Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
Why do you need an interpretation of how Daszak was misunderstood when you can watch him for yourself?

It's not "interpretation". He was interviewing Daszak in the video you are telling people to watch. In the video angrysoba linked he explains exactly what he and Daszak were discussing and how that discussion is being misinterpreted by people like you.
 
And perhaps you missed the answer because it was within a muddle of answers:

There is no "single" piece. It is an assessment of many many pieces.

Then list multiple pieces of evidence supporting the lab leak hypothesis.

Again though, "it's possible" isn't evidence for a hypothesis, it's just a restatement of the hypothesis. Give us evidence that it did happen, not just another batch of hand-waving on how "it could have happened".
 
It's not "interpretation". He was interviewing Daszak in the video you are telling people to watch. In the video angrysoba linked he explains exactly what he and Daszak were discussing and how that discussion is being misinterpreted by people like you.
:rolleyes:

It's not hard to understand the interview. The interview sounds great, all the things EcoHealth has done and is doing and the reason behind whatever. So the fact the podcast group exonerates the Daszak interview makes sense when you take the interview as a whole.

It's only the key part, from minute 27.5 to ~31 where anything of significance to this thread is mentioned. That's where Daszak gets to the wildlife market risks. He notes SARS came from bats and they found over 100 new SARS-related coronaviruses in bats in Yunnan.

"Some of them get into human cells in the lab" Daszak's own words. "Some of them can cause SARS disease in humanized mouse models."

From there Daszak explains what they are trying to do with this research and there is nothing about what he says that sounds reckless. It makes sense they are trying to reduce the number of spillover events.

It's no wonder the podcast group thinks that's all peachy keen and lay people just don't get it.

This week in virology

The point about the interview are just those key comments, they are experimenting with cultures in the lab, ie live virus, and they are infecting humanized mice meaning mice with human cells.
 
Last edited:
We did and found nothing. I have no particular objection to further investigation but unless there is some dramatic new information we have our answer.
"We?"

You mean the WHO investigation which currently more than a few experts in the field do not believe was adequate?
 
Then list multiple pieces of evidence supporting the lab leak hypothesis.

Again though, "it's possible" isn't evidence for a hypothesis, it's just a restatement of the hypothesis. Give us evidence that it did happen, not just another batch of hand-waving on how "it could have happened".

I'm not going to review the thread for you.
 
It's not hard to understand the interview.

And yet according to the person who conducted the interview you are grossly misconstruing the discussion.

"We?"

You mean the WHO investigation which currently more than a few experts in the field do not believe was adequate?

If the WHO doesn't qualify as "we" who would? (no pun intended)

Are you expecting to be granted personal access to conduct your own investigation? Are you demanding an investigation be conducted by people who already agree with your conclusion? Are you saying you'll only accept an investigation that gives you the result you want?

I'm not going to review the thread for you.

Evasion noted
 
We did and found nothing. I have no particular objection to further investigation but unless there is some dramatic new information we have our answer.
Who is "we"? The WHO? Tedros himself says the team that investigated WIV (and elsewhere) didn't get access to the right data and didn't include the proper specialists. And for crying out loud we do not have our answer.
 
And yet according to the person who conducted the interview you are grossly misconstruing the discussion. ...
See, right here you completely ignored my post and continued commenting as if I hadn't said anything. :rolleyes:

To review, this is the only relevant part of the Daszak interview:

"Some of them get into human cells in the lab" Daszak's own words. "Some of them can cause SARS disease in humanized mouse models."

That was the only thing in that interview it was cited for.

Did your podcast group address the fact Daszak admitted they were working with live coronavirus adapted to human cells at the WIV?

Have we seen these strains of coronavirus the lab claims bore no resemblance to COVID 19 yet could infect human cells? I'm guessing no we have not.


21 pages full of material and you clam, "Evasion noted". Right.
 
Last edited:
What the telegraph article states is not that the 2008 research was with a precursor to COVID 19, it states:And no, I had not looked at the 2008 study though your link is very interesting. I did read a reference to the 2010 paper but I don't believe I linked to it here.



More recently was the US withdrawing financial support for the GoF research at the WIV after determining the research was too dangerous.

I posted this upthread and I am aware of the editor's note they added contemporarily: Nature 2015: Engineered bat virus stirs debate over risky research There's a lot more in the thread about the potential for the coronavirus in bats to jump directly to humans including the case of the 6 miners in Yunnan who were infected after working around bats in the caves there. 3 died.

And it is still high on the differential that students and/or researchers brought one of these coronaviruses back after a field trip to those caves. The pictures of them collecting specimens from the bats is appalling from an infection preventionist (infection control) POV. There's a link here somewhere to those images. What that suggested to me and what I believe is probably occurring in the WIV but also elsewhere in other labs is a sense the danger is disregarded to a large extent.

There is also a link to the kind of live cultures they were using in their experiments with the coronaviruses they collected from the horseshoe bats in Yunnan.

Quoted in post # 229

2017: Discovery of a rich gene pool of bat SARS-related coronaviruses provides new insights into the origin of SARS coronavirus

I don't know the kind of lab you work in but if it is like what I see in my healthcare field, people are not meticulous around dangerous pathogens when they should be. The link a couple pages back (a very long post) to all the previous lab accidents and near misses is an example of what I am talking about.

I listened to less than a minute of the podcast recently posted but from what I saw they had the same attitude. A cavalier attitude about dangerous work is not confined to handling dangerous pathogens.


i work in high containment labs. Definitely not cavalier. We are regularly inspected by the Health and Safety Executive .


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
 
i work in high containment labs. Definitely not cavalier. We are regularly inspected by the Health and Safety Executive .
Good to know. I have lots of horror stories where that wasn't the case.

When we had the anthrax scare a decade or so ago, I was called to help a number of clients with related issues. One was to a security company the local mall used that had found some white powder in an envelope on a bench in the mall. Instead of calling in the hazmat team like they should have, it ended up in the trash compactor and a number of employees had handled it. Fortunately it wasn't anthrax.

The mistakes that happened with SARS were mind boggling. Most of those I read about in the Promed news feed. For example India would claim temperature monitoring was going on at all the international airports and someone who actually went through one of these airports said there was no monitoring at all, no one even asked them any questions about symptoms.

One of the physicians at a hospital in HongKong took care of SARS patients, developed a fever and still went on vacation to Tokyo Disneyland.

And last year when the pandemic started the first patient came here from Wuhan, China and developed symptoms. He ended up in a hospital a little north of here. Things were handled properly to a point. But the public health failed to do any contact tracing of patients on the plane or in the airport. They only looked at his close contacts just before he was hospitalized.

Granted we didn't have a lot of information then about the incubation period and contagiousness prior to symptoms. But no one knew that wasn't an issue either. By the time anyone realized it, the virus was spreading all over the county. It was too widespread to do any contact tracing.


30+ years and many examples like those it should be clear why that article on past level 4 pathogens lab mishaps was no surprise to me.

Some of these kinds of errors at the WIV have been cited in this thread. Some occurred when the WIV only had a level 2 biosafety lab. And when they did open the level 4 lab there's a link here to a complaint not enough staff were trained to work there.

Of course the Chinese government response was/is to say they have a perfect lab and perfect procedures and could have done no wrong. I am not reassured by that.
 
Last edited:
Who is "we"? The WHO? Tedros himself says the team that investigated WIV (and elsewhere) didn't get access to the right data and didn't include the proper specialists. And for crying out loud we do not have our answer.

The people who performed the investigation seem to be satisfied with the access and data.
 
See, right here you completely ignored my post and continued commenting as if I hadn't said anything. :rolleyes:

To review, this is the only relevant part of the Daszak interview:

Again, the people directly involved in the conversation have said that your interpretation is out of context and flat out wrong.
 
The people who performed the investigation seem to be satisfied with the access and data.
No they ******* aren't. What the hell is the matter with you? They said they didn't have the access they needed or the right skill set.
 
Starting to see a pattern here. You seem to have an issue with people not being entirely aligned with you, even those who actually agree with you.
He doesn't agree with me and he is lying big time. We absolutely do not have an answer in any sense at all and the investigators themselves said they are "not satisfied" in multiple ways with their report. It is simply a huge lie to say we have an answer on this subject or that the investigators themselves are satisfied. It's a filthy lie.
 
Starting to see a pattern here. You seem to have an issue with people not being entirely aligned with you, even those who actually agree with you.

Projection:
Psychology.
the tendency to ascribe to another person feelings, thoughts, or attitudes present in oneself, or to regard external reality as embodying such feelings, thoughts, etc., in some way.
 
He doesn't agree with me and he is lying big time. We absolutely do not have an answer in any sense at all and the investigators themselves said they are "not satisfied" in multiple ways with their report. It is simply a huge lie to say we have an answer on this subject or that the investigators themselves are satisfied. It's a filthy lie.

3 members of the team that produced the WHO report are interviewed here. They say it's not perfect or done the way they would do it personally but overall seem satisfied with the information and access they were provided

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d7kRxmEgzbQ&t=840s
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom