Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
I'm pretty sure they are not being honest. One need only look at some history we do know about. For example the ophthalmologist (he worked in a hospital, BTW, I hadn't known that at first) who saw an inexplicable rash of pneumonia cases and tried to talk about it was silenced. Later when he died of COVID, IIRC, the government might have apologized. Bottom line, we know the government tried to silence him.
That’s true, but it still does not mean that the Chinese government want to suppress knowledge of any wrongdoing. They are so secretive that they want to suppress anything that could be construed as bad news.

The problem is that this attitude gives us reason not to trust them at all, lab leak or not lab leak.
 
That’s true, but it still does not mean that the Chinese government want to suppress knowledge of any wrongdoing. They are so secretive that they want to suppress anything that could be construed as bad news.

The problem is that this attitude gives us reason not to trust them at all, lab leak or not lab leak.
If you had to put odds on that I'd give 99% they are hiding something real and 1% they don't trust honest reporting.

Granted Dump made that second option more likely. The fact they started taking coronavirus material off the internet well before the pandemic was recognized suggests they were hiding evidence before Dump ever accused them of being responsible.

And given no one (of any significance) blamed China for SARS, one would think had COVID 19 been a natural event the Chinese would have expected the evidence in this case to also find the same origin. Why didn't they expect that? Clamming up suggests they knew that wasn't going to be the finding.

One of the things they have suppressed is access to any case files of the initial infections. That makes zero sense if you want to show the world how the natural spillover occurred.
 
The problem is that we will never know if the Chinese are being honest or not. They have a system that punishes openness, and that throws doubt at anything they say.

They might not have anything to hide, but we’ll never know.

Maybe we will.... if the Vietnamese will eventually spill info from hacking the CCP and people in Wuhan in mid December. They do not admit to this of course but they left a trail.

https://www.securityweek.com/vietnamese-hackers-mount-covid-19-espionage-campaigns-against-china

Perhaps other countries too, like Taiwan.
 
This from my email is on Frontline tonight or streaming anytime. I haven't seen it yet but intend to. I suspect it is more about China not acting promptly when the thing started rather than about origins but I don't know.

Also, apparently China did delay informing the world about SARS 1 for three months when it started. I didn't remember correctly.

Tonight on FRONTLINE, revisit China’s COVID Secrets — our February 2021 documentary investigating the gulf between what Chinese scientists and officials knew as the coronavirus outbreak began and what they told the world.

“I believe that the true history needs to be remembered,” the first health care worker from Wuhan Central Hospital to talk to international journalists about what was happening in the early days of the outbreak says in the documentary. “We need to learn the lessons so that this doesn’t happen again.”

With leaked documents, secret recordings, and accounts from Chinese scientists and doctors, international disease experts and health officials, China's COVID Secrets reveals missed opportunities to suppress the outbreak and lessons for the world.

Watch an encore presentation of China's COVID Secrets on select PBS stations tonight at 10/9c (check local listings). You can also stream the documentary, a coproduction with the BBC, anytime on our site, on YouTube and in the PBS Video App.

PATRICE TADDONIO
Digital Writer & Audience Development Strategist, FRONTLINE
 
Channel 4 documentary (UK) about the lab leak hypothesis featuring a number of the famous DRASTIC researchers:

Just watched that excellent documentary and I see that it supports the things I've been saying and and posting about in this thread. Everything in that video has been posted about here except for a more recent HPAI GoF research I was unaware of.

And no, it isn't a Loose Change CT video like the 911 inside job stuff though I suspect at least one or two people in this thread, being incapable to evaluating the validity of evidence, to dismiss it out of hand.
 
Last edited:
Are you actually claiming the Chinese have been transparent in the investigation and virology labs in China have meticulous safety records?
I am claiming what I wrote!
Chinese scientists worked in the Wuhan labs and were free" (see below) to comment on the level of lab safety during the WHO team visit. More importantly non-Chinese scientists including members of the WHO team also visited the Wuhan labs and were definitely free to comment on the level of lab safety. Also there were no issues with the lab safety reported during 2019 before the pandemic.

I am claiming the facts - virology labs in Wuhan have meticulous safety records. As I noted, virology labs in China have had incidents like labs throughout the world: List of laboratory biosecurity incidents. If you were to read that list, you might come back with the impression that the country with the worse lab safety record is the United States :D! China has 3 incidents. The US has 15 since the 1970's. An extremely unlikely, nearly impossible scenario we could speculate about is one of the US labs researching coronavirus having a incident and an infected worker visiting Wuhan. My guess is that travel records rule this out.

The Chinese government is not being as transparent about samples and raw patient data as we would want them to be. That is no surprise given their track record. Not allowing access to data is not a conspiracy to suppress what their scientists know about lab safety. There is probably is some pressure on the scientists from Chinese officials. No one has any factual evidence of this and we can only speculate on the extent and effects.
 
Last edited:
I am claiming what I wrote!
Chinese scientists worked in the Wuhan labs and were free" (see below) to comment on the level of lab safety during the WHO team visit. More importantly non-Chinese scientists including members of the WHO team also visited the Wuhan labs and were definitely free to comment on the level of lab safety. Also there were no issues with the lab safety reported during 2019 before the pandemic.

I am claiming the facts - virology labs in Wuhan have meticulous safety records. As I noted, virology labs in China have had incidents like labs throughout the world: List of laboratory biosecurity incidents. If you were to read that list, you might come back with the impression that the country with the worse lab safety record is the United States :D! China has 3 incidents. The US has 15 since the 1970's. An extremely unlikely, nearly impossible scenario we could speculate about is one of the US labs researching coronavirus having a incident and an infected worker visiting Wuhan. My guess is that travel records rule this out.

The Chinese government is not being as transparent about samples and raw patient data as we would want them to be. That is no surprise given their track record. Not allowing access to data is not a conspiracy to suppress what their scientists know about lab safety. There is probably is some pressure on the scientists from Chinese officials. No one has any factual evidence of this and we can only speculate on the extent and effects.
How is all that not claiming the Chinese have been transparent?

Watch the Frontline piece. They do an excellent job of reporting on the Chinese not being transparent. It's really good. You need to watch it.

There is way more secrecy than I had known about.
 
Last edited:
For example the ophthalmologist (he worked in a hospital, BTW, I hadn't known that at first) who saw an inexplicable rash of pneumonia cases and tried to talk about it was silenced. Later when he died of COVID, IIRC, the government might have apologized. Bottom line, we know the government tried to silence him.
The Chinese doctor who tried to warn others about coronavirus
Li Wenliang posted about cases of what looked like SARS in a group chat with fellow doctors on 30 December. The Public Security Bureau (the local police) did their rather dubious job. They made him sign a letter about "making false comments". Local authorities apologised to him by the end of January.
 
The Chinese doctor who tried to warn others about coronavirus
Li Wenliang posted about cases of what looked like SARS in a group chat with fellow doctors on 30 December. The Public Security Bureau (the local police) did their rather dubious job. They made him sign a letter about "making false comments". Local authorities apologised to him by the end of January.
And?

That's all in the Frontline piece that I imagine you are avoiding watching because it clashes with your confirmation bias.
 
The Chinese doctor who tried to warn others about coronavirus
Li Wenliang posted about cases of what looked like SARS in a group chat with fellow doctors on 30 December. The Public Security Bureau (the local police) did their rather dubious job. They made him sign a letter about "making false comments". Local authorities apologised to him by the end of January.

On 30 December he sent a message to fellow doctors in a chat group warning them about the outbreak and advising they wear protective clothing to avoid infection.

What Dr Li didn't know then was that the disease that had been discovered was an entirely new coronavirus.

SARS
While SARS-CoV-1 probably persists as a potential zoonotic threat in its original animal reservoir, human-to-human transmission of this virus may be considered eradicated because no human case has been documented since four minor, brief, subsequent outbreaks in 2004.

The big news here isn't that Li Wenliang was sanctioned for 'spreading rumors' in a chat group, it's that apparently this is how is how doctors in China warn us about outbreaks of deadly diseases.

But I guess we shouldn't criticize when for the past 4 years our president's primary official communications channel was Twitter.
 
Looks like the conspiracists have been handed a green card, with an inconclusive consensus from US intelligence agencies.

https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2021/aug/27/coronavirus-origin-us-intelligence

Think how much time they could've saved if they'd just read this thread...
I remind you once again, take that CT crap to the CT thread and stop tying to slip a false accusation in again that people in this thread are CTers. There isn't one word in that Guardian article about any CTers. Your attempt is blatantly obvious.


Now back to the report which BTW concluded that the lab origin hypothesis was not only not a CT, but had equal weight to the natural spillover hypothesis.

Unclassified-Summary-of-Assessment-on-COVID-19-Origins
Key Takeaways
The IC assesses that SARS-CoV-2, the virus that causes COVID-19, probably emerged and infected humans through an initial small-scale exposure that occurred no later than November 2019 with the first known cluster of COVID-19 cases arising in Wuhan, China in December 2019.
No later than Nov, I think there is evidence of the same in this thread. Doesn't give an earliest date. And they can't because China hasn't released data on the earliest cases.

In addition, the IC was able to reach broad agreement on several other key issues. We judge the virus was not developed as a biological weapon. Most agencies also assess with low confidence that SARS-CoV-2 probably was not genetically engineered;
I do not believe anyone in the thread disagrees with that as long as one defines genetically engineered as chopping and inserting various genetic sequences into another virus or virus backbone.

however, two agencies believe there was not sufficient evidence to make an assessment either way. Finally, the IC assesses China’s officials did not have foreknowledge of the virus before the initial outbreak of COVID-19 emerged.
Which fits my most likely scenario, they thought they had stopped the leak in its tracks and didn't realize for another month that they had not.

After examining all available intelligence reporting and other information, though, the IC remains divided on the most likely origin of COVID-19. All agencies assess that two hypotheses are plausible: natural exposure to an infected animal and a laboratory-associated incident.
No assessment the lab origin is a CT so get over it TA.


I found this variation in confidence levels quite interesting:
Four IC elements and the National Intelligence Council assess with low confidence that the initial SARS-CoV-2 infection was most likely caused by natural exposure to an animal infected with it or a close progenitor virus—a virus that probably would be more than 99 percent similar to SARS-CoV-2. These analysts give weight to China’s officials’ lack of foreknowledge, the numerous vectors for natural exposure, and other factors

One IC element assesses with moderate confidence that the first human infection with SARS-CoV-2 most likely was the result of a laboratory-associated incident, probably involving experimentation, animal handling, or sampling by the Wuhan Institute of Virology. These analysts give weight to the inherently risky nature of work on coronaviruses.
So 4 with low confidence vs 1 with moderate confidence.

And there were some more POVs. All of the conclusions depended on the weight given certain elements:
Analysts at three IC elements remain unable to coalesce around either explanation without additional information, with some analysts favoring natural origin, others a laboratory origin, and some seeing the hypotheses as equally likely.

Variations in analytic views largely stem from differences in how agencies weigh intelligence reporting and scientific publications, and intelligence and scientific gaps.

The IC—and the global scientific community—lacks clinical samples or a complete understanding of epidemiological data from the earliest COVID-19 cases. If we obtain information on the earliest cases that identified a location of interest or occupational exposure, it may alter our evaluation of hypotheses
They go on to state China is denying access to the information needed to resolve the question.

There was another article on this and it noted this was probably the political analysis and it was hoped that the scientific investigation could still shine more light on the origin.

NPR: A U.S. Intelligence Report Fails To Pinpoint COVID's Origins
Both hypotheses remain plausible, according to an unclassified summary of the report's key takeaways that was released on Friday by the Office of the Director of National Intelligence.

The intelligence community "remains divided on the most likely origin of COVID-19. All agencies assess that two hypotheses are plausible: natural exposure to an infected animal and a laboratory-associated incident," the brief summary states.
The lab origin is not a CT, period! People really should stop trolling in this thread trying to demean people they don't agree with.

I found this confirmation bias unsurprising and also not what the summary says:
"It appears the needle was moved in the intelligence community more towards the natural origin," says Garry. "I think that you have to look at the scientific data that's out there. Follow the science, follow the animals."
Where in that summary does it look like the needle was moved in either direction?


This was the comment I noted about political vs scientific inquiries:
"This is an intelligence community report, not a scientific report," says Michael Worobey, an evolutionary biologist at the University of Arizona. He would like to see the scientific and intelligence communities collaborate on the problem. "I would hope and assume that this 90-day sprint is going to turn into a nice long jog where there could be some back-and-forth."

Key clinical samples and data from the earliest COVID-19 cases still remain out-of-reach, both for scientists and intelligence agencies, as the summary of the intelligence review states. But Worobey thinks scientists will continue to make progress, even without major revelations from the intelligence community.

Now if those hackers could actually find some incriminating emails that might move the needle one way or the other.
 
...

The big news here isn't that Li Wenliang was sanctioned for 'spreading rumors' in a chat group, it's that apparently this is how is how doctors in China warn us about outbreaks of deadly diseases.....
I believe they said in that piece that Dr Li sent a message via ProMedmail, the International Society for Infectious Diseases general email feed.

https://promedmail.org/

This is the same place it was shared with the outside medical community that a pneumonia outbreak that was infecting and killing healthcare staff was occurring in Guangdong. That turned out to be SARS.

A lot of information goes out on this platform where medical providers ask for more information and/or share what they are observing on the ground.
 
So: The result was an apology from the local authorities. This is evidence that the government made a mistake in this case of suppression. This suggests that there should be no suppression of data about the COVID-19 breakout. At least for the first months of the pandemic.

A "confirmation bias" fantasy when my bias is actually the other way. As I have stated a couple of times, I know that the Chinese government has a track record of suppression. I do not trust them. However I an a skeptic who requires evidence. What I see is the usual Chinese government paranoia about foreign agencies. Probable bureaucratic pressure to put the best spin on the WHO study results. That does not means that there was a Wuhan lab incident and there is a coverup. This means we cannot know that there was Wuhan lab incident. We are left with the only evidence we have - lab incidents happen!
 
Last edited:
Now back to the report which BTW concluded that the lab origin hypothesis was not only not a CT, but had equal weight to the natural spillover hypothesis.

Unclassified-Summary-of-Assessment-on-COVID-19-Origins.
UNCLASSIFIED SUMMARY OF ASSESSMENT ON COVID-19 ORIGINS The summary PDF is an intelligence agency assessment. They write
  • Four IC elements and the National Intelligence Council assess with low confidence that the initial SARS-CoV-2 infection was most likely caused by natural exposure to an animal infected with it or a close progenitor virus—a virus that probably would be more than 99 percent similar to SARS-CoV-2. These analysts give weight to China’s officials’ lack of foreknowledge, the numerous vectors for natural exposure, and other factors.
  • One IC element assesses with moderate confidence that the first human infection with SARS-CoV-2 most likely was the result of a laboratory-associated incident, probably involving experimentation, animal handling, or sampling by the Wuhan Institute of Virology. These analysts give weight to the inherently risky nature of work on coronaviruses.
What they are saying in that 5 intelligence elements have low confidence in a natural origin while 1 element has a moderate confidence in an lab incident origin. That confidence is presumably about the intelligence data. A scientific analysis would follow the scientific consensus of a most probable animal origin and a less probable lab incident origin.
The assessment is correct. Everyone agrees that both scenarios are plausible. Everyone also agrees that the scientific evidence makes the animal origin more plausible.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom