Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
From the link I posted:
The emails, uncovered in a Freedom of Information Request by the US-based White Coat Waste Project, suggest that viral DNA from “bats and other high-risk species” were sent to Wuhan between June 2017 to May 2019.
Kind of hard to say you are going to do something 2 years after you propose to do it.

We need to see the actual emails.
 
Last edited:
Get over it. It's not a CT, I'm not developing a conspiracy.

It has nothing to do with some secret discovery. Good grief!

Daszak and crew are searching out SARS like coronaviruses. It is their stated mission, published, in print! The emails are evidence that search included specific bat species in Laos caves which he then shipped to the WIV: also in print in the emails! Documented, you know that little thing that supports evidence based conclusions.

But now Echohealth Alliance is claiming the email only said they were going to collect those samples and that they never did so.

This story needs to ripen a bit. I'm waiting to see the actual emails.

:popcorn1

Your claim is that they had found BANAL-52, but the researchers who found it are not affiliated with EcoHealth as far as I know.
 
Excuse me while I think out loud.

I remember that EcoHealth Alliance doesn't do the work directly.

From 2018 this was an overview of the broader plan: Bat Research Networks and Viral Surveillance: Gaps and Opportunities in Western Asia
To fulfil this regional gap, EcoHealth Alliance (EHA), a global non-profit organization dedicated to protecting wildlife and public health, formed the Western Asia Bat Research Network (WAB-Net, “wah-bee-net”) in collaboration with key regional stakeholders in Western Asia in 2018.

WAB-Net aims to: conduct on-the-ground research to bring together regional experts from a variety of disciplines (e.g., bat ecologists, conservationists, virologists, public health officials); strengthen scientific capacity via research exchanges, data sharing platforms, in-region laboratory testing, and annual workshops; and promote the development and leadership of local scientists and officials.
So maybe for 2+ years the WAB-Net didn't get around to looking for CoVs in bats in Laos caves even though looking specifically for bat CoVs is mentioned multiple times in the document.

The WIV isn't mentioned in the document but references to utilizing experts including those in other countries is mentioned numerous times in the plan.

Daszak is on the Scientific Advisory Board that was/is to oversee the WAB-Net.
Additionally, WAB-Net has formed an initial Scientific Advisory Board (SAB) to help guide and oversee the network, comprised of a group of global experts with backgrounds in bat ecology and conservation, virology and laboratory diagnostics, and wildlife disease ecology. The SAB was formed to review proposed scientific activities, provide expertise during annual data sharing and capacity building workshops, monitor the network’s growth and communication, and help liaise with regional and global stakeholders.

Kind of hard to believe the emails weren't talking about work already done, though that is possible. Whether the work was done might depend on the dates on the emails and the wording.
 
With highlighting as in the original:
Again, where is the source and why has it not been found in 2 years? Yes there is a lot of territory to search. But it would not have been the immaculate infection. There should be some semblance of an outbreak on the way to Wuhan. That is epidemiology 101.
Upon wondering whether that highlighted claim would be made by anyone who had actually passed Epidemiology 101, I looked up the curriculum recommended for that course by the Faculty Development Program of the Association for Prevention Teaching and Research (APTR) and the Association of American Colleges and Universities (AAC&U).

Epidemiology 101 is
An introductory course illustrating the scientific method and designed to fulfill a science requirement, including the option for an "epidemiology laboratory," integrating such skills as quantitative thinking, inquiry and analysis, and teamwork.
According to APTR and AAC&U, the course is designed to have no prerequisites at all. One of the most popular textbooks for that course is said to be "Perfect for those with no prior familiarity with health-related fields or statistics".

So yes, it is plausible that someone who has passed that course would make the claim highlighted by Skeptic Ginger. I'm not sure we should give much weight to that, because it is also plausible that such people had "no prior familiarity with health-related fields or statistics."
 
Excuse me while I think out loud.

I remember that EcoHealth Alliance doesn't do the work directly.

From 2018 this was an overview of the broader plan: Bat Research Networks and Viral Surveillance: Gaps and Opportunities in Western Asia



So maybe for 2+ years the WAB-Net didn't get around to looking for CoVs in bats in Laos caves even though looking specifically for bat CoVs is mentioned multiple times in the document.

The WIV isn't mentioned in the document but references to utilizing experts including those in other countries is mentioned numerous times in the plan.

Daszak is on the Scientific Advisory Board that was/is to oversee the WAB-Net.


Kind of hard to believe the emails weren't talking about work already done, though that is possible. Whether the work was done might depend on the dates on the emails and the wording.

How about this a Toursist came from Laos to Wuhan urinated and the Urine was washed into an underground cave, where bats live since the limestone Wuhan is built on, allows this to happen.
Then a Bat is infected that has another Covid Virus infecting it, the Laos Virus Mutates into Covid 19, and then the bat goes out to feed over a wet Market.
It Urinates on Patient Number one and starts a world wide pandemic?
 
Again, where is the source and why has it not been found in 2 years? Yes there is a lot of territory to search. But it would not have been the immaculate infection. There should be some semblance of an outbreak on the way to Wuhan. That is epidemiology 101..
Questions ignorant of "epidemiology 101" or the contents of this thread. No one expects to find the source of a spillover event 100% of the time or within just 2 years. It took 15 years to find the source of SARS as pointed out several times in this thread. If we never find the animal reservoir for SARS-CoV-2, that is not evidence against zoonotic origin or for a lab leak.

The most likely pathway is from bats to an intermediate host to humans and then popping up in Wuhan. That means we need to sample all the mammals around the bat caves including humans and then analyze these samples. Probably ditto for Wuhan. There no reports of thousands of people collecting hundreds of thousands of samples.
 
Last edited:
But now Echohealth Alliance is claiming the email only said they were going to collect those samples and that they never did so.

This story needs to ripen a bit. I'm waiting to see the actual emails.
It is a pity she did not wait for the actual emails before spreading the tabloid rumor that Laotian bat samples were sent to Wuhan.
The EcoHealth Alliance would know exactly what was in the emails because they wrote them!
https://twitter.com/EcoHealthNYC
"The emails between EcoHealth Alliance and the NIH cited by Matt Ridley do not show, as he claims, that we were sampling bats in Laos and sending the results to Wuhan."
"It is true that EcoHealth Alliance requested permission from the NIH to conduct work in Southeast Asian countries, including Laos, and that the NIH did grant permission to do such work."
"However, we considered it a higher priority to continue our focus on China, and no work was ever conducted in Laos as a part of this collaborative research project."

This emphasizes a danger of relying on tabloids. More reputable or competent news sources would do fact checking rather than blindly reporting what Mat Ridley said. They would read the emails. They would contact the EcoHealth Alliance and the NIH. They would ask contacts in Laos whether the EcoHealth Alliance was active there.
 
For me, the new variant blows apart claims that viruses like SARS-CoV2 need a long time to mutate such impressive transmissability.

Link

In my opinion, it is nice to see Andersen back on Twitter.
 
I looked and hadn’t seen this one here. An Arizona researcher thinks that he found “not patient zero” at the wet market.

https://www.azcentral.com/story/ne...ginate-wet-market-michael-worobey/8721978002/


The female seafood vendor identified in the paper, Wei Guixian, became ill on Dec. 10 and was likely infected via respiratory transmission from an animal host, Worobey said. His original article said Dec. 11.

"The seafood vendor got sick on Dec 10 not 11," Worobey wrote in an email this week. "This will be corrected in the print version of the paper. I only pinned this down after the early release version was posted."


He noted that his research does not confirm that Guixian was ‘patient zero’ of the pandemic — that is, the very first case of COVID-19 ever in a human — but rather that she is the first known case researchers can identify, he said.

Since only about 7% of those infected with the novel coronavirus end up in the hospital as the vendor did, it’s unlikely she was the very first case, he said, although she may have been among the very first.
 
Last edited:
Time for a bump.

Scientists believed Covid leaked from Wuhan lab - but feared debate could hurt ‘international harmony’
Leading British and US scientists thought it was likely that Covid accidentally leaked from a laboratory but were concerned that further debate would harm science in China, emails show.

An email from Sir Jeremy Farrar, director of the Wellcome Trust, on February 2 2020 said that “a likely explanation” was that Covid had rapidly evolved from a Sars-like virus inside human tissue in a low-security lab.

The email, to Dr Anthony Fauci and Dr Francis Collins of the US National Institutes of Health, went on to say that such evolution may have “accidentally created a virus primed for rapid transmission between humans”.

But a leading scientist told Sir Jeremy that “further debate would do unnecessary harm to science in general and science in China in particular”. Dr Collins, the former director of the US National Institutes of Health, warned it could damage “international harmony”. ...

Collins has always maintained the lab leak was most likely. Fauci has denied it but one cannot help but consider his conflict of interest given the emails that surfaced, along with the EcoHealth Alliance grant proposal both implicating the NIH of indeed funding the GoF research at the WIV.

I don't think more discussion of the semantics what is and is not GoF is of any use at the moment. Neither is Rand Paul's focus on calling Fauci a criminal for lying to Congress. All of that is a distraction from the origin issue.


Later emails showed that by February 4, Sir Jeremy had revised his estimate of a laboratory leak to 50:50, while Professor Eddie Holmes, of the University of Sydney, gave a 60:40 estimate in favour of an accidental release.

The emails also show that Bob Garry, of the University of Texas, was unconvinced that Covid-19 emerged naturally.
I'm skeptical the 'science' is why Garry changed his tune but it's again a distraction from the origin question.


I have some more stuff from Chan, the other co-author of Viral: the search for the origin of Covid after her testimony to the UK Parliament Science Committee. A citation on Chan was posted upthread.
Viscount Ridley, co-author of Viral: the search for the origin of Covid, said: “These emails show a lamentable lack of openness and transparency among Western scientists who appear to have been more interested in shutting down a hypothesis they thought was very plausible, for political reasons.”

I was working on more evidence surrounding the furin cleavage site. I recall from early in this thread that Capsid very cynically said something like, "Not the furin cleavage [thing] again." So I wanted to pursue this more and haven't yet.
In the emails, Sir Jeremy said that other scientists also believed the virus could not have evolved naturally. One such scientist was Professor Mike Farzan, of Scripps Research, the expert who discovered how the original Sars virus binds to human cells.

Scientists were particularly concerned by a part of Covid-19 called the furin cleavage site, a section of the spike protein which helps it enter cells and makes it so infectious to humans.


Wuhan Lab Leak "More Likely" Origin Of COVID-19, Says Researcher
London: A Canadian molecular biologist on Wednesday told cross-party members of Parliament (MPs) on the House of Commons Science and Technology Committee that a leak from a laboratory in Wuhan region of China is now the “more likely” origin of the COVID-19 global pandemic.
Dr Alina Chan, specialising in gene therapy and cell engineering and co-author of ‘Viral: The Search for the Origin of COVID-19', told the Parliament panel's evidence session on scientific research that the pandemic was being caused by the unique feature of the coronavirus called “furin cleavage site”, which has been linked to the Wuhan Institute of Virology.

Asked by the panel about the probability of a lab leak as the origin of the pandemic, Chan said a “lab origin is more likely than natural origin at this point”.

I don't think I addressed Worobey sufficiently yet. His 'analysis' remains in the 'nice hypothesis but not anything to hang one's hat on' category. He has yet to account for a number of things like actual evidence the pandemic began in the Seafood wet market. If it was an animal host and spillover event, where is the animal trail? Even if the animal evidence at the market was destroyed there should still be a trail somewhere.

Claiming patient zero was infected by an animal spillover event when there is no evidence anywhere of that is simply making up facts to fill in the blanks sections (missing evidence) of his hypothesis.

From Chan's testimony:
“We all agree that there was a critical event at the Huanan Seafood Market, that was a superspreader event caused by humans. There is no evidence pointing to a natural animal origin of the virus at that market,” she noted.
 
Respectfully, you came back and posted an article from the Telegraph and some news channel from India? Isn’t the science subforum normally more sciencey in terms of source material?
 
Respectfully, you came back and posted an article from the Telegraph and some news channel from India? Isn’t the science subforum normally more sciencey in terms of source material?

Who gives a ******* rip what source I cited? Are you claiming the emails are fakes? Do you have an issue with the information in the emails or in the articles?
If all you have is to rip on the cited sources and nothing addressing the actual content, then you got nothing.


BTW, Chan's testimony in the Parliament was Dec 16, 2021. The last post here before mine was yours on Dec 2, 2021 so news on the Parliament testimony couldn't possibly be old in regards to the thread.

And while the emails were from circa Feb 2020, the new information came to light only this month:
The new details came to light after members of the US Republican House Oversight Committee were granted access to the documents, after complaining that their content had been heavily redacted when released under Freedom of Information requests.

The emails were sent in response to a teleconference between 12 scientists including Sir Patrick Vallance, the Government's chief scientific adviser, on February 1.

Looks to me like you didn't even look at the sources I cited before you hand-waved them away. Pretty consistent will the bulk of rebuttals in this thread, dissing the sources while not addressing the content, and not presenting any evidence supporting the spillover origin other than the claim it is somehow more likely historically. And that argument turns a blind eye to all the lab accidents documented in the thread.
 
Last edited:
The fact is that all of this stuff IS old news. DRASTIC had these emails unearthed months and months ago. I think I mentioned about Jeremy Farrar and his emails, and the fact that many scientists including Kristian Andersen, Patrick Vallance, Andrew Rambaut, Robert Garry, and Eddie Holmes initially believed that the virus was from a lab. The fact that they then changed their mind could be seen as science in action or of course it could be seen as a conspiracy between the US, UK and China’s entire scientific community.

“ Collins has always maintained the lab leak was most likely”.

I’m pretty sure that is NOT true but would be interested in seeing your evidence for it.

Apparently Ridley and Chan’s book largely makes a case based on the idea that there is something very fishy about RaTG13, and then the whole thing was blown out of the water with the Laotian viruses.

Also, Richard Dawkins recently got excited about Ridley and Chan’s book suggesting to me that he might be losing it a bit. Most virologists think Ridley’s book is a joke.
 
Skeptic Ginger claims "Collins has always maintained the lab leak was most likely".


This clip from Lex Fridman interviewing Francis Collins absolutely refutes that claim:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mRZE-SJShkE&t=78s
That's from Nov. There's more political pressure than ever on all these guys to quit saying it was a lab leak. He does not deny it here; he only opines that the evidence for a natural event hasn't been found.

Collins: "I can't exclude [the lab origin]. It seems unlikely. I wish we had more ability to ask more questions of the Chinese government and learn more about what kind of records might have been in the lab that we've never been able to see."

"We might know if we ever find that intermediate host...."

He goes on to claim it was 14 years with SARS to find out it was the civet cat. That's false. Even the bat origin before the intermediate species was found by 2007, 5 years from the epidemic.

He admits "With MERS it was quicker ..."

CBC News
November 23, 2006
Chinese scientists say they can prove that the virus that causes SARS jumped from civet cats to humans, but the World Health Organization is not convinced.

An official from the Guangzhou Centre for Disease Control and Prevention, said genetic testing has shown that the virus that killed more than 800 people, including 44 in Canada, came from civets.

"Our research has shown that the SARS coronavirus found in human victims is the same as the SARS coronavirus found in civet cats," said Wang Ming, China Daily reported.

2007 Bats, Civets and the Emergence of SARS
Early epidemiologic investigations suggested an animal origin for SARS-CoV. Virological and serological studies indicated that masked palm civets ( Paguma larvata ), together with two other wildlife animals, sampled from a live animal market were infected with SARS-CoV or a closely related virus. Recently, horseshoe bats in the genus Rhinolophus have been identified as natural reservoir of SARS-like coronaviruses. Here, we review studies by different groups demonstrating that SARS-CoV succeeded in spillover from a wildlife reservoir (probably bats) to human population via an intermediate host(s) and that rapid virus evolution played a key role in the adaptation of SARS-CoVs in at least two nonreservoir species within a short period.

Re the emails, they were released and posted in the thread. They were redacted and what is new is the redactions were removed.

Re Chan's book, what is new is her testimony before Parliament.

Do you have anything new to report re the spillover? Anything more about how the origin coincidentally occurred in Wuhan yet no animal source has been identified anywhere including in the bat caves in Laos and in the mine or caves in Yunnan?

There is no trail. There was a trail found in SARS 1 within a couple of months after the first cases. There was a period of time when the SARS 1 circulated in the humans and became better adapted before the virus spread out of Guangdong. All evidence points to the fact SARS 2 emerged ready to go in humans. And we see how variants are popping up right and left, yet no variants have been found that precede the Wuhan outbreak.

If there was any evidence of a spillover there is no reason in hell China would be sitting on that evidence.

In case you needed reminding.
 
Time for a bump. ...
Time for some nonsense from a newspaper and an Indian TV web site.
An article from The Telegraph on an email exchange almost 2 years ago :eye-poppi. A “likely explanation” was an origin in what looks like a SARS-like virus infected worker in a low security lab. Includes a close to conspiracy theory opinion that the lab leak explanation was shut down for political reasons.
Here in 2022 the most likely explanation is spillover.

The New Delhi TV web site mirrors the opinions of Dr Alina Chan and Lord Matt Ridley (from a syndicated feed) stated in testimony to the UK House of Commons Science and Technology Committee.
This is Alina Chan.
She misleads the committee that the furin cleavage site is unique: Furin cleavage sites naturally occur in coronaviruses (Jan 2021).
She misleads the committee that this site "has been linked to Wuhan Institute of Virology".
She is ignorant about the burden of proof. When she makes a claim, it is up to her to support it with evidence, not the WIV to debunk the claim.
Matt Ridley misleads the committee. It took 14 years to find the original bat colony that was the origin of SARS. After 2 months we found the market that was the main source of the SARS outbreak which is the current case with SARS-2.
 
Last edited:
Seems like yesterdays "bump" has added little of substance to the discussion, and added nothing that moves the actual origin of Covid 19 closer to a conclusion.
 
Seems like yesterdays "bump" has added little of substance to the discussion, and added nothing that moves the actual origin of Covid 19 closer to a conclusion.
And from my POV the evidence for the lab origin has accumulated and accumulated while not much has happened on the natural spillover origin except more and more political pressure to pretend the lab wasn't the source.

The last 'new' thing posted was the Worobey paper that was full of holes.
 
And from my POV the evidence for the lab origin has accumulated and accumulated while not much has happened on the natural spillover origin except more and more political pressure to pretend the lab wasn't the source.

The last 'new' thing posted was the Worobey paper that was full of holes.

No need to "pretend" a lab is not the source when there is no compelling evidence that a lab is, in fact, the source. Actually, in spite of all the discussion in thread, there is no compelling evidence presented for any particular source.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom