e-mail and then searched your archives
and found nothing that pertained to it. Does anyone know anything
about this problem?
"Have you heard of an epidemic in Guangzhou? An acquaintance of mine
from a teacher's chat room lives there and reports that the
hospitals there have been closed and people are dying."

The government said don't worry, we have this under control.
Commenting on the problem of pneumonia on the Mainland, Dr Yeoh said
the Department of Health has already touched base with the Guangdong
authorities to learn more about the type of infection prevalent
there. The department will also determine whether there is any
particular risk of that infection coming to Hong Kong.
He assured the public that the Government is always on the alert, as
the Department of Health has a very good communicable disease
surveillance system.
Coupled with the network of reporting sources both from the public
and private sectors, as well as communication channels with
authorities on the Mainland and Macau, the Government is informed of
any infections that may spread to Hong Kong.
He called on the public not to be unduly concerned.
"We'll certainly be doing our part as the health authorities, but
individuals should always take precautions when they travel aboard,"
he added.

And then came the downplaying which the BMJ bought.
The past 2 weeks have seen the province of Guangdong in southern China
become victim to a serious pneumonia epidemic that seized its people with
fear and caused major temporary economic damage, but that eventually turned
out to have relatively slight medical impact. By last week, there had been
8 deaths.
However, considerable anxiety was created by an "epidemic of rumours."
During the first week of February 2003 the public became aware of a
mysterious respiratory illness which apparently had a very high mortality
and caused death within hours. Symptoms included cough, fever, and
breathing difficulty....

People spread their fears and new-found information by telephone,
mobile phone, text messages, email, and word of mouth. In the absence of
public statements and official information the media communicated very little....

The rumour spread that many of the victims of the illness were hospital
staff and that a number of them had died. As a result outpatient
departments almost emptied.
That rumor turned out to be true and the one reason ProMed professionals were so concerned was that their colleagues were reporting the deaths of health care workers in the hospital.

Then came this report
WHO issues a global alert about cases of atypical pneumonia

Cases of severe respiratory illness may spread to hospital staff

Since mid February 2003, WHO has been actively working to confirm
reports of outbreaks of a severe form of pneumonia in Viet Nam, Hong Kong
Special Administrative Region (SAR), China, & Guangdong province in
China
It evolved over time when it was no longer possible to hide.


The point is, people in China from local mayors to party officials are motivated to 'save face'.

There are dozens of papers on it, this is one: Of all the idiosyncrasies of Chinese culture, the concept of “face” is perhaps most difficult for Westerns to fully grasp.

Because “saving face” is such a strong motivating force in China, it’s also one of the most important concepts in understanding the Chinese Mind....



Too bad Wolfman isn't around, he knows the Chinese culture very well.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom