Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
So, Vincent and Amy did get a question:

"Where did the virus come from? WIV?"

Their answer is no...

https://youtu.be/ydYwVis9zvE?t=1100

ETA: Another from the same person:

"Is it possible it started in bats. Was taken to WIB where they did gain of funciton serial passage research?"

Vincent's answer: "no. You can make up anything..."

https://youtu.be/ydYwVis9zvE?t=3120

Next: "Frozen food is being named as a source of origin in Wuhan being pushed by Dyzak [sic]... is that a joke? How much does the CCP pay him and how serious is frozen food as a vector?"

https://youtu.be/ydYwVis9zvE?t=3405

Vincent's Answer: "I don't think frozen food is a source. I think there is no evidence for that."
 
Last edited:
Scientists know now that Sars-COV-2 was circulating globally back in November
This isn't accurate. There are now known very few isolated cases from November, not "circulating globally". Which isn't inconsistent with what has been known for a long time about the expected time of origin for Covid.
 
This is all well and good but that's not how an epidemiological investigation works. You don't start out with your preconceived conclusion and go from there. Peter Daszak openly asserted it was not from the lab before he went on the WHO team investigation as well.

It's not a "preconceived idea" it's an educated assessment based on the fact that in the initial stages of it's exponential growth curve the highest number of cases are most likely to be centred on the place it's been reproducing the longest.

If evidence comes forward in favor of some other local I'll certainly consider it and I fully support WHO investigators looking for other plausible locals. Such searches are important, because the harder we for other locals without finding evidence, the more likely it becomes that the fish market was indeed where the crossover occurred. If we consider the weight of the evidence NOW, however ,it favors the fish market as the location of initial transmission.
 
It doesn't mean they aren't closely related, just that the differences are enough to put some point of divergence between them. They have some way of calculating (or rather estimating) how long it takes to mutate.
From earlier reports I have read it seems that viruses can be many decades past divergence are still considered very similar. (eta: of course in this sars-cov-2 case it would be a short time period)

I agree that the data is there (somewhere) to get closer to knowing. Unfortunately, not many people are allowed access to the crucial early patient data or other early samples. That is one of the things WHO asked for last month but were denied. A report is supposedly due out this week.
I knew my adjectives were going to cause trouble. Sorry about that.

It's tracing clades and seeing a mutation in one that all the subsequent virus that follows will have that mutation. But the strains not connected to the market don't have that 'marker'.

I wouldn't put too much credence in the final WHO report if it is going to blame a wet market exposure to a pangolin.

I notice there is now mention of other wet markets in Wuhan that could have been the place of the initial jump. The problem remains, there are people not connected to any wet market. If one is going to claim maybe it was a different market to confirm one's bias, one still needs to demonstrate the pathway, not just say well it could have been.

Or we can just look at 'could have been we don't know', that's fine. But to say that and then definitively rule out the lab because we are told it wasn't them is not fine.
 
Last edited:
Yes, a report is due soon, by the WHO investigative team.

I think once it comes out, maybe it will give more of a clearer picture of why they see a wildlife link as being far more likely than a lab leak.

In fact, the suggestions of early spread both elsewhere in China and abroad are some of the things that reduce the lab leak hypothesis.

China in fact have said they wanted more investigations to take place abroad, particularly in Europe (which is something that other commentators have pooh-poohed as China trying to absolve itself of responsibility etc...).

Daszak and others in the WHO team have said they wanted to see testing along the routes of the wildlife trade, suggesting that people in some of the wildlife farms may have been infected by Covid-19 and been unaware of it.

Maybe there will be maps of the genetic sequences as well.

I think we will just have to wait and see.

Wishful thinking.

The preliminary report simply denied the lab leak without evidence. Daszak denied it was the lab before the team even left. The head of the team said the lab was not ruled out. Now Daszak has some "new information" from China about wildlife farms.

I believe Daszak even suggested if China shut down the many-dollar wildlife farming industry that is the smoking gun. He said the same about the market. China shut the market that means they had evidence it was.

How is it there is new evidence that the team didn't have after their trip to investigate. Gee, no one believed us when we ruled the lab out without evidence. Better come up with some.

BTW regarding the smoking gun of China closing the wildlife industry down, they also scrubbed a lot of stuff from the lab.
 
Last edited:
So, Vincent and Amy did get a question:

"Where did the virus come from? WIV?"

Their answer is no...

https://youtu.be/ydYwVis9zvE?t=1100

ETA: Another from the same person:

"Is it possible it started in bats. Was taken to WIB where they did gain of funciton serial passage research?"

Vincent's answer: "no. You can make up anything..."

https://youtu.be/ydYwVis9zvE?t=3120

Next: "Frozen food is being named as a source of origin in Wuhan being pushed by Dyzak [sic]... is that a joke? How much does the CCP pay him and how serious is frozen food as a vector?"

https://youtu.be/ydYwVis9zvE?t=3405

Vincent's Answer: "I don't think frozen food is a source. I think there is no evidence for that."
I don't know who Vincent and Amy are but the denial any such research was going on at the lab has been repeated. The evidence: researchers at the lab said so.

I and Sherku have posted evidence to the contrary including papers on their research before COVID 19 emerged meaning before they (the Chinese government) scrubbed the information off the web.

And we posted evidence how the Gain of Function research on live cultures in the WIV led to a SARS-like coronavirus from the horseshoe bats being able to infect human cells.

There was also evidence they may have had live bats there.
 
Wishful thinking.

The preliminary report simply denied the lab leak without evidence. Daszak denied it was the lab before the team even left. The head of the team said the lab was not ruled out. Now Daszak has some "new information" from China about wildlife farms.

I believe Daszak even suggested if China shut down the many-dollar wildlife farming industry that is the smoking gun. He said the same about the market. China shut the market that means they had evidence it was.

How is it there is new evidence that the team didn't have after their trip to investigate. Gee, no one believed us when we ruled the lab out without evidence. Better come up with some.

BTW regarding the smoking gun of China closing the wildlife industry down, they also scrubbed a lot of stuff from the lab.

Let's see what the initial report from the WHO said in March 2020:

What have we learned from the investigations of the first known human COVID-19 cases?
As soon as the first cases of COVID-19 were reported in late December 2019, investigations were conducted to understand the
epidemiology of COVID-19 and the original source of the outbreak. A large proportion of the initial cases in late December 2019 and early January 2020 had a direct link to the Huanan Wholesale Seafood Market in Wuhan City, where seafood, wild, and farmed animal species were sold. Many of the initial patients were either stall owners, market employees, or regular visitors to this market.Environmental samples taken from this market in December 2019 tested positive for SARS-CoV-2, further suggesting that the market in Wuhan City was the source of this outbreak or played a role in the initial amplification of the outbreak. The market was
closed on 1 January 2020 and was cleaned and disinfected. The virus could have been introduced into the human population from an animal source in the market or an infected human could have introduced the virus to the market and the virus may have then been amplified in the market environment.Origin of SARS-CoV-2
-2-
Subsequent investigations into the first human cases have determined that they had onset of symptoms around 1 December 2019. However, these cases had no direct link to the Huanan Wholesale Seafood Market and they may therefore have been infected in November through contact with earlier undetected cases (incubation time between date of exposure and date of symptom onset can be up to 14 days). Additional studies are ongoing to as whether unrecognized infections in humans may have happened as early as
mid-November 2019

LINK

So unlike some of the very definitive statements being made by lab-leak theorists, the WHO report simply said the market had an important role (may have been the source OR may have been an amplifier). This is pretty much where the WHO still are, and yet their statements are being read as though they have been deliberately crafted to be deceptive.

I think some of the lab-leak theorists could do with being a little more nuanced in their theorizing and less definitive and categorical otherwise it becomes very confusing.

I keep assuming that some of the things that Skeptic Ginger and Sherkeu are saying are demonstrated facts but more often than not they turn out to be mere suspicions or they are repeating speculation as though it had been confidently asserted by qualified specialists. Often, it may be speculation or the assertions have been made by non-specialists, sometimes involving politicized statements by mostly right-wing figures.
 
Let's see what the initial report from the WHO said in March 2020:

LINK

So unlike some of the very definitive statements being made by lab-leak theorists, the WHO report simply said the market had an important role (may have been the source OR may have been an amplifier).
We know from the evidence it is the latter. That is specific genetic markers, not someone's hypothesis.


This is pretty much where the WHO still are, and yet their statements are being read as though they have been deliberately crafted to be deceptive.
If you would have listened to the podcast you posted you would know this is not the case. Other than Daszak's conflict of interest the limitation in the WHO investigation has to do with the political position the WHO needs to maintain with China (as with many larger countries) and the unwillingness because of that to challenge the evidence China did not allow the team access to.


I think some of the lab-leak theorists could do with being a little more nuanced in their theorizing and less definitive and categorical otherwise it becomes very confusing.

I keep assuming that some of the things that Skeptic Ginger and Sherkeu are saying are demonstrated facts but more often than not they turn out to be mere suspicions or they are repeating speculation as though it had been confidently asserted by qualified specialists. Often, it may be speculation or the assertions have been made by non-specialists, sometimes involving politicized statements by mostly right-wing figures.
Care to argue the specifics rather than this general handwaving away claim?
True, and more than a little ironic.
You got the ironic part right.
 
We know from the evidence it is the latter. That is specific genetic markers, not someone's hypothesis.


If you would have listened to the podcast you posted you would know this is not the case. Other than Daszak's conflict of interest the limitation in the WHO investigation has to do with the political position the WHO needs to maintain with China (as with many larger countries) and the unwillingness because of that to challenge the evidence China did not allow the team access to.

Care to argue the specifics rather than this general handwaving away claim?
You got the ironic part right.

If you mean the Rogan clip and his talk with Jamie Metzl I did listen to it.

I get it, you keep repeating the conflict of interest that Daszak has. I get it already!
 
Let's see what the initial report from the WHO said in March 2020:
LINK
...
Getting back to this link to the WHO statement, I'm not sure what your point is. You have so much highlighted it was hard to tell.

Did you see the date on that FAQ on the Origin of SARS-CoV-2? March 2020.

Know when the investigative team went to China? Jan 2021.

So you might want to consider all of that open-mindedness the WHO had back in March and compare it to what they had to say after their visit.

NPR: WHO Team Reconstructs Origins Of Coronavirus Outbreak In Wuhan - February 16, 2021
NPR's Steve Inskeep speaks to Marion Koopmans, ...

KOOPMANS: So the first cases that were detected were linked to the market, but it's clear that - so now there's a bigger list of cases that are confirmed. And it's clear that not everyone is linked to the market., China, to investigate the beginning of the COVID-19 outbreak. ...

The market has been one of those spreading events, but there also was circulation outside of - or aside from the market.
If you weren't looking at a 10 month old document you wouldn't have to question whether or not the market was the initial start.

She goes on:
But even if you then have a case that has not linked to the market, because of this stealth mechanism of spread, it can still be linked somehow - but because someone picked up an infection from another person that was at the market.
But now we have genetic evidence there is not a direct link from the market to the other patients. (See Sherkeu's last 2 posts.)


KOOPMANS: Yeah, yeah, yeah. Sure. So from everything that we've looked at and we've also visited three labs in (unintelligible) and also three labs that work on these viruses. From that, we have not been able to find any credible link there.

INSKEEP: How open and transparent were the Chinese once they let you in?

KOOPMANS: Of course, this is a topic and a mission that is - there are sensitivities around it, if only for the - there's, of course, big political tensions that are around it. And that's something you cannot completely avoid in a situation like this. But once we got out of our quarantine, got into the face-to-face meetings, I think we've managed to get into real good scientific exchange with stiff discussions here and there because to start from different backgrounds and different views. But I tell everyone, wait and - read the report, and let's discuss then. But I think we managed to get a good outcome of this meeting. I think it was, in that sense, quite successful. ...

KOOPMANS: Not really. So if you say, did the Chinese colleagues hand over the complete raw data files? No, they did not. But then again, I did not expect that in a mission like this. So we've seen a lot of information. We've been given a lot of information.
IOW, no they didn't give us free access but we think we got good interviews. :rolleyes:

You think you see definitive evidence in that interview the lab was ruled out?
 
Last edited:
She goes on:But now we have genetic evidence there is not a direct link from the market to the other patients. (See Sherkeu's last 2 posts.)

I don't get it.

Sherkeu's posts arguing that it wasn't the Wuhan wet market have been claiming that the virus had been circulating in Europe and other places.

Well, that's one way to dispose of the wet market theory if you absolutely must, but then it also massively reduces the evidence that it came from the WIV, doesn't it.

Instead of "Huh! Bit of a coincidence that the market was right next to the WIV!" it becomes, "Oh, you mean Wuhan may not even have been the epicenter!"

Sorry, at this point, I don't even understand what the lab leak theory is even suppposed to be:

Is it:

"Right off the bat" (a bit infected a worker who left with it?)
"Gain of function" (the scientists altered it in a lab themselves through manipulation and then left with it).
"Out the sewage pipes"
"Sold to the market"
"Somebody got it in Wuhan Institute of Virology from a bat then did gain of function on it, went skiing in Italy, spread it around Europe, then came back to China, went up and down on the subway etc..."

Or how about this...

"Someone went to Yunnan, picked up the bat, took it with them to Wuhan, released it from the third floor of the building. It had the Covid-19, but then the workers also did gain of function to make it more susceptible to human transmission, and now they are looking for that particular bat colony in Yunnan, but they are trying to stop others finding out what they already know about it..."

Or something like that....?
 
Italy:
Evidence of SARS-CoV-2 RNA in an Oropharyngeal Swab Specimen, Milan, Italy, Early December 2019
https://wwwnc.cdc.gov/eid/article/27/2/20-4632_article

Summary article:
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/research/coronavirus/publication/33176598
...
I'll come back to the other countries when I have time. I think we are getting closer to a map going back to the beginning.

The CDC data in your first link is consistent with the phylogenic tree in my link but the second one showing antibodies earlier is not.

The first two cases of 2019‐nCoV in Italy: Where they come from?
The Bayesian phylogenetic reconstruction showed that 2019‐2020 nCoV firstly introduced in Wuhan on 25 November 2019, started epidemic transmission reaching many countries worldwide, including Europe and Italy where the two strains isolated dated back 19 January 2020, the same that the Chinese tourists arrived in Italy. Strains isolated outside China were intermixed with strains isolated in China as evidence of likely imported cases in Rome, Italy, and Europe, as well. In conclusion, this report suggests that further spread of 2019‐nCoV epidemic was supported by human mobility and that quarantine of suspected or diagnosed cases is useful to prevent further transmission.

When one is looking at antibodies in serum from specimens collected for other reasons (one study looked at blood from blood bank donors) and your link looking at serum from cancer screening, my first question is why didn't they perform the most obvious control tests: test serum stored a year or more ago?

It's not likely that you'd find antibodies from COVID 19 in these stored serums because they represent a fraction of the population. There would have had to have been COVID 19 circulating widely for a small sample to contain them.

Well here's one study that did just that, looked at serum stored well before the COVID pandemic:

Pre-existing coronavirus antibodies could protect against new COVID-19 strains
The researchers made this discovery while developing highly sensitive antibody tests for COVID-19. To see how well their assay tests were performing, they compared the blood of patients with COVID-19 to patients who had not had the disease. They found that some people who had not been exposed to SARS-CoV-2 had antibodies in their blood which would recognise the virus. To confirm their findings, they analysed over 300 blood samples collected before the pandemic, between 2011 and 2018.

Nearly all samples had antibodies that reacted with common cold coronaviruses. However, a small fraction of adult donors, about one in 20, also had antibodies that cross-reacted with SARS-CoV-2 and this was not dependent on recent infection with a common cold coronavirus.

So the evidence COVID 19 was in Italy in Dec 2019 is strong. The evidence from blood tests showing antibodies sooner than Oct 2019 is weak at best.
 
I don't get it.

Sherkeu's posts arguing that it wasn't the Wuhan wet market have been claiming that the virus had been circulating in Europe and other places.

Well, that's one way to dispose of the wet market theory if you absolutely must, but then it also massively reduces the evidence that it came from the WIV, doesn't it.
[snip]

Or something like that....?
You are not looking carefully at the data, you are looking at the headlines and a couple paragraphs. See my post above where I looked at the kind of tests done and the reliability of that testing.

Look at this phylogenic tree from my link to get an idea how one traces genomes.
 
Last edited:
You are not looking carefully at the data, you are looking at the headlines and a couple paragraphs. See my post above where I looked at the kind of tests done and the reliability of that testing.

Look at this phylogenic tree from my link to get an idea how one traces genomes.

So where on that tree are the ones that were "circulating globally" in November (or late summer)?

If that's the claim, then what use is that tree?
 
So where on that tree are the ones that were "circulating globally" in November (or late summer)?

If that's the claim, then what use is that tree?

You seem to want "globally" to mean all over the world. The first case was in late Oct or early Nov in Wuhan based on genetic mapping using the rate of mutation as a clock.

By Dec (and maybe as early as late Nov), cases started spreading around China and nearby countries, to Europe, the US and those cruise ships.

That is globally.

A phylogenic tree will show where cases began and where they went.
 
Last edited:
Look at the phylogenic tree. Cases went from Wuhan to the US before they went from Wuhan to Italy. They also spread to France, Germany and Australia in separate pathways. It's pretty clear from that data that all roads lead back to Wuhan.
 
You seem to want "globally" to mean all over the world.

Stop that!

This is getting tiresome when you start making up things that I "seem" to be saying when I have not said anything remotely similar to what you say I "seem" to be saying.

As far as I understand, Wuhan is the location of the emergence of Covid-19.

Do you agree with that? Yes or No.

Now, there is a question about whether or not the wet market had a role in the emergence, isn't there? Yes or No.

Now, one reason some people think otherwise is because some early victims had no connection to the wet market, right? Yes or No.

If that's the case, then we might look elsewhere for the emergence, right? Yes or No.

If the earliest case is December 8th apparently from someone who never visited the market, then this gives rise to doubts about it emerging in the wet market, right? Yes or No.

So how do we explain it? At this point eyes turn to another place in Wuhan... the Wuhan Institute of Virology! Hmmmm...they are doing bat research there with cultures of SARSr...

But then...Sherkeu is saying oh yeah and there may have been cases abroad, in France, Italy, the US as far back as November....

But wait...wait...wait... how does that square with the escaped from the WIV theory?

:confused:

To be honest, that is what I would expect China to want you to believe! Hey maybe it didn't start in Wuhan at all...etc...Maybe not even in China!!

Obviously this is not what I think, but where does this "circulating globally" theory however you define it help the case that it came from the WIV? What is the connection?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom