Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
So does anybody here know of any reviewable records of scientific laboratory tests, under a microscope, analyzing and identifying the COVID-19 delta variant (SARS-CoV-2 Delta Variant) virus from isolated samples extracted from a human being?

Use PubMed and put in your search terms. eg https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/34462756/

Do you mean an electron microscope? You can't see a virus otherwise. You can't identify the variant by looking at it. It is done by sequencing the RNA.
 
Yeah. We’ve been through all of this before....

Re the death threats, interesting again you selectively choose who to believe.
According to Vanity Fair, “death threats flooded his inbox” from “prominent scientists,” some of whom Redfield said were once his friends. He added that one of them told him to just “wither and die.”
So he gets a slew of death threats, one colleague he knew told him to “wither and die” and he tells the Vanity reporter he didn't expect that from scientists. Reporters are known to get it wrong. Making it sound like Redfield said he got multiple death threats from scientists then becomes the next news soundbite.

This is such a minor issue here but one easily cherry picked, all the while you don't address the evidence that until recently many of the mainstream scientists avoided the lab origin hypothesis out of peer and other career pressures.


Moving on...
 
So does anybody here know of any reviewable records of scientific laboratory tests, under a microscope, analyzing and identifying the COVID-19 delta variant (SARS-CoV-2 Delta Variant) virus from isolated samples extracted from a human being?

Not sure what do you want. Viruses are not analyzed under microscope. Also what do you mean by 'isolated samples extracted from a human being' ? Isolated from what ?

Virus variants genealogy and spread can be traced here: https://nextstrain.org/ncov/open/global

Specific genetic changes are best viewed here: https://genome.ucsc.edu/covid19.html

All that is obviously from human samples.
 
Not sure what do you want. Viruses are not analyzed under microscope. Also what do you mean by 'isolated samples extracted from a human being' ? Isolated from what ?

Virus variants genealogy and spread can be traced here: https://nextstrain.org/ncov/open/global

Specific genetic changes are best viewed here: https://genome.ucsc.edu/covid19.html

All that is obviously from human samples.

I should have posed the question in this way: Is there documentation on any Covid 19 virus isolated in a human being regarding each variant and each original isolated. Therefore a showing of the original infection
I'm having a discussion at my work and this is a question some are wanting to know about. I'm hoping to simplify it to where the answer is compelling enough for them to cause further interest in research on their own.
 
I should have posed the question in this way: Is there documentation on any Covid 19 virus isolated in a human being regarding each variant and each original isolated. Therefore a showing of the original infection
I'm having a discussion at my work and this is a question some are wanting to know about. I'm hoping to simplify it to where the answer is compelling enough for them to cause further interest in research on their own.

It's not like we detect new variant and say 'hey look, this is new'. The virus changes in almost every transmission. We collect viruses over time from all over the world and every sample is different. We can compare the changes and build tree of what's closest to each other, which comes from which.

Most of those changes are insignificant. Some are important. But we can't know right away. We can only tell after several weeks, when the new variant proves itself against older variants. And by that time, the new variant itself is not 1 virus .. it's whole family sharing the important change.

So we learn about the variant by analyzing what has the current variants from new samples in common, then tracing it back to first common ancestor. Then analyzing what changed, and then usually analyzing why it is better.
New variant of concern name with Greek letter can be assigned several months after it was first detected.

Nextstrain site is good for mapping this: https://nextstrain.org/ncov/open/global
 
Everyone you don't agree with is lying and with those who evidence shows are actually lying like Shi and Daszak, you dismiss the evidence. ...
Repeating fantasies does not make Shi into a liar.

An opinion from a "data scientist" in a Vanity Fair article is not "Many scientists, especially virologists" :eye-poppi!
Gilles Demaneuf is a data scientist with the Bank of New Zealand in Auckland and one of the DRASTIC group who put out that live bats "fake news" video. The article lists a bit of idiocy from DRASTIC's founders. He had to research lab incidents in China when Wikipedia list them. de Maistre's imaginary notion of the WIV being one lab when anyone who knows about the WIV knows there are multiple labs.
A letter to Lancet from a few scientists does not intimidate scientists into silence. Research into all origins of the virus continued and was published. Anyone who follows the evidence knows that a spillover event is still the most likely origin with a lab leak coming a distant second.

The article omits vital facts about Li Wenliang.
It was the Wuhan CDC who warned hospitals in Wuhan about pneumonia cases of unknown cause.
Li actually warned his medical school classmates (not his colleagues at work) about what he said was SARS and identified as a coronavirus. He was reprimanded as a rumormonger for that SARS outbreak rumor.
Li was "lionized by the Chinese public as a hero and whistleblower", and lionized by the Chinese government as a hero and whistleblower and lionized indirectly by the Chinese Supreme People's Court.
Li was not suppressed by the Chinese government except in the sense of Chinese police procedures of suppressing any news not authorized by the government.
Li was not the only whistleblower. There were 7 others.

The article misrepresents the unclassified cable from diplomats who visited the WIV in 2018.
Reading the whole cable to get the context shows that it was talking about safe operations being limited. It is a limit on the amount of work being done, not the safety of the work. That is not quite the article statement of "threatened the facility’s safe operations".
The summary has "but its current productivity is limited by a shortage of the highly trained technicians and investigators required to safely operate a BSL-4 laboratory and a lack of clarity in related Chinese movement policies and guidelines". IOW in order to do more work the lab will need more personnel and guidance. The implication is that the lab is operating safely with the current staffing level. Page 2 has a "Unclear Guidelines on Virus Access and a Lack of Trained Talent Impede Research" section. If there was a concern about safety that should be in the title. Someone "noted that the new lab has a serious shortage of appropriately trained trained technicians and investigators needed to safely operate this high-containment facility". This is not followed by a discussion of making the lab safe lab but a discussion of how to get trained people.

The Mojiang miners idiocy from DRASTIC comes up. There is a "Blood samples were sent to the Wuhan Institute of Virology, which found that they were positive for SARS antibodies, a later Chinese dissertation documented" lie (from DRASTIC?). Shi and her colleagues found no SARS antibodies in the samples tested in late 2021. Addendum: A pneumonia outbreak associated with a new coronavirus of probable bat origin by 28 authors and Zheng-Li Shi. Published 17 November 2020. This is a June 3, 2021 article!
 
Last edited:
Re the death threats, interesting again you selectively choose who to believe.

No, what I do is apply something called "skepticism" to a) propaganda sources (such as right-wing think tanks, science-denial sites, religious media outlets and extreme left-wing outlets) and b) mainstream sources that seem to be making extraordinary claims). You should try it sometime. ;)


So he gets a slew of death threats, one colleague he knew told him to “wither and die” and he tells the Vanity reporter he didn't expect that from scientists. Reporters are known to get it wrong. Making it sound like Redfield said he got multiple death threats from scientists then becomes the next news soundbite.

Exactly, in other words you agree with me that he didn't get death threats from fellow scientists. That is what I disagree with. You may point out that he received death threats and no doubt he did - he is a public figure, so unfortunately that goes with the territory, but remember that you were using thie claim he received death threats from fellow scientists as evidence for other scientists not speaking out about the lab leak.

Now you may say, "Oh well the death threats didn't come from fellow scientists but he still got them, so that's why more scientists don't speak out about lab leak." But that would be complete bollocks. Do you have any idea how many death threats that people who think the likelihood of spillover is greater than lab leak get?

Do you think Peter Daszak, Zhengli Shi and Kristian Andersen don't get death threats?

Many of those who say spillover is more likely have had to either suspend their social media accounts or limit those who can reply to them. Angie Rasmussen apparently gets constant death and rape threats.

So when you point to Redfield and say, "Look what happens if you say lab leak" I say, "Yeah, it's nothing compared to getting the QAnon Brigade set on you!"

In fact, look at who is stirring up trouble against scientists who claim spillover. Members of Congress, and ex-president of the United States, podcasters with millions of followers.

Peter Hotez has pointed this out as well:

But it did not stop there. Dr. Peter Daszak, just to take one example—the head of the non-profit EcoHealth Alliance—has been routinely hounded by right-wing media as part of their fixation on the (still unresolved) Wuhan Lab Leak hypothesis. GOP Rep. Mike Gallagher has outrageously gone so far as to suggest Daszak may have conspired to block a fair probe of what happened. Scripps Research Institute virologist Kristian Andersen has had to deactivate his Twitter account due to similar aggression.

I’m also personally threatened by emails, phone calls, and on social media for my views on vaccines, including COVID-19 vaccinations. They mostly have far-right and even white nationalist leanings, telling me about impending attacks from “patriots,” some imbued with Nazi imagery. As one colleague eloquently said to me recently in a text: “It’s like a slow moving train coming right for us. We have more lethally armed extremists in the U.S. than anywhere, and GOP members of Congress are whipping them up right now.”

I agree with Dr. Fauci when he says that these personal attacks represent an assault on American science.

This is such a minor issue here but one easily cherry picked, all the while you don't address the evidence that until recently many of the mainstream scientists avoided the lab origin hypothesis out of peer and other career pressures.

Well, now is your day in the Sun. So you can stop complaining about it.

Also,

So he gets a slew of death threats, one colleague he knew told him to “wither and die” and he tells the Vanity reporter he didn't expect that from scientists. Reporters are known to get it wrong. Making it sound like Redfield said he got multiple death threats from scientists then becomes the next news soundbite.

First of all, don't repeat soundbites then. Second, do you not remember that I made exactly this point to you regarding Zhengli-Shi's claim of fungal infection in the miners. We don't have her exact words: we only have a paraphrased claim that it was fungal infection. It could be that she said something to the effect of "We tested for SARS-like virus and found none so we had to include they died from something else such as a fungal infection". It seems reasonable to me that she could have said what she was able to say as a virologist and speculated further, but the reporter decided to choose a sentence for brevity's sake. She is not a pathologist after all.
 
Reviewing some of the out-of-the-lab-ready-to-go evidence:

WSJ Oct 5, 2021; Quay and Muller op ed: Science Closes In on Covid’s Origins
Based on experience with SARS-1 in 2003 and MERS in 2012, we know that many people are infected by a host animal long before a coronavirus mutates to the point where it can jump from human to human. An extensive data set from late 2019—more than 9,000 hospital samples—is available of people exhibiting flulike (thus Covid-like) symptoms in China’s Hubei and Shaanxi provinces before the epidemic started. Based on SARS-1 and MERS, the natural zoonotic theory predicts 100 to 400 Covid infections would be found in those samples. The lab-leak hypothesis, of course, predicts zero. If the novel coronavirus were engineered by scientists pursuing gain-of-function research, there would be no instances of community infection until it escaped from the laboratory. The World Health Organization investigation analyzed those stored samples and found zero pre-pandemic infections. This is powerful evidence favoring the lab-leak theory.

This link is from my download file so you'll have to find it by title: "WHO-convened Global Study of Origins of SARS-CoV-2: China Final Report; 14 January-10 February 2021"

From the WHO investigation:
Review of Stored Biological Samples Testing
As part of origins of SARS-CoV-2 study, searches for stored respiratory tract, serum or other samples suitable for SARS-CoV-2 laboratory testing were requested. Sub-set of samples were identified and tested from hospitalized patients related to scientific research projects, including patient samples preserved in the biobank of Tongji Hospital, as well as patient samples preserved by the collaborative research institute jointly developed by Wuhan University and Tongji Hospital of Huazhong University of Science and Technology in late 2019. ...

... all laboratory results were negative.


In summary:
No bat source compatible with a Wuhan outbreak and no other proximal animal source found (80,000+ animals including bats were tested). No unusual spikes in pneumonia cases were found in China prior to the Dec cases in Wuhan, and no COVID 19 antibody or viral positive results were found in more than 4,000 body fluid specimens collected and stored in China in 2019.

The op-ed summarizes a number of other points re the lab leak evidence.


Wiki: Richard A Muller
Dr Richard A. Muller (born January 6, 1944) is an American physicist and emeritus professor of physics at the University of California, Berkeley. He was also a faculty senior scientist at the Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory.
And from the Wiki page he's a liberal, not a right-winger. But gee, a PhD in physics, OMG, how dare he have an opinion on COVID's origin. :rolleyes:


Discounting sources and not addressing arguments in 3 ... 2 ... 1 ...
 
Last edited:
By the way, here are two moves right out of the Climate Change Denialist playbook:

1.) Claim that scientists who dissent from the consensus are cowed into silence because they don't want to jeopardize their careers.

2.) Pore through reams of emails and extract the juicy quotes. ("Aha! This looks like they might know something different!") - See University of East Anglia emails thingy.
 
No, what I do is apply something called "skepticism" to a) propaganda sources (such as right-wing think tanks, science-denial sites, religious media outlets and extreme left-wing outlets) and b) mainstream sources that seem to be making extraordinary claims). You should try it sometime. ;)
I did not say the source should be ignored. I said only addressing the source and thereby declaring the evidence moot ignores the evidence.

In addition, I've posted the reason we aren't seeing much from more neutral sources. You've not presented evidence countering that.


Exactly, in other words you agree with me that he didn't get death threats from fellow scientists. That is what I disagree with. You may point out that he received death threats and no doubt he did - he is a public figure, so unfortunately that goes with the territory, but remember that you were using thie claim he received death threats from fellow scientists as evidence for other scientists not speaking out about the lab leak.
Cherry picking one small thing in my post and making it sound like it's the only thing I said.


Now you may say, "Oh well the death threats didn't come from fellow scientists but he still got them, so that's why more scientists don't speak out about lab leak." But that would be complete bollocks. Do you have any idea how many death threats that people who think the likelihood of spillover is greater than lab leak get?
Ostracized, peer pressure, career risks, a desire not to have their own GoF research stopped, and the US agencies having a serious issue when funding of the WIV work is scrutinized too closely... That's a lot more than death threats.


Do you think Peter Daszak, Zhengli Shi and Kristian Andersen don't get death threats?
I'm sure they do.

Many of those who say spillover is more likely have had to either suspend their social media accounts or limit those who can reply to them. Angie Rasmussen apparently gets constant death and rape threats.

So when you point to Redfield and say, "Look what happens if you say lab leak" I say, "Yeah, it's nothing compared to getting the QAnon Brigade set on you!"

In fact, look at who is stirring up trouble against scientists who claim spillover. Members of Congress, and ex-president of the United States, podcasters with millions of followers.

Peter Hotez has pointed this out as well:
Are they getting peer pressure, being ostracized professionally, does that position threaten their careers?

Of course now that it has come out Daszak has been putting his thumb on the scale, that he has a serious conflict of interest he has yet to admit to and that he and EcoHealth have a lot of data he is refusing to disclose, Daszak is getting peer pressure, being ostracized professionally, and his funding has been threatened.


First of all, don't repeat soundbites then. Second, do you not remember that I made exactly this point to you regarding Zhengli-Shi's claim of fungal infection in the miners. We don't have her exact words: we only have a paraphrased claim that it was fungal infection. It could be that she said something to the effect of "We tested for SARS-like virus and found none so we had to include they died from something else such as a fungal infection". It seems reasonable to me that she could have said what she was able to say as a virologist and speculated further, but the reporter decided to choose a sentence for brevity's sake. She is not a pathologist after all.
Your analogy sucks but I suspect you know that. Shi's exact words?

Here's the paragraph from the SciAm interview:
“The mine shaft stunk like hell,” says Shi, who, like her colleagues, went in wearing a protective mask and clothing. “Bat guano, covered in fungus, littered the cave.” Although the fungus turned out to be the pathogen that had sickened the miners, she says it would have been only a matter of time before they caught the coronaviruses if the mine had not been promptly shut.
There is nothing vague there which can be construed to fit your speculative version. And my repeating the sound bite is not the issue. You cherry picking that one thing and ignoring the rest is the issue.
 
Last edited:
Look at that quote again. Shi’s words are paraphrased, not quoted, to say that the fungus killed the miners. Again, she is not a pathologist so I have no reason to think she made some conclusive autopsy on the miners, only that she did not find any evidence of coronavirus from tested samples.
 
You can accuse me of cherry picking if you like but I am merely pointing out that you are fashioning a narrative for yourself and bolting down the components of it on every retelling. It seems to me that there is a lot speculation which you insist has been confirmed.
 
By the way, here are two moves right out of the Climate Change Denialist playbook:

1.) Claim that scientists who dissent from the consensus are cowed into silence because they don't want to jeopardize their careers.

2.) Pore through reams of emails and extract the juicy quotes. ("Aha! This looks like they might know something different!") - See University of East Anglia emails thingy.
And here you are again trying to drag this evidence based discussion into the CT forum. Is this reference to "juicy quotes" a continuation of ignoring the evidence and instead only address one cherry picked bit from my post?


It might be an issue if said repression of the lab leak hypothesis wasn't so well documented.

Attempts to make the lab leak look like a CT make heavy use of "scientists say", "researchers say", "virologists say" and so on.

I've seen 2 recent op-eds claiming this very thing.

Covid-19 lab leak theory highly unlikely, scientists say
according to a team of global scientists.
Note they are still claiming the Wuhan Seafood market was the source of the first cases when that was ruled out well over a year ago.
possibly other markets
Which have never been identified and never connected directly to any of the first cases.

And the other one:
Why many scientists say it’s unlikely that SARS-CoV-2 originated from a “lab leak”

Sept 2021 and they are still repeating this lie:
In fact, early in the pandemic, a group of prominent researchers dismissed lab-origin notions as “conspiracy theories” in a letter in The Lancet.
That letter along with Daszak have been shown to be demonstrably tainted after an email came to light where Daszak tells colleagues not to let it get out that Daszak wrote the letter.

Emails show scientists discussed masking their involvement in key journal letter on Covid origins
Daszak drafted the statement and circulated it to other scientists to sign. But the emails reveal that Daszak and two other EcoHealth-affiliated scientists thought they should not sign the statement so as to mask their involvement in it. Leaving their names off the statement would give it “some distance from us and therefore doesn’t work in a counterproductive way,” Daszak wrote. ...

The two scientists Daszak wrote to about the need to make the paper appear independent of EcoHealth, are coronavirus experts Ralph Baric and Linfa Wang.

In the emails, Baric agreed with Daszak’s suggestion not to sign The Lancet statement, writing “Otherwise it looks self-serving, and we lose impact.”

Let's list some of the more blatant lies trying to mislead opinion on the lab leak hypothesis:
Referring to the seafood market as the source when it was not connected to the first cases.

Assert there was another wet market associated with the first case and then repeating it when there is no supporting evidence.

Shi's claim the Yunnan miners died of a fungal infection.

Daszak's dishonest manipulation using the Lancet letter he wrote.

Daszak's claim there were lots of spillover events involving coronaviruses and bats when his entire paper only speculated this was a possibility. The actual evidence looking at CoV antibodies in people living near the Yunnan caves where the bats live found actual spillover events were incredibly rare.​
 
You can accuse me of cherry picking if you like but I am merely pointing out that you are fashioning a narrative for yourself and bolting down the components of it on every retelling. It seems to me that there is a lot speculation which you insist has been confirmed.

You didn't address your cherry picking. Or did I miss it? Should I repeat the problem?

"Ostracized, peer pressure, career risks, a desire not to have their own GoF research stopped, and the US agencies having a serious issue when funding of the WIV work is scrutinized too closely... That's a lot more than death threats."
 
Look at that quote again. Shi’s words are paraphrased, not quoted, to say that the fungus killed the miners. Again, she is not a pathologist so I have no reason to think she made some conclusive autopsy on the miners, only that she did not find any evidence of coronavirus from tested samples.
:eye-poppi That's quite an apology for Shi's claim that the miners died of a fungal infection.

But let's take a step back, are you agreeing they did not die of a fungal infection? Wasn't Shi's claim supposed to supersede the master's and doctorate theses which concluded the evidence pointed to a viral infection and more specifically a CoV?
 
You didn't address your cherry picking. Or did I miss it? Should I repeat the problem?

"Ostracized, peer pressure, career risks, a desire not to have their own GoF research stopped, and the US agencies having a serious issue when funding of the WIV work is scrutinized too closely... That's a lot more than death threats."

This is just singing from the climate change denier playbook.
 
:eye-poppi That's quite an apology for Shi's claim that the miners died of a fungal infection.

But let's take a step back, are you agreeing they did not die of a fungal infection? Wasn't Shi's claim supposed to supersede the master's and doctorate theses which concluded the evidence pointed to a viral infection and more specifically a CoV?

No, what I am saying is that given her role in testing samples, the most she can say with any degree of confidence is that the samples did not test positive for coronavirus.

We don't know the confidence with which she suggested they died of fungus. She may have said it was probable that they did, etc... and why not?

However you are claiming that she defo said it was fungus and you claim that she knew it was not fungus and you claim that they died of a spillover of SARS, and you claim that she and Daszak found the virus, covered up the spillover, lied (for no apparent gain) that it was fungus, secretly engineered a secret virus into SARS-CoV2.

For me, your claim is the extraordinary one and based on very cynical assumptions of motivations and it is cobbled together from some paraphrasing of her words in a single article.

To support this, you gleefully put forward all kinds of wacky news sources like the Epoch Times as confirmation.:rolleyes:
 
Other than being significantly more developed now what do you *think* has changed? The current regime is simpler a continuation of the one that has ruled China or decades.

If you are so worried about China don't you think it's worth investing in the critical thinking skills needed to figure out what they are really up to? I don't trust China so I'm willing to believe anything anyone says about it isn't exactly a good way to protect yourself, it just opens you up for manipulation.

What do I think has changed? I live in Hong Kong, mate, so I can see exactly what has changed in the 14 years that I have lived here.

Anyone who thinks the current CCP regime is a simple continuation of that under Deng is willfully blind and naïve. Deng opened up China to the west, fully embraced capitalism, opened up the financial markets and systems, and allowed western money to poor into China, which enabled them to raise millions out of poverty, generate a huge middle class and smaller number of extremely rich, and become the worlds de facto manufacturer.

Under Xi, they have gone the other way and there is a new cultural revolution on the way. The CCP has closed their borders both figuratively to outside investment and physically to non-Chinese, they have cracked down on education, on property giants, on tech giants. Not to mention the crackdown in HK, and their current military threats to Taiwan, the military expansion in the south china sea, clashes of "coastguard" vessels with Philippine and Vietnamese fishing boats etc.

HK still has a restriction of 4 people being allowed to meet in public, despite there being no local Covid cases for months. There have been no local elections for 2 years, since the government supporters got trounced last time. Under the new security law it is now a crime to "foster hatred against the government"; and that can be interpreted as loosely as it sounds. Since that law was applied, the HK government have pretty much given up pretending they are anything other than controlled by the CCP; they have no independent power or policy now.

Chinese state newspapers push the theory to their citizens that Covid comes from the US, and have recently openly accused the US of an act of biological warfare against China.

They are now planning for redistribution of wealth, a universal income and a return to actual communism.

Their stated aim is and has always been stability at all costs throughout China, as the primary goal is the continuation of the CCP. Anything that could cause instability is rooted out, hammered down, or disappeared. If there isn't a current law for it, the catch all "picking quarrels and provoking trouble" is used. Good luck getting a trial at all if that happens.

The CCP feel themselves strong enough now that they frankly don't care what the west thinks, and will act largely according to their desires. Their internal market is strong enough at the moment to support the economy, and their exports have grown during covid.

Their only concern is strength and internal stability. They have always played down the fact that the first cases started in China, but are absolutely terrified about the lab leak theory, as it would cause a big problem for internal stability and be something big enough that they feel the whole world could turn against them, not just the west. They would do anything, literally anything, to stop that theory in its tracks. Hence they deleted databases and restricted access when the WHO came calling, then flatly denied they had done those things.

Because China under the CCP is all these things, do I therefore think that their citizens are evil moustache twirling Fu Manchu caricatures, thus Covid must have started in a lab? Does that mean everything China does is untrustworthy?

No, of course not. I myself largely lean towards the natural spillover theory, but don't rule the lab leak out. In fact, much like the WHO!

My whole point all along is simply that you cannot treat China under Xi like some western country, and assume that "oh they wouldn't do that", or think that scientists like Shi are playing under the same rules as scientists in another country, because, through no fault of their own, they are not. If (and it is still an if) there is something the Chinese state does not want to get out, it will not get out. This is not a conspiracy, it is a fact.
 
Funny how the Lancet has changed its tune to embrace a CT. :rolleyes:

Voice of Healthcare, Sept 2021: Covid origins probe: The Lancet does U-turn over lab leak theory
The international team of health experts, in the open letter, make an appeal for "objective, open, and transparent scientific debate about the origin of SARS-CoV-2".

Scientists "need to evaluate all hypotheses on a rational basis, and to weigh their likelihood based on facts and evidence, devoid of speculation concerning possible political impacts", the authors wrote. ...

... it was revealed earlier that Peter Daszak -- a British scientist and president of the US-based non-profit EcoHealth Alliance that has a direct connection with China -- had secretly orchestrated the now-infamous letter. The firm has also funded research at the Wuhan Institute of Virology (WIV).

The Daszak letter said:
"We stand together to strongly condemn conspiracy theories suggesting that Covid-19 does not have a natural origin", they said, in a statement that "imparted a silencing effect on the wider scientific debate".
Like I said ...

But independent scientists struck back with a letter of their own, one that wasn't mired in deceit:
However, "there is no direct support for the natural origin of SARS-CoV-2, and a laboratory-related accident is plausible", the authors stated. ...

"For a leading medical journal like Lancet to agree to finally open its doors to a letter from scientists highlighting the ongoing uncertain origins of Covid-19, indicates how far we have come in 18 months in requesting an open scientific debate on the topic, but also indicates just how far we still have to go," he added.



Lancet Sept 17, 2021: An appeal for an objective, open, and transparent scientific debate about the origin of SARS-CoV-2
On July 5, 2021, a Correspondence was published in The Lancet called “Science, not speculation, is essential to determine how SARS-CoV-2 reached humans”.1 The letter recapitulates the arguments of an earlier letter (published in February, 2020) by the same authors,2 which claimed overwhelming support for the hypothesis that the novel coronavirus causing the COVID-19 pandemic originated in wildlife. The authors associated any alternative view with conspiracy theories by stating: “We stand together to strongly condemn conspiracy theories suggesting that COVID-19 does not have a natural origin”. The statement has imparted a silencing effect on the wider scientific debate, including among science journalists.3

There is little to no evidence for a spillover:
There is so far no scientifically validated evidence that directly supports a natural origin. Among the references cited in the two letters by Calisher and colleagues,1, 2 all but one simply show that SARS-CoV-2 is phylogenetically related to other betacoronaviruses. The fact that the causative agent of COVID-19 descends from a natural virus is widely accepted, but this does not explain how it came to infect humans. The question of the proximal origin of SARS-CoV-2—ie, the final virus and host before passage to humans—was expressly addressed in only one highly cited opinion piece, which supports the natural origin hypothesis,4 but suffers from a logical fallacy:5
The logical fallacies are described in the letter.
Although considerable evidence supports the natural origins of other outbreaks (eg, Nipah, MERS, and the 2002–04 SARS outbreak) direct evidence for a natural origin for SARS-CoV-2 is missing. After 19 months of investigations, the proximal progenitor of SARS-CoV-2 is still lacking. Neither the host pathway from bats to humans, nor the geographical route from Yunnan (where the viruses most closely related to SARS-CoV-2 have been sampled) to Wuhan (where the pandemic emerged) have been identified. More than 80 000 samples collected from Chinese wildlife sites and animal farms all proved negative.13
The letter goes on to describe all the evidence and possible mechanisms for a lab origin. In the end they state that there is no compelling evidence to choose between either origin hypotheses.
Contrary to the first letter published in The Lancet by Calisher and colleagues,2 we do not think that scientists should promote “unity” (“We support the call from the Director-General of WHO to promote scientific evidence and unity over misinformation and conjecture”). As shown above, research-related hypotheses are not misinformation and conjecture. More importantly, science embraces alternative hypotheses, contradictory arguments, verification, refutability, and controversy. Departing from this principle risks establishing dogmas, abandoning the essence of science, and, even worse, paving the way for conspiracy theories. Instead, the scientific community should bring this debate to a place where it belongs: the columns of scientific journals.31, 32
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom