Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
From the Science paper bibio: Human-animal interactions and bat coronavirus spillover potential among rural residents in Southern China

Published Nov 9, 2019 so before the outbreak was recognized but close to that time. Daszak is one of the authors.
This study provides the first serological evidence of bat-borne SARSr-CoVs and HKU10-CoV transmission to people and highlights potential spillover pathways through animal contact. Given the high diversity and recombination rate of bat coronaviruses, and close relationship of SARSr-CoVs to SARS-CoV, it is possible that exposure to these coronaviruses may lead to disease emergence in human populations.

All tangentially related to the lab-leak hypothesis until you get to the last paragraph:
Considering the proven potential of some SARSr-CoVs currently circulating in bats in southern China, to infect human cells, cause clinical signs in humanized mouse models, and lead to infections that cannot be treated with monoclonal therapies effective against SARS-CoV [[58], [59], [60]], this represents a clear and present danger to our biosafety and public health.
You wouldn't know that from looking at genome data alone. You would only know that if one were experimenting with live virus in the lab.

I'm looking at more, watch this space.
 
From the Science paper bibio: Human-animal interactions and bat coronavirus spillover potential among rural residents in Southern China

Published Nov 9, 2019 so before the outbreak was recognized but close to that time. Daszak is one of the authors.


All tangentially related to the lab-leak hypothesis until you get to the last paragraph:You wouldn't know that from looking at genome data alone. You would only know that if one were experimenting with live virus in the lab.

I'm looking at more, watch this space.


On this, and to give you some thing you might be interested in, Peter Daszak did indeed make a number of tweets around November 2019 to that effect.

I saw the screenshots of them but will have to look again. Someone reposted them on Twitter and they do look interesting, to say the least.

At this point, I would have to agree with you that there are certainly huge issues of transparency. If virologists are unconcerned about a lab leak, as they argue they are, then they have done a pretty poor job of explaining what it is they are looking at that makes them think a natural spillover event is head and shoulders the most likely.
 
It isn't. You posted that before as well.

Hard to believe since I never saw it before. :boggled:

Care to comment on the revelation Daszak himself was doing research on live bat coronavirus cultures in the WIV and showed SARS-like viruses could be coaxed to infect human cells in vitro?

That I did post before but not those specifics.

They even named it for the location they were working: Bat SARS-like coronavirus WIV1

Gee, what does the WIV1 stand for?

Bat SARS-like coronavirus WIV1 (Bat SL-CoV-WIV1), also sometimes called SARS-like coronavirus WIV1, is a strain of Severe acute respiratory syndrome-related coronavirus (SARSr-CoV) isolated from Chinese rufous horseshoe bats (Rhinolophus sinicus).[1][2] Like all coronaviruses, virions consist of single-stranded positive-sense RNA enclosed within an envelope.[3]

The discovery confirms that bats are the natural reservoir of SARS-CoV. Phylogenetic analysis shows the possibility of direct transmission of SARS from bats to humans without the intermediary Chinese civets, as previously believed.[4]
Alone that only speaks to phylogenetic analysis but Daszax discusses taking it further.
 
Last edited:
From the Science paper bibio: Human-animal interactions and bat coronavirus spillover potential among rural residents in Southern China

Published Nov 9, 2019 so before the outbreak was recognized but close to that time. Daszak is one of the authors.


All tangentially related to the lab-leak hypothesis until you get to the last paragraph:You wouldn't know that from looking at genome data alone. You would only know that if one were experimenting with live virus in the lab.

I'm looking at more, watch this space.

Seems like the paper they published in 2018 was rolled into the 2019 paper in your post.
(2018: testing done in 2015, 2019 testing done 2015-17). If it wasn't, it would be odd not to mention the previous findings. Shi and Daszak are on both.

In the 2018 paper they compared the villagers samples (n=218), all within 3mi of the 2 most interesting bat caves, to a similar sample size from Wuhan (n=240). Testing found 6 positives, all Yunnan villagers.
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6178078/

The 2.7% seropositivity for the high risk group of residents living in close proximity to bat colonies suggests that spillover is a relatively rare event, however this depends on how long antibodies persist in people, since other individuals may have been exposed and antibodies waned. During questioning, none of the 6 seropositive subjects could recall any clinical symptoms in the past 12 months, suggesting that their bat SARSr-CoV infection either occurred before the time of sampling, or that infections were subclinical or caused only mild symptoms. Our previous work based on cellular and humanized mouse infection studies suggest that these viruses are less virulent than SARS-CoV

In the 2019 paper with expanded testing (1,497) to areas outside Yunnan with farming and wildlife, the SARS-CoV responsive samples are still all from Yunnan (but now there are 7 positives). The findings in the 2019 one expand to animal and food safety and non-sars illnesses from unsanitary practices. First one was mainly about the bats.
 
Last edited:
Other than that, it confirms what Sherkeu and I have been posting.
This appears to be in response to a link I posted and I would just like to go on record right now that I have no idea if what I posted confirms anything Sherkeu and Skeptic Ginger have said.
 
This appears to be in response to a link I posted and I would just like to go on record right now that I have no idea if what I posted confirms anything Sherkeu and Skeptic Ginger have said.
I don't care if you do or don't have any idea that it confirms anything. :boggled:

It does and is easily checked. We've been discussing the genome mutation record that establishes the timing of the first cases: mid Oct to mid Nov in Wuhan before the seafood market super-spreader event.

And at that point the virus was ready to go, no period needed to simmer in Wuhan or anywhere else while it further adapted to human cells.

We have also discussed the antibody trail looking at cases much earlier and I've posted a discussion of research that those antibodies are not specific enough so they are not reliable: i.e. it's a red herring.


I should also like to point out that we've found and posted a lot of material that backs up Dr Quay's 2 papers and nothing that refutes his hypothesis.


Are we there yet, are we there yet? I do believe we are close. And Peter Daszak especially doesn't want anyone looking for a lab leak.

I should like to point out as a side note that the more I have learned about Daszak besides this big lab leak problem, I think the projects his organization has been working on sound fantastic! Believe it or not, I no longer think he was only interested in keeping his research grants going for personal reasons. IOW I don't think the issue here was financial gain for himself. He wants to stop the wildlife markets.

But he's still an ass for not disclosing his work at the WIV which is an important piece of evidence the scientific community needs.
 
Last edited:
This one...

Thank you for finding that. Guess it's what happens to one's memory as one ages.

The thing is, I only had some of the story at that time. And I didn't know as much about Daszak as I do now.

Now I do have more evidence to go on.

I'm looking for the last piece of evidence right now. While a segment of the COVID genome matches the coronavirus in a pangolin, the rest of the pangolin coronavirus is not a match. In fact the bat viruses are much more closely related.

I'm looking for more information about a bat virus picking up that genome segment in the wild. I already mentioned the coronavirus from a bat could have infected a pangolin and then been passed back to the bat.

And of course, the coincidence this virus emerged near the lab that was studying bat coronaviruses close to SARS genetically cannot be dismissed until a pangolin is found with COVID 19. And that doesn't look very likely.
 
And of course, the coincidence this virus emerged near the lab that was studying bat coronaviruses close to SARS genetically cannot be dismissed until a pangolin is found with COVID 19. And that doesn't look very likely.
I don't dismiss the possibility it was an accidental lab leak, it certainly can't be ruled out, but is that really a coincidence? The lab's location wasn't chosen by sticking a pin randomly in a map, I assume some thought went into it.
 
I don't dismiss the possibility it was an accidental lab leak, it certainly can't be ruled out, but is that really a coincidence? The lab's location wasn't chosen by sticking a pin randomly in a map, I assume some thought went into it.
The key issue is that there is a solution.
The Chinese can and will prevent the balance of the world from understanding why their lives were wrecked.
 
Thank you for finding that. Guess it's what happens to one's memory as one ages.

The thing is, I only had some of the story at that time. And I didn't know as much about Daszak as I do now.

Now I do have more evidence to go on.

I'm looking for the last piece of evidence right now. While a segment of the COVID genome matches the coronavirus in a pangolin, the rest of the pangolin coronavirus is not a match. In fact the bat viruses are much more closely related.

I'm looking for more information about a bat virus picking up that genome segment in the wild. I already mentioned the coronavirus from a bat could have infected a pangolin and then been passed back to the bat.

And of course, the coincidence this virus emerged near the lab that was studying bat coronaviruses close to SARS genetically cannot be dismissed until a pangolin is found with COVID 19. And that doesn't look very likely.

Okay, but this is where things get way, way complicated, from what I understand.

The way that most virologists are talking is something like this...

...yeah, sure, in theory it is possible for it to escape from a lab, and such lab escapes have happened in the past.

But most of the arguments that it escaped from the lab are not just "It's right there in Wuhan" but they also include "Daszak and the WIV have been dicking around with the virus and this is the virus that has escaped."

So, the evidence that the particular virus we are talking about has escaped should be in the genome somewhere.

Some people are looking at various parts of it and saying, "Oh look, this is the bit! This bit proves that there has been some kind of manipulation of the virus!"

BUT.... the way that most virologists have been talking, either on Twitter, in pre-prints, in peer-reviewed papers, and on podcasts such as TWiV is that...no... this does not look like this. It really looks just like a natural spillover.

Do I understand any of it? Absolutely not. So what do you do when you don't understand the particular science? Well, you have to put your trust in those that do.

So, anyway, just today, on TWiV, there are a group of virologists talking about this. I have to say that I don't understand what they are talking about. For the most part they are pretty engrossed in the nitty gritty details and then they do a little aside, beginning somewhere around 20 or 25 minutes in which they talk about how there are some lab leak theories and how the stuff they are talking about makes this really unlikely.

The whole thing is quite long and I am listening to it now, but maybe you might be interested in it...

 
I don't dismiss the possibility it was an accidental lab leak, it certainly can't be ruled out, but is that really a coincidence? The lab's location wasn't chosen by sticking a pin randomly in a map, I assume some thought went into it.

From my understanding, Wuhan, and Hubei in particular are not particularly well known for either:

a) SARSr viruses
b) the types of wildlife trade and culinary culture that was much more common in the south of China such as Guangzhou where the first SARS outbreak begun, and which was seen as a major cause of the problem.

That said, neither are completely unknown, and the response to SARS that happened in China, namely the closure and sanitization of a lot of wet markets drove a lot of the trade underground making it more difficult to trace.

Apparently also, there had been a state-sponsored programme of having rural and poorer provinces in China sell certain types of wildlife to the big cities and Wuhan is the ninth largest city in China.

I think the scientists who believe this is a zoonotic spillover are looking perhaps for traces of the virus sputtering and dying out until eventually there was a full-fledged emergence.

David Quammen in his book, Spillover (£4.37 on KindleAmazon.co.uk) or $5.99 on Kindle in the US Amazon defines emergence as this...

"an infectious disease whose incidence is increasing following its first introduction into a new host population".

So, I wonder if there has been some confusion here.

From what I can see, it could be that the "spillover" event is specifically the first moment when a pathogen moves from one species to another, while emergence is the increase in new infections.

If virologists are talking about the market being a superspreader event that allowed the virus to get a proper foothold on the human population then from what I understand, that might be what they mean by saying it emerged there.

It would not necessarily mean that that was the moment of spillover from bats (or an amplifying host) to humans.

By the way, there are a few passages that I have read in Spillover that might make some people's hair stand on end. I will hopefully get round to sharing them soon, but they are related to SARS.

That said, I really recommend reading the book. It has given me a view of viruses that I think makes me sympathize with the views of those who argue for a zoonotic cause.
 
Anyway, I think we need to be a little bit cautious about how much we use some rhetoric about some of the scientists here.

Basically, the conclusion is the difference between saying that the people who have invested their lives in investigating viruses that they have been warning could result in millions of deaths worldwide either:

a) should have been listened to more carefully

OR

b) have been responsible for these deaths
 
I don't care if you do or don't have any idea that it confirms anything. :boggled:

It does and is easily checked. We've been discussing the genome mutation record that establishes the timing of the first cases: mid Oct to mid Nov in Wuhan before the seafood market super-spreader event.
That is not an accurate description of what you and Sherkeu have been claiming.
 
I don't dismiss the possibility it was an accidental lab leak, it certainly can't be ruled out, but is that really a coincidence? The lab's location wasn't chosen by sticking a pin randomly in a map, I assume some thought went into it.
It's a good question. Here is the answer:

They built the level 4 biological safety lab at the University of Wuhan. It's one of China's best universities and had a whole program on virology with a level 3 lab.

State Key Laboratory of Virology

about
The State Key Laboratory of Virology (SKLV)was established in 2004, founded by the Ministry of Science and Technology of China, and supported byWuhan University and Wuhan Institute of Virology, Chinese Academy of Sciences.Up to date, it has been recognized national wide for studying virology, training high level talents, and conducting scientific collaboration in China and abroad and has became the most active center for virology research.

2004 was circa the SARS epidemic when China undertook SARS research (as did labs in other countries.) The initial SARS research was carried on in Beijing.

SARS escaped Beijing lab twice
"We suspect two people, a 26-year-old female postgraduate student and a 31-year-old male postdoc, were both infected, apparently in two separate incidents," Bob Dietz, WHO spokesman in Beijing, told us.

The woman was admitted to hospital on April 4, but the man apparently became infected independently 2 weeks later, being hospitalized on April 17. Both worked at the Chinese Institute of Virology in Beijing, part of China's Center for Disease Control.
So they could have built the level 4 biological safety lab there but the University in Wuhan was chosen as a superior option.


From the first link:
SKLV has cutting-edge technology platforms, such as ChinaCenter for Type Culture Collection, China Viral Resources and Information Center,Biological Safety Level 3 Laboratory, Biological Safety Level 3 AnimalLaboratory, and Biological Safety Level 4 Laboratory (In construction).
The level 4 lab had since been completed just before the COVID outbreak.

And it should be noted that as they began research in the level 4 lab, it was reported the staff complained they were understaffed and especially didn't have enough people who were familiar a level 4 lab. The link is here somewhere, I'll have to find it. They were pleading for more funding from the US.


So there is nothing particularly risky in the area. The bat caves where they collected specimens was 800 miles away,
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom