Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
3 members of the team that produced the WHO report are interviewed here. They say it's not perfect or done the way they would do it personally but overall seem satisfied with the information and access they were provided

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d7kRxmEgzbQ&t=840s
Here's what Tedros has to say:

https://news.un.org/en/story/2021/03/1088702

You said that we have an answer. Please indicate the timestamp in your video where they tell us what that answer is.

ETA: The discussion of the lab investigation seems to be at the 50 minute mark in your video. It describes an interview not a full investigation. In any event, see my link for Tedros' opinion.
 
Last edited:
Here you go, an article to be published in a couple of days has been previewed by the Daily Mail. You can get a head start dismissing their thesis. That it's in the Daily Mail with all the accompanying sensational language and that the thesis was rejected last year should give you all some ammo. :cool:

I was going to wait until the paper was published but the Daily Mail has quite a bit of it excerpted already. Scroll down to the actual paper excerpts. They are copy protected so I can't quote from the paper.

EXCLUSIVE: COVID-19 'has NO credible natural ancestor' and WAS created by Chinese scientists who then tried to cover their tracks with 'retro-engineering' to make it seem like it naturally arose from bats, explosive new study claims
The paper's authors, British Professor Angus Dalgleish and Norwegian scientist Dr. Birger Sørensen, wrote that they have had 'prima facie evidence of retro-engineering in China' for a year - but were ignored by academics and major journals.

Dalgleish is a professor of oncology at St George's University, London, and is best known for his breakthrough creating the first working 'HIV vaccine', to treat diagnosed patients and allow them to go off medication for months.

Sørensen, a virologist, is chair of pharmaceutical company, Immunor, which developed a coronavirus vaccine candidate called Biovacc-19. Dalgleish also has share options in the firm.
I'm sure a number of people in this thread will see the bit about the claims being rejected earlier and dismiss the paper.

The 2 scientists have serious credentials and have authored or co-authored hundreds of papers published in scientific and medical journals.

PubMed: Dalgelish

Who are Angus Dalgleish and Birger Sørensen?


In the 22-page paper which has been submitted for publication in the scientific journal Quarterly Review of Biophysics Discovery, the scientists describe their months-long 'forensic analysis', looking back at experiments done at the Wuhan lab between 2002 and 2019.

Digging through archives of journals and databases, Dalgleish and Sørensen pieced together how Chinese scientists, some working in concert with American universities, allegedly built the tools to create the coronavirus.

Much of the work was centered around controversial 'Gain of Function' research – temporarily outlawed in the US under the Obama administration. ...

Dalgleish and Sørensen claim that scientists working on Gain of Function projects took a natural coronavirus 'backbone' found in Chinese cave bats and spliced onto it a new 'spike', turning it into the deadly and highly transmissible SARS-Cov-2. ...

But Sørensen said that he believes the virus escaped from lower security areas of the institute, where he believes Gain of Function research was performed.

'We have seen lab leaks and we know it's happening. We also know from the reports we've seen, that coronavirus is worked on in Biosafety Level 2 or 3 labs. If they do Gain of Function in such labs, what do you expect?' he said. ...
The lower level biosafety labs have been noted in citations in this thread.


I don't have any background in the paper's claim:
One tell-tale sign of alleged manipulation the two men highlighted was a row of four amino acids they found on the SARS-Cov-2 spike.

... Sørensen said the amino acids all have a positive charge, which cause the virus to tightly cling to the negatively charged parts of human cells like a magnet, and so become more infectious.

But because, like magnets, the positively charged amino acids repel each other, it is rare to find even three in a row in naturally occurring organisms, while four in a row is 'extremely unlikely,' the scientist said.

'The laws of physics mean that you cannot have four positively charged amino acids in a row. The only way you can get this is if you artificially manufacture it,' ...
I understand the positive and negative charges, just not that amino acids have these charges. I'll look for more relevant information on that and await critique by contributors to the thread.


QRB Discovery to save people time looking for the paper when it's published.
 
Here you go, an article to be published in a couple of days has been previewed by the Daily Mail. You can get a head start dismissing their thesis. That it's in the Daily Mail with all the accompanying sensational language and that the thesis was rejected last year should give you all some ammo. :cool:

I was going to wait until the paper was published but the Daily Mail has quite a bit of it excerpted already. Scroll down to the actual paper excerpts. They are copy protected so I can't quote from the paper.

EXCLUSIVE: COVID-19 'has NO credible natural ancestor' and WAS created by Chinese scientists who then tried to cover their tracks with 'retro-engineering' to make it seem like it naturally arose from bats, explosive new study claims

I'm sure a number of people in this thread will see the bit about the claims being rejected earlier and dismiss the paper.

The 2 scientists have serious credentials and have authored or co-authored hundreds of papers published in scientific and medical journals.

PubMed: Dalgelish

Who are Angus Dalgleish and Birger Sørensen?


The lower level biosafety labs have been noted in citations in this thread.


I don't have any background in the paper's claim:
I understand the positive and negative charges, just not that amino acids have these charges. I'll look for more relevant information on that and await critique by contributors to the thread.


QRB Discovery to save people time looking for the paper when it's published.

We went over this one way back.

Remember that YOU also reject the idea it was a bio weapon which is claimed by them.

They said at the time that any attempts to make a vaccine will fail because of the nature of the virus.

Then, guess what? They said they had made their own vaccine (hmmmm, sounds a bit Andrew Wakefield-esque to me).

Maybe if you search the thread for the names or their attempt at a vaccine you might find the discussion.
 
The search terms below don't return any results:
Angus Dalgleish Birger Sørensen +site:internationalskeptics.com
And I can't find them connected to bioweapon claims anywhere.
 
We went over this one way back.

Remember that YOU also reject the idea it was a bio weapon which is claimed by them.
How did we go over it when it hasn't been published yet?

I was not convinced the military was involved when more than a few scientists said the virus had no obviously inserted segments that demonstrated it was straight-on manufactured. The debate on that matter was that the virus was not built as a bioweapon. And it was pointed out how stupid it would be for the Chinese to have released this on their own population.

This is not that argument.

They said at the time that any attempts to make a vaccine will fail because of the nature of the virus.
I vaguely remember something like that but you are mistaken it was about this research.

A search for Dalgleish in this thread turns up nothing. I see from a broader search Dalgleish was mentioned in the CT thread so clearly I had not discussed his work.

And reviewing that thread I see Bubba posted a reference to a Newsmax article on Dalgleish that was only published on May 29th so you must be thinking of something else. Bubba's link is to the same DailyMail story repackaged for Newsmax.

Then, guess what? They said they had made their own vaccine (hmmmm, sounds a bit Andrew Wakefield-esque to me).

Maybe if you search the thread for the names or their attempt at a vaccine you might find the discussion.
I did, see above.

No, these guys are not like Wakefield but that is the kind of mindless critique I expect to see in reply to this paper.:rolleyes:
 
This part seems like a strange claim:

But because, like magnets, the positively charged amino acids repel each other, it is rare to find even three in a row in naturally occurring organisms, while four in a row is 'extremely unlikely,' the scientist said.

'The laws of physics mean that you cannot have four positively charged amino acids in a row. The only way you can get this is if you artificially manufacture it,' ...


If the laws of physics prevented that sequence of amino acids from replicating in cells (as opposed to some implied "artificial manufacturing" process) then the virus would be non-viable in that form. If it can replicate in cells, it can evolve into that sequence.
 
This part seems like a strange claim:

If the laws of physics prevented that sequence of amino acids from replicating in cells (as opposed to some implied "artificial manufacturing" process) then the virus would be non-viable in that form. If it can replicate in cells, it can evolve into that sequence.
Meh. Hard to tell if those are Dalgleish's words or the reporter's or Dalgleish's dumbing the explanation down for the reporter or only meant naturally occurring.
 
This part seems like a strange claim:

If the laws of physics prevented that sequence of amino acids from replicating in cells (as opposed to some implied "artificial manufacturing" process) then the virus would be non-viable in that form. If it can replicate in cells, it can evolve into that sequence.
Since the sentence immediately prior to that says it more accurately but less understandably I thought he was probably just trying to dumb it down for his audience.
 
How did we go over it when it hasn't been published yet?

I was not convinced the military was involved when more than a few scientists said the virus had no obviously inserted segments that demonstrated it was straight-on manufactured. The debate on that matter was that the virus was not built as a bioweapon. And it was pointed out how stupid it would be for the Chinese to have released this on their own population.

This is not that argument.

I vaguely remember something like that but you are mistaken it was about this research.

A search for Dalgleish in this thread turns up nothing. I see from a broader search Dalgleish was mentioned in the CT thread so clearly I had not discussed his work.

And reviewing that thread I see Bubba posted a reference to a Newsmax article on Dalgleish that was only published on May 29th so you must be thinking of something else. Bubba's link is to the same DailyMail story repackaged for Newsmax.

I did, see above.

No, these guys are not like Wakefield but that is the kind of mindless critique I expect to see in reply to this paper.:rolleyes:

The claims they made were posted in this thread a while back. The paper might be new but their claims are not. They may have repackaged them just like the “sick scientists” has been reheated.

And you are not acknowledging their conflict of interest! ;)
 
The claims they made were posted in this thread a while back. The paper might be new but their claims are not. They may have repackaged them just like the “sick scientists” has been reheated.

And you are not acknowledging their conflict of interest! ;)

You're welcome to look for it. I couldn't find it and neither could RY.

And how can I know if there is a conflict of interest without seeing the paper?

And the ill scientists is not analogous to this. Honestly your analogy meter is busted or something.
 
Last edited:
OK here it is on page 4 and there's nothing new there, neither is there some post with me siding against Dalgleish. I don't see I even replied to that particular post but I didn't look past page 5.

Here's the quote from your citation:
The British/Norwegian team -- also working on a vaccine -- argued that their vaccine approach was likely to work where other existing efforts would fail. They claim the virus' RNA sequence has elements that appear man-made, or artificially inserted, and that their vaccine, Biovacc-19, will take these purported elements into account.

From your link, so claims Mr Racaniello:
"It is absolutely 100% impossible that SARS-CoV-2 was made in a laboratory. The elements in the virus, SARS-CoV-2, all came from bat SARS-like CoVs that circulate in nature," Racaniello told ABC News.
We know that is bull ****. It's not impossible and that particular attitude is what Dalgleish alluded to when he said no one wanted to look at the lab accident hypothesis a year ago and they dismissed the paper out of hand.

This is how that is described in the Daily Mail:
They said they tried to publish their findings but were rejected by major scientific journals which were at the time resolute that the virus jumped naturally from bats or other animals to humans.

Even when former MI6 chief Sir Richard Dearlove spoke out publicly saying the scientists' theory should be investigated, the idea was dismissed as 'fake news.'

Over a year later, leading academics, politicians and the media finally flipped, and have begun to contemplate the possibility that COVID-19 escaped from the Wuhan Institute of Virology in China - a lab where experiments included manipulating viruses to increase their infectiousness in order to study their potential effects on humans.

I'm not claiming this paper is going to be the definitive smoking gun. I haven't even seen it yet. But I am interested in critiques of their work.
 
I searched this thread for "Angus", "Dalg", "Birger", and "rensen". First appearance is today.
We couldn't find it because the names aren't mentioned. :rolleyes:

They are referred to as a Norwegian and a British researcher. I found it using a search string "a vaccine will fail" or something like that now I can't remember which section of the sentence I used.
 
Since the sentence immediately prior to that says it more accurately but less understandably I thought he was probably just trying to dumb it down for his audience.


The prior sentence seems just as illogical. If a chain of four positive charges provides an advantage to this organism i.e. improved infectiousness in a crossover species (which seems to be part of their whole point), and doesn't prevent the protein from forming (which it obviously doesn't), why would the fact (if it is indeed a fact) that it's rare elsewhere in nature matter? What would prevent evolution from, say, two consecutive positive charges to three to four?

I think the lab leak hypothesis should be seriously considered and thoroughly investigated, but for this particular claim, either both of the reported phrasings have garbled the point, or that particular point doesn't make much sense.
 
The prior sentence seems just as illogical. If a chain of four positive charges provides an advantage to this organism i.e. improved infectiousness in a crossover species (which seems to be part of their whole point), and doesn't prevent the protein from forming (which it obviously doesn't), why would the fact (if it is indeed a fact) that it's rare elsewhere in nature matter? What would prevent evolution from, say, two consecutive positive charges to three to four?
If the natural mechanism of protein formation can't overcome the repulsive charges but artificial mechanisms can then the statement makes sense. I have no idea if that's true though.
 
If the natural mechanism of protein formation can't overcome the repulsive charges but artificial mechanisms can then the statement makes sense. I have no idea if that's true though.


If the natural mechanism of protein formation can't overcome the repulsive changes, then the virus can't replicate that protein when it infects a cell. In which case it can't function as a virus.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom