Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
It's science to look at the strength of evidence supporting each hypothesis. The longer it goes without finding even a hint of the natural reservoir, the less likely the natural spillover hypothesis becomes. Whereas there is a growing body of evidence supporting the lab accident hypothesis. And the Chinese are the ones with the key evidence but they are refusing to share that evidence.

LOL! The longer it takes to find out what exactly went bump in the night, the more we must conclude it was a ghost! That’s science!

Ummmm….no! Nice try at making up your own epistemology though.
 
Yeah—no. Re that bolded part and I'm not going to repeat this **** again and again:..
Followed by mostly nonsense irrelevant to the fact that there are decades of evolution between bat viruses and SARS-CoV-2.

The number of collected bats for a decade is irrelevant (decades of evolution!).

Nonsense about a "biased" WHO report.

My English was clear: "If I recall right, there is also evidence or opinion that the evolution happened in a immune system, i.e. an animal or human.". As I recall, this was that the genetic changes looked like natural selection in immune systems. You should be comfortable with my reliance on memory when you do the same :D.

A "pangolin source was ruled out long ago" error. WHO-convened global study of origins of SARS-CoV-2: China Part
Although the closest related viruses have been found in bats, the evolutionary distance between these bat viruses and SARS-CoV-2 is estimated to be several decades, suggesting a missing link (either a
missing progenitor virus, or evolution of a progenitor virus in an intermediate host). Highly similar viruses have also been found in pangolins, suggesting cross-species transmission from bats at least once, but again with considerable genetic distance
Both bats and pangolins were sold in wet markets. A still plausible animal origin is bat to pangolin to humans.

A "labs were not well run" error. Shi and others complained about a lack appropriate technicians back in 2017 for the new BSL4 lab.
 
Last edited:
I can’t understand why this argument is still brought up when we know that for lots of patients COVID-19 is asymptomatic.

It was a claim that was made as part of the initial accusations against the lab.

Mike Pompey claimed “we have totally evidence that people from the Wuhan Institute of Virology went to the hospital because of Covid 1111!”

Now it is “Yeah well maybe they were sick and they didn’t even know it!” :rolleyes:
 
I can’t understand why this argument is still brought up when we know that for lots of patients COVID-19 is asymptomatic.
A reason is that a worker involved in a lab incident will interact with their colleagues at work, their family and friends. They may be one of the 1 asymptomatic cases in 5 infections. But the chances of everyone they infect being asymptomatic is low. There should be reported cases a step away from that worker. Competent contact tracing might extend that to 2 or more steps away from the worker.
 
It's like breeding a dog, you pick the more and more adapted strains and the mutations add up eventually to be fit to infect humans version. Humanized mice, for one thing can be used in this way. Lineages that weren't adapted wouldn't reproduce well in the mice while lineages that were would.

Well, this is Angie Rasmussen's answer to that:

hACE2 transgenic mice are not "humanized." They express the human ACE2 gene & you can see if a virus can infect a host in vivo using this system. This is basic virology research.

But there's no evidence that this virus was "pre-adapted" to a human host via serial passage in cells or in mice. Even in hACE2 transgenic mice, serial passage will result in rodent adaptive mutations throughout the entire genome. There's also zero evidence of that.

Plus, the strongest evidence that this virus wasn't well adapted to humans when it emerged has been accumulating right before our eyes.

They are called alpha, beta, gamma, and delta. And all the other variants that have emerged.

he emergence of variants with improved fitness and infectivity show that the early viruses weren't well-adapted to human hosts at all. Not from studies in cell culture, or in transgenic mice, or in employees of the WIV.
 
First, they were also using human respiratory tract cells in petri dishes (see the links to Baric's work).

Second, Baric sent the humanized mice to the WIV (also in cites upthread).

Third, the proof is in the pudding: Nature: The pathogenicity of SARS-CoV-2 in hACE2 transgenic mice
... Here we infected transgenic mice that express human ACE2 (hereafter, hACE2 mice) with SARS-CoV-2 and studied the pathogenicity of the virus. We observed weight loss as well as virus replication in the lungs of hACE2 mice infected with SARS-CoV-2. The typical histopathology was interstitial pneumonia with infiltration of considerable numbers of macrophages and lymphocytes into the alveolar interstitium, and the accumulation of macrophages in alveolar cavities. We observed viral antigens in bronchial epithelial cells, macrophages and alveolar epithelia. These phenomena were not found in wild-type mice infected with SARS-CoV-2. Notably, we have confirmed the pathogenicity of SARS-CoV-2 in hACE2 mice.

I don't see then how one can claim:
But there's no evidence that this virus was "pre-adapted" to a human host via serial passage in cells or in mice. Even in hACE2 transgenic mice, serial passage will result in rodent adaptive mutations throughout the entire genome. There's also zero evidence of that.
If that were the case then how does the process work in reverse with COVID 19 readily able to infect the mice?

The idea the original virus collected in Yunnan couldn't have been adapted toward a human pathogen is refuted not just with direct evidence, but Daszak also noted in that interview that the coronavirus was easy to manipulate in the lab.
 
Last edited:
I remind you once again, take that CT crap to the CT thread and stop tying to slip a false accusation in again that people in this thread are CTers.

:dl:

The lady do protest too much, methinks.

What's a conspiracy, SG?

Let me give you a hand - I have my Dictionary.com ready to go.

noun, plural con·spir·a·cies.

the act of conspiring.

an evil, unlawful, treacherous, or surreptitious plan formulated in secret by two or more persons; plot.

a combination of persons for a secret, unlawful, or evil purpose: He joined the conspiracy to overthrow the government.

Law. an agreement by two or more persons to commit a crime, fraud, or other wrongful act.

any concurrence in action; combination in bringing about a given result.


You are proposing that there is a conspiracy. The lab, the researchers, the Chinese government and some others are all involved in attempting to cover up a leak from a lab. That's your entire shtick. You have no evidence of a leak, and claim everyone who says it's not a lab leak has a vested interest, from Fauci to Daszak.

That is the perfect example of what a conspiracy is.

Your defensiveness is telling.
 
Do you really watch those 2 hour programs?

You really should watch it. It's always best to listen to what actual experts have to say on any issue, in this podcast series you get to see what a wide range of actual virologists think about how unlikely a lab leak is.


Back to the preprint,

No longer a preprint, as it's already cleared peer review.



yes that has been linked here along with the faux claim there was supporting evidence about cases in Wuhan linked to other wet markets when they weren't.


The reviewers clearly saw no problem, and as I recall your "complaint" wasn't about this paper at all, but an interview segment from a paper you refused to read in the fist place. (Like so many other actual scientific sources you have refused to look at)

And they rely on unconfirmed evidence that no WIV staff were ill or had antibodies and that was challenged as the Chinese merely told the WHO team that fact but would not allow them to see the actual data.

Mushy thinking on your part. There is no evidence anywhere for any WiV staff being sick and the serology data reported by the WiV showed no SARS-CoV-2 antibodies in any of the staff. Even if you dismiss the information the WiV provided you still have no evidence for illness, and don't get to say a lack of evidence "confirmed" you claims some of the staff were infected.

Also, if you are going to reject the information being provided why the **** would anyone think your demands for "more openness" are honest? If you are already rejecting any data that doesn't fit your belief, what good would providing more data do? You'd just reject that as a coverup as well.


It's bothersome that all those researchers seemed to have glossed over the significant problems with the WHO report and they simply accept it without question.
You say all 18 researchers from countries all over the world in this paper, a dozen or so more from the WHO team and the hundreds of researchers publishing and reviewing papers are all out to hide the supposed lab leak. How is this anything but a conspiracy theory?
 
First, they were also using human respiratory tract cells in petri dishes (see the links to Baric's work).

Second, Baric sent the humanized mice to the WIV (also in cites upthread).

Third, the proof is in the pudding: Nature: The pathogenicity of SARS-CoV-2 in hACE2 transgenic mice

I don't see then how one can claim:If that were the case then how does the process work in reverse with COVID 19 readily able to infect the mice?

The idea the original virus collected in Yunnan couldn't have been adapted toward a human pathogen is refuted not just with direct evidence, but Daszak also noted in that interview that the coronavirus was easy to manipulate in the lab.


Weren't the ACE2 mouse studies done in Beijing? Zhengli Shi isn't an author.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
You're missing some alternatives here.

One, the RaTG13 is not genetically close enough to fit the scenario.

There is no know virus that is genetically close enough to fit any form of the lab leak hypothesis.

Two, we don't know anything about the very first cases because the Chinese refuse to release the data on those cases.
The earliest cases occurred 4-6 weeks before there was any possibility of detecting the outbreak. How can they "release data" they can't plausibly have?
One doesn't have to engineer a virus to get a lab culture with better and better adaptation to human cells.
SARS-CoV-2 in it's original form was sub-optimal in terms of binding to human ACE2. It only has a partial furin cleavage site instead of a full cleavage site. There are other corona viruses that are already more efficient at binding to human ACE2 and most of these have never circulated in humans.


There is also the problem that the culturing technique used by the WiV is know to destroy furin cleavage sites, and so could not have produced SARS-CoV-2

And to that issue, Shi has denied they had cultures or live bats and there is a lot of evidence that simply is not true.

You claiming evidence is not the same as you presenting convincing evidence. I have seen not seen you produce satisfactory supporting evidence for this claim.

The origin of the video self styled internet sleuths are claiming as evidence is purportedly a promotional video released for the lab opening. There is no evidence where the video was actually taken, but it seems unlikely that it was the lab that was just opening.


Even if there were live bats there, SO WHAT? It's not unthinkable they would study live bats but neither is there any reason for the WiV to lie about it if they did. The idea that live bats would be some sort of smoking gun is silly.
 
It's not surprising, it's what one would expect if the origin was in a lab.

NO. This is completely backwards. Researchers don't work with viruses without cataloging them first. If it was a lab origin it should have been easy to find the proximal ancestor because it would have been cataloged and studied.


Tracking down the wild animal source for a novel virus is something you expect to take decades if it's possible to find at all.

It's absurd. It's been almost 2 years. What's the holdup?

The "holdup" is that it's something that normally takes decades.
 
It's like breeding a dog, you pick the more and more adapted strains and the mutations add up eventually to be fit to infect humans version. Humanized mice, for one thing can be used in this way. Lineages that weren't adapted wouldn't reproduce well in the mice while lineages that were would.

This sounds like it's nearly impossible to do this in living organisms. If someone was attempting such a thing it would almost certainly be in vitro. Again, as the Holmes paper points out the culturing techniques used by the WiV destroys furin cleavage sites and therefor could not produce SARS-CoV-2
 
It was a claim that was made as part of the initial accusations against the lab.

Mike Pompey claimed “we have totally evidence that people from the Wuhan Institute of Virology went to the hospital because of Covid 1111!”

Now it is “Yeah well maybe they were sick and they didn’t even know it!” :rolleyes:


Pompey had political reasons for saying what he did. Political lies are not the subject of this discussion.
 
Weren't the ACE2 mouse studies done in Beijing? Zhengli Shi isn't an author.
That article is about infecting the mice after the pandemic was going. Angrysoba cited a source claiming work with the humanized mice could not have resulted in COVID 19.

Baric sent the mice to Shi at the WIV after they ended their joint study on the chimera coronavirus in the NC lab. The source said at that point they quit collaborating and became more competitive. And from there on the US had no eyes on the ground observing what research was going on at the WIV.

Feel free to weigh in if you think the GoF research could not have produced a gradually modified SARS CoV 2 adapted to humans. I'll be happy to go back over the sources linked in this thread which said a modified virus could have been created in the lab which looked no different from one which evolved in the wild.
 
Last edited:
I don't see then how one can claim:If that were the case then how does the process work in reverse with COVID 19 readily able to infect the mice?

SARS-CoV-2 readily infects many different animals for which it has no prior adaption. It's therefor silly to suggest it had or needed to have any prior adaptation to infect humans. Once in humans, however, it developed human specific adaptations. Per Dr Rasmussen, we see no similar rodent specific adaptations.
 
A reason is that a worker involved in a lab incident will interact with their colleagues at work, their family and friends. They may be one of the 1 asymptomatic cases in 5 infections. But the chances of everyone they infect being asymptomatic is low. There should be reported cases a step away from that worker. Competent contact tracing might extend that to 2 or more steps away from the worker.


I agree. But the claim was that it was evidence that none of the lab workers were registered as having been sick. We don’t know if relatives of lab workers were sick with with Covid-19 because this would have been at a stage when nobody would have connected a bout of cough or influenza with having an unknown disease, and I don’t think anybody would have started contact tracing at this stage.
 
Pompey had political reasons for saying what he did. Political lies are not the subject of this discussion.

Pompey! :D

Of course, I meant Pompeo.

Anyway, we are still at "no evidence of infected lab workers". As mentioned, if they got infected but were asymptomatic, then presumably they would have passed that on to their co-workers and families. Apparently we don't see evidence of that either.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom