Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
... So, the evidence that the particular virus we are talking about has escaped should be in the genome somewhere.
It might be but right as the pandemic started the Chinese government took access to a lot of work on coronaviruses offline and has denied access to it. The link in is the thread somewhere. I'll look for it.

angrysoba said:
... For the most part they are pretty engrossed in the nitty gritty details and then they do a little aside, beginning somewhere around 20 or 25 minutes in which they talk about how there are some lab leak theories and how the stuff they are talking about makes this really unlikely.

The whole thing is quite long and I am listening to it now, but maybe you might be interested in it...


Re the lab leak hypothesis This should be of interest (don't know if it was posted before):
MIT Tech Review: Did the coronavirus leak from a lab? These scientists say we shouldn’t rule it out.

Perhaps no one played a greater role in galvanizing scientific opinions in support of natural origins than Peter Daszak,...

Daszak is purported to have written a first draft of the Lancet statement condemning hypotheses other than natural origins as conspiracy theories. ...

Relman agrees that in the absence of conclusive evidence, the message on origins should be “We don’t know.” After the Lancet statement, and then a subsequent paper on SARS-CoV-2’s origins written by scientists who concluded that “we do not believe any type of laboratory-based scenario is plausible,” he found himself increasingly disheartened by those who he claimed had seized on a spillover scenario, despite “an amazing absence of data.” Relman says he felt he had to push back.

Motive:
Relman proposes that among those trying to suppress the lab-release hypothesis, there might have been “far too much protection of one’s self and one’s peers before allowing a really important question to receive a hearing.” And scientists collaborating with researchers in China “might worry about their working relationship if they say anything other than ‘This threat comes from nature.’”
 
That is not an accurate description of what you and Sherkeu have been claiming.
:confused:

No offense but this is silly. From your second link:
We employed a coalescent framework to combine retrospective molecular clock inference with forward epidemiological simulations to determine how long SARS-CoV-2 could have circulated prior to the time of the most recent common ancestor. Our results define the period between mid-October and mid-November 2019 as the plausible interval when the first case of SARS-CoV-2 emerged in Hubei province.

Sherkeu and I have been discussing how the biological clock was used to estimate when and where the first case(s) occurred.
 
Last edited:
Yeah, right. Are you walking back all the lab leak claims??
Of course not!

WTF???

I give up. You have some misconception somewhere that is beyond my ability to understand what you are even talking about.

Maybe if you spelled your issue out in more detail than these little quips I might understand so I could reply.
 
Last edited:
Sometimes it's easier to search for the link again than to find it in the thread. This is from 11 months ago.

China clamping down on coronavirus research, deleted pages suggest
Two websites for leading Chinese universities appear to have recently published and then removed pages that reference a new policy requiring academic papers dealing with Covid-19 to undergo extra vetting before they are submitted for publication.

But then I always find new stuff I missed earlier. There are caches of these papers somewhere.

I posted this earlier but there is no way to see the article other than the bullets.
Chinese laboratory that first shared coronavirus genome with world ordered to close for ‘rectification’, hindering its Covid-19 research

And there is this which oddly cites Sept 2019 for the removal databases.

An investigation into the WIV databases that were taken offline On the 12th Sep 2019, the main database of samples and viral sequences of the Wuhan Institute of Virology went offline. Eventually every single of the 16 virus databases managed by the WIV was taken offline. Here we show how these databases may provide essential clues at to the origins of SARS-CoV-2 and review the circumstances in which they were taken offline. I'm going to see what's on that site about the specific COVID 19 precursor viruses.
 
Last edited:
...

It might be but right as the pandemic started the Chinese government took access to a lot of work on coronaviruses offline and has denied access to it. The link in is the thread somewhere. I'll look for it.

Re the lab leak hypothesis This should be of interest (don't know if it was posted before):
MIT Tech Review: Did the coronavirus leak from a lab? These scientists say we shouldn’t rule it out.

Perhaps no one played a greater role in galvanizing scientific opinions in support of natural origins than Peter Daszak,...

Daszak is purported to have written a first draft of the Lancet statement condemning hypotheses other than natural origins as conspiracy theories. ...

Relman agrees that in the absence of conclusive evidence, the message on origins should be “We don’t know.” After the Lancet statement, and then a subsequent paper on SARS-CoV-2’s origins written by scientists who concluded that “we do not believe any type of laboratory-based scenario is plausible,” he found himself increasingly disheartened by those who he claimed had seized on a spillover scenario, despite “an amazing absence of data.” Relman says he felt he had to push back.

Motive:
Relman proposes that among those trying to suppress the lab-release hypothesis, there might have been “far too much protection of one’s self and one’s peers before allowing a really important question to receive a hearing.” And scientists collaborating with researchers in China “might worry about their working relationship if they say anything other than ‘This threat comes from nature.’”

I am puzzled by the sides of this argument of 'lab' vs 'natural'.
Why are 'naturally occurring" viruses in the wild and the 'naturally occurring' viruses the lab was collecting in the wild mutually exclusive to determining origin?

There are many different scenarios where it comes from nature (or is otherwise natural as in a mutation happening from live specimens) but connected to work the lab was doing.

Sure, viruses of all kinds are likely to cross species much more in nature, millions of interactions. And there are far far more farmers and traders working with animals than researchers. However, the work in Southern China was not a random sample among these interactions. It was in a high-risk, very small, targeted area of caves where SARS viruses that can infect human cells were found, where the closest known relation of SARS-Cov-2 was found, and where test results showed spillover of some unknown bat SARS virus in nearby villagers.

eta: removes specific cave number since RaTG13 was collected in an abandoned mine and not one of the 2 'tourist' caves near the villages. looking for proximity....
 
Last edited:
Daszak did a PBS interview Aug 2016. (At this point he would have had at least the initial results of the testing on villagers from Oct 2015 near the Yanzi and Shitou caves))

Why southern China is a hotbed for disease development
https://www.pbs.org/newshour/show/southern-china-hotbed-disease-development

Daszak: This is a big tourist cave. Shall we go?

Sreenivasan: Daszak is concerned about a bat cave that is a popular tourist destination.
The bats here in this cave are the same bats that carry SARS virus.

Daszak:Bats live in the cave all day long, because they're nocturnal. And when they're up there, they urinate and defecate, right on top of the tourists that are walking through.

And all you have got to do is be that one person to breathe in at the wrong time, and suddenly you have been infected with a virus that is not only potentially lethal to people. It could cause a future pandemic.

He doesn't say specifically if tourists could catch a SARS virus direct from bats but that seem to be the implication.
 
...

I am puzzled by the sides of this argument of 'lab' vs 'natural'.
Why are 'naturally occurring" viruses in the wild and the 'naturally occurring' viruses the lab was collecting in the wild mutually exclusive to determining origin?

There are many different scenarios where it comes from nature (or is otherwise natural as in a mutation happening from live specimens) but connected to work the lab was doing.

Sure, viruses of all kinds are likely to cross species much more in nature, millions of interactions. And there are far far more farmers and traders working with animals than researchers. However, the work in Southern China was not a random sample among these interactions. It was in a high-risk, very small, targeted area of caves where SARS viruses that can infect human cells were found, where the closest known relation of SARS-Cov-2 was found, and where test results showed spillover of some unknown bat SARS virus in nearby villagers.

eta: removes specific cave number since RaTG13 was collected in an abandoned mine and not one of the 2 'tourist' caves near the villages. looking for proximity....
It's called framing the argument with a nice straw man distraction.

Claim there is no evidence the virus was developed as a bioweapon or "made in a lab" and cite the fact one would expect to see evidence in the genome if it had been. Let the news media, sometimes with a bit of a nudge here and there, conflate that with any virus coming from a lab leak.

I know people on this forum love to discount anything that might be a CT. So when Dasvak started suggesting well ahead of the WHO investigation that any suggestion of an origin in the WIV was a conspiracy theory, not only did a lot of people here buy it, but so did other investigators that have been cited here.

Take this Twitter feed angrysoba linked to from K G Anderson who asserts the lab leak story isn't supported by any evidence.
After one year of political bluster and pure speculation, still nothing.
The Twitter thread seems to be somewhat dead and it appears that Mr Andersen neither addressed any of the evidence posted in the thread, nor did he respond to posts in the thread that the animal jump had just as much evidence.

I've seen other researchers and scientists making the same kind of statements, the lab leak is so unlikely..... look over here at the animal 'spillover' hypothesis.

And as I cited a source above, Daszak made sure that 'couldn't have been the lab' narrative got out there well ahead of anyone suggesting the lab remains a viable hypothesis. The narrative makes it look like if you dare to look at the lab, you are a CTer.

A lot of scientists have pushed back and continue to do so.
 
Last edited:
Daszak did a PBS interview Aug 2016. (At this point he would have had at least the initial results of the testing on villagers from Oct 2015 near the Yanzi and Shitou caves))

Why southern China is a hotbed for disease development
https://www.pbs.org/newshour/show/southern-china-hotbed-disease-development

He doesn't say specifically if tourists could catch a SARS virus direct from bats but that seem to be the implication.
I had to poke around a bit to find the video since it is older. It's less than 7 minutes. Much better with the pics.

It won't play directly here, but you can watch it on YT

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vb4oDJ4T1kE
 
I had to poke around a bit to find the video since it is older. It's less than 7 minutes. Much better with the pics.

It won't play directly here, but you can watch it on YT

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vb4oDJ4T1kE

Thanks! Yes, better with video.

Digging further into what caves had which viruses, the virus that killed 3 of 6 hospitalized guano-cleaners in 2012 was about 100mi SW (as the crow flies) along the same highway. That cave (an abandoned copper mine) is not for tourists (or journalists). The RaTG13 sample came from this location.

A summary here:
Lethal Pneumonia Cases in Mojiang Miners (2012) and the Mineshaft Could Provide Important Clues to the Origin of SARS-CoV-2
https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fpubh.2020.581569/full

It was found that RaTG13/CoV4991 was collected from Tongguan mineshaft in Mojiang, Yunnan, China, in 2013. Surprisingly, the same mineshaft was also associated with a severe pneumonia-like illness in miners in 2012 killing three of the six miners. A Master's thesis (in the Chinese language) was found on the cnki.net website which described in detail the severe illness in miners. The thesis concluded that a SARS-like CoV originating from Chinese horseshoe bats (Rhinolophus) was the predicted causative agent. The cases were remotely monitored by a prominent pulmonologist in China. Retrospective analysis of the pneumonia cases shows striking similarities with COVID-19. Bilateral pneumonia, vascular complications like pulmonary thromboembolism, and secondary infections are the main similarities. The treatment regimes were similar to the current treatments for COVID-19.

The translation of the paper referred to above can be found here:

MS Thesis 2013 (medical case documentation/"glassy" xrays here! one patient was in hospital for 109 days before succumbing)
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1d6GdDYtVrstULLSZmmqcu3NlLsYol2OA/view

Phd Thesis 2015 (partial translation)
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1OdWCjEJEqEyxbujWwvkf0hknxDoRTCAw/view

This one follows the first with the addition of bat/rat samples and antibody blood testing.

...blood test results of 4 cases showed that: 4 people carried SARS virus lgG antibodies, of which 2 were discharged with higher antibody levels and 2 were hospitalized with lower antibody levels (Wuhan, Chinese Academy of Sciences) Virology Institute).
 
...



I am puzzled by the sides of this argument of 'lab' vs 'natural'. Why are 'naturally occurring" viruses in the wild and the 'naturally occurring' viruses the lab was collecting in the wild mutually exclusive to determining origin?
There are many different scenarios where it comes from nature (or is otherwise natural as in a mutation happening from live specimens) but connected to work the lab was doing.

Sure, viruses of all kinds are likely to cross species much more in nature, millions of interactions. And there are far far more farmers and traders working with animals than researchers. However, the work in Southern China was not a random sample among these interactions. It was in a high-risk, very small, targeted area of caves where SARS viruses that can infect human cells were found, where the closest known relation of SARS-Cov-2 was found, and where test results showed spillover of some unknown bat SARS virus in nearby villagers.

eta: removes specific cave number since RaTG13 was collected in an abandoned mine and not one of the 2 'tourist' caves near the villages. looking for proximity....

It's called framing the argument with a nice straw man distraction.

No, it is NOT framing with a strawman.

I have asked, and not been told, what the theory that you are proposing is.

On the one hand we have claims of gain of function creating a virus that is highly adaptive to humans, right?


So we have:

1.) Lab leak of manipulated virus.

How does someone address this claim? Well, maybe by seeing if there is evidence of a manipulated virus.

But then you argue that that is a "strawman"???!?!? Okay, so what role does GoF have in this thing? If you want us to dispense with this claim then we have...

2.) Lab leak of virus that just so happens to be well adapted to humans.

Okay, how does someone address this? Well, we just look and see if there is evidence of it. Apparently, no evidence that it just got out through someone being sickened by it. Or is there? But also no evidence that the specific virus was even there in the lab to begin with.

So then, I presume you are arguing that maybe it was there, and the WIV sequenced it and put it in its database but then hid the evidence by taking down the database.

Okay, then the answer is in the database?

Yes, or maybe no.

If not, then what?

Then, maybe there was a bat that had the virus in the WIV but nobody realized it. Or maybe it was on some guano or something else.......


Ummmm...okay, but what exactly is being covered up here if they just happened to have the virus but didn't know about it.

Sorry, I am asking you to tell me what your theory is. You can't complain about a strawman if you don't clearly explain the theory.
 
Last edited:
Thanks! Yes, better with video.

Digging further into what caves had which viruses, the virus that killed 3 of 6 hospitalized guano-cleaners in 2012 was about 100mi SW (as the crow flies) along the same highway. That cave (an abandoned copper mine) is not for tourists (or journalists). The RaTG13 sample came from this location.

A summary here:
Lethal Pneumonia Cases in Mojiang Miners (2012) and the Mineshaft Could Provide Important Clues to the Origin of SARS-CoV-2
https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fpubh.2020.581569/full



The translation of the paper referred to above can be found here:

MS Thesis 2013 (medical case documentation/"glassy" xrays here! one patient was in hospital for 109 days before succumbing)
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1d6GdDYtVrstULLSZmmqcu3NlLsYol2OA/view

Phd Thesis 2015 (partial translation)
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1OdWCjEJEqEyxbujWwvkf0hknxDoRTCAw/view

This one follows the first with the addition of bat/rat samples and antibody blood testing.

What claim are you making about RaTG13?

What is its significance?
 
What claim are you making about RaTG13?

What is its significance?

I'm simply adding some pieces to the puzzle.

2012- cleaners at a mine hospitalized with symptoms strikingly similar to Covid.
2013- sample RaTG13 taken from a bat at same location
2014- samples of 2012 patients are positive for SARS antibodies
2020- RaTG13 is closest known relation to SARS-Cov-2

What I take from it is that 2019 is not the first lethal SARS coronavirus from bats since the original SARS outbreak (2002-3). I would strongly suspect that the area around this location held the bat with a SARS virus that started the 2019 outbreak, whether it happened there or followed some other chain to humans.

What do you think? Related novel virus? or coincidence? or other?
 
I'm simply adding some pieces to the puzzle.

2012- cleaners at a mine hospitalized with symptoms strikingly similar to Covid.
2013- sample RaTG13 taken from a bat at same location
2014- samples of 2012 patients are positive for SARS antibodies
2020- RaTG13 is closest known relation to SARS-Cov-2

What I take from it is that 2019 is not the first lethal SARS coronavirus from bats since the original SARS outbreak (2002-3). I would strongly suspect that the area around this location held the bat with a SARS virus that started the 2019 outbreak, whether it happened there or followed some other chain to humans.

What do you think? Related novel virus? or coincidence? or other?

Sure, related, but research by Linfa Wang and others show that these types of related viruses have a wide range over which they are found in bats.
 
I'm going to answer this without repeating all the sources which can be found in this thread. Cited sources for all this are in the thread.
No, it is NOT framing with a strawman.

I have asked, and not been told, what the theory that you are proposing is.
I don't understand how you don't know what my lab-leak hypothesis is. I have spelled it out including recently summarizing the evidence supporting it and stating what evidence still needs to be found.

As for the second viable hypothesis: a species jump to humans in the wild, I'm not ruling that out. It could be proven if the animal harboring the intermediate virus could be found. With SARS they did just that. They found infected civet cats in the wet market where the first infections were found. That is not the case with COVID 19.

IMO the lab leak is supported by more evidence than the natural jump (spillover) hypothesis.

On the one hand we have claims of gain of function creating a virus that is highly adaptive to humans, right?
It's high up on the likely hypothesis list. It is not, however, what the assertion being made that 'one could tell' claims. By straw man I mean describing a virus originating in the lab in only one way, thereby making it easy to argue that didn't happen or we would see it. The harder arguments against a lab leak are ignored. Thus it is a straw man.


So we have:

1.) Lab leak of manipulated virus.

How does someone address this claim? Well, maybe by seeing if there is evidence of a manipulated virus.

But then you argue that that is a "strawman"???!?!? Okay, so what role does GoF have in this thing? If you want us to dispense with this claim then we have...
If by "manipulated" you mean one built in a lab by taking a piece of virus here and a piece of virus there, that is the virus which the narrative uses to dismiss any and all lab-leaked virus as if anything touched by a researcher would show these same manipulated patterns. The GoF research is much different from a built-in-the-lab or bioengineered type virus.
2.) Lab leak of virus that just so happens to be well adapted to humans.

Okay, how does someone address this? Well, we just look and see if there is evidence of it. Apparently, no evidence that it just got out through someone being sickened by it. Or is there? But also no evidence that the specific virus was even there in the lab to begin with.

So then, I presume you are arguing that maybe it was there, and the WIV sequenced it and put it in its database but then hid the evidence by taking down the database.

Okay, then the answer is in the database?
You have a mixed bag of issues here. As for "just so happened to be ready to go", there is some evidence that is possible. There is evidence that all the parts are there in the wild in horseshoe bats in a cave in Yunnan. All those parts found in one bat that matches COVID 19 has not been found.

There is evidence the pangolin coronaviruses could have been passed back and forth between bat and pangolin and back.

In addition, a generalist bat coronavirus has been found that can infect humans directly. In fact, several cases of a coronavirus pneumonia occurred in miners who worked in one of the bat caves in Yunnan.

No one has said yet that those infections were with a virus that contained the pangolin genome segment. (Only a segment of the pangolin coronavirus matches COVID 19, BTW. As a whole genome, the bat coronaviruses are much closer genetically.)

Recombinant viruses are occurring: Mutation = drift; recombination = shift.


Yes, or maybe no.

If not, then what?

Then, maybe there was a bat that had the virus in the WIV but nobody realized it. Or maybe it was on some guano or something else.......
Oh they realized it. The Chinese government removed the evidence from where it had been available online.
I found additional evidence this was done in Sept 2019. DRASTIC via ResearchGate: An investigation into the WIV databases that were taken offline
Abstract
On the 12th Sep 2019, the main database of samples and viral sequences of the Wuhan Institute of Virology went offline. Eventually every single of the 16 virus databases managed by the WIV was taken offline. Here we show how these databases may provide essential clues at to the origins of SARS-CoV-2 and review the circumstances in which they were taken offline.

It's quite technical, not like research write-up would be structured. It's copy protected anyway so I can't quote anything from it. But I can repeat this:
Objectives
List all the DBs that were taken offline
Explain their significance
Back it up with screenshots and proofs of deletion​
It's extensive.

I'm going to come back to the Sept date of action in a follow up post.


Ummmm...okay, but what exactly is being covered up here if they just happened to have the virus but didn't know about it.

Sorry, I am asking you to tell me what your theory is. You can't complain about a strawman if you don't clearly explain the theory.
The straw man is what Daszak and other government officials have done claiming any manipulated virus in the lab would have an easily spotted genetic pattern. Try to argue: yes but what about possible lab cultures that were coaxed but not artificially created and they shift back to distracting people with the implication anything that comes from the lab would have a signature.
 
Last edited:
Sure, related, but research by Linfa Wang and others show that these types of related viruses have a wide range over which they are found in bats.
Types of related, sure but these isolated viruses were very closely related to COVID 19.

This is one of the caves the researchers from the WIV collected specimens and were working with them.

This is very much narrowed down and has little to do with the fact bat coronaviruses are found over a wide range.
 
Last edited:
Oh they realized it. The Chinese government removed the evidence from where it had been available online.

You are talking about the database, right? But do we know what was in it or not?

If not, we can't say what was in it?

If we do, we can see if they had SARS CoV2.

Now, Peter Daszak says they do know what was in the database. Obviously you don't trust him.

Obviously we can argue for greater transparency, but I am still not clear on whether or not you are saying:

a) the database has the smoking gun virus!

or

b) I think it should be investigated.

Maybe I am misreading you, but sometimes you are saying things that look far more defininitive than we know to be true.

Now, from what I can see, gain of function involves "any selection process involving an alteration of genotypes and their resulting phenotypes is considered a type of Gain-of-Function (GoF) research"

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK285579/

The alteration is what I am talking about as being something that the virologists on the TWiV episode seem to be disputing.

One thing, from what I understand, is that they say, "Sure, you can alter the genome to see how it will behave in vitro, in cell cultures, but the idea that you can then make it viable in animals is another vastly more complicated step, that we don't know anyone who is able to do that...." etc...

Maybe you might want to watch that latest TWiV called "Weiss hath no furin like a virus scorned". It seems that some of the lab leak theorists are interested in the "furin cleavage site", and there is loads of discussion about it on Twitter.

 
Types of related, sure but these isolated viruses were very closely related to COVID 19.
This is one of the caves the researchers from the WIV collected specimens and were working with them.

This is very much narrowed down and has little to do with the fact bat coronaviruses are found over a wide range.

Which viruses are we talking about?

RaTG13 is 96% similar to SARS CoV2

According to Wikipedia:

It was discovered in 2013 in bat droppings from a mining cave near the town of Tongguan in Mojiang county in Yunnan, China. As of 2020, it is the closest known relative of SARS-CoV-2, the virus that causes COVID-19

I've been reading a bit about the genetics of COVID 19, I'll post the inks and specifics later. But there is a general principle here that needs addressing.

There is a bat strain that is about 97ish% a match for COVID. And either all or just the spike protein of the pangolins is about the same, 97%.
Given the genetics and assuming a recombinant event, it does not get you to COVID-19. It's not close enough. I brought this up earlier, chimpanzee DNA is ~99% match for human DNA. And look how different we are.
...
With the bat COVID relative being ~97% different from COVID-19, you can't just take the pangolin COVID relative and end up with a virus capable of infecting human cells no matter how you recombine the viruses.

...

97% might sound like a very close match, but as far as genomes go, it's not close. Chimpanzees are not like Neanderthals, they are not close enough to breed with humans (think in vitro). 98.8% is not close enough...

As for it being a natural event, the evidence is clear that it was. But such recombinant events can be coaxed in the lab and that is what there is at least some question the researchers were working with coronaviruses where such a 'natural' event could have taken place.

So...forgive my confusion, but when I talked about related viruses, you yourself ahile back said that they are not related. Now, you say they are.

And it looks to me as though you were claiming some kind of genetic alterations being done in the lab.

This is why I am confused.
 
I want to carry on this discussion with you, angrysoba, and I will . But you need to follow the discussion.

Yes, I did say that. Yes it's not a problem. If you'd been following you might understand we've been gathering evidence and posting it throughout the thread. My position, and I believe Sherkeu's as well have been developing. You expect the case to be established from the beginning of the thread but that is not the case.

For example, I'm correcting the molecular time frame yet again BECAUSE I HAVE NEW EVIDENCE.

More than one researcher tracked the timing of the first case back using the molecular clock. One said the end of Oct. One said the middle of Oct. But I now find one researcher who believes the clock shows the first case in Wuhan was in early Sept based on the molecular clock. These people are using good science. There is a discrepancy in the timeline but they are all essentially on the same page.

Now there is corroborating evidence the Sept date for the first case is right. The Chinese government moved at that time to start removing any evidence that might exist implicating the WIV.
They may not have known at that time the virus had been beyond stopping. And the scenario sounds just like a movie.

An accident occurs at the level 4 bio-safety lab. Someone got infected. No one is absolutely sure the exposed worker (or student) didn't pass it on. But this person took the mass transit line 2. Posted upthread:

COVID-19 Origin and Spread Linked to PLA Hospital and Wuhan Metro System Line 2 by Physician-Scientist Dr. Steven Quay

The researchers know an accident occurred. They probably knew it because at least one person developed symptoms. The government acted right away covering up any research with a dangerous coronavirus they know had infected human cells in vitro.

Is there any other explanation for the removal of all the files in Sept that might contain this research? Come on, any explanation?
I'm not sure this was widely known in the WIV. Daszak knows what he was working on. Did he know about the lab accident at the time it happened?

Someone needs to ask Daszak why he thinks the Chinese government purged (or tried to given it was discovered and the database viewed) the data bases of the WIV's genomic work with dangerous coronaviruses.
It's very likely the government was unaware the infection had gone from an accident to an outbreak until the cluster of pneumonia cases related to the seafood market emerged in early Dec. It was too late at that time to stop it. I don't believe the government would have been able to contact trace everyone who the initial accident person had contact with.

So coverup, yes. Incompetence to stop it before it spread around and out of Wuhan, no, I don't think so. The US would not have been able to do any better. You are trying to contain a contagious disease but it's already potentially spread within a large city.

This is my hypothesis to date.

Give me more evidence and I might revise that position. But I do believe the pieces are coming together.
There still needs to be that initial viral culture in the WIV that matches COVID 19. And it may have been effectively purged.

Look at the alternative hypothesis that it was a jump (spillover) from a pangolin or even a horseshoe bat and there is no growing body of evidence to support that hypothesis.
 
I want to carry on this discussion with you, angrysoba, and I will . But you need to follow the discussion.

Yes, I did say that. Yes it's not a problem. If you'd been following you might understand we've been gathering evidence and posting it throughout the thread. My position, and I believe Sherkeu's as well have been developing. You expect the case to be established from the beginning of the thread but that is not the case.

For example, I'm correcting the molecular time frame yet again BECAUSE I HAVE NEW EVIDENCE.

More than one researcher tracked the timing of the first case back using the molecular clock. One said the end of Oct. One said the middle of Oct. But I now find one researcher who believes the clock shows the first case in Wuhan was in early Sept based on the molecular clock. These people are using good science. There is a discrepancy in the timeline but they are all essentially on the same page.

Now there is corroborating evidence the Sept date for the first case is right. The Chinese government moved at that time to start removing any evidence that might exist implicating the WIV.
They may not have known at that time the virus had been beyond stopping. And the scenario sounds just like a movie.

An accident occurs at the level 4 bio-safety lab. Someone got infected. No one is absolutely sure the exposed worker (or student) didn't pass it on. But this person took the mass transit line 2. Posted upthread:

COVID-19 Origin and Spread Linked to PLA Hospital and Wuhan Metro System Line 2 by Physician-Scientist Dr. Steven Quay

The researchers know an accident occurred. They probably knew it because at least one person developed symptoms. The government acted right away covering up any research with a dangerous coronavirus they know had infected human cells in vitro.

Is there any other explanation for the removal of all the files in Sept that might contain this research? Come on, any explanation?
I'm not sure this was widely known in the WIV. Daszak knows what he was working on. Did he know about the lab accident at the time it happened?

Someone needs to ask Daszak why he thinks the Chinese government purged (or tried to given it was discovered and the database viewed) the data bases of the WIV's genomic work with dangerous coronaviruses.
It's very likely the government was unaware the infection had gone from an accident to an outbreak until the cluster of pneumonia cases related to the seafood market emerged in early Dec. It was too late at that time to stop it. I don't believe the government would have been able to contact trace everyone who the initial accident person had contact with.

So coverup, yes. Incompetence to stop it before it spread around and out of Wuhan, no, I don't think so. The US would not have been able to do any better. You are trying to contain a contagious disease but it's already potentially spread within a large city.

This is my hypothesis to date.

Give me more evidence and I might revise that position. But I do believe the pieces are coming together.
There still needs to be that initial viral culture in the WIV that matches COVID 19. And it may have been effectively purged.

Look at the alternative hypothesis that it was a jump (spillover) from a pangolin or even a horseshoe bat and there is no growing body of evidence to support that hypothesis.

Okay, but just for the benefit of anyone reading this, the red stuff and what follows from it are complete speculation.

The blue stuff is also conjecture.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom