Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
There is no credible evidence that market or any other market in Wuhan was the initial 'crossover' site. By continuing to repeat this you reinforce the falsehood.

And as for Worobey's genetic walk-back, he had missing information on the first patients and while people like Bloom politely said the walk-back had no obvious flaws, he also said it wasn't conclusive evidence.


It could have come from the lab. "Likely came from" is bull ****. No trail was found be it from frozen food to the wildlife farms to the mine in Yunnan to the caves in Laos.

As for find the furin cleavage site in the wild, sure, it was in a different bat species but recombinant coronaviruses are found in bats. That fact doesn't provide a smoking gun.

Indeed, for any source so far proposed. Each proposed source has exactly the same evidence, ie; speculation.
 
You see, this is why a lot of people think that the lab leak is a conspiracy theory.
So what?

It relies on the idea of a massive cover-up by, let's see, the Wuhan Institute of Virology, the NIH, most of the world's virologists, and Google.
Massive cover-up? What nonsense. It only requires the Chinese government and a natural self-preservation of Shi and Daszak to not want to face the music.

It is apparently being exposed by some right-wing Senators, ivermectin proponents, anti-vaxxers and ...erm... Gab dwellers?
Again, this is not the least bit relative.

If you want to use a CT as your evidence against a lab origin hypothesis it does not belong in this thread.
 
Last edited:
I am not remotely convinced either that you have demonstrated that the WIV made SARS-CoV2, that you know what you are talking about, or that you aren't putting forward a vast conspiracy theory. You even said that you use Duck Duck Go because Google is somehow suppressing searches for the documents you are talking about.

"Because Google is somehow suppressing searches" belongs in the other forum.

Google uses an algorithm that favors frequent hits. I often switch between DuckDuckGo and Startpage because they can turn up different results.
 
Indeed, for any source so far proposed. Each proposed source has exactly the same evidence, ie; speculation.

I don't agree about the same amount of supporting evidence, obviously. But you are correct in that in neither origin hypotheses is there conclusive evidence.
 
I haven't gotten back to the specifics in the emails yet though I did link to a source summarizing what was in those early emails.

First, in this post I'm repeating the proposal's incriminating paragraph because it is relevant:

DARPA proposal
LEAKED GRANT PROPOSAL DETAILS HIGH-RISK CORONAVIRUS RESEARCH
The proposal, rejected by U.S. military research agency DARPA, describes the insertion of human-specific cleavage sites into SARS-related bat coronaviruses....

“We will introduce appropriate human-specific cleavage sites and evaluate growth potential in [a type of mammalian cell commonly used in microbiology] and HAE cultures,” referring to cells found in the lining of the human airway, the proposal states.
You can't get a more incriminating pre-pandemic proposal.
Expert opinions in the article:
“We will introduce appropriate human-specific cleavage sites and evaluate growth potential in [a type of mammalian cell commonly used in microbiology] and HAE cultures,” referring to cells found in the lining of the human airway, the proposal states.

Martin Wikelski, a director at the Max Planck Institute of Animal Behavior in Germany, whose work tracking bats and other animals was referenced in the grant application without his knowledge, also said it made him more open to the idea that the pandemic may have its roots in a lab. “The information in the proposal certainly changes my thoughts about a possible origin of SARS-CoV-2,” Wikelski told The Intercept. “In fact, a possible transmission chain is now logically consistent — which it was not before I read the proposal.”

And experts who disagreed:
But others insisted that the research posed little or no threat and pointed out that the proposal called for most of the genetic engineering work to be done in North Carolina rather than China. “Given that the work wasn’t funded and wasn’t proposed to take place in Wuhan anyway it’s hard to assess any bearing on the origin of SARS-CoV-2,” Stephen Goldstein, a scientist who studies the evolution of viral genes at the University of Utah, and an author of the recent Cell article, wrote in an email to The Intercept.
Baric (N Carolina) and Shi parted ways shortly thereafter. Baric set Shi the genetically engineered mice to continue the work at the WIV. And obviously there were alternative sources of funding.


June 2021 Technology Review article discussing the not denied funding. There was plenty.
They did share resources—for example, Baric sent the transgenic mice with human lung receptors to Wuhan. But after their initial collaboration, the two centers were more like competitors. They were in a race to identify dangerous coronaviruses, assess the potential threat, and develop countermeasures like vaccines.


In Baric’s lab, the chimeras were studied at BSL-3, enhanced with additional steps like Tyvek suits, double gloves, and powered-air respirators for all workers. Local first-responder teams participated in regular drills to increase their familiarity with the lab. All workers were monitored for infections, and local hospitals had procedures in place to handle incoming scientists. It was probably one of the safest BSL-3 facilities in the world. That still wasn’t enough to prevent a handful of errors over the years: some scientists were even bitten by virus-carrying mice. But no infections resulted.
The WIV was reportedly doing its work in a level 2 biosafety lab.
Two years later, Daszak and Shi published a paper reporting how the Chinese lab had engineered different versions of WIV1 and tested their infectiousness in human cells. The paper announced that the WIV had developed its own reverse-genetics system, following the Americans’ lead. It also included a troubling detail: the work, which was funded in part by the NIH grant, had been done in a BSL-2 lab. That meant the same viruses that Daszak was holding up as a clear and present danger to the world were being studied under conditions that, according to Richard Ebright, matched “the biosafety level of a US dentist’s office.”


Baric quietly weighed in:
Since the pandemic began, Baric has not said much about the possible origins of the virus or about his Chinese counterparts. On several occasions, however, he has quietly pointed to safety concerns at the WIV. In May 2020, when few scientists were willing to consider a lab leak in public, he published a paper acknowledging that “speculation about accidental laboratory escape will likely persist, given the large collections of bat virome samples stored in labs in the Wuhan Institute of Virology, the facility’s proximity to the early outbreak, and the operating procedures at the facility.” He flagged Daszak and Shi’s BSL-2 paper, in case anyone didn’t understand what he was saying.

I say quietly because he officially he stayed on the natural spillover side of the origin argument.
Baric says he still believes a natural spillover is the most likely cause. But he also knows the intricate risks of the work well enough to see a possible path to trouble. That is why, in May of this year, he joined 17 other scientists in a letter in the journal Science calling for a thorough investigation of his onetime collaborator’s lab and its practices. He wants to know what barriers were in place to keep a pathogen from slipping out into Wuhan’s population of 13 million, and possibly to the world.

“Let’s face it: there are going to be unknown viruses in guano, or oral swabs, which are oftentimes pooled. And if you’re attempting to culture a virus, you’re going to have novel strains being dropped onto culture cells,” Baric says. “Some will grow. You could get recombinants that are unique. And if that was being done at BSL-2, then there are questions you want to ask.”

NOTE: There is no CT here either discussed or implied.
 
Last edited:
Yeah, you read the DARPA proposal and you realize just how insane they are, then you read the NIAID grant report and realize they simply did the DARPA proposal under the NIAID grant.
 
]

The Huanan Market is literally 400 meters from the WIV.

The lab is 20Km from where the first cases were found, and the early cases are all much closer to the Wuhan Fish Market than any building occupied by WIV.


We have to be talking about trillion to one odds, hell maybe even gazillion to one odds, that a completely novel human infectious,

every virus that is capable of infecting humans was once a novel virus.
ACE2 targeting,
Viruses that target ACE2 are a thing, and SARS-COV-2 binds to the ACE2 of other animals (eg mink) more efficiently than human ACE2.

gene edited

Gene editing has been ruled out. The RBD is out of frame meaning it can't be read and copied reliably making it difficult for the virus to replicate. This occurs from time to time in nature, but no researcher would ever do such a thing if they wanted a viable virus.

furin cleavage site having

There are other corona viruses with a furin cleavage site, in fact some even have a full furin cleavage site rather than the inefficient partial furin cleavage site in SARS-CoV-2

400 meters away from a lab

Again 20Km from the lab. Most of the early cases were that close to the Wuhan fish market though.
that was working on creating that exact same virus.

There is no evidence to support such a claim. None at all.
 
They moved that market and the imagery doesn't line up any more.

The lab isn't located at the WIV headquarters, and while the headquarters is a little closer it's still several Km away and on the opposite side of the river from most of the early cases. The Qyimen market is a little closer, but not as strongly implicated in early cases as the Wuhan Fish Market.
 
Yeah, you read the DARPA proposal and you realize just how insane they are, then you read the NIAID grant report and realize they simply did the DARPA proposal under the NIAID grant.

They were studying the process under which these viruses can cross over into humans. Any similarity tells us they were on the right track and had correctly identified something with a real danger potential.

In fact from your own link, the sentence IMMEDIATELY after the part you quoted says:

We found that the RBDs of these viruses differ from that of SARS-CoV-2 by only one or two residues, bind as efficiently to the hACE2 protein as the SARS-CoV-2 Wuhan strain isolated in early human cases, and mediate hACE2-dependent entry into human cells, which is inhibited by antibodies neutralizing SARS-CoV-2.


So viruses found in the wild that are have even more potential to cross over into humans and are even inhibited by SARS-CoV-2 antibodies.

Later on they say:

Our findings therefore indicate that bat-borne SARS-CoV-2-like viruses potentially infectious for humans circulate in Rhinolophus spp. in the Indochinese peninsula.
 
lomiller, I'd argue with you, but it seems like you can't comprehend what the EHA grant report says, so it would be a waste of my time.
 
lomiller, I'd argue with you, but it seems like you can't comprehend what the EHA grant report says, so it would be a waste of my time.

You can't tell the difference between 400 meters and 20 Km in this thread, and you can't tell the difference between 50 years and 60 years in the moon landing thread. Maybe you shouldn't be casting aspersions on folks' comprehension skills.
 
Last edited:
lomiller, I'd argue with you, but it seems like you can't comprehend what the EHA grant report says, so it would be a waste of my time.

You are clearly the one who doesn't get it. Virologists all over the world do research similar to this, and they do it so they can identify what viruses are a threat to jump species. It's important work if you want to prevent pandemics like the current one.
 
So what?

Massive cover-up? What nonsense. It only requires the Chinese government and a natural self-preservation of Shi and Daszak to not want to face the music.

Again, this is not the least bit relative.

If you want to use a CT as your evidence against a lab origin hypothesis it does not belong in this thread.

I think there was a cover up in CHina, but it was CHinese officials trying to cover their ass to his all the mistakes they made handling the intial outbreak.
I have noted most real life coverups are not to hide some huge evil plot, but people trying to cover up their screwups.
 
I think there was a cover up in CHina, but it was CHinese officials trying to cover their ass to his all the mistakes they made handling the intial outbreak.
I have noted most real life coverups are not to hide some huge evil plot, but people trying to cover up their screwups.

Indeed. The closing and scrubbing of the market is no doubt a good example of a cover-up that we know about.
 
I think there was a cover up in CHina, but it was CHinese officials trying to cover their ass to his all the mistakes they made handling the intial outbreak.
I have noted most real life coverups are not to hide some huge evil plot, but people trying to cover up their screwups.

It's also entirely possible that identification of Covid as a unique disease is simply non-trivial. Even 6 weeks after the disease first enters the human population you would only expect ~200 infections and perhaps 5-10 hospitalizations. Now split that up between several hospitals and several doctors within each. Is any single doctor really going to see enough cases to distinguish Covid pneumonia from pneumonia cases by other diseases?

Maybe by week 7 (3rd week in Dec) there would be enough cases for people to begin hypothesizing there is a new virus at play, but it is still going to take time to confirm this and begin looking for the virus.

IMO while China's performance in identifying SARS-CoV-2 isn't perfect neither does it suggest any gross incompetence. If a similar new virus were to arise in Florida right now I'm not convinced it would be isolated as quickly as China isolated SARS-CoV-2
 
Indeed. The closing and scrubbing of the market is no doubt a good example of a cover-up that we know about.

That was part of the play book that came from SARS lessons learned. With SARS the market stayed open and continued to create new animal to human crossover events and ultimately contributed to the death toll. The lesson this time is that while the market should still be closed, cleaned and the animals disposed of, everything needs to be sampled first.
 
I think there was a cover up in CHina, but it was CHinese officials trying to cover their ass to his all the mistakes they made handling the intial outbreak.
I have noted most real life coverups are not to hide some huge evil plot, but people trying to cover up their screwups.

China is refusing to put the genome data back online showing all the coronaviruses the WIV had in their system.
They have refused to share the demographics and exposure history of the initial Wuhan patients.
They called for all the specimens (there were a number of them all over the country) to be destroyed.
Daszak purposefully misled the WHO investigative team to call the lab accident hypothesis a CT before it was ever investigated (according to Tedros at the WHO).
Shi at the WIV denied they had any live coronavirus cultures or live bats but evidence surfaced both existed at the WIV.
Shi claimed the 3 miners in Yunnan died of a fungal infection and subsequently both a master's thesis and a doctoral thesis surfaced contradicting that.
A grant proposal surfaced that Daszak had not properly reported on requesting funds to add the furin cleavage site to an existing strain of coronavirus that already had the ability to infect human respiratory cells.​

Those are off the top of my head, there are more. Only the information on the initially infected patients fits your scenario.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom