Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
There are a lot of possibilities. I just don't think it's CTish to not rule the lab out until the origin is definitively identified.

Not ruling it out, just suggesting an explanation for the earlier scattered infections (assuming they really were a form of covid).
 
I'm not sure how relevant this is, but when I was at Newark International airport in May last year, they kept playing an announcement from the mayor of Newark telling us that "this virus" came to the US from Europe (Italy presumably) and NOT China!

That may well be true, because there's a well-known link between Wuhan and Northern Italy, but I did wonder at the time why he felt the need to tell us that several times an hour. Also, it was apparently extremely racist to refer to the virus as Wuhan Flu, but I don't recall any complaints ever about e.g. Spanish Flu, Hong Kong Flu, Ebola, and Marburg.

It made me wonder just how much Chinese influence there is on our media.

I seem to recall that the actual infection path to the eastern US was from europe, whilst the west coast was infected from Asia.

As to calling it Wuhan flu, supposedly it's racist to blame China for the flu but the international media have no problem calling the infectious variants UK Variant, Brazil Variant, South Africa Variant etc. Eh, that's where they were identified, so what's the problem?

That said, I seem to recall there were fears of attacks on people of Chinese origin at the time.
 
Last edited:
Has that been narrowed down? I thought there were one or more possible animals besides the pangolin.

This isn't something I have followed closely for a while so there may be newer research but Covid-19 appears to have arisen from a recombination event involving a coronavirus that infects bats and one that infects Pangolins.

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7450963/

Most of the virus is closely related to the bat virus, however the spike structure of that virus is unlikely to infect humans. The spike protein of covid-19 is very closely related genetically and structurally to one found in Pangolins but the rest of the Pangolin virus is considerably more distant from Covid-19.

Pangolins were in the market where the first major outbreak started so the simplest answer is that's where the recombination occurred, and then it jumped to humans. There may be other potential places the recombination occurred but they appear more complicated and unlikely
 
So let's look at this: The WHO said so.
The one researcher in the SA article said so.

Have you seen anything else?

He is the WHO mission leader there. Peter Ben Embarek gave a pretty frank interview here in the link below, some highlights:

https://www.sciencemag.org/news/202...-chief-reflects-china-trip-seeking-covid-19-s

"Q: At Friday’s press conference in Geneva, Tedros seemed to contradict you by saying that with respect to the origins of SARS-CoV-2: “All hypotheses are on the table.” Was it a mistake to call the lab origin hypothesis “extremely unlikely”?

A: No. We first developed a pathway of all the possible ways the virus could be introduced into the human population in late 2019. A lab accident is one hypothesis, another is the direct introduction from an animal host, and the others are different versions of intermediary hosts.

For each hypothesis, we tried to put facts on the table, look at what we had in terms of arguments, and then make an assessment of each. It was already a big step to have Chinese colleagues assess and evaluate such a hypothesis based on what we had on the table, which was not much. Yes, lab accidents do happen around the world; they have happened in the past. The fact that several laboratories of relevance are in and around Wuhan, and are working with coronavirus, is another fact. Beyond that we didn’t have much in terms of looking at that hypothesis as a likely option."

"Q: But my question is whether you learned anything new in China. Now that you’ve been there, do you have more reason to say it’s “extremely unlikely” than before?

A: Yes. We had long meetings with the staff of the Wuhan Institute of Virology and three other laboratories in Wuhan. They talked about these claims openly. We discussed: What did you do over the past year to dismiss this claim? What did you yourself develop in terms of argumentations? Did you do audits yourself? Did you look at your records? Did you test your staff?

And they explained how they worked and what kind of audit system they had. They had retrospectively tested serum from their staff. They tested samples from early 2019 and from 2020. There were a lot of discussions that we could not have had if we had not traveled to Wuhan. We also did not have evidence provided by outsiders to support any of the claims out there. That could potentially have tipped the balance. What we saw and discussed gave us much more confidence in our assessment. The consensus was that this is an unlikely scenario."

"Q: Would it have been better to project less certainty at the press conference in Wuhan? The way most journalists understood it, the way I understood it, was that this has been ruled out.

A: Let me be clear on this: The fact that we assessed this hypothesis as extremely unlikely doesn’t mean it’s ruled out. … We also state in the report that all these hypothesis assessments will be reviewed on a regular basis. We may pick that one up again if new evidence comes up to make it more likely. It’s work in progress."
 
If I may, I assume you mean that was the main reason for the thread...

The main reason for the thread is to get it out of the main Covid thread.

I couldn't care less where it came from; it's of historical relevance only, while the Covid thread is about the ongoing pandemic and science related to it.
 
Edited by zooterkin: 
<SNIP>
Reply to off topic post removed.


Both the location and the intermediary animal are unknown. That it "probably crossed over to humans from bats" doesn't seem the exclude the Institute of Virology, since they were studying bat-derived coronaviruses there.
Except that same link that you snippeted from has the same scientists saying that this scenario was "extremely unlikely".
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Not ruling it out, just suggesting an explanation for the earlier scattered infections (assuming they really were a form of covid).

This:
Lplus said:
One might postulate that an earlier variant with much less transmissability occurred first - maybe starting closer to the bats - which only became more infectious after mutation in one of the human population of Wuhan?
Is speculation. That's fine.

This:
Lplus said:
an explanation for the earlier scattered infections (assuming they really were a form of covid
Says something different.

What earlier "scattered infections"? If you mean the cases they found in Aug, we don't know yet if those originated in Wuhan or "closer to the bats".
 
The first SARS outbreak was covered up by the Chinese government (or as Fox News likes to say, the CCP) until it was no longer possible to keep the world quiet about it.

Similar story in this outbreak. It was well known to virologists that SARS-like coronaviruses existed among the bat populations and probably other mammals in southern China and probably elsewhere at some level.

I won't rule out that it escaped from a lab but I don't see any good reason to favor that hypothesis and I don't see any reason to blame Bill Gates or invoke some cynical conspiracy theory about that. Researchers HAD to study SARS like they study any new and emerging disease and efforts were made shortly after the epidemic to do that.
 
Last edited:
This isn't something I have followed closely for a while so there may be newer research but Covid-19 appears to have arisen from a recombination event involving a coronavirus that infects bats and one that infects Pangolins.

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7450963/

Most of the virus is closely related to the bat virus, however the spike structure of that virus is unlikely to infect humans. The spike protein of covid-19 is very closely related genetically and structurally to one found in Pangolins but the rest of the Pangolin virus is considerably more distant from Covid-19.

Pangolins were in the market where the first major outbreak started so the simplest answer is that's where the recombination occurred, and then it jumped to humans. There may be other potential places the recombination occurred but they appear more complicated and unlikely
But keep in mind the wet market was not the original source of the pandemic.

Newsweek 04-27-20
In the early days, the prevailing theory of the virus' origins was that it, like SARS, arose in bats, passed to some other mammal such as a pangolin, and ultimately entered the population through the wild-animal markets. ...

The DIA report, however, cites U.S. government and Chinese researchers that found "about 33 percent of the original 41 identified cases did not have direct exposure" to the market. That, along with what's known of the laboratory's work in past few years, raised reasonable suspicion that the pandemic may have been caused by a lab error, not the wet market.


Sidenote:
This is no nefarious secret program in an underground military bunker. The Wuhan lab received funding, mostly for virus discovery, in part from a ten-year, $200 million international program called PREDICT, funded by the U.S. Agency for International Development and other countries.
Needed clarification because the issue of US funding the lab keeps coming up.


And this was an issue just as digging up samples of the 1918 flu virus from dead people buried in the permafrost was.
Some of this research involves taking deadly viruses and enhancing their ability to spread quickly through a population—research that took place over the objections of hundreds of scientists, who have warned for years of the program's potential to cause a pandemic.


A point I brought up earlier:
In the years since the SARS outbreak, many instances of mishaps involving the accidental release of pathogens have taken place in labs throughout the world. Hundreds of breaches have occurred in the U.S., including a 2014 release of anthrax from a U.S. government lab that exposed 84 people. The SARS virus escaped from a Beijing lab in 2004, causing four infections and one death. An accidental release is not complicated and doesn't require malicious intent. All it takes is for a lab worker to get sick, go home for the night, and unwittingly spread the virus to others.

And this should put an end to the argument the Wuhan lab was perfect:
The Wuhan Institute has a record of shoddy practices that could conceivably lead to an accidental release, as officials at the U.S. Embassy in Beijing reportedly warned in a cable on January 19, 2018. "During interactions with scientists at the WIV laboratory, they noted the new lab has a serious shortage of appropriately trained technicians and investigators needed to safely operate this high-containment laboratory," states the cable, according to the Washington Post.

There's a lot in this Newsweek article, more than usual for a news magazine. The whole next section is worth a read.


Moving on to this:
By the time the current pandemic hit, animal-passage experiments had become commonplace. Scientists in many of the more than 30 BSL-4 labs around the world had used them to enhance the transmissibility of respiratory-tract pathogens. ...

... The [Wuhan] Institute began a program of gain-of-function research into bat coronaviruses in 2015. ...

... The lab got its first BSL-4 lab in 2018, which is now considered a requirement for this kind of work (though some work proceeds in BSL-3-enhanced labs). It's possible that researchers started animal passage work in the BSL-4 lab but didn't finish it in time to publish before the current pandemic, when China tightened up on publications.
One argument against the lab origination source was that lab manipulation could be spotted genetically. But passing the virus through other animal species would not be visible.
 
He is the WHO mission leader there. Peter Ben Embarek gave a pretty frank interview here in the link below, some highlights:

https://www.sciencemag.org/news/202...-chief-reflects-china-trip-seeking-covid-19-s

"Q: At Friday’s press conference in Geneva, Tedros seemed to contradict you by saying that with respect to the origins of SARS-CoV-2: “All hypotheses are on the table.” Was it a mistake to call the lab origin hypothesis “extremely unlikely”?

A: No. We first developed a pathway of all the possible ways the virus could be introduced into the human population in late 2019. A lab accident is one hypothesis, another is the direct introduction from an animal host, and the others are different versions of intermediary hosts.

For each hypothesis, we tried to put facts on the table, look at what we had in terms of arguments, and then make an assessment of each. It was already a big step to have Chinese colleagues assess and evaluate such a hypothesis based on what we had on the table, which was not much. Yes, lab accidents do happen around the world; they have happened in the past. The fact that several laboratories of relevance are in and around Wuhan, and are working with coronavirus, is another fact. Beyond that we didn’t have much in terms of looking at that hypothesis as a likely option."

"Q: But my question is whether you learned anything new in China. Now that you’ve been there, do you have more reason to say it’s “extremely unlikely” than before?

A: Yes. We had long meetings with the staff of the Wuhan Institute of Virology and three other laboratories in Wuhan. They talked about these claims openly. We discussed: What did you do over the past year to dismiss this claim? What did you yourself develop in terms of argumentations? Did you do audits yourself? Did you look at your records? Did you test your staff?

And they explained how they worked and what kind of audit system they had. They had retrospectively tested serum from their staff. They tested samples from early 2019 and from 2020. There were a lot of discussions that we could not have had if we had not traveled to Wuhan. We also did not have evidence provided by outsiders to support any of the claims out there. That could potentially have tipped the balance. What we saw and discussed gave us much more confidence in our assessment. The consensus was that this is an unlikely scenario."

"Q: Would it have been better to project less certainty at the press conference in Wuhan? The way most journalists understood it, the way I understood it, was that this has been ruled out.

A: Let me be clear on this: The fact that we assessed this hypothesis as extremely unlikely doesn’t mean it’s ruled out. … We also state in the report that all these hypothesis assessments will be reviewed on a regular basis. We may pick that one up again if new evidence comes up to make it more likely. It’s work in progress."
I did not know there were other labs in the area.

An open discussion with the staff is not as strong given the Chinese culture of secrecy and face saving. But I'll put it up there with said researcher verified it wasn't close to the virus genomes they were working with. Reasonably strong but not conclusive evidence.

But I'd like it better had the WHO verified those serologies themselves.
 
Last edited:
If you mean the State Department page, monitoring for bioterrorism is clearly one of their functions. So you would expect that to be the focus. Doesn't mean the information on the page should be dismissed out of hand. I cited it because it was clearcut and easy to read, unlike my link in the last post and Chris H's link. Some of this stuff is more clear when it's in lay terms and not the genetic science terminology.



No, it doesn't. If this was BS manufactured by Trump it would not look this sophisticated. All that moron knows how to do is demonize China in a crude way. He certainly has not appointed scientists with actual expertise to investigate.

Going back to this webpage. It is from the State Department:

US politicians began spreading the conspiracy theories, including GOP Senators Tom Cotton, Josh Hawley and Marsha Blackburn especially President Donald Trump and Secretary of State Mike Pompeo.[

Look at the wording. Do you consider this to be "sophisticated"?

For more than a year, the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) has systematically prevented a transparent and thorough investigation of the COVID-19 pandemic’s origin, choosing instead to devote enormous resources to deceit and disinformation.

I don't think it was written by Trump, but it is totally Trumpian in its tone. Whoever wrote it probably did so with Mike Pompeo's guidance.

Okay, now, back to this....

1. Illnesses inside the Wuhan Institute of Virology (WIV):

The U.S. government has reason to believe that several researchers inside the WIV became sick in autumn 2019, before the first identified case of the outbreak, with symptoms consistent with both COVID-19 and common seasonal illnesses. This raises questions about the credibility of WIV senior researcher Shi Zhengli’s public claim that there was “zero infection” among the WIV’s staff and students of SARS-CoV-2 or SARS-related viruses.

Have you found anything more about this?
 
This isn't true. The intermediary is almost certainly a Pangolin. The spike protean for Covid-19 has characteristic who's only known natural counterpart is found in several Coronaviruses that infect Pangolins. It's not out of the question it exists elsewhere and we just haven't found it yet, but Pangolins as the intermediary fits everything else as well.

So the WHO is wrong?

https://www.webmd.com/lung/news/20210210/did-the-new-coronavirus-come-from-pangolins#1

Importantly here, we've shown two key things. Firstly, that this bat virus would unlikely be able to infect pangolins. And secondly, that a pangolin virus could potentially infect humans," Wrobel said in an institute news release.

So, it came straight from pangolins to humans then? (not from bats to pangolins to humans?)
 
So the WHO is wrong?

https://www.webmd.com/lung/news/20210210/did-the-new-coronavirus-come-from-pangolins#1



So, it came straight from pangolins to humans then? (not from bats to pangolins to humans?)

The bat virus is Covid-19's closest know relative, it's significantly more closely related to Covid-19 than the Pangolin virus. Only the spike protein came from the Pangolin virus.

It's possible the recombination event joined the two happened in yet another species, but given Pangolin's presence at the epicenter of the original outbreak the simplest solution is that it occurred in Pangolins. Either way Pangolins are involved because that is the apparent source of the spike protein.

Don't follow the red herring of reports that the Pangolin virus could jump directly to humans on it's own. Given that the spike protein in that virus does a good job or attaching to human ACE-2 receptors that was always likely to be the case.
 
Lots of people saw those planes with their own eyes, and we all saw it on TV.

It's in a whole different category of implausible. We know who the hijackers were. There's just overwhelming evidence of what actually happened there.

Here, they don't really have anything nailed down. They are even considering imported frozen food.

If "highly implausible" is part of the definition of "conspiracy theory" you're applying, then you're using it in the pejorative sense more than the descriptive sense. If you're using it in the pejorative, dismissve sense, then there's not much use in discussing the thing or having a forum area for it.

I think the descriptive sense of "conspiracy theory" simply requires that a theory heavily involves a significant number of people wielding power and working together in secret in a way that's contrary to their public statements.
 
Several off-topic posts moved to AAH.

There are other threads for discussing the general medical situation regarding Covid-19 or the political responses to it, and another for conspiracy theories.

For this thread to remain open, you need to confine your posts to discussing the origins of Covid-19.

Thank you.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: zooterkin
 
I think the only way they can 100% rule out the lab being the source is if they actually find the source of the outbreak.

Bit hard to 100% prove something didn't come from somewhere otherwise.
Genetic trail can lead to a conclusive source. It takes a while to test animal sources.

They can also get back to patient zero with a bit of detective work.

Doesn't mean that will happen.
 
Going back to this webpage. It is from the State Department:

Look at the wording. Do you consider this to be "sophisticated"?

I don't think it was written by Trump, but it is totally Trumpian in its tone. Whoever wrote it probably did so with Mike Pompeo's guidance.
That was typical state department wording in a public information page and like I said, one can ignore things that aren't relevant like the militarized stuff. Yes, I said this was during Trump's 4 years

Just use these sources as part of the whole. There are sources claiming it was the lab and other sources saying it wasn't. We don't have a definitive answer, IMO. Though there is some good evidence coming out in this thread that it wasn't the lab.

If you don't buy any information coming from the US defense agencies, can you believe anything coming from China? There are issues with both.

Okay, now, back to this....

Have you found anything more about this?
Not yet. There is the evidence posted elsewhere that through satellite images there was activity around the Wuhan hospital and an uptick of net searches for pneumonia and other related terms in August of 2019 suggesting COVID began spreading that month. The wet market was a super-spreader event but not the source.
 
Genetic trail can lead to a conclusive source. It takes a while to test animal sources.

They can also get back to patient zero with a bit of detective work.

Doesn't mean that will happen.

This has been achieved to a relatively high degree. It's possible there are still some missing steps, but what we already know is more than enough to say it's unlikely it would have been in a lab in the first place.

Covid-19 is very much a new virus. How would a lab even get hold of it before it started circulating? It's a very infectious virus that can infect many different animal species. I don't find it credible that it was just sitting around waiting for a laboratory to pick it up and study. It's infectious enough that it would have begun circulating widely among animals almost the moment it came into existence and found it's way into humans shortly after. If it were not so infectious than the "escaped from a lab" story wouldn't make sense either.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom