Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
Could be an exciting opportunity for someone! Not me obvs.
 

Attachments

  • 9D720128-090A-4325-B51A-20DC88DA9DA4.jpg
    9D720128-090A-4325-B51A-20DC88DA9DA4.jpg
    85.3 KB · Views: 24
Okay, so 2 things related to the Lab Leak Notion.

1.) Stuart Neil gives an interesting break-down of the research grant proposal that EcoHealth Alliance made to DARPA. I think it is pretty even-handed in that Stuart Neil is clearly not happy with some of the proposals that they were making. In particular, he says that this was definitely a case of GoF research, although the GoF was to be performed in UNC (Baric's lab) and/or Duke University (I believe in Singapore by Linfa Wang), and that WIV would not conduct that particular part of the program but would be involved in swabbing bats and sequencing viruses, etc... ETA: One of the things that seems most striking is mention of inserting an FCS in the grant application and that is of course something that turned up in SARS-CoV2

Link

I do notice that Stuart Neil is a little disquieted by this revelation, and Yuri Deigin has responded with the picture below...

2.) Also interesting is a planned discussion on the origins of Covid-19 on 30th Septmber between Michael Worobey, Jesse Bloom, Alina Chan and Linfa Wang.

Link
 

Attachments

  • yuri come join us.jpg
    yuri come join us.jpg
    31.8 KB · Views: 11
Last edited:
There's quite a bit of discussion about the origins of Covid on The Decoding the Gurus podcast. In this one, they talk with Stuart Neil who is a virologist based at King's College London.

Link

There's some discussion about a lot of issues related to SARS-CoV2, but mostly debunking or arguing against non-mainstream views such as GoF, the Monjiang mine etc... and other stuff such as ivermectin.
 
C -SPAN 2016 panel discussion on pandemics (1 hour 35 minutes).

Here is what Peter Daszak had to say at one point in the discussion (1 minute 27 seconds).

Here's the transcript from that clip, the all caps is the way all C-SPAN transcripts are written:
IT IS NOT STRAIGHTFORWARD. FIRST OF ALL, WE ARE ONLY LOOKING AT VIRAL FAMILIES THAT INCLUDE THOSE THAT HAVE GOTTEN TO PEOPLE FROM ANIMALS. WE HAVE NARROWED IT DOWN FROM THERE. THEN, WHEN YOU GET A SEQUENCE, AND IT LOOKS LIKE A RELATIVE TO THE KNOWN NASTY PATHOGEN, JUST LIKE WE DID WITH SARS -- WE FOUND VIRUSES IN BATS. SOME OF THEM LOOKED VERY SIMILAR TO SARS. WE SEQUENCED THE SPINE [Correction, he says spike not spine.] PROTEIN, THE PROTEIN THAT ATTACHES TO CELLS, AND THEN YOU CREATE PSEUDO-PARTICLES, INSERT PROTEINS FROM THE VIRUSES THAT COMBINED TO HUMAN CELLS. EACH STEP OF THIS, YOU MOVE CLOSER AND CLOSER TO COULD THE VIRUS BECOME PATHOGENIC IN PEOPLE? YOU NARROW DOWN THE FIELD. YOU REDUCE THE COST, AND END UP WITH A SMALL NUMBER OF VIRUSES THAT REALLY DO LOOK LIKE KILLERS. AND YOU LOOK AT THE PEOPLE, AND THE PEOPLE IN THE REGION THAT LIVE WHERE THE ANIMAL LIVES, DO WE

Here's a more complete transcript:
Then when you get a sequence of a virus, and it looks like a relative of a known nasty pathogen, just like we did with SARS. We found other coronaviruses in bats, a whole host of them, some of them looked very similar to SARS. So we sequenced the spike protein: the protein that attaches to cells. Then we…

Well I didn’t do this work, but my colleagues in China did the work. You create pseudo particles, you insert the spike proteins from those viruses, see if they bind to human cells. At each step of this you move closer and closer to this virus could really become pathogenic in people.

“You end up with a small number of viruses that really do look like killers,”

So here is Daszak in 2016 saying his colleagues in China were manipulating coronaviruses, changing the spike proteins to ones that bind to human cells step by step. And in 2019 a virus just like Daszak is describing in 2016 shows up and results in a pandemic.
 
C -SPAN 2016 panel discussion on pandemics (1 hour 35 minutes).

Here is what Peter Daszak had to say at one point in the discussion (1 minute 27 seconds).

Here's the transcript from that clip, the all caps is the way all C-SPAN transcripts are written:


Here's a more complete transcript:


So here is Daszak in 2016 saying his colleagues in China were manipulating coronaviruses, changing the spike proteins to ones that bind to human cells step by step. And in 2019 a virus just like Daszak is describing in 2016 shows up and results in a pandemic.


The spike is engineered onto lentiviral or vesicular stomatitis virus backbones. They aren’t making modified coronaviruses.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
 
C -SPAN 2016 panel discussion on pandemics (1 hour 35 minutes).

Here is what Peter Daszak had to say at one point in the discussion (1 minute 27 seconds).

Here's the transcript from that clip, the all caps is the way all C-SPAN transcripts are written:


Here's a more complete transcript:


So here is Daszak in 2016 saying his colleagues in China were manipulating coronaviruses, changing the spike proteins to ones that bind to human cells step by step. And in 2019 a virus just like Daszak is describing in 2016 shows up and results in a pandemic.

The spike is engineered onto lentiviral or vesicular stomatitis virus backbones. They aren’t making modified coronaviruses.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

Does this not refer to the pseudotype viruses that were made at BSL-2 that we have already discussed numerous times?

I think this is all referring to well-known public statements, and DRASTIC have been showing clips of this meeting for some time now, particularly noting that Amy Maxmen was sitting next to Peter Daszak.

The only thing that is a little surprising to me is that Ian Lipkin is sitting on the other side of Daszak and I think he recently said he was unaware of this being done at BSL-2 which he thought was completely inappropriate.
 
Does this not refer to the pseudotype viruses that were made at BSL-2 that we have already discussed numerous times?

I think this is all referring to well-known public statements, and DRASTIC have been showing clips of this meeting for some time now, particularly noting that Amy Maxmen was sitting next to Peter Daszak.

The only thing that is a little surprising to me is that Ian Lipkin is sitting on the other side of Daszak and I think he recently said he was unaware of this being done at BSL-2 which he thought was completely inappropriate.


Making Pseudotyped viruses is done at BSL-2


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Making Pseudotyped viruses is done at BSL-2


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Right, so I wonder why this is being brought up as if it is a big problem. It seems to me more that people are looking into this and saying, "Oh, my God! Can you believe what they were doing here?!?" then a lot of virologists saying, "That's pretty standard..."
 
Right, so I wonder why this is being brought up as if it is a big problem. It seems to me more that people are looking into this and saying, "Oh, my God! Can you believe what they were doing here?!?" then a lot of virologists saying, "That's pretty standard..."


And why is it not a problem that virologists regard BSL-2 for this research as pretty standard?
 
Well. Not sure but it is off-topic in that nobody is seriously claiming the research in question led to SARS-CoV2.


Well, I can only say that even if SARS-Cov-02 has not been created in a lab, it still worries me that such research is conducted under such lax conditions.
 
Well, I can only say that even if SARS-Cov-02 has not been created in a lab, it still worries me that such research is conducted under such lax conditions.


Not lax at all. BSL-2 is still a regulated containment laboratory.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Not lax at all. BSL-2 is still a regulated containment laboratory. ...
Yeah right. :rolleyes:

Consider what Baric described in his work with chimeras at the UNC:
2015, authors include Shi and Baric: A SARS-like cluster of circulating bat coronaviruses shows potential for human emergence
All virus cultivation was performed in a biosafety level (BSL) 3 laboratory with redundant fans in the biosafety cabinets, as described previously by our group2. All personnel wore powered air purifying respirators (Breathe Easy, 3M) with Tyvek suits, aprons and booties and were double-gloved. ...

BSL3 users are subject to a medical surveillance plan monitored by the University Employee Occupational Health Clinic (UEOHC), which includes a yearly physical, annual influenza vaccination and mandatory reporting of any symptoms associated with CoV infection during periods when working in the BSL3. All BSL3 users are trained in exposure management and reporting protocols, are prepared to self-quarantine and have been trained for safe delivery to a local infectious disease management department in an emergency situation. All potential exposure events are reported and investigated by EHS and UEOHC, with reports filed to both the CDC and the NIH....


And at the WIV:
Daszak and Shi in 2016: Bat Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome-Like Coronavirus WIV1 Encodes an Extra Accessory Protein, ORFX, Involved in Modulation of the Host Immune Response
All experiments using live virus was conducted under biosafety level 2 (BSL2) conditions.


And what did Baric have to say about the work his colleague was doing at the WIV?
https://www.technologyreview.com/20...bat-virus-engineering-links-america-to-wuhan/
The genetic code of SARS-CoV-2 does not resemble that of any virus the WIV was known to be culturing in its lab, such as WIV1, and Baric says he still believes a natural spillover is the most likely cause. But he also knows the intricate risks of the work well enough to see a possible path to trouble. That is why, in May of this year, he joined 17 other scientists in a letter in the journal Science calling for a thorough investigation of his onetime collaborator’s lab and its practices. He wants to know what barriers were in place to keep a pathogen from slipping out into Wuhan’s population of 13 million, and possibly to the world.

“Let’s face it: there are going to be unknown viruses in guano, or oral swabs, which are oftentimes pooled. And if you’re attempting to culture a virus, you’re going to have novel strains being dropped onto culture cells,” Baric says. “Some will grow. You could get recombinants that are unique. And if that was being done at BSL-2, then there are questions you want to ask.”
 
The paper by Daszak and Shi at WIV was done with recombinant viruses not wild type and BSL-2 would be appropriate. What is the context of Baric's quote you highlighted? Is he criticising WIV or is it a general statement? Are bat viruses sent to WIV cultured in their BSL-3 labs?

Your cynicism of the regulation of containment labs is painful to read given the amount of work that is needed to keep these labs safe and operational .
 
... Your cynicism of the regulation of containment labs is painful to read given the amount of work that is needed to keep these labs safe and operational .
And your idealism is unrealistic, especially how you assume because there are safety standards in the US the same applies to China.

If the labs are so safe why have there been multiple accidents that resulted in people getting infected? Do I need to list them again? The latest one was an employee getting infected with COVID-19.

Baric was very clear: he had concerns about the WIV using level 2 BSL when there might be unknown coronaviruses resulting from their work.
 
Last edited:
And your idealism is unrealistic, especially how you assume because there are safety standards in the US the same applies to China.

If the labs are so safe why have there been multiple accidents that resulted in people getting infected? Do I need to list them again? The latest one was an employee getting infected with COVID-19.

Baric was very clear: he had concerns about the WIV using level 2 BSL when there might be unknown coronaviruses resulting from their work.
You do need to list those "multiple accidents" that show that the WIV labs were unsafe.
In the real world, there was one old double accident which is evidence that the WIV labs are safer than that labs! The WIV labs would have learned from this.
List of laboratory biosecurity incidents
Two researchers at the Chinese Center for Disease Control and Prevention contracted the virus in Beijing, China around April 2004, and then spread the infection to around six other people. The two researchers contracted the virus in two incidents, two weeks apart.[31]
Note the safety protocols at the Beijing lab in 2004 limited the outbreak to 8 people. Note that this incident was reported. An incident releasing SARS-2 is likely to be reported and tracked.

Baric's opinion is legitimate and irrelevant. His opinion is that the WIV "gain of function" (some debate about whether it strictly fit the definition) research should be in BSL-3 or higher. It seems the WIV researchers opinion was that they could not make more infectious coronavirus so BSL-2 was enough. They were not trying to make a virus primarily spread through contact into an air-borne virus.
SARS-CoV-2 cannot have come from that research.
Baric's opinion is that SARS-CoV-2 most likely came from natural spillover as you quoted.
 
Last edited:
And why is it not a problem that virologists regard BSL-2 for this research as pretty standard?

It doesn't appear to be an issue. Pseudotyped viruses are don't have a viral core that is dangerous or that can even reproduce. Even if it got into a living organism instead of a cell in a petri dish they couldn't infect it.
 
There's quite a bit of discussion about the origins of Covid on The Decoding the Gurus podcast. In this one, they talk with Stuart Neil who is a virologist based at King's College London.

Link

There's some discussion about a lot of issues related to SARS-CoV2, but mostly debunking or arguing against non-mainstream views such as GoF, the Monjiang mine etc... and other stuff such as ivermectin.
I came here to post that as well. The discussion of the Monjiang mine starts at around one hour three minutes or so. Maybe 1:06 at the latest.


You do need to list those "multiple accidents" that show that the WIV labs were unsafe.
I never did see these "multiple accidents" from the Wuhan Institute of Virology, but I haven't followed the thread here close enough. Google isn't helping me.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom