Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
Peter Daszak is talking here to MSNBC about origins of Covid-19 and the report that is to come out.

I don't claim to be good at spotting anyone being shifty or lying, etc... but he comes across as pretty genuine to me and explains why he thinks it is likely to have originated from the wildlife farms, and why it is unlikely to have emerged from a lab:

https://www.msnbc.com/ayman-mohyeld...19-origins-expected-within-weeks-108171333677
 
You ignoring evidence cited in this thread doesn't make your position true. I'm not saying [whatever you think], I am telling you what we have found sources refuting and ruling out your hypothesis.
No you haven’t and repeating yourself isn’t changing that. See below for more detail, but I’ve already addressed any legitimate source you have linked, and you have not provided any counterargument.

I’ve already addressed the actual paper the article is discussing. It’s:
-Outdated and contradicted by more recent work
-Doesn’t address genetic similarities with Pangolin virus spike structures. Evolution can result in similar physical structures but the chances of something evolving to become more similar at a genetic level is astronomically small.
-Doesn’t address how such a structure could have evolved in species that isn’t susceptible to SARS-CoV-2. The jump from bats to humans requires the virus to be able to infect BOTH animals, Covid can’t do this. (it could be the paper predates the research showing the Covid-19 spike can’t bind efficnetly too bat ACE2 receptors.)
-The specific genetic sequence from Pangolin viruses has been identified within the Covid spike structure proving the suspected recombination event with Pangolin virus did in fact occur.


Not an actual paper and it doesn’t even support your assertions. The Chinese scientist it’s interviewing speculates that Pangolins imported from SE Asia as the source of the initial outbreak. (Did you not tell us that we were not supposed to trust Chinese scientists because they are into “face saving”) The primary point of the article is that there is potential for Corona viruses to jump from Chinese Horseshoe bats to humans, something that has been know since the SARS outbreak at least.


An outdated blog post written by Matt Ridley, who is a right wing journalist and climate change denier with no particular qualifications to speak on virology.

The quote you provided was discussing SARS rather than Covid. Unlike SARS, RaTG13 can’t infect people readily nor can Covid infect bats readily, which speaks strongly against the possibility of a direct jump.

While he is correct in saying RaTG13 was (and still is) the closest known relative of SARS-CoV-2, he ignores the fact that Covid spike is genetically more similar to the one found in the Pangolin viruses. He is not correct in saying the Pangolin virus was originally thought to be the closest Covid Relative, this was never the case. Because the spike, but only the spike was more closely related to the Pangolin virus it was thought to have been a product of recombination. As I showed in previous posts, this has been confirmed and the specific genetic sequence involved has been identified.

Do you really think a climate change denial site like polarbearsceince is going to do any better when it comes to Covid? In any case all they do is quote Ridley from the previous blog so there is nothing to discuss.
 
Daszak (note the spelling!) and the WHO investigation has been discredited?

Discredited by whom?

The links to climate denier websites would suggest it's the same people who claim Michael Mann is "discredited"

Lolmiller claims Covid-19 comes from bat soup? Or is this a strawman?

I'm arguing that it's very unlikely to come directly from bats at all, due to the inefficient binding to bat ACE2. Covid may have descended from a bat virus it can't circulate in bats and would have needed an intermediary which is highly likely to be a Pangolin.

So year. More made up than it is strawman, but either way it has nothing to do with anything I have written.
 
Last edited:
In all that did you find evidence pangolins specifically were sold at the market?

Did you provide evidence the first infections actually were at the market?

I'm trying to simplify this in order to facilitate a discussion.
 
In all that did you find evidence pangolins specifically were sold at the market?

It's been alluded to in many papers and media reports and I have been given no reason to doubt that it is in fact the case.

Did you provide evidence the first infections actually were at the market?

While a some early cases had no obvious link to the market, most did. The most likely explanation for this is that the crossover to humans occurred there.

There are other possible scenarios like the crossover occurring at a different market and spreading to the fish market from there, but these are lower probability. If new data comes along that favors some other scenario I'll certainly consider it, but as of right now this is the most plausible scenario.
 
Re Daszak sounds credible...

RCP: How the COVID-19 Censors Killed the Truth
It's in everybody's interest to understand exactly where it came from and how it started, but efforts at investigation have been stymied from the start. Among those eager to suppress dissent on this topic are: the Chinese government, U.S. media outlets, the Big Tech platforms and scientists with a financial or reputational stake in the outcome of any investigation....

... Dr. Peter Daszak, the sole U.S. citizen on the WHO investigative team, is a close associate of China's premier bat-based coronavirus researcher and was a key figure in directing American taxpayer funds to the Wuhan Institute of Virology. Daszak even organized a public relations campaign in early 2020 to paint the lab leak hypothesis as a "conspiracy" before any thorough investigation had been conducted. His spokesperson later said the goal was to protect the lab's scientists, but ultimately the beneficiary was Beijing and its preferred narrative.
How is that not a conflict of interest?


WHO COVID-19 Investigation Is Tainted by Conflict of Interest, Says AHF
The alleged conflict of interest stems from the connection one of the investigators, a British zoologist and EcoHealth Alliance President Dr. Peter Daszak has with the Wuhan Institute of Virology (WIV). According to The Wall Street Journal, Dr. Daszak has worked closely with a leading virologist at WIV, Dr. Shi Zhengli on the study of bat viruses, which from 2014, was in part funded by US government grants. The institute is located just a few miles away from the wet market where Chinese authorities say SARS-CoV-2 first emerged.

“For the WHO [World Health Organization] investigation in Wuhan to stand up to scientific scrutiny, neutrality is a must,” said AHF President Michael Weinstein. “Dr. Daszak has a clear-cut conflict of interest that should’ve disqualified him from participation on the WHO team.
Chinese authorities say it started in the wet market, earliest cases had no exposure or connection to the market.


Politico: In 2018, Diplomats Warned of Risky Coronavirus Experiments in a Wuhan Lab. No One Listened. - After seeing a risky lab, they wrote a cable warning to Washington. But it was ignored.
These researchers, the American officials learned, had found a population of bats from caves in Yunnan province that gave them insight into how SARS coronaviruses originated and spread. The researchers boasted that they may have found the cave where the original SARS coronavirus originated. But all the U.S. diplomats cared about was that these scientists had discovered three new viruses that had a unique characteristic: they contained a "spike protein” that was particularly good at grabbing on to a specific receptor in human lung cells known as an ACE2 receptor. That means the viruses were potentially very dangerous for humans—and that these viruses were now in a lab with which they, the U.S. diplomats, were largely unfamiliar....

In total, the [US] embassy sent three teams of experts in late 2017 and early 2018 to meet with the WIV scientists, among them Shi Zhengli, often referred to as the “bat woman” because of her extensive experience studying coronaviruses found in bats.

When they sat down with the scientists at the WIV, the American diplomats were shocked by what they heard. The Chinese researchers told them they didn’t have enough properly trained technicians to safely operate their BSL-4 lab. The Wuhan scientists were asking for more support to get the lab up to top standards.

The diplomats wrote two cables to Washington reporting on their visits to the Wuhan lab. More should be done to help the lab meet top safety standards, they said, and they urged Washington to get on it. They also warned that the WIV researchers had found new bat coronaviruses could easily infect human cells, and which used the same cellular route that had been used by the original SARS coronavirus....
Of course Trump would not have wanted to send funds to China.
 
Re Daszak sounds credible...

RCP: How the COVID-19 Censors Killed the Truth
How is that not a conflict of interest?


WHO COVID-19 Investigation Is Tainted by Conflict of Interest, Says AHF
Chinese authorities say it started in the wet market, earliest cases had no exposure or connection to the market.

I'm at a loss as to what expertise the AIDS Healthcare Foundation would have on bat viruses in China.

the motivation for Realclearpolitics is a little easier to understand given their support for far right causes. I'm still not going to trust their opinion on, well anything.
 
It's been alluded to in many papers and media reports and I have been given no reason to doubt that it is in fact the case.



While a some early cases had no obvious link to the market, most did. The most likely explanation for this is that the crossover to humans occurred there.

There are other possible scenarios like the crossover occurring at a different market and spreading to the fish market from there, but these are lower probability. If new data comes along that favors some other scenario I'll certainly consider it, but as of right now this is the most plausible scenario.

The wet market is an incidental cluster, not the origin of anything.
Scientists know now that Sars-COV-2 was circulating globally back in November- before anyone at the market was sick (which was Dec 8). Samples from the Dec 2019 patients in China, with no connection to the market, already showed divergent strains.

Even China's CDC states the market was not the origin.
 
The wet market is an incidental cluster, not the origin of anything.
Scientists know now that Sars-COV-2 was circulating globally back in November- before anyone at the market was sick (which was Dec 8). Samples from the Dec 2019 patients in China, with no connection to the market, already showed divergent strains.

Even China's CDC states the market was not the origin.

Circulating globally by November? If that’s the case then that is a massive hole in the WIV lab release theory isn’t it given that the major claim for it coming from the lab is that it started in Wuhan.

Are you now saying we have no evidence it started in Wuhan?
 
I'm at a loss as to what expertise the AIDS Healthcare Foundation would have on bat viruses in China.
Their assertion had to do with Daszak's conflict of interest. You don't need a PhD in virology to recognize a conflict of interest in a WHO investigation team.

AIDS Healthcare Foundation (AHF), the largest global AIDS organization, currently provides medical care and/or services to over 1.5 million clients in 45 countries worldwide in the US, Africa, Latin America/Caribbean, the Asia/Pacific Region and Europe.


the motivation for Realclearpolitics is a little easier to understand given their support for far right causes. I'm still not going to trust their opinion on, well anything.

There are a dozen reports of Daszak's conflict of interest. You don't like the ones I cited, pick some others.

Are there any sources defending Daszak's untainted credibility? No, there isn't.
 
Scientists know now that Sars-COV-2 was circulating globally back in November- before anyone at the market was sick (which was Dec 8).

False.

This thread really ought to be in the conspiracy section - what idiot posted it in science?
 
It's been alluded to in many papers and media reports and I have been given no reason to doubt that it is in fact the case.
I'm not sure how reliable "alluded to" is supposed to be.

It's been denied and didn't show up on a list of animals sold in the market, with the caveat that they might want to hide the sale of illegal meat.

Before pangolins were being considered, they did not show up as openly for sale at the market.

Jan 2020: Bizarre Wuhan Wet Market Menu Shows Over 100 Wild Animals Sold As Food, Link With Virus Unclear

One could "allude to" it was one of those animals on the list.


While a some early cases had no obvious link to the market, most did. The most likely explanation for this is that the crossover to humans occurred there.

There are other possible scenarios like the crossover occurring at a different market and spreading to the fish market from there, but these are lower probability. If new data comes along that favors some other scenario I'll certainly consider it, but as of right now this is the most plausible scenario.
This is all well and good but that's not how an epidemiological investigation works. You don't start out with your preconceived conclusion and go from there. Peter Daszak openly asserted it was not from the lab before he went on the WHO team investigation as well.
 
Perhaps I can clarify on 'global' for Mr. Atheist in case my post was misinterpreted.
Samples from late 2019 blood, swabs, and even sewage samples in several geographical areas around the globe, including USA west coast, Italy, Spain and France, show antibodies or segments of the SARS-COV-2 genome itself.

Perhaps the conclusions of those tests are wrong and someone might want to contribute their own knowledge here.

Members of the WHO team have put the origin anywhere from late summer to early November.
 
Last edited:
Perhaps I can clarify on 'global' for Mr. Atheist in case my post was misinterpreted.
Samples from late 2019 blood, swabs, and even sewage samples in several geographical areas around the globe, including USA west coast, Italy, Spain and France, show antibodies or segments of the SARS-COV-2 genome itself.

Perhaps the conclusions of those tests are wrong and someone might want to contribute their own knowledge here.

Members of the WHO team have put the origin anywhere from late summer to early November.
Citation required.
 
Circulating globally by November? If that’s the case then that is a massive hole in the WIV lab release theory isn’t it given that the major claim for it coming from the lab is that it started in Wuhan.

Are you now saying we have no evidence it started in Wuhan?

No it isn't and no there is no evidence of another origin source. However, one always has to consider that possibility until the source is pinned down.



Jaime Metzl interview (also interviewed in the podcast)
JAMIE METZL: I wouldn't necessarily categorize it that way. Some people have talked about genetically engineered virus versus non genetically engineered. By that would mean using the tools of genome editing, like CRISPR. Then there are other tools to actually manipulate, using genome editing tools, a virus. Then the second possibility is there is just a really dangerous virus that maybe exists in a remote cave somewhere and it exists in one of these labs. So without any kind of manipulation, that leaks. A third possibility is that there is this dangerous, naturally occurring pathogen and then experiments are done on that virus in the lab. Some people are starting to hear about this so-called gain of function research. Like with dogs, you understand that you now have a dog. But the dog's ancestors were wolves. And how did wolves become dogs? It wasn't through genome editing. It was through selective breeding. Essentially, gain of function research is selective breeding. You select for qualities in a virus, it could be the ability to replicate rapidly or infect human cells. ...

JAMIE METZL: Let's look at these four options. One would be a series of animal to animal jumps. Zoonotic jump through intermediate hosts is the technical terms. Basically, it means bat to pangolin or civet or cat, to human. That would be a very likely possibility. That's what happened with the first SARS. But in the first SARS, there was actually evidence that turned up. Here we are more than one year after the beginning of the pandemic and there is absolutely no evidence for that. It could be. There are lots of scientists who think that's what happened. It's a very real possibility.
Frozen food hypothesis. I think it's extremely unlikely. Absolutely no evidence. It's kind of a ridiculous hypothesis. ...

That leads us to the possibility of an accidental lab leak. Here would be my best case for why I think this is the most likely option.
You all can read his detailed case or ignore it.

... That doesn't mean genetically engineered, but it means pushed in the direction of being highly contagious and transmissible for humans.

MICHAEL MORELL: What would be the purpose of such research?

JAMIE METZL: Gain of function research is very controversial in the scientific world and in the United States and elsewhere.

Daszak's conflict of interest:
There was a huge debate about that. So much so that after some very controversial research came out in 2014, the Obama administration established a moratorium on U.S. government funding for gain of function research. There was a grant, however, that had already been provided to an organization called the Eco Health Alliance. They passed some of that money to the Wuhan Institute of Virology for this research. ...


Back to the lab hypothesis:
Jaime Metzl: [he summarizes the above about the research]...but then we need to look at what China did in the earliest days of the pandemic until now. In the earliest days of the pandemic, China prevented World Health inspectors from coming to Wuhan for nearly a month. They immediately started taking down databases that had previously been accessible to the public. They immediately started silencing people who may have been able to provide invaluable evidence to the world about the origins of COVID-19. As a matter of fact, the only reason that we had the sequenced genome of the SARS-COV-2 virus as early as we did is that there was a Chinese scientist who went rogue and paid the consequences for sharing that information.
That last one is not a reference to the Ophthalmologist whistle blower who later died. I hadn't known it was an ask forgiveness, not permission leak (the genome data).

So far I only found a paywalled source on that initial sharing of the genome. But it is consistent with Metzl's interview.

Chinese laboratory that first shared coronavirus genome with world ordered to close for ‘rectification’, hindering its Covid-19 research
No reason was given for the closure of Shanghai facility, which released information about the virus ahead of authorities

I'm going to come back to this but I found another rabbit hole to go down.
 
Last edited:
Citation required.

Italy:
Evidence of SARS-CoV-2 RNA in an Oropharyngeal Swab Specimen, Milan, Italy, Early December 2019
https://wwwnc.cdc.gov/eid/article/27/2/20-4632_article

Summary article:
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/research/coronavirus/publication/33176598

This study shows an unexpected very early circulation of SARS-CoV-2 among asymptomatic individuals in Italy several months before the first patient was identified, and clarifies the onset and spread of the coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) pandemic. Finding SARS-CoV-2 antibodies in asymptomatic people before the COVID-19 outbreak in Italy may reshape the history of pandemic.

France:
Evidence of early circulation of SARS-CoV-2 in France: findings from the population-based “CONSTANCES” cohort
https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10654-020-00716-2

https://presse.inserm.fr/en/was-sars-cov-2-already-in-france-in-november-2019/42169/

Their findings: SARS-CoV-2 antibodies were detected in 353 participants (3.9%). The proportion of positive participants had increased from 1.9% in November and 1.3% in December to 5.0% in January, 5.2% in February, and 6.7% in the first half of March. Neutralizing antibodies were detected in 44 participants,


U.S.
Coronavirus Was In U.S. Weeks Earlier Than Previously Known, Study Says
https://www.npr.org/sections/corona...eeks-earlier-than-previously-known-study-says

This discovery adds to evidence that the virus was quietly spreading around the world before health officials and the public were aware, disrupting previous thinking of how the illness first emerged and how it has since evolved. It also shows the virus's presence in U.S. communities likely didn't start with the first case identified case in January.

and China:

Covid-19 Was Spreading in China Before First Confirmed Cases, Fresh Evidence Suggests
https://www.wsj.com/articles/covid-...med-cases-fresh-evidence-suggests-11613730600

New evidence from China is affirming what epidemiologists have long suspected: The coronavirus likely began spreading unnoticed around the Wuhan area in November 2019, before it exploded in multiple different locations throughout the city in December.

In examining 13 genetic sequences of the virus from December, Chinese authorities found similar sequences among those linked to the market, but slight differences in those of people without any link to it, according to the WHO investigators. The two sets likely began to diverge between mid-November and early December, but could possibly indicate infections as far back as September, said Marion Koopmans, a Dutch virologist on the WHO team.
 
Going down another rabbit hole:

https://www.statnews.com/2020/01/24...navirus-genome-tracing-origins-and-mutations/
By comparing the two dozen genomes, scientists can address the “when did this start” question. The 24 available samples, including from Thailand and Shenzhen as well as Wuhan, show “very limited genetic variation,” Rambaut concluded on an online discussion forum where virologists have been sharing data and analyses. “This is indicative of a relatively recent common ancestor for all these viruses.”

Given what’s known about the pace at which viral genomes mutate, if nCoV had been circulating in humans since significantly before the first case was reported on Dec. 8, the 24 genomes would differ more. Applying ballpark rates of viral evolution, Rambaut estimates that the Adam (or Eve) virus from which all others are descended first appeared no earlier than Oct. 30, 2019, and no later than Nov. 29....

The genome sequences suggest that was a one-time-only jump. “The genomes [from the 24 samples] are very uniform,” Andersen said. “If there had been multiple introductions,” including from many different animals, “there would be more genomic diversity. This was a single introduction.”
Quay refers to this lack of diversity in the first couple of cases for which he found essentially 2 clades.
 
Italy:
Evidence of SARS-CoV-2 RNA in an Oropharyngeal Swab Specimen, Milan, Italy, Early December 2019
https://wwwnc.cdc.gov/eid/article/27/2/20-4632_article

Summary article:
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/research/coronavirus/publication/33176598

France:
Evidence of early circulation of SARS-CoV-2 in France: findings from the population-based “CONSTANCES” cohort
https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10654-020-00716-2

https://presse.inserm.fr/en/was-sars-cov-2-already-in-france-in-november-2019/42169/
We'll have to see how those antibody tests pan out. But the relatedness of the Wuhan strains pretty much pin down the origin in Wuhan.


U.S.
Coronavirus Was In U.S. Weeks Earlier Than Previously Known, Study Says
https://www.npr.org/sections/corona...eeks-earlier-than-previously-known-study-says
This was also revealed when genetic tracks showed outbreaks from the single patient in Everett (north of Seattle) and the military base in CA where passengers from the infected ship spread out from. And the cases in NY had an EU origin that festered quite a while before it was recognized.


and China:

Covid-19 Was Spreading in China Before First Confirmed Cases, Fresh Evidence Suggests
https://www.wsj.com/articles/covid-...med-cases-fresh-evidence-suggests-11613730600
In examining 13 genetic sequences of the virus from December, Chinese authorities found similar sequences among those linked to the market, but slight differences in those of people without any link to it, according to the WHO investigators. The two sets likely began to diverge between mid-November and early December,
That is interesting.

So the market cluster is closely related but the cases not connected to the market are not closely related to the market cluster.

It comes back to Quay's analysis of the mass transit line #2.

COVID-19 Origin and Spread Linked to PLA Hospital and Wuhan Metro System Line 2 by Physician-Scientist Dr. Steven Quay

I'm not sure why we haven't seen a better genetic map yet the same way we have one for human migrations out of Africa. It looks like the data is all there waiting for someone to put it together. It's only a matter of a little more time.
 
Last edited:
That is interesting.

So the market cluster is closely related but the cases not connected to the market are not closely related to the market cluster.

It doesn't mean they aren't closely related, just that the differences are enough to put some point of divergence between them. They have some way of calculating (or rather estimating) how long it takes to mutate.
From earlier reports I have read it seems that viruses can be many decades past divergence are still considered very similar. (eta: of course in this sars-cov-2 case it would be a short time period)

I agree that the data is there (somewhere) to get closer to knowing. Unfortunately, not many people are allowed access to the crucial early patient data or other early samples. That is one of the things WHO asked for last month but were denied. A report is supposedly due out this week.
 
Last edited:
Italy:
Evidence of SARS-CoV-2 RNA in an Oropharyngeal Swab Specimen, Milan, Italy, Early December 2019
https://wwwnc.cdc.gov/eid/article/27/2/20-4632_article

Summary article:
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/research/coronavirus/publication/33176598



France:
Evidence of early circulation of SARS-CoV-2 in France: findings from the population-based “CONSTANCES” cohort
https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10654-020-00716-2

https://presse.inserm.fr/en/was-sars-cov-2-already-in-france-in-november-2019/42169/




U.S.
Coronavirus Was In U.S. Weeks Earlier Than Previously Known, Study Says
https://www.npr.org/sections/corona...eeks-earlier-than-previously-known-study-says



and China:

Covid-19 Was Spreading in China Before First Confirmed Cases, Fresh Evidence Suggests
https://www.wsj.com/articles/covid-...med-cases-fresh-evidence-suggests-11613730600

We'll have to see how those antibody tests pan out. But the relatedness of the Wuhan strains pretty much pin down the origin in Wuhan.


This was also revealed when genetic tracks showed outbreaks from the single patient in Everett (north of Seattle) and the military base in CA where passengers from the infected ship spread out from. And the cases in NY had an EU origin that festered quite a while before it was recognized.


That is interesting.

So the market cluster is closely related but the cases not connected to the market are not closely related to the market cluster.

It comes back to Quay's analysis of the mass transit line #2.

COVID-19 Origin and Spread Linked to PLA Hospital and Wuhan Metro System Line 2 by Physician-Scientist Dr. Steven Quay

I'm not sure why we haven't seen a better genetic map yet the same way we have one for human migrations out of Africa. It looks like the data is all there waiting for someone to put it together. It's only a matter of a little more time.

It doesn't mean they aren't closely related, just that the differences are enough to put some point of divergence between them. They have some way of calculating (or rather estimating) how long it takes to mutate.
From earlier reports I have read it seems that viruses can be many decades past divergence are still considered very similar. (eta: of course in this sars-cov-2 case it would be a short time period)

I agree that the data is there (somewhere) to get closer to knowing. Unfortunately, not many people are allowed access to the crucial early patient data or other early samples. That is one of the things WHO asked for last month but were denied. A report is supposedly due out this week.

Yes, a report is due soon, by the WHO investigative team.

I think once it comes out, maybe it will give more of a clearer picture of why they see a wildlife link as being far more likely than a lab leak.

In fact, the suggestions of early spread both elsewhere in China and abroad are some of the things that reduce the lab leak hypothesis.

China in fact have said they wanted more investigations to take place abroad, particularly in Europe (which is something that other commentators have pooh-poohed as China trying to absolve itself of responsibility etc...).

Daszak and others in the WHO team have said they wanted to see testing along the routes of the wildlife trade, suggesting that people in some of the wildlife farms may have been infected by Covid-19 and been unaware of it.

Maybe there will be maps of the genetic sequences as well.

I think we will just have to wait and see.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom