Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
Okay, but just for the benefit of anyone reading this, the red stuff and what follows from it are complete speculation.

The blue stuff is also conjecture.

And what changes something from speculation to an evidence based hypothesis?

Also answer these two questions:

Is there any other explanation for the government removing access to a lot of genome databases from the WIV in Sept?

And upon what evidence are you speculating about the 'spillover' hypothesis?

Go on, support your position with evidence, not conjecture.
 
Last edited:
And what changes something from speculation to an evidence based hypothesis?

Also answer these two questions:

Is there any other explanation for the government removing access to a lot of genome databases from the WIV in Sept?

Well, an explanation has been given, whether you believe it or not...

In January this year, Prof Shi Zhengli became one of the first people in the world to sequence Sars-Cov-2, which was already spreading rapidly through the streets and homes of her city.

She then compared the long string of letters representing the virus's unique genetic code with the extensive library of other viruses collected and stored over the years.

And she discovered that her database contained the closest known relative of Sars-Cov-2.

RaTG13 is a virus whose name has been derived from the bat it was extracted from (Rhinolophus affinis, Ra), the place it was found (Tongguan, TG), and the year it was identified, 2013.

...

In what has become the definitive paper ruling out the possibility of a lab leak, RaTG13 has a starring role.

Published in March in the magazine Nature Medicine, it suggests that if there had been a leak, Prof Shi Zhengli would have found a much closer match in her database than RaTG13.

While RaTG13 is the closest known relative - at 96.2% similarity - it is still too distant to have been manipulated and changed into Sars-Cov-2.

...

Prof Shi has also faced questions about why the WIV's online public database of viruses was suddenly taken offline.

She told the BBC that the WIV's website and the staff's work emails and personal emails had been attacked, and the database taken offline for security reasons. "All our research results are published in English journals in the form of papers," she said. "Virus sequences are saved in the [US-run] GenBank database too. It's completely transparent. We have nothing to hide."
After a decade of sampling and experimenting on viruses collected from bats, we now know that back in 2013 the closest known ancestor was discovered of a future threat that would claim well over a million lives and devastate the global economy.

Yet the WIV, according to the published information, did nothing with it, except sequence it and enter it into a database.

Link


And upon what evidence are you speculating about the 'spillover' hypothesis?

Go on, support your position with evidence, not conjecture.

Why do I think spillover is more likely than lab leak?

Well, if the virus was not in the lab, then where else would it be, except in nature?
 
Have you actually found any actual lies that Zhengli Shi or Peter Daszak have said?

Do you have any reason to think that the rest of the world's virologists are just covering for them?
 
Sure, related, but research by Linfa Wang and others show that these types of related viruses have a wide range over which they are found in bats.

I tried looking for this research but did not find anything. Of course bats all over the world carry viruses with a chance of adapting to infect humans, many of them coronaviruses, many SARS related. Transferring these to humans is still a rare event.

The point of those teams collecting bat samples (besides hunting down the origin of the first SARS) was to find hotspots where a virus is most likely to jump to humans. They did, and they reported it. It's in Yunnan. They spent years taking samples from bats there to Wuhan for study (as was their job to do)

As far as I know, before the current pandemic emerged, only areas in Yunnan showed strong evidence of SARS-CoV bat viruses that had the ability to efficiently infect and replicate in human cells.

The original SARS was traced to a cave in Yunnan (by Shi), the workers in the mine sick and dead with Covid-like symptoms and SARS-antibody positive tests were in Yunnan, and the closest related virus to the current pandemic is also in Yunnan.

Could other far-away bats also be the source? Anything is possible. A similarly capable virus would need to arise and cause spillover elsewhere, independently. Before 2002, SARS-CoV viruses were unknown to infect humans.
Could we be so unlucky?

*One could argue (not saying you would) that maybe the first SARS outbreak circulated (and mutated) among other mammals or back into different bats in a different area, and then infected human populations years later. Also possible. However, all the elements of human SARS, past and present, are right there in Yunnan where researchers had warned was high risk for another emergence.

disclaimer: This is all stated as my opinion citing the available evidence and is not 100% a claim for anything. It is meant to add to collaborative discussions about the origin of SARS-CoV-2 as well as can be deduced by laypersons on a forum. I reserve the right to be wrong, correct errors, and to change my mind at any time with or without compelling new information.
 
Last edited:
I tried looking for this research but did not find anything. Of course bats all over the world carry viruses with a chance of adapting to infect humans, many of them coronaviruses, many SARS related. Transferring these to humans is still a rare event.

The research is here and was conducted in Thailand.

These are not just viruses, but pretty similar (if RatG13 is similar) to SARS CoV2:

Phylogenetic analysis of the SC2r-CoV RacCS203
When screened by a published pan-CoV PCR method targeting a 328-bp region in the RdRp gene19, 13 of the 100 rectal swabs were positive (Supplementary Table 1). Sequencing of PCR amplicons from all positive samples revealed an identical sequence which has the highest sequence identity of 96.21% to bat CoV-RaTG13 (NCBI accession no. MN996532.1), 95.86% to human SARS-CoV-2 (NCBI accession no. MT631834.1), and 94.48% to CoV-RmYN02 (GISAID no. EPI_ISL_412977). Five samples with high levels of viral RNA were chosen for further analysis by next-generation sequencing (NGS). The whole-genome sequence with the best assembly quality, named RacCS203, was used as a reference genome for subsequent analysis. The sequences from the other four genomes were almost identical to RacCS203 (Supplementary Fig. 1), indicating this to be the most dominant CoV circulating in this bat colony at the time of sampling.

The point of those teams collecting bat samples (besides hunting down the origin of the first SARS) was to find hotspots where a virus is most likely to jump to humans. They did, and they reported it. It's in Yunnan. They spent years taking samples from bats there to Wuhan for study (as was their job to do)

As far as I know, before the current pandemic emerged, only areas in Yunnan showed strong evidence of SARS-CoV bat viruses that had the ability to efficiently infect and replicate in human cells.

The original SARS was traced to a cave in Yunnan (by Shi), the workers in the mine sick and dead with Covid-like symptoms and SARS-antibody positive tests were in Yunnan, and the closest related virus to the current pandemic is also in Yunnan.

Could other far-away bats also be the source? Anything is possible. A similarly capable virus would need to arise and cause spillover elsewhere, independently. Before 2002, SARS-CoV viruses were unknown to infect humans.
Could we be so unlucky?

*One could argue (not saying you would) that maybe the first SARS outbreak circulated (and mutated) among other mammals or back into different bats in a different area, and then infected human populations years later. Also possible. However, all the elements of human SARS, past and present, are right there in Yunnan where researchers had warned was high risk for another emergence.

disclaimer: This is all stated as my opinion citing the available evidence and is not 100% a claim for anything. It is meant to add to collaborative discussions about the origin of SARS-CoV-2 as well as can be deduced by laypersons on a forum. I reserve the right to be wrong, correct errors, and to change my mind at any time with or without compelling new information.

Well, the authors of the piece I quoted said...

Although the origin of the virus remains unresolved, our study extended the geographic distribution of genetically diverse SC2r-CoVs from Japan and China to Thailand over a 4800-km range. Cross-border surveillance is urgently needed to find the immediate progenitor virus of SARS-CoV-2.
 
Before 2002, SARS-CoV viruses were unknown to infect humans.
Could we be so unlucky?

Well, wait a second here.

Before 2002, we had nothing named SARS at all. SARS is just the name given initialy to the syndrome caused by the disease, hence Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome.

SARS is itself a type of coronavirus, and within that family is the betacoronavirus and then there are four lineages a, b, c, and d. The common cold is often caused by a betacoronavirus from lineage a, whereas lineage b is known as a sarbecovirus, within which there are:

SARS-Cov1
SARS-Cov2

and...

MERS! But wait, MERS comes to humans presumably from bats via camels, and yet that one emerged not that long after SARS. How can we be that unlucky?
 
Well, wait a second here.


MERS! But wait, MERS comes to humans presumably from bats via camels, and yet that one emerged not that long after SARS. How can we be that unlucky?

Yes, MERS is a coronavirus originally from bats. It had (has?) a different mechanism of infection (something other than ACE2). I know it has been in camels for a long time. Don't know much more about MERS evolution or where those bats came from as it just isn't discussed in depth in the SARS papers.

Is it relevant to sources for either SARS? Or were you kindly pointing out another bat-derived coronavirus that infected humans?
It did, and I failed to include it in my post.
 
Last edited:
China has pragmatically and correctly deleted the evidence.
Putin would do so but ramshackle America would fail
China has control financially and geopollitically.
 
Yes, MERS is a coronavirus originally from bats. It had (has?) a different mechanism of infection (something other than ACE2). I know it has been in camels for a long time. Don't know much more about MERS evolution or where those bats came from as it just isn't discussed in depth in the SARS papers.

Is it relevant to sources for either SARS? Or were you kindly pointing out another bat-derived coronavirus that infected humans?
It did, and I failed to include it in my post.

I think it is relevant in the sense that the WHO among others have been warning about the increased emergence of coronaviruses that can be deadly to humans. I think many of them simply don't think this will be the last SARS or deadly coronavirus and I think that many of the virologists working on this think that more zoonotic spillovers are likely in the future because of bad ecological policies.

ETA: And I have just seen this...

UN’s Kunming biodiversity summit delayed a second time

...
Cop15 will be the first time China has led the world in a major international agreement on the environment.

Links between the destruction of the natural world and the emergence of zoonotic diseases have been amplified during the coronavirus pandemic, with increased awareness about humanity’s destruction of nature. But parties to the CBD have not been able to carry out scientific and preparatory work before Cop15, with some states objecting to online negotiations. The UN said it was working with regional representatives to find a solution so the meetings could take place before the Kunming summit.

Kunming is of course in Yunnan Province.
 
Last edited:
China has pragmatically and correctly deleted the evidence.Putin would do so but ramshackle America would fail
China has control financially and geopollitically.

Okay, so the theory here is that they found SARS CoV2 and had it on their database.

Then, when the outbreak occurred (and the theory is now pushing it back to September 2019) they just deleted the whole database.

Oops! And no one had duplicate information anywhere - except Zheng-li Shi said a copy of it is at GenBank:

GenBank and its collaborators receive sequences produced in laboratories throughout the world from more than 100,000 distinct organisms. The database started in 1982 by Walter Goad and Los Alamos National Laboratory. GenBank has become an important database for research in biological fields and has grown in recent years at an exponential rate by doubling roughly every 18 months.

Apparently this is GenBank.

How would that work? Does anyone know if they can access it at GenBank?

It seems to me if Zheng-li Shi is lying it would be pretty easy to discover right now. And why delete the whole thing?

Why didn't they just decide to remove the incriminating ones?

This attempt at trying to force everything to fit a completely made-up narrative looks full of holes to me.
 
Have you actually found any actual lies that Zhengli Shi or Peter Daszak have said?
Why does it have to be a lie?
Daszak has refused to acknowledge he has a conflict of interest.
He stated the lab leak was unlikely before the WHO team went to Wuhan.
He came back saying they had completely discounted the lab leak based on interviews but not based on any objective evidence which they were denied access to.
We don't know if he was the only person working with live cultures at the WIV or elsewhere​

Do you have any reason to think that the rest of the world's virologists are just covering for them?
Here you go again repeating this falsehood. You know there are many virologists questioning the WHO's conclusion. I've cited many of them. And there is an even larger number of virologists who have not weighed in.

your cite said:
She then compared the long string of letters representing the virus's unique genetic code with the extensive library of other viruses collected and stored over the years.
And some of the viruses studied at the WIV were not entered into the the data base. Plus she compared COVID 19 in Jan after the data was scrubbed by the Chinese government in Sept.
 
This is from my DRASTIC link of all the data bases taken off line (I opened it in pdf and now I can copy-paste from it).

WIV: Bat and rodent borne viral pathogens - batvirus.whiov.ac.cn

Part of batvirus.whiov.ac.cn data was always confidential ...

The aim of the projects funded by the NIH includes pathogenicity enhancement studies using unpublished viruses...

External access to Batvirus.whiov.ac.cn ended on 12th Sep 2019...

Batvirus.whiov.ac.cn holds essential information on SARS-CoV-2 origins

Questions as to the unavailability of batvirus.whiov.ac.cn are not being properly answered

The author of 'I looked and it wasn't there' is
The administrator of the database is Shi Zhengli herself.

Does she say she included her access to the confidential parts of the data base?

And more importantly:
Batvirus.whiov.ac.cn holds a password protected section for data that was not to be freely shared. That private data includes:
■ (1) Sampling data of viruses not yet sequenced and (2) sequences of viruses that have not yet been the object of publication.
● Note: The idea is very likely to get the WIV and its associates the privilege of writing the first papers on the viruses sampled by the WIV.
■ (3) sampling data from sites that the WIV prefers not to make public
The rest of the password protected parts of the data base are for the usual research reasons, holding one's research close to the vest in order to be first to be published.

So we have Daszik (see my next post) and the Chinese keeper of the data base all telling us "nothing to see here".
 
Why does it have to be a lie?
Daszak has refused to acknowledge he has a conflict of interest.
He stated the lab leak was unlikely before the WHO team went to Wuhan.
He came back saying they had completely discounted the lab leak based on interviews but not based on any objective evidence which they were denied access to.
We don't know if he was the only person working with live cultures at the WIV or elsewhere​

Here you go again repeating this falsehood. You know there are many virologists questioning the WHO's conclusion. I've cited many of them. And there is an even larger number of virologists who have not weighed in.

And some of the viruses studied at the WIV were not entered into the the data base. Plus she compared COVID 19 in Jan after the data was scrubbed by the Chinese government in Sept.

That doesn’t help your theory then if it was taken down in response to a virus on the database being the cause of Covid 19 because if it wasn’t on the database why take it down?

If it WAS on the database then it would be accessible through GenBank.

If it was in the confidential part of the database why not take that portion down and leave the rest up so as not to appear too obvious?

You are using the takedown of the database as a clue but also trying to have it both ways by saying maybe it wasn’t on the database. Huh?
 
That doesn’t help your theory then if it was taken down in response to a virus on the database being the cause of Covid 19 because if it wasn’t on the database why take it down?

If it WAS on the database then it would be accessible through GenBank.

If it was in the confidential part of the database why not take that portion down and leave the rest up so as not to appear too obvious?

You are using the takedown of the database as a clue but also trying to have it both ways by saying maybe it wasn’t on the database. Huh?

I have more, it's just very long and I'm trimming. If you want extra credit homework, start at page 5 of the DRASTIC record and go from there.

But as to them not knowing what the COVID sequence was, it explains the shotgun approach: take down everything.
 
Last edited:
So have the DRASTIC people been looking through the database on GenBank if Big Virology haven’t done so?

Why GenBank when the data was not entered in that DB?

Page 8:
They are likely the same as the 8 from the 7896 clade published as part of a batch of 630 viruses of Latinne et al without further details . On that occasion only the RdRp portions were uploaded to GenBank on the 13 Aug 2019 (around 360 bases, not the full sequences of the viruses). ■ That clade is very close to RaTG13 (the closest relative of SARS-CoV-2), so should offer some very important clues as to but is not discussed in the literature.
■ Questions as to why no more attention is being paid to that essential clade are not being answered.
COVID 19 has almost 30,000 bases.
 
Okay, so the theory here is that they found SARS CoV2 and had it on their database.

Then, when the outbreak occurred (and the theory is now pushing it back to September 2019) they just deleted the whole database.
No, that is not the hypothesis. The hypothesis is people working on one specific project discovered a lab leak, be it someone got infected or they found and corrected the breach. But they either knew it had already gone beyond the lab down that metro line, or they weren't sure, but they decided to be proactive about removing the incriminating evidence. And another case for removing a whole database is that someone from the lab turned up seriously ill with a coronavirus of unknown type.

Or maybe just the suspicious ground glass chest X-ray was seen at one of the hospitals and they knew what that X-ray meant. It's a reason to remove lots of files.

And another possibility is removing a large amount of data supported the cover-up story that it was to prevent hacking the data while removing specific files would be incriminating.

We have here another improbable coincidence: They just happened to remove these files just before the outbreak which just happened to be very near the WIV where research on these particular pathogens was taking place and it just coincidentally included live (in vivo) studies with human adapted cells, which also was denied at first. The first story was no live virus was being studied, just the genomes.

I answered the rest of your post already.

Supporting the significance of missing data and the less than convincing denials to come.
 
Last edited:
No, that is not the hypothesis. The hypothesis is people working on one specific project discovered a lab leak, be it someone got infected or they found and corrected the breach. But they either knew it had already gone beyond the lab down that metro line, or they weren't sure, but they decided to be proactive about removing the incriminating evidence. And another case for removing a whole database is that someone from the lab turned up seriously ill with a coronavirus of unknown type.

Or maybe just the suspicious ground glass chest X-ray was seen at one of the hospitals and they knew what that X-ray meant. It's a reason to remove lots of files.

And another possibility is removing a large amount of data supported the cover-up story that it was to prevent hacking the data while removing specific files would be incriminating.

We have here another improbable coincidence: They just happened to remove these files just before the outbreak which just happened to be very near the WIV where research on these particular pathogens was taking place and it just coincidentally included live (in vivo) studies with human adapted cells, which also was denied at first. The first story was no live virus was being studied, just the genomes.

I answered the rest of your post already.

Supporting the significance of missing data and the less than convincing denials to come.

Okay, thanks. I’ll look at this information more carefully. It’s interesting.
 
I'm correcting the molecular time frame yet again BECAUSE I HAVE NEW EVIDENCE.

More than one researcher tracked the timing of the first case back using the molecular clock. One said the end of Oct. One said the middle of Oct. But I now find one researcher who believes the clock shows the first case in Wuhan was in early Sept based on the molecular clock. These people are using good science. There is a discrepancy in the timeline but they are all essentially on the same page.

Now there is corroborating evidence the Sept date for the first case is right. The Chinese government moved at that time to start removing any evidence that might exist implicating the WIV.

May I ask about this claim of Covid-19 cases stretching back as far as September.

You say you have found one researcher saying this. Do they have a paper or some evidence?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom