Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
... Unlike you,
:rolleyes:

I don’t need jump from "I question the motives of people saying differently" to saying the market must of have been where the virus crossed into humans. I have actual evidence, specifically the genetic connection to the Pangolin virus and Pangolin’s presence at the market. Granted there are other possibility’s but they all involve a more complex series of events. Occam’s razor applies and Pangolins at the Wuhan market is the simplest plausible explanation.
So actual evidence related viruses have been found in Pangolins? Or actual evidence the pangolin has been narrowed down to being the source?

Because no one has argued against the former.

And pangolin's presence in the market? Did you miss the memo the original cases did not occur in the market? :boggled:
 
A study released by the National Cancer Institute (INT) in Milan in November showed the new coronavirus was circulating in Italy in September 2019."

https://www.independent.co.uk/news/health/covid-origin-wuhan-who-investigation-china-b1802081.html

Anyone know anymore detail about this?

That was brought up a while back in the Covid thread, and I don't buy it.

If it was in Italy in September, it would have broken out before February. I've mentioned several times the "phony war" period of Covid, where it looks to be minimal before busting out all over.

That typical period is 3-4 weeks, as shown by all the outbreaks to date. The idea that it was circulating undiscovered anywhere for over three months (five in Italy's case) is nonsensical.

The opinion was formed early in the pandemic that a significant percentage of people are immune to Covid, and that's probably due to the same antibodies being claimed in Italy. Coronaviruses are all related - which is why they're all coronaviruses - and the very high probability is that some people produce the right antibodies to combat Covid.

Give it another year or so and we'll know what that it, which is going to be quite helpful.
 
Why drag their feet at all?

You can refuse to look at the role Chinese culture plays when it comes to scientific research reliability, but it doesn't change the fact it does. I believe that's called ethnocentrism: a tendency to view other ethnic or cultural groups from the perspective of one's own.

....

It only makes sense if you understand the Chinese culture of 'saving face'. And lest you think that's an ancient thing, look at the ophthalmologist who was told by authorities to shut up when he tried to raise the alarm about another pneumonia of unknown etiology that was all too frequently fatal.


I can imagine you don't see how the lab could be the source when you build a straw man like this to argue with.

First, I said I don't know. I am just not ready to rule out the lab.

Second, the point about considering the Wuhan lab people and the WHO may not be reliable is where the 'face saving' comes in. It's why those reports are not absolutely reliable. Reliable? Possibly maybe even probably, but not irrefutable.

Nobody is saying that Chinese culture doesn't have any concept of face, or that it is ancient. The problem for me is the way you are applying it.

You don't need to invoke face given that any country with a secret lab doing secret research is going to be resistant to having the WHO turn up and inspecting whatever they like.

This kind of thing is hardly unique to China. If you want to look at a previous escape/deliberate release from a lab example, look at the anthrax poisonings of 2001. Coverups and destruction of evidence happening all over the place there. Are these to be explained by "face"?

The point is, the concept of face is far too nebulous to do any of the heavy-lifting for your theory. Any normal investigation should assume secrecy, especially from an authoritarian government (do you think Soviet and US secrecy is down to face?).

But I love the way you turn it back against people who disregard your clumsy stereotyping and argue that those people are the racists for being ethnocentric.

Honestly, you may as well be saying that Bat Woman, being an industrious Boomer, did the hard work of collecting the samples, but may have left the security down to a Gen Xer, who are notorious slackers. That's really the level at which "face" is doing any legwork here.
 
Just to be clear neither Pangolin-CoV-2019 nor the bat virus RaTG13 is a direct ancestor to Covid-19. RaTG13 is the closest relative but not an ancestor. Pangolin-CoV-2019 is even more distantly related but it or a closely related Pangolin virus supplied important genes that give Covid-19 specific features to it’s spike that make if very efficient in infecting humans.
This contradicts your claim you have evidence the pangolin is the source. :boggled:

This exchange of genetic material from Pangolin-CoV-2019 to the real Covid-19 direct ancestor is very unlikely to have been deliberate manipulation for 2 reasons:

First, we can’t even find the direct ancestor after a year of intense search, so how would a lab have had it 18 months ago?
Umm, because maybe they did but they don't want to admit it?


Second, while the spike protein in the Pangolin virus is very efficient for infecting humans this wasn’t know prior to seeing Covid itself. Similarly, the bat virus couldn’t infect humans. So essentially the researcher would have to have been splicing together random chunks of random viruses to see if they could make something that infects humans. This isn’t how a research would proceed with something like this they would take parts of viruses already know to infect humans.
Or for pity's sake.

You don't have to splice "random" chunks. It's much more sophisticated than that.

You think they wouldn't do research on a known serious human pathogen? :boggled:


Nature, on the other hand does this kind of thing all the time RNA viruses undergo recombination all the time. Most, like Covid, show signs of numerous recombination events. For this to happen either the bat virus would have needed to infect a Pangolin or the Pangolin virus would have needed to infect a bat. Even if the two viruses are not very infectious across species this can still occur on occasion. In this case it looks like the bat virus infected the Pangolin. The resultant virus isn’t very infectious to bats so it would have been facing a dead end if it was stuck inside a bat. Since it was infectious to both Pangolins and humans it could spread within Pangolins until one of them was take to the Wuhan market where it jumped to humans.

It’s possible that both jumped to a third species but this is completely unnecessary and would require 2 unlikely infections simultaneous rather than just one. Also, we now know that Covid-19 neutralizing antibodies can be found in wild bats and Pangolins in SE Asia indicating closely related viruses or Corvid itself was already circulating there.
So much rationalizing and speculating. The research is close, we in the thread all know that. But the source and the jump event has not yet been pinned down.


I thought this was interesting, just a comment, no specific significance just yet..
New Scientist Feb 16: Exclusive: Two variants have merged into heavily mutated coronavirus
If confirmed, the recombinant would be the first to be detected in this pandemic. In December and January, two research groups independently reported that they hadn’t seen any evidence of recombination, even though it has long been expected as it is common in coronaviruses.
So after a year, one recombinant found.

Influenza, OTOH, recombines every time two strains infect one cell. They shuffle the cards.
 
Last edited:
.... If it was in Italy in September, it would have broken out before February. I've mentioned several times the "phony war" period of Covid, where it looks to be minimal before busting out all over.

That typical period is 3-4 weeks, as shown by all the outbreaks to date. The idea that it was circulating undiscovered anywhere for over three months (five in Italy's case) is nonsensical.
What outbreaks to date? :confused: You mean the outbreaks after intense surveillance was looking for it?

People died here in WA State a couple weeks or more before it was recognized to be circulating.

NYT (still no paywall on COVID articles) April 2020: Hidden Outbreaks Spread Through U.S. Cities Far Earlier Than Americans Knew, Estimates Say
By the time New York City confirmed its first case of the coronavirus on March 1, thousands of infections were already silently spreading through the city, a hidden explosion of a disease that many still viewed as a remote threat as the city awaited the first signs of spring.

Hidden outbreaks were also spreading almost completely undetected in Boston, San Francisco, Chicago and Seattle, long before testing showed that each city had a major problem, according to a model of the spread of the disease by researchers at Northeastern University who shared their results with The New York Times.

Even in early February — while the world focused on China — the virus was not only likely to be spreading in multiple American cities, but also seeding blooms of infection elsewhere in the United States, the researchers found.

Yet Dr Redfield claimed:
“Through Feb. 27, this country only had 14 cases,” he said during a briefing.
We had more cases than that already in WA State. So he was lying.
“We weren’t testing, and if you’re not testing you don’t know,” Dr. Heguy said. The new estimates suggesting that thousands of infections were spreading silently in the first months of the year “don’t seem surprising at all,” she said....

In mid-February, a month before New York City schools were closed, New York City and San Francisco already had more than 600 people with unidentified infections, and Seattle, Chicago and Boston already had more than 100 people, the findings estimate. By March 1, as New York confirmed its first case, the numbers there may already have surpassed 10,000.
Not to get too far off the topic of the origin, I have seen reports of early cases in Italy and some rebuttals. But believing we would have known is only if people were looking and if they had the tools to look.
The virus moved under the radar swiftly in February and March, doctors and researchers said, because few cities or states had adequate surveillance systems in place. And testing, if it was being done at all, was haphazard.
And denial:
“We were talking to officials here, and it was the same reaction we got in Italy, in the U.K., in Spain,” Dr. Vespignani said. “They told me, ‘OK, that’s happening on your computer, not in reality.’
Seems to be a common human affliction.

There's pretty good evidence we should look for the jump event sometime in Oct or Nov. And we should keep an open mind if evidence pushes that back further.


The opinion was formed early in the pandemic that a significant percentage of people are immune to Covid, and that's probably due to the same antibodies being claimed in Italy. Coronaviruses are all related - which is why they're all coronaviruses - and the very high probability is that some people produce the right antibodies to combat Covid. ...
If you mean this just as a rebuttal to the early antibodies detected in blood in Italy, then yeah, some of the data has been questioned.

Beyond that, "significant percentage of people are immune" is an unsupported assertion but that debate belongs in the other thread. An asymptomatic infection is not the same as being immune to infection.
 
Denials, lies, secrecy...

This is exactly why you don’t need to invoke a special category “saving face” to explain the same behaviour at the Wuhan lab.
 
Denials, lies, secrecy...

This is exactly why you don’t need to invoke a special category “saving face” to explain the same behaviour at the Wuhan lab.

It's a special category in China because it affects researchers who one would not think needed denials, lies, and secrecy.
 
It's a special category in China because it affects researchers who one would not think needed denials, lies, and secrecy.

Well, from what I can see, Shi Zhengli has been pretty open to having her work studied and looked at. Lots of the “evidence” that you and Sherkeu are using to support your lab escape theory is hers. But the institute itself has said that these are just her personal opinions and don’t reflect those of the Institute.
 
:rolleyes:


So actual evidence related viruses have been found in Pangolins? Or actual evidence the pangolin has been narrowed down to being the source?

Because no one has argued against the former.

And pangolin's presence in the market? Did you miss the memo the original cases did not occur in the market? :boggled:

Genetic material from a Pangolin virus makes up a key part of the Covid-19 genome. That's a little difficult to explain if Pangolins didn't play a major role in the origin of the disease. I've also show that being carried to the Wuhan market in a Pangolin is by far the simplest most plausible explanation for how the jump to humans occurred.
 
That typical period is 3-4 weeks, as shown by all the outbreaks to date. The idea that it was circulating undiscovered anywhere for over three months (five in Italy's case) is nonsensical.

3-4 weeks is a little to short to go from a single case to a major outbreak IMO.

Using a very crude model where infections go up 2.5X every weak and cumulative deaths are ~1% of the cumulative cases 3 weeks early it takes ~ 8 weeks on average to see the first death but between weak 8 and weak 12 cases and deaths absolutely explode.

Again, it's a crude model but the explosion of cases in Italy in march would suggest the first infection in Italy was in early Jan, or late Dec at the soonest.
 
This contradicts your claim you have evidence the pangolin is the source. :boggled:
No, it doesn’t. The recombination that put Pangolin virus genes into the bat virus almost certainly occurred in a Pangolin.
Umm, because maybe they did but they don't want to admit it?
Why were they trying to hide it before it “escaped” and why has no one been able to find it since?
You don't have to splice "random" chunks. It's much more sophisticated than that.

You think they wouldn't do research on a known serious human pathogen? :boggled:
Exactly my point. In this case, neither virus was a known human pathogen. It’d be completely nonsensical for a researcher to use them as a starting point. There is no logical reason to say this was a lab experiment and not recombination.

So much rationalizing and speculating. The research is close, we in the thread all know that.
Recombination is well understood and known to be a major source of novel RNA viruses. If you are going to hand wave such well understood science I don’t know where we can go from here.

But the source and the jump event has not yet been pinned down.
There are 2 sources, 1 bat virus 1 Pangolin virus.

I thought this was interesting, just a comment, no specific significance just yet..
New Scientist Feb 16: Exclusive: Two variants have merged into heavily mutated coronavirusSo after a year, one recombinant found.
Covid-19 IS the product recombination between a bat virus and a Pangolin virus.
 
It's a special category in China because it affects researchers who one would not think needed denials, lies, and secrecy.

“Face saving” would be more relevant for discussing why Chinese scientists would want to downplay the role of the Pangolins and Wuhan market in the outbreak. In the wake of Covid-19 there have been widespread international condemnation of live animal markets and calls to shut them down permanently.

Secrecy around the Wuhan lab is better explained by nationalism, the existence of government research and participation in industrial espionage.
 
Genetic material from a Pangolin virus makes up a key part of the Covid-19 genome. That's a little difficult to explain if Pangolins didn't play a major role in the origin of the disease. I've also show that being carried to the Wuhan market in a Pangolin is by far the simplest most plausible explanation for how the jump to humans occurred.

Of all the gin joints is a fictional line. :)

I didn't say pangolins weren't involved in the genome mixing.
 
Second, while the spike protein in the Pangolin virus is very efficient for infecting humans this wasn’t know prior to seeing Covid itself. Similarly, the bat virus couldn’t infect humans. So essentially the researcher would have to have been splicing together random chunks of random viruses to see if they could make something that infects humans. This isn’t how a research would proceed with something like this they would take parts of viruses already know to infect humans.

Nature, on the other hand does this kind of thing all the time RNA viruses undergo recombination all the time. Most, like Covid, show signs of numerous recombination events. For this to happen either the bat virus would have needed to infect a Pangolin or the Pangolin virus would have needed to infect a bat. Even if the two viruses are not very infectious across species this can still occur on occasion. In this case it looks like the bat virus infected the Pangolin. The resultant virus isn’t very infectious to bats so it would have been facing a dead end if it was stuck inside a bat. Since it was infectious to both Pangolins and humans it could spread within Pangolins until one of them was take to the Wuhan market where it jumped to humans.

It’s possible that both jumped to a third species but this is completely unnecessary and would require 2 unlikely infections simultaneous rather than just one. Also, we now know that Covid-19 neutralizing antibodies can be found in wild bats and Pangolins in SE Asia indicating closely related viruses or Corvid itself was already circulating there.

This whole cross-species infection is quite interesting to me because the current virus seems to cross many species in it's current iteration.

What we know now is that there are many mammals that can be infected with the Covid-19 virus- directly and unadulterated. Some mammals can then infect others. Some infections are essentially dead-ends. Many are unknown.

Q: If I gave a researcher a Covid-19 virus sample from a currently covid-19 infected tiger, ferret, deer mouse, house cat, dog, mink, hamster, etc... could they tell the difference from a sample from a human?

If that virus went back, in short time, to a human from one of these mammals, could science tell us if it came from a human or other mammal?
 
I've just been reading a 26 February Nature summary about COVID-19's origins, and thought I'd share the conclusion.

https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-021-00502-4

To establish which animal passed the virus to people, researchers need to find evidence of the virus in that species. Researchers in China have tested some 30,000 wild, farmed and domestic animals in 2019 and 2020 but found no evidence of active or past SARS-CoV-2 infection, except in some cats in Wuhan in March 20205.

However, Ben Embarek says these surveys were not representative of China’s overall animal population, and that many more animals need to be tested for traces of infection, particularly on wildlife farms. “The amount of testing that’s been done is not sufficient to say, in any way, that wildlife farms were not carrying the virus,” says Daszak.

The explosive way in which the outbreak took off in Wuhan in December suggests that the virus was probably introduced once, through the wildlife trade, says Daszak. He says future testing should focus on farmed wild animals.
 
Wildlife farms are a viable place to look for the origin, Orphia. Thanks for the link.

I just did a cursory search for wildlife farms near Wuhan and it seems all the farms are in southern provinces. Pangolin farms are uncommon because they are hard to breed.

And referring to the seafood market in Wuhan continues after the idea has been discarded when cases unrelated to the market were found. The article in Nature notes it didn't seem to come from the market.
The intermediate animal that passed the virus from bats to people has not been identified, but researchers think it might be a wild species that is sold as food in ‘wet markets’, which typically sell live animals. Early in the pandemic, investigators homed in on the Huanan Seafood Market in Wuhan, because it sold fresh and frozen animals and many of the earliest infections were in people who had visited it. But the lead went cold when other early cases were found that were not associated with the market. Viral material was identified in drains and sewage at the market, but none was found on any animal carcasses.
I don't see anything saying the viral material was COVID. ???

Then it goes on describing the WHO investigators still focusing on the market.
The WHO team concluded that it’s most likely the virus jumped from live animals to people, but Ben Embarek says it is possible the virus entered the Huanan market through infected frozen wild animals from farms in southern China, and then sparked an outbreak. Daszak wonders whether frozen ferret-badgers sold at the market could have carried the virus. “These were carcasses skinned at the market, not just cubes of meat in a plastic packet,” he says.

Focus on farmed wild animals, focus on the market, anything except the lab. I doubt investigators are being given free reign to look at the virology lab.

If it truly was ruled out, meaning we can trust the researchers and the claims they tested all the lab workers and students for the virus was verified by WHO investigators, ..... to be continued.
 
Last edited:
I was looking for additional virology labs in Wuhan... I haven't found any yet but I thought there were some.

In the meantime there were a couple news stories with headlines blaming the lab. But they turned to be based on a Fox News report. Nuff said.

Then I found this: TaiwanNews Feb 23, 2021: German scientist says 99.9% chance coronavirus leaked from Wuhan lab - Year-long study of pandemic's origin concludes it started with 'laboratory accident' in Wuhan The Chinese embassy in Germany is having a cow over it. But here's what the researcher based his conclusion on.

A new study based on a year of research by a German physicist ...

Dr. Roland Wiesendanger, who specializes in nanoscience at the University of Hamburg, on Feb. 18 published a 105-page report on ReasearchGate titled "Study on the Origin of the Coronavirus Pandemic." The study was carried out from January to December 2020 based on scientific literature, print articles, online media, and correspondence with international researchers.

In his report, Wiesendanger listed six "significant indications" that the coronavirus pandemic started with a leak from the WIV....

His evidence:
No natural host found
Well-suited for hACE2 receptors
Wrong bats in Wuhan
History of making chimeras
Lax safety measures
Direct evidence of a lab leak​


Re the chimeras:
The scientist then mentioned that a research group, which is headed by Shi Zhengli (石正麗), also known as "Bat Woman," has since 2007 been researching how spike proteins in natural and chimeric SARS-like coronaviruses bind to the ACE2 receptors in the cells of humans, bats, and other animals. Wiesendanger alleged that the goal of this research is to make these viruses "more infectious, more dangerous, and more fatal."


Re the Direct indications of lab leak:
Wiesendanger then cites several incidents that are indicative of a lab accident, such as reports that a young researcher in the lab, identified as Huang Yanling, was allegedly "patient zero" and had disappeared after contracting the disease. The WIV and Chinese government have vehemently denied she was infected, but over a year later, her whereabouts are still unknown, and all information about her has been scrubbed from the WIV website.

He also touched on analysis by American intelligence agencies of a private report purporting to have found evidence of a "shutdown" and "hazardous event" allegedly taking place at the WIV in October 2019. More recently, on Jan. 15, the U.S. State Department released a report stating that several scientists inside the lab had become ill with "symptoms consistent with both COVID-19 and common seasonal illnesses" in the fall of 2019.

Unfortunately for that last bit we are stuck with the evidence having been found on Trump's watch making it unreliable.

There are other stories in the link that sound outrageous:
PLA experimented in Wuhan lab, covered up outbreak
2021/02/22 18:11
WHO inspector's 'natural hosts' experimented on in Wuhan lab
2021/02/20 17:59
WHO inspector's denial of bats in Wuhan lab contradicted by facts
2021/02/18 18:29
Vanished 150,000 elderly residents raise doubts about Wuhan's Covid death toll
2021/02/18 13:20

But I will take a look at them after I look for the original article published in Researchgate.
 
Oh darn, DW News discredits the study because they don't consider it an actual study, but DW is neutral on the hypothesis.

Google translated
The University of Hamburg is disseminating a professor's research that the coronavirus came from a laboratory in Wuhan. In the fact check you can read why the term "study" does not fit here and what problems the publication has....

... or it was caused by an accident at the Institute of Virology in the metropolis.

Roland Wiesendanger, professor at the University of Hamburg , supports the latter theory with his recently published "Study on the Origin of the Coronavirus Pandemic". Since, as he emphasizes in the text, there is no "scientifically based, strict evidence" for the theories about the origin of the coronavirus, he compiles evidence: on the basis of scientific articles, publications in the media and social networks and discussions with international scientists. Work on it ran throughout 2020.
I can't read the captions to the true/false meter but I am totally guessing that's what it is. If you move the needle it looks like vote tallies. Maybe people reading this thread speak German and can fill us in.

ETA Maybe the meter is a referendum on the web site.

One side says:
It's good. Citizens should be protected from misinformation.
And the other side says:
I see that critically. There can be no official truth by law.
Google translate leaves a lot to be desired.


Here's a link to the 105 page pdf but I don't know how to translate it. Does anyone else know?

scroll down to Studie zum Ursprung der Coronavirus-Pandemie


Edited to add from the Focus link:
Conclusion
The publication from Wiesendanger can be viewed as a search to collect possible evidence for the theory of the laboratory origin of Sars-CoV-2. We do not evaluate this theory and the quality of the evidence here. But the university professor did not adhere to some basic criteria of scientific work, so that the publication cannot be described as a study.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom