Reality Check
Penultimate Amazing
There is a 30 December 2019 "Undiagnosed pneumonia - China (HU): RFI" post on ProMed. The source though is Finance Sina. It looks like articles from the newspaper with a mobile feed and a moderator comment.I believe they said in that piece that Dr Li sent a message via ProMedmail, the International Society for Infectious Diseases general email feed.
https://promedmail.org/
Frontline A Timeline of China’s Response in the First Days of COVID-19
ThsnDECEMBER 30, 2019 Around this time, hospitals in Wuhan start seeing dozens of patients with severe pneumonia.
More virus samples are sent to other labs for sequencing. One lab tells Wuhan Central Hospital, mistakenly, that the virus is SARS itself. The lab’s results circulate quickly among the doctors and reach Li Wenliang, an ophthalmologist.
Li forwards a message to a group of doctors with a warning: “Don’t circulate this information outside the group, tell your family and loved ones to take precautions.”
His message goes viral.
The local health commission orders Wuhan hospitals to report new cases directly to them and bars the release of information to the public. The orders leak and spread online.
Word of the virus also reaches Marjorie Pollack, an epidemiologist, in New York. “My reaction was ‘we’re in trouble.’ It was very much a deja vu of what happened with SARS-1.” Her organization, Promed, sends a notification out to around 80,000 subscribers around the world.
There was an order that no lab results be published without authorization. The full genetic sequence showing the virus to be SARS-related was done on 5 January 2020 and released on 11 January 2020.JANUARY 1, 2020 Wuhan police reprimand several of the doctors who spread news about an outbreak. Chinese state TV labels them “rumormongers.” Li Wenliang is called to a police station to sign a confession that accuses him of “publishing fictitious discourse” that has “severely disrupted social order.”
The Chinese government disputes that what happened to Li is proof that they were trying to suppress information about the outbreak. They maintain he was merely urged not to spread unconfirmed information.
Last edited: