Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
But I'm at a loss to you repeating the bat to pangolin to human when there has been since that research cited showing it wasn't necessary. It could have come directly from a bat virus. This is what I mean by not keeping up.

The only paper you linked on this subject simply hand waved the issue away by insisting that it's "only a model" in much the same way climate science deniers try to hand wave away the greenhouse effect as "only a model"


Even if there had been such a paper released in the last couple weeks (remember the paper in Nature was from last month) it would need extraordinary evidence to counter a years worth of publications showing that Covid doesn't bind efficiently to bat ACE2 receptors.
 
There isn't a single citation here supporting that hypothesis.

This has been discussed extensively. The first confirmed hospitalization occurred in mid Dec, while the virus itself is believed to have infected it's first human in early Oct or Late Nov.

We also know how quickly Covid spreads, this is how the Reproduction number is defined.

Whether you look a the timeline for the first cases or just purely at the R value Covid can easily spread beyond the market weeks before there is any chance for health officials to spot it. It takes 5 generations and 6 weeks to get to ~100 cases and even more time is likely to elapse before these cases turn serious.

The cases showing up in early Dec were 7-10 generations removed from the initial infection back in early Oct. That is LOTS of time for people with no direct connection to the market to become infected.
 



You are ignoring most of what that link contains. For example this exchange between Koopmans and the interviewer:

You probably also are hinting at the laboratory hypothesis.

I'll just raise it because people raised it. Is there any evidence or can you rule it out?

So from everything that we've looked at and we've also visited three labs involved and also three labs that work on these viruses. From that, we have not been able to find any credible link there.

IMO you are also misrepresenting what she is saying wrt uncertainly about the market. She is NOT saying the crossover didn't occur there, she is saying that it's not impossible the crossover didn't occur elsewhere

And you there also see the market is not the whole story. The market has been one of those spreading events. But there also was circulation outside of, aside from the market.

And this is a long way of saying we really don't know. So the market has amplified. But even if you then have a case that has not [been] linked to the market, because of this stealth mechanism of spread, it can still be linked somehow, because someone picked up an infection from another person that was at the market.


As to where else it could have occurred:

So if there's a lot of evidence pointing to the market, but maybe not all the evidence necessarily pointing to the market, is there any other location that's a suspect in your mind?

Other markets that's clearly there. And what we have recommended is really to [trace] back from those markets, follow the supply chains, go to the farms, see where they are. And that's already done. That will be in the report. Those supply chains do lead to regions where there's also the hotspot for the bat coronavirus. So that's a line to follow.
 
You are ignoring most of what that link contains. For example this exchange between Koopmans and the interviewer:

IMO you are also misrepresenting what she is saying wrt uncertainly about the market. She is NOT saying the crossover didn't occur there, she is saying that it's not impossible the crossover didn't occur elsewhere

As to where else it could have occurred:
Re the bolded, I am, because the WHO investigation and Daszik have been discredited. Not a CT but rather the nature of politics working with China. Daszik, however, has a huge financial interest in the research at the WIV.

I've skimmed the thread from the beginning. You latched onto the bat to pangolin to human hypothesis and never let go of it despite citation after citation supporting direct link from bats to the lab to people.

You were the one arguing "more evolution was needed" earlier in the thread. I told you several pages back that because we now know the spike from the Pangolin virus is ALREADY efficient at attaching to human ACE2 bindings that the resulting virus would be very infectious to humans as soon as the recombination event occurred.

The argument that this is a natural event is that this spike stricture was unknown prior to research into Covid-19 so no one knew it could infect humans until mid 2020. No researcher could have been working with it in 2019, and even if they were they would have had zero reason to expect it would help create a more infectious version of a bat virus.
Multiple citations in this thread have refuted this.


No, it doesn’t. The recombination that put Pangolin virus genes into the bat virus almost certainly occurred in a Pangolin.

Why were they trying to hide it before it “escaped” and why has no one been able to find it since?

Exactly my point. In this case, neither virus was a known human pathogen. It’d be completely nonsensical for a researcher to use them as a starting point. There is no logical reason to say this was a lab experiment and not recombination.

Recombination is well understood and known to be a major source of novel RNA viruses. If you are going to hand wave such well understood science I don’t know where we can go from here.

There are 2 sources, 1 bat virus 1 Pangolin virus.

Covid-19 IS the product recombination between a bat virus and a Pangolin virus.
Evidence was posted that the coronaviruses pass from bat to pangolin and back to bats. The recombination event easily could have happened in this process. There is no evidence of a direct pangolin source.


I read it the other day and didn't find it compelling. they offer no explanation for why the spike protein so closely resembles the one found in the Pangolin virus and they handwave away the evidence for the what that spike protein can and can't attach to. Subsequent finding that the Pangolin virus can directly infect humans directly contradicts their claim that spike protein cannot.
This was your response to my posting of the innocent pangolin paper. AT THAT POINT I hadn't taken a stand the pangolin to human occurred.


This isn't true. The intermediary is almost certainly a Pangolin. The spike protean for Covid-19 has characteristic who's only known natural counterpart is found in several Coronaviruses that infect Pangolins. It's not out of the question it exists elsewhere and we just haven't found it yet, but Pangolins as the intermediary fits everything else as well.
You have stuck to this hypothesis from the beginning of the thread.

Maybe because scientific papers rarely contain the word “eureka”

And more recently, the papers I linked up-thread
https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-020-78703-6

https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-021-21240-1

Identifies a new Covid relative circulating in bats in Thailand. They suggest that Covid-19’s bat ancestor could come from a much wider area than is currently being looked at, and this includes places like Thailand where bats and Pangolins live in the same areas.

Furthermore, they report Covid-19 reactive antibodies not just in bats but in a Pangolin as well indicating Covid-19 or a very close relative may be circulating there.
Again, the virus has jumped back and forth between the bats and pangolins.


I also cannot find at any time that I ignored your responses.
 
Re the bolded, I am, because the WHO investigation and Daszik have been discredited.

Nothing in the link says anything of the kind. In fact I'd go so far as to say there is no logical connection whatsoever between what you bolded and the wildly unsubstantiated claim you jumped.

I've skimmed the thread from the beginning. You latched onto the bat to pangolin to human hypothesis and never let go of it despite citation after citation supporting direct link from bats to the lab to people.

A single citation for which I detailed a number of issues. I also went on to show newer, better, work which continues to find a distinct connection to Pangolins. You know what type of people attach themselves to a single questionable paper and ignore the larger body of published work...

Evidence was posted that the coronaviruses pass from bat to pangolin and back to bats. The recombination event easily could have happened in this process. There is no evidence of a direct pangolin source.

You seem to be confusing recombination events with other bat viruses which is neither surprising nor relevant.

A direct covid ancestor being passed back to a bat after recombination with a Pangolin virus is extremely unlikely because the resulting spike structure doesn't bind efficiently to bat ACE2. It DOES bind efficiently to both human and Pangolin ACE2. There are plausible sequence of events, but none of them involve passing the virus back to a bat.

Again, the virus has jumped back and forth between the bats and pangolins.

You repeating something doesn't make it true.

The jump to Pangolins is a one way trip because after the recombination alters the viruses spike it looses it's ability to propagate in bats (due to the inefficient binding with bat ACE2).
 
Last edited:
Nothing in the link says anything of the kind. In fact I'd go so far as to say there is no logical connection whatsoever between what you bolded and the wildly unsubstantiated claim you jumped.



A single citation for which I detailed a number of issues. I also went on to show newer, better, work which continues to find a distinct connection to Pangolins. You know what type of people attach themselves to a single questionable paper and ignore the larger body of published work...



You seem to be confusing recombination events with other bat viruses which is neither surprising nor relevant.

A direct covid ancestor being passed back to a bat after recombination with a Pangolin virus is extremely unlikely because the resulting spike structure doesn't bind efficiently to bat ACE2. It DOES bind efficiently to both human and Pangolin ACE2. There are plausible sequence of events, but none of them involve passing the virus back to a bat.

You repeating something doesn't make it true.

The jump to Pangolins is a one way trip because after the recombination alters the viruses spike it looses it's ability to propagate in bats (due to the inefficient binding with bat ACE2).
You ignoring evidence cited in this thread doesn't make your position true. I'm not saying [whatever you think], I am telling you what we have found sources refuting and ruling out your hypothesis.
It's really hard to address all these falsehoods.

Supporting evidence is in the thread. Pick one and I'll hunt some evidence citations refuting the conclusion you latched onto and can't seem to see the problems with that hypothesis.
 
One thing at a time (again). Was a pangolin to human transmission required?

Review of findings appear today (July 28, 2020) in Nature Microbiology.Evolutionary origins of SARS-CoV-2 identified
"SARS-CoV-2's RBD sequence has so far only been found in a few pangolin viruses," said Robertson. "Furthermore, the other key feature thought to be instrumental to SARS-CoV-2's ability to infect humans -- a polybasic cleavage site insertion in the Spike protein -- has not yet been seen in another close bat relative of the SARS-CoV-2 virus. Yet, while it is possible that pangolins may have acted as an intermediate host facilitating transmission of SARS-CoV-2 to humans, no evidence exists to suggest that pangolin infection is a requirement for bat viruses to cross into humans. Instead, our research suggests that SARS-CoV-2 likely evolved the ability to replicate in the upper respiratory tract of both humans and pangolins."


The NEXT coronavirus pandemic? Bats in China are carrying other viruses that may infect humans
Dr Shi and other scientists had also discovered multiple species of horseshoe bats that were living in a single cave in China's Yunnan Province. They found that “genetic recombination between viral strains in bats” may have produced the "direct evolutionary ancestor" of the strain that caused a deadly outbreak of SARS in humans. Besides, the study also revealed that various SARS-related coronaviruses, capable of using human ACE2 (the receptor of SARS-CoV in humans), are still circulating among bats in this region. Accordingly, the risk of spillover into people and the emergence of a disease similar to SARS is possible, the team concluded
And that is from a WIV researcher who is downplaying the chance of a lab leak.


MattRidley blog: THE BATS BEHIND THE PANDEMIC
In Shitou Cave, south of Kunming, the capital of Yunnan, they found viruses in the bats’ droppings and anal swabs that were more similar to human SARS than anything found in palm civets, the small mammals that until then were presumed to be the source of human infection. Back in the laboratory, they found that one of the viruses from bat droppings, called WIV1, could thrive in monkey and human cells specially engineered to activate the gene for ACE2 receptors, the lock to which a coronavirus’s spike protein can fit as a key. This suggested that people could catch SARS directly from a bat dropping....

Bats are sold in markets and supplied directly to restaurants throughout China and southeast Asia, but no direct evidence of their sale in Wuhan’s wet market has come to light. Also, horseshoe bats, which are much smaller than the tastier fruit bats, are generally not among the species eaten. The significance of the Yunnan cave sample is that it shows the bat virus didn’t need to recombine with viruses in other species in a market to be infectious to people.
So much for the bat soup myth.


Useful relevant science: the bats behind the Covid-19 pandemic
The role of pangolins in the spread of Sars-CoV-2, the virus that causes Covid-19, remains unclear. A closer look at more of the Sars-CoV-2 genome, published last week by Maciej Boni at Penn State University and David Robertson at Glasgow University, together with Chinese and European colleagues, finds that human versions of the virus are more closely related to the RaTG13 horseshoe bat sample from the cave than they are to the known pangolin versions. It is not yet possible to tell whether the virus went from bat to pangolin to people, or from bat to pangolin and bat to people in parallel.


Is that enough yet for you to recognize bat to pangolin to human is only a possibility, not a certainty?

There's another citation in this thread discussing bat to pangolin to bat recombination events.
 
Re the bolded, I am, because the WHO investigation and Daszik have been discredited. Not a CT but rather the nature of politics working with China. Daszik, however, has a huge financial interest in the research at the WIV.

Daszak (note the spelling!) and the WHO investigation has been discredited?

Discredited by whom?

You can't just make such a sweeping generalization and assume that that is now an uncontroversial fact.

Sorry, but that's really like the way some CTers thought about NIST.

"Oh look, they didn't investigate the possibility of explosives! They didn't even look into Building 7! They all have conflicts of interest! They have been discredited by Isaac Newton...etc....!"

However, the people making these allegations tend to be amateurs talking way outside their fields apparently failing to understand that what most concerns them is not necessarily what most concerns actual virologists doing actual virology work.
 
The bat soup myth? Who is making this claim?
Lomiller and it was a viral claim.

Did the new coronavirus originate with bat soup?
One popular rumor is that the new coronavirus originated from people eating “bat soup” in China.

This is false. Bat soup consumption didn’t cause the COVID-19 pandemic. ...

In turn, many people believe that the new coronavirus came from bat meat or bat soup. But this is a rumor. There’s no evidence that the new coronavirus came from bat soup consumption. ...
 
Last edited:
Daszak (note the spelling!) and the WHO investigation has been discredited?

Discredited by whom?

You can't just make such a sweeping generalization and assume that that is now an uncontroversial fact.

Sorry, but that's really like the way some CTers thought about NIST.

"Oh look, they didn't investigate the possibility of explosives! They didn't even look into Building 7! They all have conflicts of interest! They have been discredited by Isaac Newton...etc....!"

However, the people making these allegations tend to be amateurs talking way outside their fields apparently failing to understand that what most concerns them is not necessarily what most concerns actual virologists doing actual virology work.

Daszak has a serious conflict of interest and the director of the WHO delegation when pressed as to how the lab was ruled out said it wasn't.

Now Daszak has a new claim about live animals at the market. But the market has been ruled out as the initial source. People with no connection to the market had the virus before the market cluster was detected.
When are you guys either going to provide evidence the market was the initial source or stop chasing hypotheses as to how the animals got to the market?
 
Last edited:
Lolmiller didn't make the claim, then.

The "viral claim" is just your way of dismissing it.

I suppose you think it was from a bioweapon?

No? Then don't distort other people's positions.
This is one of your more ridiculous posts.

I have said from the start there is no evidence of a bioweapon, so why are you bringing that straw man up?

I cited a source dismissing the claim plus another one noting horseshoe bats are not on the Chinese menu. Lomiller has indeed claimed the Chinese consumption of bats is one of several of the potential problems.
 
This is one of your more ridiculous posts.

I have said from the start there is no evidence of a bioweapon, so why are you bringing that straw man up?
I cited a source dismissing the claim plus another one noting horseshoe bats are not on the Chinese menu. Lomiller has indeed claimed the Chinese consumption of bats is one of several of the potential problems.

Indeed! And no one said "bat soup" so why do you bring that up?
 
Indeed! And no one said "bat soup" so why do you bring that up?
Did I quote you in that post? Nope.

Was the post addressing lomiller? Yep.

Did you think I was addressing you? :confused:

Though I did address more than one person in this thread still falling back on the wet market origin to support their assertions.
 
Last edited:
It was Skeptic Ginger who first mentioned bat soup.
Yes I did, here:
...I think if you read some of the links in this thread you'll see this is true for rural China but not necessarily true in the more modernized areas of China. Of course they eat ethnic foods (like bat soup) and use traditional medicines. But there is no evidence that is how the virus jumped species.

In response to these two posts:
Since Chinese cultural norms like live animal markets and “traditional medicine” are being called into question because of the Covid outbreak doesn’t it make sense that Chinese researches would try to downplay the role of the Wuhan market? As such I don’t think we can trust any claims that the market or Pangolins held therein were not the source of the virus.

And here:
IMO protecting that negligent animal trade would be the top priority for any Chinese officials trying to hide something "for the greater good". Such trade cuts deep into traditional Chinese culture and would reflect badly on the culture and Chinese sense of identity as a whole. It'd have been far easier to scapegoat a local scientist or two than to revaluate traditional food and medicine practices for an entire culture.

So I'm not sure how that ended up offending angrysoba.



As long as I'm here:
.... I have actual evidence, specifically the genetic connection to the Pangolin virus and Pangolin’s presence at the market. Granted there are other possibility’s but they all involve a more complex series of events. Occam’s razor applies and Pangolins at the Wuhan market is the simplest plausible explanation.
Haven't seen that evidence yet, have we? Because I looked for confirmation pangolins were even in the seafood market and couldn't find any. There were live animal species there but pangolins are not mentioned.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom