Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
If the natural mechanism of protein formation can't overcome the repulsive changes, then the virus can't replicate that protein when it infects a cell. In which case it can't function as a virus.
Having tried to google this a bit I realize that it may not be a question of whether the protein formation mechanism can produce them but whether mutations would be more likely to move away from those configurations rather than toward them. But I also realize I'm unlikely to find an answer to this via google with my level of understanding.
 
Is this verifiable? It seems like this point would be very persuasive in favor of recombination in nature so would lead to a greater consensus on this issue. I was under the impression this had been looked for and not found.

Yeah, it's verifiable. The elements are there and a lot of recombinant events take place in the bat population. Even the pangolin gene segment can be found in the horseshoe bats in Yunnan.

But the sequence all in one bat has not been found. That's my understanding of it anyway.

I'll hunt back in the thread for the citations.
 
Thanks very much. Hope you didn't do that on my account, I'm perfectly willing to traipse through the thread if I care enough.
 
OK here it is on page 4 and there's nothing new there, neither is there some post with me siding against Dalgleish. I don't see I even replied to that particular post but I didn't look past page 5.

Here's the quote from your citation:

From your link, so claims Mr Racaniello:We know that is bull ****. It's not impossible and that particular attitude is what Dalgleish alluded to when he said no one wanted to look at the lab accident hypothesis a year ago and they dismissed the paper out of hand.

This is how that is described in the Daily Mail:

I'm not claiming this paper is going to be the definitive smoking gun. I haven't even seen it yet. But I am interested in critiques of their work.

No, I don't think you replied to it, but I only remember the claims that were made.

I assume that these counterclaims remain as well:

"No scientist or group of scientists created this virus in a laboratory. That would require insight into [viral] pathogenesis and protein engineering that does not exist," said Robert Garry, Ph.D., virologist at Tulane University.

Garry explained that much of the genetic material of the virus that caused COVID-19 is similar to that found in viruses sampled from animals, and was unknown to science until after the pandemic, ruling out the possibility the virus was created beforehand in a lab.

The genetic material and genetic changes to the novel coronavirus are "all what you would expect from natural evolution and an animal source," said Amesh Adalja, MD, infectious disease fellow and senior scholar at Johns Hopkins Center for Health Security.

"There've been multiple rumors and conspiracy theories," he said. "And I do think you'll probably see more."

The thing is, whenever there are "made-in-a-lab" claims, you seem to think they are worth investigating. Whenever you find someone saying, "The virus wasn't made in a lab" you say, "Strawman! Nobody claims that! This is an attempt at misdirection because the claim is it escaped from a lab."

It seems to me that the virologists who dispute it are saying that a Gain of Function research cannot produce Covid-19, or at least not from known viruses such as RaTG13.

This means in order for the Gain of Function argument to work, it requires a virus we don't know about.

But then, if you claim that the virus we don't know about escaped from a lab after gain of function, then maybe we don't even need the gain of function part of the argument.

But then, gain of function isn't doing much work in the theory.... hmmm...
 
No, I don't think you replied to it, but I only remember the claims that were made.
Then go find it. Go to the link which you already got wrong claiming names had been said when they weren't. If you think I replied please post the quote or a link to the post.
I assume that these counterclaims remain as well:

The thing is, whenever there are "made-in-a-lab" claims, you seem to think they are worth investigating. Whenever you find someone saying, "The virus wasn't made in a lab" you say, "Strawman! Nobody claims that! This is an attempt at misdirection because the claim is it escaped from a lab."

It seems to me that the virologists who dispute it are saying that a Gain of Function research cannot produce Covid-19, or at least not from known viruses such as RaTG13.

This means in order for the Gain of Function argument to work, it requires a virus we don't know about.

But then, if you claim that the virus we don't know about escaped from a lab after gain of function, then maybe we don't even need the gain of function part of the argument.

But then, gain of function isn't doing much work in the theory.... hmmm...
Your memory is grossly inaccurate. Please quit making assertions about me without a quote. It's annoying.

And I don't know what you are on about with the GoF statements. Your post is confusing.
 
Last edited:
I never said you replied. In fact, I said the opposite.

So now you are playing games? You said:
The thing is, whenever there are "made-in-a-lab" claims, you seem to think they are worth investigating. Whenever you find someone saying, "The virus wasn't made in a lab" you say, "Strawman! Nobody claims that! This is an attempt at misdirection because the claim is it escaped from a lab."

Post a quote or stop with the false assertions, thank you.
 
Here is the abstract of the original paper by the Dalgliesh and Sorenson. There is also a third writer, Susrud, about their vaccine Biovacc-19.

This study presents the background, rationale and method of action of Biovacc-19, a candidate vaccine for corona virus disease 2019 (Covid-19), now in advanced preclinical development, which has already passed the first acute toxicity testing. Unlike conventionally developed vaccines, Biovacc-19’s method of operation is upon nonhuman-like (NHL) epitopes in 21.6% of the composition of severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2)’s spike protein, which displays distinct distributed charge including the presence of a charged furin-like cleavage site. The logic of the design of the vaccine is explained, which starts with empirical analysis of the aetiology of SARS-CoV-2. Mistaken assumptions about SARS-CoV-2’s aetiology risk creating ineffective or actively harmful vaccines, including the risk of antibody-dependent enhancement. Such problems in vaccine design are illustrated from past experience in the human immunodeficiency viruses domain. We propose that the dual effect general method of action of this chimeric virus’s spike, including receptor binding domain, includes membrane components other than the angiotensin-converting enzyme 2 receptor, which explains clinical evidence of its infectivity and pathogenicity. We show the nonreceptor dependent phagocytic general method of action to be specifically related to cumulative charge from insertions placed on the SARS-CoV-2 spike surface in positions to bind efficiently by salt bridge formations; and from blasting the spike we display the NHL epitopes from which Biovacc-19 has been down-selected.

https://www.researchgate.net/public..._its_General_Method_of_Action_for_Infectivity
 
Here is the abstract of the original paper by the Dalgliesh and Sorenson. There is also a third writer, Susrud, about their vaccine Biovacc-19.



https://www.researchgate.net/public..._its_General_Method_of_Action_for_Infectivity

Hmmm, I don't think that is peer-reviewed. Antibody-dependent enhancement has not been observed for COVID vaccines and is pretty much considered a non-issue.

"Gus" Dalgliesh is well known for discovering that CD4 is the receptor for HIV-1.
 

He is discussing the WHO's readiness to conduct follow-up missions. There was a follow planned for further investigating the frozen food chain as well. As I stated before, I have no particular objection to further investigation into these unlikely possibilities but the fact remains there is no supporting evidence for either hypothesis.

You said that we have an answer. Please indicate the timestamp in your video where they tell us what that answer is.

They did discuss their access to information on the mission early on, around the 11 min mark and say that they asked for a lot of information and were generally satisfied with what they were provided.

With most conspiracy theories no investigation is ever enough for those that buy into the conspiracy, and I expect that will be the case here. If the follow up mission to the lab happens the CT'ers will still find reasons to insist the investigation was inadequate.
 
Hmmm, I don't think that is peer-reviewed. Antibody-dependent enhancement has not been observed for COVID vaccines and is pretty much considered a non-issue.

"Gus" Dalgliesh is well known for discovering that CD4 is the receptor for HIV-1.

That is either an earlier abandoned paper or it is a pre-print.

Earlier there was a claim that they had not had their paper published because people thought the lab leak theory was a crackpot one. However, apparently they will now get something published.

I wonder how much will be the same.
 
Here you go, an article to be published in a couple of days has been previewed by the Daily Mail. You can get a head start dismissing their thesis. That it's in the Daily Mail with all the accompanying sensational language and that the thesis was rejected last year should give you all some ammo. :cool:

I was going to wait until the paper was published but the Daily Mail has quite a bit of it excerpted already. Scroll down to the actual paper excerpts. They are copy protected so I can't quote from the paper.

EXCLUSIVE: COVID-19 'has NO credible natural ancestor' and WAS created by Chinese scientists who then tried to cover their tracks with 'retro-engineering' to make it seem like it naturally arose from bats, explosive new study claims

I'm sure a number of people in this thread will see the bit about the claims being rejected earlier and dismiss the paper.

The 2 scientists have serious credentials and have authored or co-authored hundreds of papers published in scientific and medical journals.

PubMed: Dalgelish

Who are Angus Dalgleish and Birger Sørensen?


The lower level biosafety labs have been noted in citations in this thread.


I don't have any background in the paper's claim:
I understand the positive and negative charges, just not that amino acids have these charges. I'll look for more relevant information on that and await critique by contributors to the thread.


QRB Discovery to save people time looking for the paper when it's published.

This looks like just another rehash of speculation about the furin cleavage site. This was examined a year ago and found to be consistent a natural origin and inconsistent with a lab origin. Since then the evidence for it being natural has grown. It's discussed extensively around the 55 min mark of the TWiV podcast linked previously.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IxwrDSYrhjU&t=5527s

A few of the points made:
- no one would have thought to create a furin cleavage site this way unless they had already studied Covid-19
- There is regulatory RNA for the furin cleavage site no one would have thought to use unless they had already studied Covid-19
- Since it was studied in Covid-19 similar structures of various ranges of completeness and efficiency have been found in a wide range of corona viruses, including some of Covid-19's close relatives.
- It's not a full furin cleavage site. If someone was actually designing it they would have used a full furin cleavage site because that would bind even more efficiently than the structure that exists in Covid-19
- it's an example of un-intelligent design commonplace in evolution. there are other "mistakes" in the way the furin cleavage site is constructed that no competent designer would make.
 
Yeah, it's verifiable. The elements are there and a lot of recombinant events take place in the bat population. Even the pangolin gene segment can be found in the horseshoe bats in Yunnan.

Evidence?

There have been similar spike features found in a number of viruses, but this doesn't mean the genetic sequences are identical. The RNA from the Pangolin Sabercorona virus spike structure is 98% - 99% identical to Covid-19 so while the closest know, it's still possible something even closer may yet be found in bats.

The flip side, however is that RaTG13 is only 95% - 96% similar to Covid-19. If\when something closer is identified there is no guarantee it will be in a bat. A LOT of bat samples have been studied in comparison to other animals so the fact that the closest know relative was found in bats may just be a sampling issue.
 
You said we had an answer. You have not cited that answer.

I said the investigation team found no evidence and was satisfied with the information they provided and backed that up with comments provided by members of that investigation team.

You have had ample time to provide evidence for a lab leak and have failed to do so.

You have also had ample time to provide evidence for the conspiracy and cover-up the lab leak hypothesis is built on, and again you have failed to do so.

What it comes down to is that there IS no evidence to support either of these.
 
JFC you've provided evidence for the coverup. It was discussed in the video you presented.

And, pray tell, what am I supposed to be providing evidence for? And, what? Agreeing with Fauci makes me a conspiracy theorist now? Where the heck do you see anyone arguing for a conspiracy theory in this thread (I assume the off topic posts got moved to the correct thread).
 
Last edited:
You want evidence for coverup ? It happened in China. That's all you should need to know. Of course there was coverup. Even if the virus did not escape from the lab.
 
JFC you've provided evidence for the coverup. It was discussed in the video you presented.

In the mind of the conspiracy theorist every failure to find evidence for their pet theory is evidence someone is covering it up. This is the lifeblood of a CT.

And, pray tell, what am I supposed to be providing evidence for? And, what? Agreeing with Fauci makes me a conspiracy theorist now?

What makes you think you agree with Fauci? All he's said is that he's in favor of a follow-up investigation of the lab itself. I expect he's also in favor off a follow-up investigation into the possibility the virus emerged elsewhere and was carried to China on frozen food. Even if thinks that either of these things are extremely unlikely he's going to support follow-up to everything mentioned in the WHO report.

This is VERY different than suggesting either of these be considered legitimate possibilities at this point. Hell even I have said that I have no objection to further investigation of the lab and cold food chain, I just happen to think it's extremely unlikely any supporting evidence will ever be found.
Where the heck do you see anyone arguing for a conspiracy theory in this thread (I assume the off topic posts got moved to the correct thread).

Every version of the lab leak hypothesis requires numerous scientists to be actively participating in a cover-up. At a minimum it requires that scientists actively destroyed data and samples to hide the fact Covid-19 was in the lab. It also required scientists to be lying about illness within the lab, the work they were conducting, etc, etc, etc.

How many times have we seen Peter Daszak slandered in this very thread? The mans active field of research is the possibility of a pandemic coronavirus emerging in China. The "justification" for slandering him has been that most of the scientists working on this subject are Chinese and he's "suspect" simply because he works with these Chinese scientists.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom