At this point we don't have conclusive evidence
one way or the other about GoF research at the WIV..
We have Daszak saying manipulating coronaviruses in the lab is easy to do.
We have Shi claiming they had no live bats at the WIV and no live coronavirus cultures, both of which there is good evidence was untrue.
We have Baric giving Shi the humanized mice.
We have Shi's paucity of coronavirus genomes in the WIV records and that is absurd given they had been specifically studying them and collecting samples for a decade.
Shi was well aware funding for the GoF research from the US had been stopped. Her work with Baric had an exception because it was already in progress when the hold on the US funds began.
Once the work was being done only at the WIV, there was no real access to what they were doing.
Daszak also 'laundered' $600K (I think that was the amount) of US funds from his company to the WIV.
And we have Daszak very much interested in finding PPPs (potentially pandemic pathogens) or demonstrating they were possible as his goal was in protecting wildlife from human encounters by showing how close the next pandemic was.
Do you have evidence of what Shi and the WIV were researching other than pinpointing the reservoir of SARS 1 which was completed a couple of years ago?
Even if they weren't using GoF to study PPPs, there are other possibilities they collected coronavirus pathogens ready to go in their samples. One scenario is they found a significant PPP collected from the Yunnan mine and that is when they themselves shut things down. That is one explanation for removing the genome data base back on Sept 9.
I think that possibility is remote however.
It's not hard to see with a genetic timeline how the first cases do go a couple patients back to early Sept.
I also think there will be conclusive evidence found re the lab leak hypothesis despite the Chinese attempt to cover it up; like the evidence Bloom found in the cloud, for example, despite the researcher presenting a rationale for removing the research.
There are the hackers that a source upthread revealed who were working to hack the Chinese data. Unfortunately anything they find will likely be suspect.
There are a lot of doom and gloom "we'll never know" voices out there right now. From what has come out so far I believe we will know though not sure how long that will be.
I have significant doubt about the natural spillover proponents who hold up the WHO report as strong evidence. They don't even acknowledge Daszak's conflict of interest. But even beyond that, we have
Embarek's description of the pressure the Chinese put on the WHO team to discount anything supporting the lab accident hypothesis.
The ones who have modeled the genome timeline and show it doesn't match the lab leak hypothesis have more credence but they don't have conclusive evidence just as there is no conclusive evidence of either hypothesis.
I've not heard your evidence/opinion of how the 2 lineages in the early cases proves the pathogen emerged outside of Wuhan. I think it has been sufficiently shown it is not evidence of a beginning of the pandemic outside of Wuhan.
From an epidemiological POV (my area of expertise), there would have been evidence had the pandemic began outside of Wuhan. There is none. And I have cited
other expert sources that agree this was a one time event and it occurred in Wuhan.
In addition, some here in the thread and some cited sources have speculated about the sputtering, and spillovers dying out until one didn't. That requires evidence we don't see. With SARS 1 it was found, actually observed as it was happening. With several HPAIs (highly pathogenic avian flu) we have the cases that sputtered and are only one or two mutations away from being adapted to the human airway cells. They've been studied, observed, and we know why a few human cases emerged without significant spreading person to person.
If sputtering occurred in this case one would expect the same pattern of asymptomatic to fatal pneumonia proportions.
It's not realistic to think only mild cases occurred in the first cases and then suddenly the pathogen became virulent. That would require different genetic changes, one for person to person spread and one for increased virulence.
Once you start going on with this speculation you start seeing how what might look reasonable at first turns out not to be.
I could go on; I've already posted this stuff.