Origin of the paint that was found as red-gray chips - any ideas?

Hi all,

The offers of financial support for these tests pouring in are great. Some are coming to me privately and some here on the thread. Hold off for now... next week I ask Kevin Ryan for chip samples HE thinks have thermitic material. He may say yes he may say no, and if he says no we have to decide if we can come up with a protocol where we have a match for what Harritt et al SAY are red-gray chips and not paint. I'm guessing at best it will be two or three weeks before I actually ask people for the $$. People on both sides have offered to contribute, which I think is very cool.

I think you guys know I own a wedding chapel. It used to be a Lutheran Church and now everyone gets married there. During World War II, Camp Hale near Leadville Colorado (elevation 10,500') was a POW camp for German soldiers captured in the war. The American captain running the camp was a Lutheran, and it soon dawned on him that his prisoners were mostly Lutherans as well. So one day he said, hey guys, would you like to work on building a Lutheran Church together as long as we're all sitting up here waiting for the war to end? A bunch of the POWs said yes, and they built fabulous stained glass windows, stained glass lanterns to hold light bulbs, etc. In 1946 they hauled it all down to Denver and built their Lutheran Church, which opened in 1947. If the Nazis and the Americans could work together on a project during the fierce fighting of WWII, it's nice to know Truthers and Debunkers can do the same! So Happy Holidays all.
 
Hi all,

The offers of financial support for these tests pouring in are great. Some are coming to me privately and some here on the thread. Hold off for now... next week I ask Kevin Ryan for chip samples HE thinks have thermitic material. He may say yes he may say no, and if he says no we have to decide if we can come up with a protocol where we have a match for what Harritt et al SAY are red-gray chips and not paint. I'm guessing at best it will be two or three weeks before I actually ask people for the $$. People on both sides have offered to contribute, which I think is very cool.

I think you guys know I own a wedding chapel. It used to be a Lutheran Church and now everyone gets married there. During World War II, Camp Hale near Leadville Colorado (elevation 10,500') was a POW camp for German soldiers captured in the war. The American captain running the camp was a Lutheran, and it soon dawned on him that his prisoners were mostly Lutherans as well. So one day he said, hey guys, would you like to work on building a Lutheran Church together as long as we're all sitting up here waiting for the war to end? A bunch of the POWs said yes, and they built fabulous stained glass windows, stained glass lanterns to hold light bulbs, etc. In 1946 they hauled it all down to Denver and built their Lutheran Church, which opened in 1947. If the Nazis and the Americans could work together on a project during the fierce fighting of WWII, it's nice to know Truthers and Debunkers can do the same! So Happy Holidays all.

Interesting story, Chris and kudos on the pursuit of testing the materials. Just a brief observation. The German soldiers might be best described as just that, German soldiers. Granted, they were fighting for the Nazis, but it's hard to say that all the soldiers were card-carrying Nazis, although I'm sure they had to pledge allegiance. I'm just saying that we can distinguish between soldiers and Nazis. Sort of like how Max Schmelling can't be rightfully called a Nazi. I say this as a Jewish American, and I'm certainly not defending anything to do with Nazism, but I suspect many German soldiers were more interested in defending their homeland, as opposed fighting to insititute a Final Solution. Anyway, that's my holiday message and I too, hope everyone has a peaceful New Year and ChrismaHanaKwanzaFestivakusEid.
 
ahhh, RedI, long time no see.
At some point those soldiers at least had some sense of allegience to the goals of their government. In the same way there are varying degrees that bunkos and debunkers hold to their positions.

For eg. I personally believe that a great deal of CYA occured post 9/11 from lower levels of military and gov't , all the way to the top.

I am very interested in whether or not the thermitic characteristics of WTC dust, specifically the red-gray chips, can be established. Especially given that Harrit did not bother to do so simply because he already believed' that it was thermitic.

Both sides need to ask themselves where they will go next if the chips prove to be either thermitic or not. For instance; It is possible that they can be self oxidizing yet not thermitic but it is not possible that they are not self oxidizing and thermitic.
 
Hi all,

The offers of financial support for these tests pouring in are great. Some are coming to me privately and some here on the thread. Hold off for now... next week I ask Kevin Ryan for chip samples HE thinks have thermitic material. He may say yes he may say no, and if he says no we have to decide if we can come up with a protocol where we have a match for what Harritt et al SAY are red-gray chips and not paint. I'm guessing at best it will be two or three weeks before I actually ask people for the $$. People on both sides have offered to contribute, which I think is very cool.

I think you guys know I own a wedding chapel. It used to be a Lutheran Church and now everyone gets married there. During World War II, Camp Hale near Leadville Colorado (elevation 10,500') was a POW camp for German soldiers captured in the war. The American captain running the camp was a Lutheran, and it soon dawned on him that his prisoners were mostly Lutherans as well. So one day he said, hey guys, would you like to work on building a Lutheran Church together as long as we're all sitting up here waiting for the war to end? A bunch of the POWs said yes, and they built fabulous stained glass windows, stained glass lanterns to hold light bulbs, etc. In 1946 they hauled it all down to Denver and built their Lutheran Church, which opened in 1947. If the Nazis and the Americans could work together on a project during the fierce fighting of WWII, it's nice to know Truthers and Debunkers can do the same! So Happy Holidays all.

I think German soldiers being labeled as Nazi's is unfair, and so is your comparing Nazis and Americans to Truthers and Debunkers.

MM
 
Great efford, Chris - thanks!

Speaking as a German, I am not offended if German soldiers who got caught while fighting for Nazi Germany are called "nazis" in a short hand form, especially when they are mentioned in an uplifting anecdote. I think we are all adult enough to know that not all German soldiers adored the Fuhrer, not all Americans are messangers of Enlightment, not all debunkers have sharp rational brains, and not all truthers eat babies for breakfast. Or whatever clichés may come to your mind.

Happy Hanukah, Yalda mobarak (that's Persian), and Fröhliche Weihnachten!
 
Hopefully by tomorrow I will be ready to ask Kevin Ryan for some samples of red-gray chips for our lab guy's WTC dust thermXte tests. He already has tested ten red-gray chips himself (with a solid chain of custody) and produced and shown to me spectographs of their chemical contents. So far no conclusive results, but as I already quoted him as saying, "Additional testing by PLM, SEM, TEM and FTIR after sample treatment may tell us differently." These are the four main tests he will be doing after he uses microscopy to find the specific chips. He has also talked to some of the top forensic analysts in the country, and has also read many of the posts on this thread, all of which he is using to help finalize his protocol. One final email from him may be coming today, then I will contact Kevin Ryan et al. If Kevin refuses to cooperate, this guy is highly confident he has already found his own red grey chips and can go forward with the tests with or without Kevin's help. Will keep you all posted.
 
Lab Guy update

Here are some of the emails I have received from my "Lab Guy" Jim Millette of MVA Scientific Consultants, who has taken a strong interest in this research and I believe has the tools to do a competent job. He believes if thermitic materials are there in significant quantities, he can find it (above a certain low threshold). I am convinced he is our man; he has experience, credentials, openmindedness, a good lab with access to multiple tests, even several samples of WTC dust with an ironclad chain of custody:

Chris, I’ll take some time to think about the best way to proceed. I too wish for an objective study that can be replicated in other laboratories. I will try and send a proposal next week. I have the Harritt Open Journal article of 2009.

Chris, I read your email. After reading the articles concerning the theory of Thermite causing the World Trade Center building collapse I looked briefly at one of the WTC dust samples we have in archive. We would be happy to be involved in a full study of the material.

Chris, We have looked at a number of red/gray particles from WTC dust samples we have archived and concluded that there is no simple test that can answer your question. However, we are interested in doing some forensic research analysis with samples we have and would be willing to look at a sample from the published work if you can make it available. If you are willing to fund the project with $1,000, we will provide additional analyses at no cost. We will only invoice you after we have sent you a report with something substantial. The attached preliminary data report shows elemental spectra that are consistent with paint layers we have seen previously. Additional testing by PLM, SEM, TEM and FTIR after sample treatment may tell us differently.

Chris, I have no problem with your release of our preliminary data to Kevin Ryan. If he sends us his red-gray chips, it is my intention to try and replicate his analyses and then do additional testing by PLM, SEM-EDS, TEM-SAED-EDS and FTIR after sample treatment as seems appropriate. We will return all unused portions of the samples he sends. Jim Millette

James R. Millette, Ph.D.
MVA Scientific Consultants
 
Kevin Ryan says no access to his dust samples

Kevin Ryan just informed me in no uncertain terms that he wants no part of these WTC dust tests. I asked him if he would provide a few red gray chips that HE believes are thermitic. He said no. Then I asked if he would at least look at the red gray chips in Jim Millette's collection to be sure we're looking at chips he considers thermitic, not just paint (Kevin believes he has samples of both and that they are different). He refused even to answer, accusing me of being dishonest by not revealing that the lab guy I found had been involved in "deceptive" 9/11 research, linking me to an EPA study Millette was part of, and asking me to ask him why he ignored the iron microspheres in this report.

I thought, OK, (gulp) I'll ask our lab guy if there waas anything "deceptive" in his EPA work or if he has any reason to falsify data in our tests. Here is Dr. Millette's most recent email in response: "Chris, I can assure you that we will proceed in an objective, scientific manner and report what we find. At present, I have no opinion as to whether we will find any active thermitic material. All I can say is that to this point in time we have not found any during the general particle characterizations we have done. Because we have not focused on this particular question in the past analyses, we are proceeding with a careful, forensic scientific study focused on the red-gray chips in a number of WTC dust samples. When I present the data, it will be in front of critical members of the forensic science community... I am an independent researcher without an interest in how the research results come out. Our laboratory is certified under ISO 17025 which includes audits of our accuracy, reliability and integrity. I am a member of the American Academy of Forensic Scientists and have sworn to uphold the high ethical standards of the organization. I do not see anything in our article that he linked (an original copy of the article published in Environmental Health Perspectives [57_Lioy-characterization east of wtc.pdf]) to suggest that we were publishing misleading data. Jim Millette"

So... I have a high degree of trust in Dr. Millette's integrity, knowledge and abilities. I asked several dozen labs, universities, firefighters, police forensic people in several states, etc etc etc. and Dr. Millette and his lab have shown themselves to be by far the most eminently qualified and openminded.

Kevin Ryan disagrees and has already rejected the upcoming results because 1) the experimenter is deceptive and 2) I am dishonest. I predict he will also reject it because he will say these tests will be on paint chips, not thermitic chips, even though he himself refused to participate in any way in deciding which chips to test!

I am telling everyone this in the interests of full disclosure. If you are a 9/11 Truth advocate, know that Kevin Ryan has rejected this study befopre it is even launched. I would love your support as well as the support of JREF'ers but know that Kevin Ryan does NOT support this. Some of you who have gotten to know me will nevertheless decide that finding out the truth is more important than what a 9/11 Truth leader says. To you I will say thank you, you deserve the 9/11 Truth moniker in the best sense of the word.
 
I'm not sure if this has been discussed before, but could you ask for samples / identification confirmation from Harrit or good ol' Dr. Jones?

If anything, it would be interesting/revealing to see their response.
 
...
Kevin Ryan disagrees and has already rejected the upcoming results because 1) the experimenter is deceptive and 2) I am dishonest. I predict he will also reject it because he will say these tests will be on paint chips, not thermitic chips, even though he himself refused to participate in any way in deciding which chips to test!
...

How predictable: Poisoning the Well Logical Fallacy + Major weasle dodge. Can you ask Kevin for proof that Jim and his lab have been deceptive? Or at least a more detailed explanation of what the deception was all about?

Anyway, now that Kevin is not supporting this, it becomes even more important that Jim repeats the test that Harrit e.al. did specifically on chips a-d, and that he only does additional tests on those chips that match their data. At a minimum:
  • Attracted by magnet
  • SEM-BSE image shows stacked platelets and rhonbohedric particles
  • XEDS of red layer resembles Fig. 7 (shows lots of Fe, O and C, and significant Si and Al, wit Si peak equal to or slightly higher than Al peak; traces of Cr)
  • XEDS of gray layer resembles closely Fig. 6 (lots of Fe and O, traces of Mn, and hardly anything else))
In addition, the following would be nice:
  • Chips ignite near 440°C in air
  • XEDS map of several elements shows Si and Al closely associated (having equal spacial distribution), and other elements (Fe, O, ...) not specially associated with any other elements)
This to ensure that no honest and reasonable truther can hand-wave the provenance of the chips Jim goes on to examine - that they are in fact the same material that Harrit e.al. declared to be thermitic.
 
ahhh, RedI, long time no see.
At some point those soldiers at least had some sense of allegience to the goals of their government.

Most were conscripted and had to swear allegiance to Hitler. Not doing so was a quick route to a concentration camp. Its doubtful that a majority ever were real nazis.



In the same way there are varying degrees that bunkos and debunkers hold to their positions.

No comparison, Twoofers have zero credible evidence and debunkers just point this out. Only one side is "believing" anything.
 
Kevin Ryan just informed me in no uncertain terms that he wants no part of these WTC dust tests. I asked him if he would provide a few red gray chips that HE believes are thermitic. He said no. Then I asked if he would at least look at the red gray chips in Jim Millette's collection to be sure we're looking at chips he considers thermitic, not just paint (Kevin believes he has samples of both and that they are different). He refused even to answer, accusing me of being dishonest by not revealing that the lab guy I found had been involved in "deceptive" 9/11 research, linking me to an EPA study Millette was part of, and asking me to ask him why he ignored the iron microspheres in this report.

I thought, OK, (gulp) I'll ask our lab guy if there waas anything "deceptive" in his EPA work or if he has any reason to falsify data in our tests. Here is Dr. Millette's most recent email in response: "Chris, I can assure you that we will proceed in an objective, scientific manner and report what we find. At present, I have no opinion as to whether we will find any active thermitic material. All I can say is that to this point in time we have not found any during the general particle characterizations we have done. Because we have not focused on this particular question in the past analyses, we are proceeding with a careful, forensic scientific study focused on the red-gray chips in a number of WTC dust samples. When I present the data, it will be in front of critical members of the forensic science community... I am an independent researcher without an interest in how the research results come out. Our laboratory is certified under ISO 17025 which includes audits of our accuracy, reliability and integrity. I am a member of the American Academy of Forensic Scientists and have sworn to uphold the high ethical standards of the organization. I do not see anything in our article that he linked (an original copy of the article published in Environmental Health Perspectives [57_Lioy-characterization east of wtc.pdf]) to suggest that we were publishing misleading data. Jim Millette"

So... I have a high degree of trust in Dr. Millette's integrity, knowledge and abilities. I asked several dozen labs, universities, firefighters, police forensic people in several states, etc etc etc. and Dr. Millette and his lab have shown themselves to be by far the most eminently qualified and openminded.

Kevin Ryan disagrees and has already rejected the upcoming results because 1) the experimenter is deceptive and 2) I am dishonest. I predict he will also reject it because he will say these tests will be on paint chips, not thermitic chips, even though he himself refused to participate in any way in deciding which chips to test!

I am telling everyone this in the interests of full disclosure. If you are a 9/11 Truth advocate, know that Kevin Ryan has rejected this study befopre it is even launched. I would love your support as well as the support of JREF'ers but know that Kevin Ryan does NOT support this. Some of you who have gotten to know me will nevertheless decide that finding out the truth is more important than what a 9/11 Truth leader says. To you I will say thank you, you deserve the 9/11 Truth moniker in the best sense of the word.


Kevin Ryan KNOWS theres no therm*te whatsoever in his own samples and refuses to be proven that he has been untruthful, deceptive, lying charlatan, Just like everyone else in this truth bowel movement. There you have it. The jig is up! Their truth movement ends here. Same reason Jones refused to send his samples to an independent lab. Same reason they sent their pseudoscience "paper" to a vanity publishing mill. Its a cold three dog night for the troll movement.

:dl: :dl: :dl:
 
Last edited:
One would think that Kevin Ryan would be one of the first people to WANT an independent analysis of his work. I mean, I have done tests for my fire science research, and ALWAYS go to another body for confirmation of any findings. If my findings don't match theirs pretty closely (with about 2% of accuracy) I redo any experiments, and start with a fresh sheet of paper.

Dr. Millette's integrity is above reproach. I've used his lab in arson cases where a death occurred, and needed results quicker than the FDLE or FBI labs could provide. I've gotten results that disproved my findings and evidence. So, I know he is not biased whatsoever.

Kevin Ryan isn't suited to even shine Dr. Millette's boots, or cut his lawn.
 
Surprise, surprise, surprise.

Thanks for doing the leg work anyway. Perhaps some of the few remaining Truthers will see this excuse for what it is, at least.

Enjoy the holidays.
 
This to ensure that no honest and reasonable truther can hand-wave the provenance of the chips Jim goes on to examine - that they are in fact the same material that Harrit e.al. declared to be thermitic.

I'm not convinced there are any.

Kevin Ryan isn't suited to even shine Dr. Millette's boots, or cut water his lawn.

Fixed that. ;)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom