I don’t dispute that they have been making chimeric viruses using SARS viral backbones. We have been back and forth on this thread about that. Much of that research was done in Ralph Baric’s lab in North Carolina, so you haven’t shown me anything I didn’t know.
Your claim is that they inserted SARS-CoV2 spike proteins, and they did it in the WIV. Have you proved THAT?
On page 20, the report lists SHI, ZHENGLI and GE, XINGY as co-investigators working for the WIV.
On page 23, the report lists the foreign component of the research being the WIV.
On page 24, report states the WIV is responsible for the
"Principal Laboratory for all Research in China and detailed in our Specific Aims"
All of this was done at the WIV between 2014-2019.
SARS-CoV-2 wasn't characterized at the time they were doing the report, so obviously there isn't going to be a quote in the report where I can say "AH HA! Here's where they say they made SARS-CoV-2!" SARS-CoV-2 didn't exist until it escaped from a humanized mouse's lungs and went on to infect the world.
Here's the relevant passage from the Nature
study explaining what we are looking for:
1. The acquisition of both the polybasic cleavage site and predicted O-linked glycans also argues against culture-based scenarios. New polybasic cleavage sites have been observed only after prolonged passage of low-pathogenicity avian influenza virus in vitro or in vivo17.
2. Furthermore, a hypothetical generation of SARS-CoV-2 by cell culture or animal passage would have required prior isolation of a progenitor virus with very high genetic similarity, which has not been described.
3. Subsequent generation of a polybasic cleavage site would have then required repeated passage in cell culture or animals with ACE2 receptors similar to those of humans, but such work has also not previously been described.
4. Finally, the generation of the predicted O-linked glycans is also unlikely to have occurred due to cell-culture passage, as such features suggest the involvement of an immune system18.
EHA states,
"To analyze which viruses were a potential public health risk, we managed to culture three strains of SARSr-CoVs from bat feces: WIV1, WIV16 and Rs4874."
Rs4874 has the most
closely related spike protein to SARS-CoV-2. Rs4874
can bind to human ACE2
So we know they are in possession of a highly genetically similar virus. Point 2 is met.
EHA states,
"Using the reverse genetic system we previously developed, we constructed two chimeric viruses with the WIV1 backbone replaced with the S gene of Rs7327 and Rs4231, respectively. Vero E6 cells [cells that are interferon-deficient so they do not secrete anti-viral interferon when infected by viruses] were respectively infected with Rs4874, WIV1-Rs4231S and WIV1- Rs7327S, and efficient virus replication was detected by immunofluorescence assay in all infections. To assess the usage of human ACE2 by the three novel SL-CoVs, we conducted virus infectivity studies using Hela cells with or without the expression of human ACE2. All viruses replicated efficiently in the human ACE2-expressing cells."
So we know they are infecting human cells with engineered viruses with ACE2 selective RBDs. We know they are able to create completely novel viruses. We know they have the ability manipulate large segments of genetic code:
“Infectious clones with the S gene of novel SARSr-CoVs and the SARSr-CoV WIV1 genome backbone using the reverse genetic system developed in our previous R01 [previously approved grants]. The correct infectious BAC [bacterial artificial chromosome, a biological system allowing storage and manipulation of large segments of genetic code] clones will be screened by BAC DNA digestion with appropriate restriction enzyme or PCR amplification. The chimeric viruses will be rescued in Vero cells and then verified by sequence analyses. Our research group is well versed in coronavirus reverse genetics.”
And from the previous quote I cited, we know they were infecting humanized mice with engineered viruses specifically targeting ACE2. That takes care of points 1, 3 and 4.
Still think a "natural emergence" is the most likely scenario?
Here's what Tulane's Bob Garry
had to say about it:
“I really can’t think of a plausible natural scenario where you get from the bat virus or one very similar to it to nCoV where you insert exactly 4 amino acids 12 nucleotide that all have to be added at the exact same time to gain this function – that and you don’t change any other amino acid in S2? I just can’t figure out how this gets accomplished in nature."
Again, we come to the question of what is most likely.
Is it more likely nature magically solved an impossible problem or is it more likely the people who were conducting gain-of-function research on SARS viruses in a Wuhan Lab, specifically working on ACE2 RBDs, and that had the knowledge and equipment necessary to make SARS-CoV-2, made it.