Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
GENEVA (AP) — A team of international and Chinese scientists is poised to report on its joint search for the origins of the coronavirus that sparked a pandemic after it was first detected in China over a year ago — with four theories being considered, and one the clear frontrunner, according to experts.

...

Team member Vladimir Dedkov, an epidemiologist and deputy director of research at the St. Petersburg Pasteur Institute in Russia, summarized the four main leads first laid out at a marathon news conference in China last month about the suspected origins of the first infection in humans. They were, in order of likelihood: from a bat through an intermediary animal; straight from a bat; via contaminated frozen food products; from a leak from a laboratory like the Wuhan Institute of Virology.

Link
 
but who is "they " ?
WIV ? Hubei ? Beijing ?
Remember, the top Hubei politicians were fired by Beijing for
early Jan-2020-coverup .
Remember the Shi-interview, how she couldn't speep and was relieved when the
sequences came out.
Remember the early papers, the WHO-mission in Feb.2020
Then the appointment of Zong Nanshan (SARS1) as a demonstration of new
openness and transpartency.
Then the Xi Jinping speach to the world and the declared new openness.

This doesn't make sense, if they(Beijing) knew about a lab-connection
(at that time) and wanted to cover it up
 
Last edited:
but who is "they " ?
WIV ? Hubei ? Beijing ?
Remember, the top Hubei politicians were fired by Beijing for
early Jan-2020-coverup .
Remember the Shi-interview, how she couldn't speep and was relieved when the
sequences came out.
Remember the early papers, the WHO-mission in Feb.2020
Then the appointment of Zong Nanshan (SARS1) as a demonstration of new
openness and transpartency.
Then the Xi Jinping speach to the world and the declared new openness.

This doesn't make sense, if they(Beijing) knew about a lab-connection
(at that time) and wanted to cover it up

As you say - IF. That's the operative word here.
 
For better or worse, here is the report...
{URL deleted}
Okay, so I did not know this bit....

---------------------
I remember they talked about it in spring 2020 . Only 300m,
much closer than the WIV. But they didn't do the bat-experiments there,
those were done in Beijing , so people lost interest in CCDC (afair)

Andersen twitter-thread :
[search for it, I'm not allowed to post links/urls)
@K_G_Andersen
 
---------------------
I remember they talked about it in spring 2020 . Only 300m,
much closer than the WIV. But they didn't do the bat-experiments there,
those were done in Beijing , so people lost interest in CCDC (afair)

Andersen twitter-thread :
[search for it, I'm not allowed to post links/urls)
@K_G_Andersen

Okay, thanks. I'll try to find it.

I suppose the point is that there are actually a number of labs throughout China doing research on SARSr coronaviruses, as well as further afield. Perhaps saying, "Ah, look, the Wuhan Institute of Virology is here in Wuhan" as being a coincidence is just a case of the sharpshooter fallacy. If Covid-19 had been found in Beijing or Guilin, maybe the same questions could have been raised about how it was a coincidence that people were doing virus research there.

Anyway, in the meantime, this is from TWiV. They talk a little about the findings of the report and address the different possibilities of lab escape. Of course, there are strong and weak versions of this theory.

The Strong Version is that it was engineered there, maybe through gain-of-function or something along those lines.

The Weak Version is that somehow it got out on someone's clothes or something like that.

I suppose the inbetween ones are that they had found it, sequenced it and put it on the database, then took it down when they feared it got loose and some lab people got sick, and then tried to cover it up, but failed, and since then they have been stone-walling and got Peter Daszak and some others in to help cover it up for them.

The virologists on TWiV and, I would say most around the world, seem to give this a low probability and say so on this podcast. Vincent Racaniello does say he has been trying to get Daszak on his show to talk about it, but Daszak hasn't replied.

https://youtu.be/LqGPuFoYiNY?t=3935
 
So Vincent Racaniello was on one of his Q&As and is asked about the origins of Covid. Obviously he doesn't know but sketches a plausible way in which it may have spiller over. In his answer he also mentions that Peter Daszak and two others from the WHO study on the origins of Covid will be appearing on TWiV:

https://youtu.be/6TLXKkHr1C4?t=3038
 
A new article strongly suggesting that the origin might be a Chinese lab. No idea how legit it is, but it is a scientific article;

On the Origin of SARS-CoV-2: Did Cell Culture Experiments Lead to Increased Virulence of the Progenitor Virus for Humans?
BERND KAINA
In Vivo May 2021, 35 (3) 1313-1326; DOI: https://doi.org/10.21873/invivo.12384
 
A new article strongly suggesting that the origin might be a Chinese lab. No idea how legit it is, but it is a scientific article;

On the Origin of SARS-CoV-2: Did Cell Culture Experiments Lead to Increased Virulence of the Progenitor Virus for Humans?
BERND KAINA
In Vivo May 2021, 35 (3) 1313-1326; DOI: https://doi.org/10.21873/invivo.12384

It puts together the evidence we've posted here with some additions.
The presence of a human sequence in SARS-CoV-2 supports the hypothesis that the progenitor was propagated in human cells where it gained the sequence by a recombination event. ...

The presence of a human sequence in SARS-CoV-2 supports the hypothesis that the progenitor was propagated in human cells where it gained the sequence by a recombination event. ...

d) The presence of a human sequence in the virus genome (40) strongly indicates that SARS-CoV-2 was propagated in human cells before it caused the pandemic.

The Chinese may have covered their recent tracks, there are a number of relevant papers published from the Wuhan research that cannot be taken back or covered up.

The pangolin doesn't look like the intermediator when one considers:
Pangolins have a low rate of reproduction, which would probably have been zero at the Huanan wildlife market in Wuhan, if they were offered there. As a selection medium for adaptation to humans, pangolins (or similar exotic animals) are therefore not likely to be a particularly good choice for the virus.

In view of this, primary infection from animals on the wildlife market is unlikely to have happend. One could also speculate that house cats from families of asymptomatic infected people were the intermediate host.


All in all, an excellent synopsis with well supported evidence of the lab error hypothesis.
 
A new article strongly suggesting that the origin might be a Chinese lab. No idea how legit it is, but it is a scientific article;

On the Origin of SARS-CoV-2: Did Cell Culture Experiments Lead to Increased Virulence of the Progenitor Virus for Humans?
BERND KAINA
In Vivo May 2021, 35 (3) 1313-1326; DOI: https://doi.org/10.21873/invivo.12384

Very informative, but the conclusion:

Even though evidence is lacking that the virus was intentionally genetically engineered, the possibility that the virus could have emerged unintentionally through laboratory experiments should lead to a rethinking of the need for gain-of-function experiments aimed at enhancing the pathogenicity of a disease-causing agent.

doesn't advance the theory beyond possibilities.

One thing did stand out for me - in the piece, Bernd says:

Another possibility to be considered is that there was no intermediate animal host, but natural selection took place in humans directly. The predecessor of SARS-CoV-2 would therefore have jumped directly from the bat into humans (e.g. by inhaling dust or droplets/aerosols exhaled by bats, from which SL-CoVs were isolated, or when hunting and preparing the animals for consumption) and initially there would have been an undetected human-to-human transmission. The virulence was initially very low, but increased over time when the furin cleavage site and other supportive mutations were gained. In this scenario, selection took place in humans until the insertion of the furin cleavage site was perfect. Thus, the virus gained the property to be efficiently propagated in humans and clusters of infection were formed due to high infectivity, which allowed the virus to survive evolutionarily. This scenario assumes that there was a period of undetected infection and transmission even before the furin cleavage site was incorporated into the viral genome.

That could explain the plethora of results that apparently show Covid infections prior to December 2019.
 
Of course they are going to use the term 'possibility'. :rolleyes:

Tell us TA, which hypothesis/theory do you think the evidence favors?

And have you put the pangolin speculation to rest yet?
 
Tell us TA, which hypothesis/theory do you think the evidence favors?

I don't think the evidence we have so far favours any of them.

Given the fact that SARS, MERS, Ebola and other coronaviruses have happened naturally, I think natural transmission is still the warm favourite.
 
I don't think the evidence we have so far favours any of them.

Given the fact that SARS, MERS, Ebola and other coronaviruses have happened naturally, I think natural transmission is still the warm favourite.

By that standard, lab leaks have happened before.
 
---------------------
I remember they talked about it in spring 2020 . Only 300m,
much closer than the WIV. But they didn't do the bat-experiments there,
those were done in Beijing
, so people lost interest in CCDC (afair)

I wondered about the claims about live bats in Wuhan and asked in here some time ago for decent proof of it, to no avail. Today, I looked further into it.
There actually is clear evidence bats were kept in the Wuhan lab and had been experimented on there for many years.

Taiwan News has a good article citing the evidence, some of which can only be seen on Internet Archive now. I've posted the main ones below...


Peter Daszak tweeted Dec 10, 2020 (now deleted)(archive link):

1613636912-602e253041ba0.jpg

1613638175-602e2a1f2496f.jpg

---------------------------------------------------
This is from a human-interest piece done on Shi done in March 2009 (archived/translated):

Like many scientists, Shi Zhengli is very low-key whether she is doing things or being a person. In February of this year, when the reporter learned that the research team led by her first discovered the presence of Nipah virus antibodies in bats in mainland China, they contacted her for an interview and was declined. The reporter had to take the liberty to come to her research group. Unexpectedly, her assistant told the reporter: "Mr. Shi is on a business trip to Beijing." The reporter simply started talking with her assistant and colleagues.

(snip)....

In the eyes of colleagues, Shi Zhengli's life is very frugal. If you don't travel on business, you can basically see her in the office or laboratory.

Zhang Huajun said: “The research team captured a few bats from the wild to be used as experimental animals. They need to be fed every day. This Spring Festival, the students went home for a holiday, and Teacher Shi silently undertook the task of raising bats. No one knows until now.
--------------------------------------------------

From page 12 of a "Meeting Report" (pdf) following a China-US Emerging Infections Workshop held in China, May 2017

(Shi is "bat woman" but here is referred to as "he"...then again, it's a Chinese translation.)
Zhengli Shi (Principal Investigator, Wuhan Institute of Virology, CAS) spoke about the evolution and pathogenesis of bat SARS like coronavirus (SL CoV). Shi is working on corona virus and other emerging infections and said that bat SL CoV could be the next pandemic. He described the cases and countries involved in the 2003 SARs outbreak. For bat corona virus to cause the next SL CoV outbreak many factors will have to be involved. His research looks at the pathogenesis of SL CoV in transgenic mice. It replicates very well in mice and human tissue. The virus can easily enter human cells but in the animal model the virus has less pathogenesis; this is good news.
His research shows that some bat SL CoVs have potential interspecies transmission to other animals and humans.

An audience member asked if one could clear an infected bat of this virus? Zhengli said that he tried this with Nipah virus in bats and bats could produce antibodies, clear within seven days. In nature we found that bats produce antibodies to some viruses but not all. SL CoV can exist in bats for several months. An audience member said that you cannot be sure that this pathogen willcause human disease and that more data are needed. Right now infections are very mild and there is no clinical syndrome. Further studies are needed.
---------------------------------------------------

Taiwan News also refers to a Sixth Tone article published in May 2018 called: How China’s Bat Caves Hold the Secret to Preventing Epidemics

Luo’s supervisor Shi Zhengli, has been studying bat-borne viruses since 2004. Luo and his fellow researchers’ Hubei expedition is but one leg of a regular sampling tour that takes them from the Tibetan highlands to the southern coast.
...
PREDICT, an international project run by the U.S.-based nonprofit EcoHealth Alliance (Daszak's company) that also sponsors some of the WIV’s work, aims to detect newly discovered viruses and map epidemic hot spots across more than 30 countries.

By 8:30 p.m., Luo’s team has collected a full rack of swabs and bagged a dozen live bats for further testing back at the lab. Luo hopes that this time, the results will come out differently. His colleague points out a firefly bobbing up and down in the pitch-black cave. “It might be a good omen,” Luo says with a smile.
-------------------------------------------------

Here is an archived description of the Wuhan lab:
The facility has 126 cages for Japanese white rabbits, 340 cages for SD and Wistar rats, inbred strains, closed groups, mutant strains, and genetically engineered mice. There are 3268 cages, 12 ferrets, 12 bats, and 2 species of cotton bollworm and beet armyworm, totaling 52 strains.

Each cage holds multiple bats according to their 2018 patent application:

Current Assignee: Wuhan Institute of Virology of CAS
2018-06-15 Application filed by Wuhan Institute of Virology of CAS
2019-01-04 Application granted
-------------------------
A kind of carnivorism bat rearging cage

The utility model relates to a kind of wild animals to tame breeding apparatus technical field, more particularly, to a kind of carnivorism bat Rearging cage.

Bat becomes a variety of cause of diseases preferably natural place due to characteristics such as more with type, widely distributed, service life length It is main.But up to the present, at home and abroad there is no under artificial condition captive breeding successfully report.Both at home and abroad when research bat, Major part is to be captured as needed, and bat is freeed after taking required sample or is temporarily raised a period of time.But it raises Usually with cage of keeping pet, or the net cage being temporarily transformed, there is no a kind of special bat rearging cages to relax the cage tool of bat for bat Suitable life.

The utility model makes bat being capable of healthy growth and breeding under artificial condition.


eta: diagram of bat cage here. It's too large to post.
 
Last edited:
Incorrect. Read the article again, and keep note that:
...is not exactly an unbiased source when it comes to China.

Taiwan News also reported that the Three Gorges Dam was about to collapse in June 2020.
Incorrect. Read the article again, and keep note that: China like many countries was experiencing record floods. With that in mind the article says: "could", "is in danger of" and so on.

Nowhere in the article does it say, "will" or even "is about to". In fact, you altered the title which says: "in danger of collapse".
You do know the difference between "in danger of' and 'was about to" right?


Now why did you imply the article said something it didn't say?

And it's not like the article was a propaganda piece. Three Gorges Dam deformed but safe, say operators
In a rare revelation, Beijing has admitted that its 2.4-kilometer Three Gorges Dam spanning the Yangtze River in Hubei province “deformed slightly” after record flooding.

The official Xinhua News Agency quoted the operator of the the world’s largest hydroelectric gravity dam as saying that some nonstructural, peripheral parts of the dam had buckled.
Holy cow! It was noted in satellite images which you can see in the images in the article. The straight line of the dam is no longer straight.

But back to the topic: You are dismissing evidence that is corroborated elsewhere (despite Sherkeu not remembering ;) ). I posted upthread about the live bats at the WIV.

And look at you, ignoring Daszak's blatant conflict of interest
 
Last edited:
But back to the topic: You are dismissing evidence that is corroborated elsewhere (despite Sherkeu not remembering ;) ). I posted upthread about the live bats at the WIV.
[/HILITE]

Sorry! I recalled claims of it but must have missed a post- or even a few- about the sources.
 
I don't know if bats were kept in the Wuhan labs, but when reading Spillover, I did not that David Quammen talked about going to caves (not in Yunnan), and capturing bats with two scientists (neither of whom wore PPE, which Quammen was a bit concerned about in the book), then took the bats back to the lab (in the southeast of China, took samples, and then released them out the 3rd floor window.

The only time one of the scientsists put on a mask was when he dissected a horseshoe bat that they had accidentally killed while collecting it.

Quammen expresses concerns about contracting SARS from a bat. The American scientist that he is with laughs it off and compares biosecurity to seatbelts. Sure, in America you will wear seatbelts all the time, but good luck thinking you can wear them all over the world.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom