Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
https://www.researchsquare.com/article/rs-871965/v1

Paper on BANAL-52 and other similar viruses:

Darn, doesn't sound like we have a winner with BANAL-52.

No, I already told you that.

Literally nobody is claiming that BANAL-52 is the progenitor virus that led to SARS-CoV2.

The significance of the discovery is that we now know that a certain feature that was considered to be unique to SARS-CoV2 and that was specified in the Segreto and Deigin paper actually turned up in the wild.

Therefore the claim that it was probably engineered in a lab has lost one of the main pillars.

The other one, of course, is the furin cleavage site. That has not been found yet.
 
No, I already told you that.

Literally nobody is claiming that BANAL-52 is the progenitor virus that led to SARS-CoV2.

The significance of the discovery is that we now know that a certain feature that was considered to be unique to SARS-CoV2 and that was specified in the Segreto and Deigin paper actually turned up in the wild.

Therefore the claim that it was probably engineered in a lab has lost one of the main pillars.

The other one, of course, is the furin cleavage site. That has not been found yet.

Ok, so we know a team of virologists in Wuhan, the place where the pandemic originated, were working on taking bat viruses and weaponizing them to target human ACE2 receptors, and that they were doing so with spike proteins that are highly genetically similar to SARS-CoV-2, while using tools that would normally put two human-preferred codons in the furin cleavage site of an engineered virus, just like SARS-CoV-2 has.

And again, let's just savor the flavor of Tulane's Bob Garry one last time.
“I really can’t think of a plausible natural scenario where you get from the bat virus or one very similar to it to nCoV where you insert exactly 4 amino acids 12 nucleotide that all have to be added at the exact same time to gain this function – that and you don’t change any other amino acid in S2? I just can’t figure out how this gets accomplished in nature."

But you believe that happened by chance in a bat cave located right next door to the laboratory these guys were working in.
 
Ok, so we know a team of virologists in Wuhan, the place where the pandemic originated, were working on taking bat viruses and weaponizing them to target human ACE2 receptors, and that they were doing so with spike proteins that are highly genetically similar to SARS-CoV-2, while using tools that would normally put two human-preferred codons in the furin cleavage site of an engineered virus, just like SARS-CoV-2 has.

And again, let's just savor the flavor of Tulane's Bob Garry one last time.


But you believe that happened by chance in a bat cave located right next door to the laboratory these guys were working in.

Nope. The highlighted is editorializing/just plain wrong.

I don't think you are characterizing very much of this accurately.
 
Nope. The highlighted is editorializing/just plain wrong.

I don't think you are characterizing very much of this accurately.

Ok, tell me where the bat cave was located that SARS-CoV-2 came from.

You do believe the pandemic originated in Wuhan, correct?
 
Ok, tell me where the bat cave was located that SARS-CoV-2 came from.

You do believe the pandemic originated in Wuhan, correct?

We don't know where the virus came from.

Some evidence suggests it probably came from the Huanan Market.

And the virus could have got into the market through the wild-life trade, which means that it likely came from a rural wild-life farm.

However, there is still a lot that is unknown.
 
We don't know where the virus came from.

Some evidence suggests it probably came from the Huanan Market.

And the virus could have got into the market through the wild-life trade, which means that it likely came from a rural wild-life farm.

However, there is still a lot that is unknown.

The Huanan Market is literally 400 meters from the WIV.

I mean think about what you are saying.

We have to be talking about trillion to one odds, hell maybe even gazillion to one odds, that a completely novel human infectious, ACE2 targeting, gene edited furin cleavage site having, bat borne corona virus just happens to erupt into a pandemic 400 meters away from a lab that was working on creating that exact same virus.
 
5a1e5b38986cb99b.jpg
 
The Huanan Market is literally 400 meters from the WIV.

I mean think about what you are saying.

We have to be talking about trillion to one odds, hell maybe even gazillion to one odds, that a completely novel human infectious, ACE2 targeting, gene edited furin cleavage site having, bat borne corona virus just happens to erupt into a pandemic 400 meters away from a lab that was working on creating that exact same virus.

Arguments from incredulity are the weakest arguments.
 
The Huanan Market is literally 400 meters from the WIV.

I mean think about what you are saying.

We have to be talking about trillion to one odds, hell maybe even gazillion to one odds, that a completely novel human infectious, ACE2 targeting, gene edited furin cleavage site having, bat borne corona virus just happens to erupt into a pandemic 400 meters away from a lab that was working on creating that exact same virus.

[qimg]https://media.gab.com/system/media_attachments/files/096/959/158/original/5a1e5b38986cb99b.jpg[/qimg]

You see, this is why a lot of people think that the lab leak is a conspiracy theory.

It relies on the idea of a massive cover-up by, let's see, the Wuhan Institute of Virology, the NIH, most of the world's virologists, and Google.

It is apparently being exposed by some right-wing Senators, ivermectin proponents, anti-vaxxers and ...erm... Gab dwellers?

Look, Michael, I am sure you are a nice guy... well, I'm not sure, but I'll say I hope you're a nice guy, but I don't really have a lot of confidence in your analysis of the documents you feel support your conclusion that the lab leak is the best explanation for the pandemic (just as I'm not confident of your claims about ivermectin and vaccines).

I think these are all difficult topics and require a lot of real expertise. Those who I think have that expertise don't seem to be as persuaded as you are.
 
You see, this is why a lot of people think that the lab leak is a conspiracy theory.

It relies on the idea of a massive cover-up by, let's see, the Wuhan Institute of Virology, the NIH, most of the world's virologists, and Google.

It is apparently being exposed by some right-wing Senators, ivermectin proponents, anti-vaxxers and ...erm... Gab dwellers?

Look, Michael, I am sure you are a nice guy... well, I'm not sure, but I'll say I hope you're a nice guy, but I don't really have a lot of confidence in your analysis of the documents you feel support your conclusion that the lab leak is the best explanation for the pandemic (just as I'm not confident of your claims about ivermectin and vaccines).

I think these are all difficult topics and require a lot of real expertise. Those who I think have that expertise don't seem to be as persuaded as you are.

You don't need confidence in my analysis, I'm giving all the evidence for you to make your own analysis. I'm literally handing you the documents where EHA is telling you explicitly what they were up to, the emails between Fauci, Collins and the scientists, everything.

I don't think its possible for there to be any more evidence short of Fauci coming right out and saying they did it and he funded them. This wasn't some vast conspiracy, this took place between about 10 people.
 
You don't need confidence in my analysis, I'm giving all the evidence for you to make your own analysis. I'm literally handing you the documents where EHA is telling you explicitly what they were up to, the emails between Fauci, Collins and the scientists, everything.

I don't think its possible for there to be any more evidence short of Fauci coming right out and saying they did it and he funded them. This wasn't some vast conspiracy, this took place between about 10 people.

I am not remotely convinced either that you have demonstrated that the WIV made SARS-CoV2, that you know what you are talking about, or that you aren't putting forward a vast conspiracy theory. You even said that you use Duck Duck Go because Google is somehow suppressing searches for the documents you are talking about.
 
I am not remotely convinced either that you have demonstrated that the WIV made SARS-CoV2, that you know what you are talking about, or that you aren't putting forward a vast conspiracy theory. You even said that you use Duck Duck Go because Google is somehow suppressing searches for the documents you are talking about.

That's a shame, because this means it's the end of the debate. I appreciate you pushing and refusing to believe no matter what because it forced me to refine every aspect of my argument until I fully understood every last detail of what went on for myself. I have learned a tremendous amount by arguing with you.

You have all the evidence should you wish to look at it, including the fact that Google censors the hell out of their search results.
 
With my highlighting:
The Huanan Market is literally 400 meters from the WIV.
I mean think about what you are saying.

We have to be talking about trillion to one odds, hell maybe even gazillion to one odds, that a completely novel human infectious, ACE2 targeting, gene edited furin cleavage site having, bat borne corona virus just happens to erupt into a pandemic 400 meters away from a lab that was working on creating that exact same virus.

Those highlighted statements are incorrect.

As was explained earlier in this thread, WIV's Wuchang campus is on the other side of the Yangtze River, at least 10km away from the Huanan Market.

michaelsuede's confusion is likely explained by the fact that a branch office of the Chinese Center for Disease Control and Prevention is located in Wuhan, not far from the Huanan Market:
Wikipedia said:
The Wuhan office of the CCDC is 300 yards from the wet market that was considered a source of the COVID-19 coronavirus.[11][12]


As was pointed out by Skeptic Ginger earlier in this thread, there are some who think a lab leak, if one occurred, was more likely to have occurred at that CCDC facility than at WIV:
“What is more concerning to me is the other lab,” Ben Embarek said. “The one that is next to the market,” he explained, referring to the Wuhan branch of the Chinese CDC, located just 500 meters (547 yards) away from the Huanan market.
 
Clinger, I just showed you a report written by the scientists engaged in making the virus themselves, explicitly telling you that this took place at the WIV, with no mention of any other lab being involved.

As for the market being 17 miles away, I've looked at the Snopes article on this, I've looked at other commentary on this, and I understand that it appears to be 17 miles away.

That said, I know with total certainty that I looked up the location of the WIV and Huanan market myself nearly two years ago on Google maps when this conspiracy theory first started to swirl around the internet and saw with my own two eyes that they were right next door to each other.

This is what the market looked like:
https://sg.news.yahoo.com/wuhan-huanan-seafood-wholesale-market-060729015.html

That Yahoo article has images of the market that look exactly like what I saw. If you search on Google Maps for it, the satellite map has been replaced with an old super-low resolution image where you can't see anything. Bing and Apple don't even take you to the correct place.

They closed that market and reopened it somewhere else, changed the address, and did the same for the WIV, which also looks nothing like the building I saw two years ago.

Look at the Snopes Google Earth video of the market - it looks NOTHING like the Yahoo pictures. They aren't looking at the right place.

Here is a Washington Times article from March 2020:

https://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2020/mar/30/china-researchers-isolated-bat-coronaviruses-near-/


A State Department official said the reports about Mr. Tian and his role in working with bat viruses are concerning.

“He lives and works at Wuhan’s CDC, a few hundred yards away from the Huanan wet market,” the official said. “He is among the small team in Wuhan that has contributed to China’s obsession in recent years with virus hunting and research.”
 
Last edited:
Clinger, I just showed you a report written by the scientists engaged in making the virus themselves, explicitly telling you that this took place at the WIV, with no mention of any other lab being involved.
If you believe this took place at the WIV, then the fact that the CCDC facility is located only a few hundred meters from the market cannot count as evidence in support of your belief.

That said, I know with total certainty that I looked up the location of the WIV and Huanan market myself nearly two years ago on Google maps when this conspiracy theory first started to swirl around the internet and saw with my own two eyes that they were right next door to each other.
Google, Yahoo, Bing, and Apple maps are not infallible. In your own use of those maps, you discovered the fact that they do not always agree. That should have given you a clue to their fallibility.

Here is a Washington Times article from March 2020:

https://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2020/mar/30/china-researchers-isolated-bat-coronaviruses-near-/

A State Department official said the reports about Mr. Tian and his role in working with bat viruses are concerning.

“He lives and works at Wuhan’s CDC, a few hundred yards away from the Huanan wet market,” the official said. “He is among the small team in Wuhan that has contributed to China’s obsession in recent years with virus hunting and research.”
Your quotation correctly identifies Tian Junhua as working at Wuhan's CDC. If you believe a lab leak took place at the WIV, then the fact that Tian Junhua works at Wuhan's CDC rather than WIV does not count as evidence in support of your belief.

It does, however, count as evidence of your continuing confusion.
 
Clinger, I just showed you a report written by the scientists engaged in making the virus themselves, explicitly telling you that this took place at the WIV, with no mention of any other lab being involved.

As for the market being 17 miles away, I've looked at the Snopes article on this, I've looked at other commentary on this, and I understand that it appears to be 17 miles away.

That said, I know with total certainty that I looked up the location of the WIV and Huanan market myself nearly two years ago on Google maps when this conspiracy theory first started to swirl around the internet and saw with my own two eyes that they were right next door to each other.

This is what the market looked like:
https://sg.news.yahoo.com/wuhan-huanan-seafood-wholesale-market-060729015.html

That Yahoo article has images of the market that look exactly like what I saw. If you search on Google Maps for it, the satellite map has been replaced with an old super-low resolution image where you can't see anything. Bing and Apple don't even take you to the correct place.

They closed that market and reopened it somewhere else, changed the address, and did the same for the WIV, which also looks nothing like the building I saw two years ago.

Look at the Snopes Google Earth video of the market - it looks NOTHING like the Yahoo pictures. They aren't looking at the right place.

Here is a Washington Times article from March 2020:

https://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2020/mar/30/china-researchers-isolated-bat-coronaviruses-near-/

Didn’t you say Google was rubbish?
 
They moved that market and the imagery doesn't line up any more.

Here's what the National Review said about the incident:

The second disputable contention is that, “satellite imagery of Wuhan in September and October 2019 that showed a significant uptick in the number of people at local hospitals surrounding the WIV’s headquarters, coupled with an unusually high number of patients with symptoms similar to COVID-19.” The problem is that we don’t know if those upper-respiratory illnesses and viral infections represented cases of SARS-CoV-2; Wuhan has a lot of other viruses going around! In June and July 2019, the streets of Wuhan saw massive protests of thousands of people, objecting to construction of a new incinerator plant, complaining that the city’s air quality was bad enough.
 
We don't know where the virus came from.

Some evidence suggests it probably came from the Huanan Market.
There is no credible evidence that market or any other market in Wuhan was the initial 'crossover' site. By continuing to repeat this you reinforce the falsehood.

And as for Worobey's genetic walk-back, he had missing information on the first patients and while people like Bloom politely said the walk-back had no obvious flaws, he also said it wasn't conclusive evidence.


And the virus could have got into the market through the wild-life trade, which means that it likely came from a rural wild-life farm.

However, there is still a lot that is unknown.
It could have come from the lab. "Likely came from a rural wild-life farm" is bull ****. No trail has been found be it from frozen food to the wildlife farms to the mine in Yunnan to the caves in Laos.

As for finding the furin cleavage site in the wild, sure, it was in a different bat species but recombinant coronaviruses are found in bats. That fact doesn't provide a smoking gun.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom