Covid-19 isn’t a bat virus anymore. It’s spike doesn’t attach well to the receptors in bats so at best it’s minimally infections to bats. It’s unlikely that it could even spread from bat to bat. Someone studying bat viruses is very unlikely to encounter Covid-19.
The spike structure that allows Covid-19 to infect humans is completely different than it’s bat predecessor. It’s certainly NOT just one or two mutations. The bat virus
This fails for the same reason “it was created in a lab” conspiracy theories fail.
Essentially you are suggesting that someone took pieces from 2 random viruses, neither of which was thought to be able to infect humans, in the hopes that the result would somehow be able to infect humans. This isn’t how human researchers work, it IS characteristic of how of how recombination in RNA viruses works in the wild to occasionally produce something entirely new that can spread jump species easily.
So many false assumptions here about what I know and what I'm thinking.
I know all about the middle animal in the chain (bat-animal x-human) and why it is thought the mutations have to go through that middle animal before adapting to humans.
I said bat soup sarcastically because a wide collection of coronaviruses were obtained in the field by the researchers in the Wuhan Institute.
That is what they are studying.
No CT is needed and frankly, trying to dismiss a viable possibility of a lab accident as a CT is so typical of this forum. People are so quick to label something as a CT after new evidence surfaces if they first went with the CT.
Unfortunately it doesn't move the discussion forward.
And if you look at sherkeu's link above, it is about more than one coronavirus species being found in the people around the caves in China suggesting it is possible that a direct infection from bats can occur, no pangolin intermediary necessary. Maybe you missed this sentence:
To support this hypothesis, we provide serological evidence of bat SARSr-CoV infection in humans in Yunnan Province where no prior exposure to SARS-CoV was recorded
If it is at all like the influenza virus, people close to infected birds get infected but the virus is not in an efficient state, thus no sustained human to human transmission occurred. But it is worth noting that those needed mutations could occur in a human as easily as in the intermediary animal.
The point is the Wuhan lab was studying multiple strains of bat coronaviruses.
Nature 2015: A SARS-like cluster of circulating bat coronaviruses shows potential for human emergence
Affiliations: ...
Key Laboratory of Special Pathogens and Biosafety, Wuhan Institute of Virology, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Wuhan, China
Xing-Yi Ge & Zhengli-Li Shi
Not a big deal, just saying this is the kind of research that was going on in Wuhan.
As for the flu peaking before COVID in 2019, that has nothing to do with the conversation.
The issue was, is the spike in cars in Wuhan hospital parking lots explained by natural flu season?
Flu did not peak in Aug in Wuhan.
Now that that is cleared up, you'll all be happy to see the
BBC rebuttal to the satellite and search engine evidence:
Coronavirus: Fact-checking claims it might have started in August 2019
Moving on.
Evidence against it being a lab leak:
The WHO and the top researcher in the Wuhan Institute says it was not.
There no genomic evidence it was a manufactured virus, something one would expect to see. (No one here is claiming purposefully manufactured.)
The evidence for it being a lab leak:
The initial outbreak was in Wuhan which is hundreds of miles from the bat caves.
China is known to cover things like this up.
If it was a lab leak the researcher would be fired or maybe worse, IOW the lab people have sufficient motive to lie.
There are probably more on those lists, I'll add them as we go.