Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
And yet you brought up Deigin directly followed by your "bat **** crazy" accusation.

I know how to read. Maybe you need a grammar lesson in antecedents.

And you brought up my citing Deigin. Have you seen me bring the other two up because I don't recognize their names.
[

Not for the first time you are arguing that I should only talk about things that YOU bring up. Yet at other times you get annoyed if I make any posts about you.

When it comes to lab leak, I am talking about various lab leak theories including ones that you don’t endorse. Because it is not about you.
 
Not for the first time you are arguing that I should only talk about things that YOU bring up. Yet at other times you get annoyed if I make any posts about you.

When it comes to lab leak, I am talking about various lab leak theories including ones that you don’t endorse. Because it is not about you.

Oh for pity's sake! :crazy:

I said no such thing. Please reread the exchange. You started with an attempt to drag the discussion into the CT realm. I called you on it. Then you said Deigin, your example of bat **** crazy, was your source. I showed he was not in the bat **** crazy category. Then you denied saying it, pointing out you only meant the other two were bat **** crazy. And I said I don't recognize the names.

And now you come up with this nonsense.

Could you please get back to discussing the evidence and facts in the case and stop discussing CTs, stop dismissing valid sources as too right-wing, or too [fill in the blank], stop implying I buy into CTs on the origin debate.

The only place the CT matter belongs in this thread is when discussing Daszak's temporary success getting the scientific community to buy into the falsehood the lab hypothesis was a CT. If you have something else relevant feel free to bring it up, otherwise PLEASE get over it. Regardless of which origin hypothesis you feel the evidence favors, the lab leak hypothesis is a valid, evidence supported hypothesis and it isn't a CT.
 
Oh for pity's sake! :crazy:

I said no such thing. Please reread the exchange. You started with an attempt to drag the discussion into the CT realm. I called you on it. Then you said Deigin, your example of bat **** crazy, was your source. I showed he was not in the bat **** crazy category. Then you denied saying it, pointing out you only meant the other two were bat **** crazy. And I said I don't recognize the names.

What I wrote was perfectly clear. Not to you, maybe, because you seem to be insistent on acting hard done by.
 
Oh for pity's sake! :crazy:

I said no such thing. Please reread the exchange. You started with an attempt to drag the discussion into the CT realm. I called you on it. Then you said Deigin, your example of bat **** crazy, was your source. I showed he was not in the bat **** crazy category. Then you denied saying it, pointing out you only meant the other two were bat **** crazy. And I said I don't recognize the names.

Skeptic Ginger said:
And yet you brought up Deigin directly followed by your "bat **** crazy" accusation.
I know how to read. Maybe you need a grammar lesson in antecedents.
Hey SG, as someone who is reading and following the thread, this really doesn't do what you describe. The only "antecedents" to these comments were Bret and Jordan.

Funny you should say that because some lab leak theorists do indeed claim that Omicron came from a lab as well. I have seen Yuri Deigin float that idea (though not for Delta).[new sentence starts here-carlito] Bret Weinstein and Jordan Peterson have been showing how completely bat **** they have become by suggesting that the variants are some kind of Big Pharma ruse (honestly, people used to think they were smart dudes but the pandemic has turned them into Alex Jones).
"They" is not referring to Yuri. "They" are the two guys who are appearing on News and podcasts with audiences in the millions - Fox News, Joe Rogan etc.
 
Last edited:
Hey SG, as someone who is reading and following the thread, this really doesn't do what you describe. The only "antecedents" to these comments were Bret and Jordan.
Sure in hindsight. Once angrysoba pointed out putting the three names in the same paragraph, with one sentence following the other OK fine he technically didn't call Diegin bat **** crazy.

Not to mention in the past that angrysoba has dismissed Diegin's comments on the origin of COVID.

But this is now a stupid off-topic discussion.


"They" is not referring to Yuri. "They" are the two guys who are appearing on News and podcasts with audiences in the millions - Fox News, Joe Rogan etc.
Your point? :confused: How does dragging CTers and crazy people out there into this discussion move the evidence based debate forward?
 
Sure in hindsight. Once angrysoba pointed out putting the three names in the same paragraph, with one sentence following the other OK fine he technically didn't call Diegin bat **** crazy.

Not to mention in the past that angrysoba has dismissed Diegin's comments on the origin of COVID.

But this is now a stupid off-topic discussion.


Your point? :confused: How does dragging CTers and crazy people out there into this discussion move the evidence based debate forward?

SG, but please. This whole digression happened as an aside when lionking asked if anyone considers Delta or Omicron to be lab releases. I point out that some have suggested that.

Then you repeatedly questioned me on various points and told me I was wrong while misreading me. Carlitos and I have tried to correct those mistakes and while doing so you criticize us for a pointless off-topic discussion. The off-ramp has been there for you from the beginning.
 
How does dragging CTers and crazy people out there into this discussion move the evidence based debate forward?
I don't know; it's an awkward topic. Most of the people who hear about a lab leak hypothesis are going to hear about it from "a crazy conspiracy theorist," aren't they?

Twice as many Americans believe that this thing leaked from a lab as believe in the wet market hypothesis.
 
My letter to the Senate explains exactly where it came from. In fact, I even have a link to the NIH report showing how the gain of function research was conducted.

https://www.scribd.com/document/553669611/Letter-to-Senate-Detailing-NIH-NIAID-and-FDA-Malfeasance

3.1 In vivo infection of Human ACE2 (hACE2) expressing mice with SARSr-CoV S protein variants

In Year 5, we continued with in vivo infection experiments of diverse bat SARSr-CoVs on transgenic mice expressing human ACE2. Mice were infected with 4 strains of SARSr-CoVs with different S protein, including the full-length recombinant virus of SARSr-CoV WIV1 and three chimeric viruses with the backbone of WIV1 and S proteins of SHC014, WIV16 and Rs4231, respectively. Pathogenicity of the 4 SARSr-CoVs was evaluated by recording the survival rate of challenged mice in a 2-week course. All of the 4 SARSr-CoVs caused lethal infection in hACE2 transgenic mice, but the mortality rate vary among 4 groups of infected mice (Fig. 13a). 14 days post infection, 5 out of 7 mice infected with WIV1 remained alive (71.4%), while only 2 of 8 mice infected with rWIV1-SHC014 S survived (25%). The survival rate of mice infected with rWIV1-WIV16S and rWIV1-4231S were 50%. Viral replication was confirmed by quantitative PCR in spleen, lung, intestine and brain of infected mice. In brain, rWIV1, rWIV1- WIV16S and rWIV1-4231S cannot be detected 2 days or 4 days post infection. However, rWIV1-SHC014 was detected at all time points and showed an increasing viral titer after infection. The viral load reached more than 109 genome copies/g at the dead point (Fig. 13b). We also conducted histopathological section examination in infected mice. Tissue lesion and lymphocytes infiltration can be observed in lung, which is more significant in mice infected with rWIV1-SHC014 S (Fig. 13d) than those infected with rWIV1 (Fig. 13c). These results suggest that the pathogenicity of SHC014 is higher than other tested bat SARSr-CoVs in transgenic mice that express hACE2.

In Vivo Infection of Human ACE2 (hACE2) Expressing Mice with SARSr-CoV S Protein variants

Using the reverse genetic methods we previously developed, infectious clones with the WIV1 backbone and the spike protein of SHC014, WIV16 and Rs4231, respectively, were constructed and recombinant viruses were successfully rescued. In Year 4, we performed preliminary in vivo infection of SARSr-CoVs on transgenic mice that express hACE2. Mice were infected with 105 pfu of full-length recombinant virus of WIV1 (rWIV1) and the three chimeric viruses with different spikes. Pathogenesis of the 4 SARSr-CoVs was then determined in a 2-week course. Mice challenged with rWIV1-SHC014S have experienced about 20% body weight loss by the 6th day post infection, while rWIV1 and rWIV-4231S produced less body weight loss. In the mice infected with rWIV1-WIV16S, no body weight loss was observed (Fig. 35a). 2 and 4 days post infection, the viral load in lung tissues of mice challenged with rWIV1-SHC014S, rWIV1-WIV16S and rWIV1-Rs4231S reached more than 106 genome copies/g and were significantly higher than that in rWIV1-infected mice (Fig. 35b). These results demonstrate varying pathogenicity of SARSr-CoVs with different spike proteins in humanized mice.


Here's the reason the NIH investigative team gave for saying it could not have come from a lab:

“subsequent generation of a polybasic cleavage site would have then required repeated passage in cell culture or animals with ACE2 receptors similar to those of humans, but such work has also not previously been described.”


Check out this paper on it.
https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/bies.202000240
 
Last edited:
Glad that's settled then. I'll ask for the thread to be closed.

I'm glad I could help out. I see you guys were spinning your wheels here for a bit.

Not sure if I mentioned it, but those quotes come from the EcoHealth Alliance NIH grant report on the research they were conducting at the Wuhan Lab.
 
Last edited:
I don't know; it's an awkward topic. Most of the people who hear about a lab leak hypothesis are going to hear about it from "a crazy conspiracy theorist," aren't they?

Twice as many Americans believe that this thing leaked from a lab as believe in the wet market hypothesis.

Honestly, Bret Weinstein was one of the first people to promote the idea of the lab leak, and he did so when Yuri Deigin went on his show to discuss it.

Then they fell out when Weinstein became obviously anti-vax and promoted ivermectin as a prophylactic.

So I don't think that Weinstein is just some rando.
 
I don't know; it's an awkward topic. Most of the people who hear about a lab leak hypothesis are going to hear about it from "a crazy conspiracy theorist," aren't they?

Twice as many Americans believe that this thing leaked from a lab as believe in the wet market hypothesis.
Everything that follows in this post is well documented in this thread:

You have Daskin who was very influential, injecting himself into the debate as an expert, who steered the whole science/medical communities into believing the lab leak origin was a CT. He did this, as noted by Tedros, the head of the WHO, before any information on a potential lab origin was ever investigated. Daszak also manipulated some researchers into signing a letter dismissing the lab leak hypothesis by disguising the fact he was the author of the letter.

He kept that CT myth going despite the incriminating problem that had the origin been the lab, Daszak was in it up to his eyeballs. He's been caught lying and hiding the grant proposal which he wanted to make a SARS CoV more deadly in order to develop a universal coronavirus vaccine.

There was pressure on the scientific community not to discuss/investigate the lab leak hypothesis as they had concerns it might be a career killer.

On top of that you have Dump and the right wingers mucking up everything. When I've posted evidence/facts in this thread it's often hand-waved away, not based on the merits of the evidence, but based on the fact (oh the horror) that the information came from a right-wing source.

THERE IS A THREAD IN THE CT SUB-FORUM to discuss any and everything related to the nonsense that suggesting a lab origin is purely a CT. I will continue to resist having this thread dragged into a CT discussion.

I know it's difficult boys and girls but there actually is plenty of science to be discussed on this topic. How easy it is to dismiss the possible lab leak origin by denigrating it to a CT.

This is not a 9/11-like discussion. This is not a QAnon-like discussion. Too many people on this forum, especially in this discussion, have categorized the COVID origin debate into black and white categories of CT vs science.


Who cares what nut-jobs have appeared in Rogan's podcast? Who cares that they believe CTs about the omicron variant? That discussion does not belong in this thread.

There's nothing scientifically relevant about the omicron variant when it comes to the COVID origin debate. It really only serves to muddy the discussion about the lab origin hypothesis. There's absolutely no evidence China, the WIV or Daszak had anything to do with that even if omicron had anything to do with a lab. It's just another attempt to drag this discussion into CT territory.
 
Last edited:
My letter to the Senate explains exactly where it came from. In fact, I even have a link to the NIH report showing how the gain of function research was conducted.

https://www.scribd.com/document/553669611/Letter-to-Senate-Detailing-NIH-NIAID-and-FDA-Malfeasance






Here's the reason the NIH investigative team gave for saying it could not have come from a lab:




Check out this paper on it.
https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/bies.202000240

Yeah, I think we know that the genetic structure does not rule out a lab leak.

Almost nothing can ever rule it out.

The point is what is the likeliest origin?

At first, the structure was indeed considered unique, and some parts such as the furin cleavage do seem unusual. But that was also said about the receptor binding domain. Given that at the time of the paper being written by Segreto and Deigin, RaTG13 was the closest known coronavirus, the theory that SARS-CoV2 might have come from the same place when Zhengli-Shi and the WIV sampled viruses from the Mojiang Mine had a certain superficial plausibility.

However, looking at their claims now....

We here describe how the two main SARS-CoV-2 features, (1) the presence of a furin cleavage site missing in other CoVs of the same group and (2) an receptor binding domain (RBD) optimized to bind to human cells[[2] might be the result of lab manipulation techniques such as site-directed mutagenesis.

Well, the RBD has turned up more recently in a bat coronavirus found in Laos, known as BANAl-52.

Link

Scientists have found three viruses in bats in Laos that are more similar to SARS-CoV-2 than any known viruses. Researchers say that parts of their genetic code bolster claims that the virus behind COVID-19 has a natural origin — but their discovery also raises fears that there are numerous coronaviruses with the potential to infect people.

...The results, which are not peer reviewed, have been posted on the preprint server Research Square1. Particularly concerning is that the new viruses contain receptor binding domains that are almost identical to that of SARS-CoV-2, and can therefore infect human cells. The receptor binding domain allows SARS-CoV-2 to attach to a receptor called ACE2 on the surface of human cells to enter them.
...

“When SARS-CoV-2 was first sequenced, the receptor binding domain didn’t really look like anything we’d seen before,” says Edward Holmes, a virologist at the University of Sydney in Australia. This caused some people to speculate that the virus had been created in a laboratory. But the Laos coronaviruses confirm these parts of SARS-CoV-2 exist in nature, he says.

...

Last year, researchers described another close relative of SARS-CoV-2, called RaTG13, which was found in bats in Yunnan5. It is 96.1% identical to SARS-CoV-2 overall and the two viruses probably shared a common ancestor 40–70 years ago6. BANAL-52 is 96.8% identical to SARS-CoV-2, says Eloit — and all three newly discovered viruses have individual sections that are more similar to sections of SARS-CoV-2 than seen in any other viruses.

So this discovery removes ONE of the two main claims from Segreto and Deigin's paper, and also shows a virus closer to SARS-CoV2 than RaTG13. ETA: Even Deigin was surprised by this discovery and said he hadn't expected an RBD to turn up in a natural coronavirus.

Now, if a furin-cleavage site is also found in a new coronavirus from the wild (and the EcoHealth Alliance clearly expect that such a virus exists in nature judging by the grant proposal that some are using to argue that it was a lab leak), then both of the main planks of Segreto and Deigin's argument would be taken out.
 
Last edited:
Yeah, I think we know that the genetic structure does not rule out a lab leak.

Almost nothing can ever rule it out.

The point is what is the likeliest origin?

At first, the structure was indeed considered unique, and some parts such as the furin cleavage do seem unusual. But that was also said about the receptor binding domain. Given that at the time of the paper being written by Segreto and Deigin, RaTG13 was the closest known coronavirus, the theory that SARS-CoV2 might have come from the same place when Zhengli-Shi and the WIV sampled viruses from the Mojiang Mine had a certain superficial plausibility.

However, looking at their claims now....



Well, the RBD has turned up more recently in a bat coronavirus found in Laos, known as BANAl-52.

Link



So this discovery removes ONE of the two main claims from Segreto and Deigin's paper, and also shows a virus closer to SARS-CoV2 than RaTG13. ETA: Even Deigin was surprised by this discovery and said he hadn't expected an RBD to turn up in a natural coronavirus.

Now, if a furin-cleavage site is also found in a new coronavirus from the wild (and the EcoHealth Alliance clearly expect that such a virus exists in nature judging by the grant proposal that some are using to argue that it was a lab leak), then both of the main planks of Segreto and Deigin's argument would be taken out.

So.... a bunch of guys at the Wuhan lab that are explicitly writing reports about how they are infecting humanized mice with engineered SARS-CoV-2 viruses saying things like, "we will assess potential for each isolated virus and those with receptor binding site sequence, to spill over. We will do this by sequencing the spike (or other receptor binding/fusion) protein genes from all our bat-CoVs, creating mutants to identify how significantly each would need to evolve to use ACE2, CD26/DPP4 (MERS-CoV receptor) or other potential CoV receptors. We will then use receptor-mutant pseudovirus binding assays, in vitro studies in bat, primate, human and other species’ cell lines, and with humanized mice where particularly interesting viruses are identified phylogenetically, or isolated." - is clearly not the most likely place it came from.
 
So.... a bunch of guys at the Wuhan lab that are explicitly writing reports about how they are infecting humanized mice with engineered SARS-CoV-2 viruses saying things like, "we will assess potential for each isolated virus and those with receptor binding site sequence, to spill over. We will do this by sequencing the spike (or other receptor binding/fusion) protein genes from all our bat-CoVs, creating mutants to identify how significantly each would need to evolve to use ACE2, CD26/DPP4 (MERS-CoV receptor) or other potential CoV receptors. We will then use receptor-mutant pseudovirus binding assays, in vitro studies in bat, primate, human and other species’ cell lines, and with humanized mice where particularly interesting viruses are identified phylogenetically, or isolated." - is clearly not the most likely place it came from.

Could you show me the source of where that quote comes from?

I tried to Google it but nothing came up.
 
I told you, it comes from the EcoHealth Alliance NIH grant report they are obligated to do annually. It's linked in my letter.

Here's a link from the House Energy and Commerce Committee's host. https://republicans-energycommerce.house.gov/wp-content/uploads/2021/10/Year-5-EHA.pdf

You can look at this in two different ways:

1.) It appears the very thing they were looking for and warning about turned up in China.

OR...

2.) iT appeArs ThE very tHINg ThEY wERE LOokING fOr And wARNIng ABoUt turneD uP IN cHIna.
 
Could you show me the source of where that quote comes from?

I tried to Google it but nothing came up.

Oh one more thing, you're not going to find anything using Google. It's heavily censored. It came right up for me using DuckDuckGo. Never use Google. It's evil.
 
You can look at this in two different ways:

1.) It appears the very thing they were looking for and warning about turned up in China.

OR...

2.) iT appeArs ThE very tHINg ThEY wERE LOokING fOr And wARNIng ABoUt turneD uP IN cHIna.

They weren't "looking" for it, they were engineering it. They made those virus bind to ACE2, they didn't dig them up from a bat cave. They explicitly tell you how they made them.
 
They weren't "looking" for it, they were engineering it. They made those virus bind to ACE2, they didn't dig them up from a bat cave. They explicitly tell you how they made them.

They absolutely were:

Specific Aim 1: Assessment of CoV spillover potential at high risk human-wildlife interfaces. We will examine if: 1) wildlife
markets in China provide enhanced capacity for bat-CoVs to infect other hosts, either via evolutionary adaptation or
recombination; 2) the import of animals from throughout Southeast Asia introduces a higher genetic diversity of mammalian
CoVs in market systems compared to within intact ecosystems of China and Southeast Asia; We will interview people about
the nature and frequency of contact with bats and other wildlife; collect blood samples from people highly exposed to wildlife;
and collect a full range of clinical samples from bats and other mammals in the wild and in wetmarkets; and screen these for
CoVs using serological and molecular assays.

Note also the mention of wet markets!

What about these references to virus surveillance?
 

Attachments

  • Virus surveillance.jpg
    Virus surveillance.jpg
    54.3 KB · Views: 2
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom