Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
For China to push origin theories that reduce culpability is a given- plenty of evidence that they are about as transparent as a tar pit- but the motives of the global scientists, ie the "experts", is interesting. There seems to be some "greater good" reason for it in not hampering future virus research by focusing on what is still the next big risk (negligent animal trade across regions) and not what might actually have happened.

IMO protecting that negligent animal trade would be the top priority for any Chinese officials trying to hide something "for the greater good". Such trade cuts deep into traditional Chinese culture and would reflect badly on the culture and Chinese sense of identity as a whole. It'd have been far easier to scapegoat a local scientist or two than to revaluate traditional food and medicine practices for an entire culture.
 
Repeating this part:
clear evidence of coinfection and evolution in bats without involvement of other species.
It means the pangolin wasn't needed. And earlier stuff was posted about coronaviruses being transmitted back and forth between bats and the pangolin.

This was interesting and makes perfect sense.
However, identifying mutations under positive selection from frequency data alone can be misleading, as allele frequencies in viral pandemics are significantly driven by biased sampling, founder effects, and superspreading events [22].
I'm not sure how common it is for researchers to address this but it's encouraging to read here that at least some do.

These results suggest that the majority of adaptive changes which generated SARS-CoV-2 took place prior to its emergence in the human population....

That we fail to find evidence of diversifying selection on the terminal branch leading up to the emergence of SARS-CoV-2 in humans (Fig 2B), indicates that the adaptations that created a generalist capable of efficient replication in humans and other mammals, probably did not occur in the unsampled SARS-CoV-2 lineage.
I think this is consistent with what Quay discussed. I have to go review that.

ETA: Yep, this is a paragraph from Quay's work in post #182.
Furthermore, when one of us (Chan, in collaboration with Zhan) scrutinized the evolution of SARS-CoV-1 and SARS-CoV-2 in the early months of their respective epidemics, the former was observed to have mutated rapidly in early human cases as the virus adapted to its new host, while the latter had not. "The virus was well adapted to human transmission from the moment it was first detected," the World Health Organization's global study on the origins of the virus commented in November.
He supported that with his genetic analysis of the first cases.


... a future spillover, potentially coupled with a recombination event with SARS-CoV-2, is possible, and such a “SARS-CoV-3” emergence could be sufficiently divergent to evade either natural or vaccine-acquired immunity, as demonstrated for SARS-CoV-1 versus SARS-CoV-2 [68]. We must therefore dramatically ramp up surveillance for Sarbecoviruses at the human–animal interface [15] and monitor carefully for future SARS-CoV emergence in the human population.
I wonder if this monitoring will occur given it is in China. But also given this is what the WIV was studying and now being suspected of being the source of COVID 19, that might set some of this research back.
 
Last edited:
You might have some catching up to do since some of this has been addressed.

Corona viruses in bats in that region have been recognised as dangerous and a risk for making the jump from bats to humans even before the SARS outbreak 20 years ago. OF COURSE the Wuhan lab is studying this issue. China only has 2 BSL-4 labs where live viruses can be studied and this one is located in a known high risk area. In fact studying this known risk is likely a major reason why the lab was built in the first place.
You were doing good until you got to this. The bats are in the Yunnan caves some distance from Wuhan.

Distance from Yunnan to Wuhan is 1,292 kilometers. This air travel distance is equal to 803 miles.

The fact that a virology lab is studying viruses tells us absolutely nothing about whether this is where the viruses came from because this is what BSL-4 labs do and they would be doing it REGARDLESS of where the outbreak occurred.

As to why the outbreak and lab are in exactly the same city, there is a little coincidence there but you also need to take into account that:
- Since SARS, another bat virus jumping to humans has been considered highly probabaly and possibly inevitable.
- the region is a high risk for this type of event so it makes sense for this lab to be doing the work.
- not only is the city in an area where bat viruses could jump to humans, there are cultural practices like live animal markets where infected animals are brought into close contact with a large number of people.
This is factually wrong.

If we narrow down where this "inevitable" crossover is likely to occur to a large city, in that region of China where live animal markets are still the norm and Wuhan looks like a probable epicenter for any such event. It's no coincidence e at all that is where China would center it's research.
Again, factually wrong. Wuhan is a modern city and the seafood market initially suspected was not where the first cases occurred.


Identifying bat viruses in China has been an ongoing research topic since SARS, because a virus like Covid has emerging there been a known risk for at least that long.

What is actually most telling is that for all the samples collected in that time Covid-19 was NOT one of them.
China destroyed some of the work at the WIV and blocked access to the genome work that had been pubic previously

For it to get into a lab in the first place someone needed to have collected it, so finding either in the wild or in the previously collected samples should be relatively straightforward. The fact that no really close ancestor has yet been identified suggests Covid was never collected and never in a lab and therefor could not have escaped from one.
I'll find the relevant posts addressing this and get back to you.


IMO protecting that negligent animal trade would be the top priority for any Chinese officials trying to hide something "for the greater good". Such trade cuts deep into traditional Chinese culture and would reflect badly on the culture and Chinese sense of identity as a whole. It'd have been far easier to scapegoat a local scientist or two than to revaluate traditional food and medicine practices for an entire culture.
I think if you read some of the links in this thread you'll see this is true for rural China but not necessarily true in the more modernized areas of China. Of course they eat ethnic foods (like bat soup) and use traditional medicines. But there is no evidence that is how the virus jumped species.

In fact if you look at angrysoba's post above it provides evidence the virus jumps species from bats and back on a regular basis.
 
You were doing good until you got to this. The bats are in the Yunnan caves some distance from Wuhan.

Distance from Yunnan to Wuhan is 1,292 kilometers. This air travel distance is equal to 803 miles.

Hence me using the term region. In fact post Covid research is saying that the region where similar viruses may be found is much larger still and may extend all the way from SE Asia to eastern Europe.

Nonetheless my point stands. Wuhan is centrally located in the region of concern following SARS and the lab there is China's only BSL-4 lab working with human infection. Corona virus work was guaranteed to be going on there so is military and potentially industrial work is guaranteed to be going on there as well.

This is factually wrong.

No, it isn't

Again, factually wrong. Wuhan is a modern city and the seafood market initially suspected was not where the first cases occurred.

Sure it's a modern city, but it's still a more recently developed city in a more remote region where these practices are more common. I never said these practices are non-existent elsewhere. but they are more common in places like Wuhan.

I think if you read some of the links in this thread you'll see this is true for rural China but not necessarily true in the more modernized areas of China. Of course they eat ethnic foods (like bat soup) and use traditional medicines. But there is no evidence that is how the virus jumped species.

Yes there is. Covid-19 has RNA from a Sabrecorona virus that infects Pangolins as part of it's spike structure. Since this specific spike structure doesn't infect bats efficiently but does infect both Pangolins and Humans efficiently it must have been acquired while infecting a Pangolin.

In fact if you look at angrysoba's post above it provides evidence the virus jumps species from bats and back on a regular basis.

Ok, and?

It's no surprise that related corona viruses can readily infect other bats as their spike structure already attaches efficiently to bat ACE2 receptors.
 
Hence me using the term region. In fact post Covid research is saying that the region where similar viruses may be found is much larger still and may extend all the way from SE Asia to eastern Europe.

Nonetheless my point stands. Wuhan is centrally located in the region of concern following SARS and the lab there is China's only BSL-4 lab working with human infection. Corona virus work was guaranteed to be going on there so is military and potentially industrial work is guaranteed to be going on there as well.
This has all been addressed yet here you are repeating a falsehood without addressing the evidence that has been posted that you are wrong. Wuhan is not the same region, not even close.

No, it isn't
Yes it is and the evidence it is has been posted. Please address the evidence if you want to keep repeating these falsehoods.

Sure it's a modern city, but it's still a more recently developed city in a more remote region where these practices are more common. I never said these practices are non-existent elsewhere. but they are more common in places like Wuhan.
No they are not. :rolleyes:


Yes there is. Covid-19 has RNA from a Sabrecorona virus that infects Pangolins as part of it's spike structure. Since this specific spike structure doesn't infect bats efficiently but does infect both Pangolins and Humans efficiently it must have been acquired while infecting a Pangolin.
You are not keeping up with the discussion. That has been addressed. It's an early assumption that was wrong.

Ok, and?

It's no surprise that related corona viruses can readily infect other bats as their spike structure already attaches efficiently to bat ACE2 receptors.
Again, moving on.

I just went back through the posts from ~page 6 and I see you were involved in the discussion at that time. Yet here you are posting while you either ignored everything in between or you are simply plugging back in where you left off. :confused:

I'm not sure how to address this without just saying go catch up.


Here are evidence supported facts that have been discussed with citations in the thread.

The bat caves are nowhere near Wuhan.

The fact Wuhan is a large transportation hub is not evidence a bat virus from Yunnan should just show up there. Why there, where the viruses were being studied? Why not in Beijing or Hong Kong? And not just that, but Quay showed the cases clustered around a mass transit line that included the WIV.

Despite the denial, there is evidence the WIV was working with live viral cultures in Vero cells (monkey cells}, and there is evidence they had live bats at the Institute.

No one here thinks the lab 'created' COVID-19. But there is evidence they were working with closely related viruses.

post #229
They were studying live cultures at the WIV It’s from a paper before the COVID 19 pandemic they were looking at coronaviruses related to SARS.
... particularly in the receptor binding domain of the spike protein. Most importantly, we report the first recorded isolation of a live SL-CoV (bat SL-CoV-WIV1) from bat faecal samples in Vero E6 cells, which has typical coronavirus morphology, 99.9% sequence identity to Rs3367 and uses ACE2 from humans, civets and Chinese horseshoe bats for cell entry.*…


Re the seafood market: There is no evidence live pangolins and live bats were in close proximity with each other in the seafood market.

But more importantly, THE SEAFOOD (AKA WET) MARKET WAS NOT THE PLACE THE FIRST INFECTIONS OCCURRED. It is suspected that maybe a superspreader event took place there. And I believe that only included 4 cases.

There is evidence the WHO and China produced a limited investigation. Since the report the director of the WHO walked back his claim the lab was ruled out.

China removed related research from public view.

For the best summary of what we know to date and why the lab cannot be ruled out, listen to the podcast (2 parts) in post #271.

It should be required material for this thread. I have a post before that which summarized much of what was said, but honestly the podcast is all about critically thinking the origin discussion.

And there is this: Call for a Full and Unrestricted International Forensic Investigation into the Origins of COVID-19 published in the WSJ. More than 25 scientists signed it (see the last 2 pages for their names and credentials.

If you do nothing else, listen to the podcast. It will catch you up to where this discussion is.
 
Last edited:
Well let's address this latest headline because obviously it will be posted here:

NPR: WHO Points To Wildlife Farms In Southern China As Likely Source Of Pandemic

I'm keeping an open mind to a point.

Convenient:
China shut down those wildlife farms in February 2020,

And then we get to this:
says Peter Daszak, a disease ecologist with EcoHealth Alliance and a member of the WHO delegation that traveled to China this year. During that trip, Daszak says, the WHO team found new evidence that these wildlife farms were supplying vendors at the Huanan Seafood Wholesale Market in Wuhan with animals.

So why are they trying to pass this off as a valid conclusion? We know the seafood market wasn't the origin. Are they hoping people would have forgotten that by now?

And the evidence?
"China closes that pathway down for a reason," Daszak says. "The reason was, back in February 2020, they believed this was the most likely pathway [for the coronavirus to spread to Wuhan]. And when the WHO report comes out ... we believe it's the most likely pathway too."
China shut down a whole industry of farming wild animals so they must have thought it was where the jump occurred. :rolleyes:

There is this claim which I'd love to see corroborating evidence for but we already have it and they are playing fast and loose with their definition of "many positive samples". I'll go search the earlier pages of the thread:
Wang says that after the outbreak at the Huanan market, Chinese scientists went there and looked for the virus.

"In the live animal section, they had many positive samples," Wang says. "They even have two samples from which they could isolate live virus."
Funny, a year later as we are just now hearing this? And conveniently it's after the WHO report (now they have a new report?), and after that report was seriously questioned? (See link above to the open letter.)

But most importantly of all, WTF is this when we know the first cases were not connected to the market.
 
Last edited:
Well let's address this latest headline because obviously it will be posted here:

NPR: WHO Points To Wildlife Farms In Southern China As Likely Source Of Pandemic

I'm keeping an open mind to a point.

Convenient:

And then we get to this:

So why are they trying to pass this off as a valid conclusion? We know the seafood market wasn't the origin. Are they hoping people would have forgotten that by now?

Who are "they" and why are "they" hoping people have forgotten?
 
Who are "they" and why are "they" hoping people have forgotten?

Did you even read my post or the source link? :confused:

They are the Chinese government and the members of the WHO team that are going along with this coverup.

And before you start screaming CT that way>, this is all documented here in the thread, well documented.

And in addition, didn't you post the link to the podcast where this was laid out? Yes, you did. Maybe you need to listen to it again.

From your post:
Jamie Metzl, who I think organized that recent letter, has appeared on the Joe Rogan podcast.

He explains why he thinks a lab leak is a strong possibility... ...and also about the pushback against the lab leak hypothesis. He talks quite a bit about Peter Daszak as well:

BTW, it involves the nature of the working relationship between the WHO and the Chinese government. It doesn't involve some back-room conspiracy.
 
Last edited:
An earlier statement from the WHO investigator Jamie Metzl, who he is and the investigative team's response to Metzl.

In response to the WHO-China joint study press conference, held in Wuhan on February 9, 2021, I today issued the following statement:

Although I remain a steadfast supporter of the World Health Organization and its Director General, Dr. Tedros Adhanom, I am appalled by the WHO expert committee’s announcement in its ill-advised February 9 Wuhan press event that the possibility of an accidental lab leak does not merit further investigation. While no evidence has yet been found indicating that COVID-19 stems from a transmission between animal hosts in the wild or from frozen foods, as the committee entertains, significant evidence points to an accidental leak from the Wuhan Institute of Virology as being a possible origin of the pandemic.

That the Chinese government had veto power over who from the international community could participate in the investigation and stage managed the investigation process itself, as well as the clear conflict of interest of WHO investigator Peter Daszak, raise fundamental questions about the credibility of the investigation as currently construed.
It continues until we get to this:
I therefore call on WHO Director General Dr. Tedros Adhanom, whom I greatly respect and admire, to remove Peter Daszak from the investigation team, announce that all hypotheses will be fully examined, including the possibility of an accidental lab leak, and renegotiate the terms of reference for the investigation to ensure that a full and unrestricted examination of the pandemic’s origins will be possible.

Note: The day after I released this statement, on February 11, 2021, WHO Director General Adhanom wisely stated in a briefing event for member states: “I want to clarify that all hypotheses remain open and require further study.” It is certainly my hope that this statement makes clear that all hypotheses, including the possibility of an accidental lab leak, be fully explored by the WHO expert committee and others.


About Metzl
Jamie Metzl is a technology and healthcare futurist, geopolitical expert, novelist, social entrepreneur, media commentator, Senior Fellow of the Atlantic Council, Singularity University faculty member, and the Founder and Chair of the global social movement OneShared.World. In 2019, he was appointed to the World Health Organization expert advisory committee on human genome editing. Jamie previously served in the U.S. National Security Council, State Department, Senate Foreign Relations Committee, and as a Human Rights Officer for the United Nations in Cambodia. He serves on the Advisory Council to Walmart’s Future of Retail Policy Lab and has been an election monitor in Afghanistan and the Philippines and advised the government of North Korea on the establishment of Special Economic Zones....

The podcast is well worth people's time.
 
Last edited:
Well let's address this latest headline because obviously it will be posted here:

NPR: WHO Points To Wildlife Farms In Southern China As Likely Source Of Pandemic

I'm keeping an open mind to a point.

Convenient:

And then we get to this:

So why are they trying to pass this off as a valid conclusion? We know the seafood market wasn't the origin. Are they hoping people would have forgotten that by now?

And the evidence? China shut down a whole industry of farming wild animals so they must have thought it was where the jump occurred. :rolleyes:

There is this claim which I'd love to see corroborating evidence for but we already have it and they are playing fast and loose with their definition of "many positive samples". I'll go search the earlier pages of the thread:Funny, a year later as we are just now hearing this? And conveniently it's after the WHO report (now they have a new report?), and after that report was seriously questioned? (See link above to the open letter.)

But most importantly of all, WTF is this when we know the first cases were not connected to the market.

China did sample the animals in the market: all negative
They also sampled 35 species in various wild and farm locations- all negative (though it was less than 2k samples which seems low! - see paper below)

I have yet to hear of any of the farm or market samples collected early on having a positive SARS-COV-2 result. None. Which is kind of amazing since humans have transmitted Sars-COV-2 to a variety of animals. (The pangolin and bat samples were taken long before the outbreak.)

Someone did a summary paper on animal testing here:
https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/tbed.13885

Another study from China reported testing for SARS‐CoV‐2 on 1,914 serum samples, collected at varying times and obtained from varying sources, from 35 animal species (including pigs, cows, sheep, horses, chickens, ducks, geese, experimental mice, rats, guinea pigs, rabbits, monkeys, dogs, cats, wild camels, foxes, minx, alpacas, ferrets, bamboo rats, peacocks, eagles, tigers, rhinoceroses, pangolins, leopard cats, jackals, giant pandas, masked civets, porcupines, bears, yellow‐throated martens, weasels, red pandas and wild boar) using a double‐antigen sandwich ELISA, with no positive results (Deng et al., 2020). Of most note is the lack of positive ELISA results among 15 pet and 99 street dogs from Wuhan (Deng et al., 2020). Otherwise, there is very limited information presented regarding the animal populations from which the samples were derived.

*I think he mentions the negative dogs because cats early on were negative, but then later many were testing positive (14% or so...its in the above paper), but none of the dogs.

Where are the results of all the testing I am sure they have done?
e.g.:
Where are results from the Yunnan bat caves they took over a year ago? (and what became of scientists' confiscated samples?)
What about the villagers nearby? Did they have antibodies for SARS-COV-2?
Where are the results of the hundreds of bat samples the WIV had not processed yet before 2020?
What was the data from testing other wet markets around Wuhan?
Where are the retroactive flu sample results from Fall of 2019?

At every point in the supply chain of things coming into Wuhan, or things that could help narrow down a start date or area or origin, testing should have been done. And I bet China did do lots of testing. How could they not when it is also dangerous for them not to know? Either way, they aren't sharing.


These are not difficult things to do and China had plenty of resources to go collect and test. This is basic stuff. Where is all the data?

It's possible I missed it somewhere so anyone with good scientific googling abilities, please let me know if you find something!
 
Last edited:
Is that a Q&A about the origin or just general COVID questions?

It’s general but I have seen questions abiut the origins there. I am assuming the WHO report is coming out soon (this month?) so it may be even more relevant than usual.

I would like Racaniello to go on Rogan not just about Covid origins but also because Rogan seems to be spreading or allowing a lot of bad Covid-related information re: vaccines, vitamin D and lockdowns.
 
This has all been addressed yet here you are repeating a falsehood without addressing the evidence that has been posted that you are wrong. Wuhan is not the same region, not even close.

This is both false and dishonest. I've posted the links to the peer reviewed science multiple times and you have responded with nothing but hand waving.



You are not keeping up with the discussion. That has been addressed. It's an early assumption that was wrong.

False again. The paper in Nature that I linked to confirming the recombination event and Pangolin virus RNA in the Covid spike structure was published Feb 2021. The other one that found Covid reactive antibodies in bats in close proximity to Pangolins that are know to end up in markets like the one in Wuhan was published in Dec 2020.

Your media comment are all older than that. So is the only actual paper you have provided.

WRT to that paper. It argued that the similarities in spike structure could be accounted for by parallel evolution. While parallel evolution could be for physical similarities, it seems unlikely to explain the genetic similarities with Pangolin virus spike structure.

I pointed this out at the time, and you had no response. I linked to newer research that came to the same conclusion as the initial paper from last year and you STILL provided no response beyond your own assertions that the papers were wrong.
 
China did sample the animals in the market: all negative

Even the "early" cases of Covid occurred up to 6 weeks after the initial jump to humans and testing of the animals in the market would have happened 3-4 months after the crossover. The infected animal would certainly be long gone at this point.

This is also why there were some early cases that had no direct link to the market. 6 weeks is plenty of time for community circulation to begin. Some of these early cases could easily have been 4 jumps from removed from anyone who was at the market personally.
 
This is both false and dishonest. I've posted the links to the peer reviewed science multiple times and you have responded with nothing but hand waving.
Let's start with the specifics here.

the region is a high risk for this type of event so it makes sense for this lab to be doing the work.
What region? The bat region is 800 miles from the WIV which is studying bat viruses.
- not only is the city in an area where bat viruses could jump to humans, there are cultural practices like live animal markets where infected animals are brought into close contact with a large number of people.
China is not an homogenous country.

Do you believe there are bat caves in Wuhan? Think people from Wuhan are exposed to live horseshoe bats? Do you have any evidence of that?

You called it "a little coincidence". No, it is a huge smoking gun coincidence.

I remind you the outbreak didn't start at the market.
False again. The paper in Nature that I linked to confirming the recombination event and Pangolin virus RNA in the Covid spike structure was published Feb 2021. The other one that found Covid reactive antibodies in bats in close proximity to Pangolins that are know to end up in markets like the one in Wuhan was published in Dec 2020.
The outbreak did not start in the market.
Yes there are pangolin segments in the COVID 19 genome. No one, here anyway, is arguing that there isn't.

What the research has shown however, is that coronaviruses have crossed between pangolins and bats and back again multiple times. For a similar example COVID has crossed from humans to mink and back again.

There are no papers that have definitively said this virus went from bat to pangolin to humans. There are papers that said it didn't have to. It could have come directly from a bat virus.

lomiller said:
WRT to that paper. It argued that the similarities in spike structure could be accounted for by parallel evolution. While parallel evolution could be for physical similarities, it seems unlikely to explain the genetic similarities with Pangolin virus spike structure.
No one attributed it to parallel evolution. :confused:

lomiller said:
I pointed this out at the time, and you had no response. I linked to newer research that came to the same conclusion as the initial paper from last year and you STILL provided no response beyond your own assertions that the papers were wrong.
How far back do I need to go to find this paper which I didn't respond to? I recall posting a source saying it didn't come from a pangolin which some people in the thread (could have been you) said it wasn't convincing. At that point in this discussion I didn't know which paper was correct.

There have also been cites here of other lab accidents. They happen from time to time even in level 4 labs and they have happened in countries besides China including the US and the UK.

But I'm at a loss to you repeating the bat to pangolin to human when there has been since that research cited showing it wasn't necessary. It could have come directly from a bat virus. This is what I mean by not keeping up.
 
Even the "early" cases of Covid occurred up to 6 weeks after the initial jump to humans and testing of the animals in the market would have happened 3-4 months after the crossover. The infected animal would certainly be long gone at this point.

This is also why there were some early cases that had no direct link to the market. 6 weeks is plenty of time for community circulation to begin. Some of these early cases could easily have been 4 jumps from removed from anyone who was at the market personally.

There isn't a single citation here supporting that hypothesis.
 
To review:

NPR: Virologist: WHO Team Found No 'Credible Link' Between Wuhan Labs, COVID-19
Dutch virologist Marion Koopmans was part of that team that "reconstructed every step in that initial outbreak" in two weeks of investigation.

The team said the pandemic did not start at the city's Huanan Seafood Market, which was a location of an early coronavirus outbreak, because the virus was already circulating beforehand.


Now Daszik is claiming they have new evidence. But it isn't evidence the first cases were linked to the market, it is evidence supposedly showing wild animals were shipped to the market. And as for the WHO ruling the lab out, many virologists questioned that conclusion because no evidence was provided that it did not start in the lab and I posted a citation where the leader of that team denied the lab had been ruled out.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom