On Again Off Again Airfones

And you have added zip with that post. Explain how the American Airlines annotate their changes in their manuals? If you can not you have failed to add to the thread as usual. Why are all truthers challenged with research and facts?

This is funny stuff, blind led by the blind and spewing junk. How truthy.

Are you referring to James or me? It was James who questioned the guy's motive which adds nothing. I simply provided plausible answers.

Do you still believe jetfuelA changed colors?;)
TAM
so I am sure there were documents indicating what was installed and not installed on the two 9/11 flights in question....I am not an expert, but I would imagine each airplane had some sort of equipment list...don't wanna remove something, even an airfone, without ticking it off on a list for other important people to see...track down those docs and you have your answer.

So is this Chad Hilder fellow on the record as saying that no 757's had airfones on 9/11/2001. If so, what title does he hold at AA?

The following email content was confirmed by the authors.

Dear Mr. XXXXXXXX:

Thank you for contacting Customer Relations. I am pleased to have the opportunity to assist you.

That is correct we do not have phones on our Boeing 757. The passengers on flight 77 used their own personal cellular phones to make out calls during the terrorist attack.

However, the pilots are able to stay in constant contact with the Air Traffic Control tower.

Mr. XXXXXXXX, I hope this information is helpful. It is a privilege to serve you. This is an "outgoing only" email address. If you 'reply' to this message by simply selecting the reply button, we will not receive your additional comments. Please assist us in providing you with a timely response to any feedback you have for us by always sending us your email messages via AA.com at http://www.aa.com/customerrelations.
Sincerely,
Chad Kinder
Customer Relations
American Airlines

Those work order documents are precisely what the article refers to as conclusive confirmation.
DRG-We believe, incidentally, that the statement by the 757 AMM that the phone system was “deactivated” and the statement by USA Today that the phones were “ripped out” refer to two different processes, so that within AA’s records there would be a work order for the phones to be physically removed from the 757 fleet at some point between the time at which they were deactivated, perhaps late in 2000, and September 11, 2001. Locating such a work order would provide the final confirmation of the claim that Flight 77 had no onboard phones.

So conclusive proof? Not really. Is it leaning in that direction, sure appears that way.
 
Kudos for the admission.

Billdave2 is quite correct.

I don't think you understood what we are talking about. I am saying that the Jan 28, 2007 at the top is the revision of the document, meaning that it has been changed recently.

Unless you are admitting that you are wrong and this is obviously not evidence.
 
Because his reply only states that effective the date of his reply there were no phones on the 757's. The email reply does not indicate anything about the airfone status on 9/11.

Lyte, watch your tone, or I'll be forced to report every single infraction you make on this site.

TAM:)
 
Listen....we have obtained this evidence from a licensed A&P mechanic employee within American Airlines.

He remembers clearly the phones with inoperable placards and was pissed he had to keep replacing the phones during C Checks (IIRC it was C Checks)... because the phones didnt even work and he felt it was double the work for nothing.. they should have kept the phones out since they weren't even operative he thought. But AA told their mechanics to put them back in even though they were deactivated. you cant leave a hole in the back of a seat.

Fascinating. Knowing that he had evidence that 9/11 was an inside job was NOT enough motivation for him to reveal the document. However, being pissed off that he had to put inoperative phones back into airplanes was.
 
And actually, given I believe the official story on this matter, I do not have to do any research.

If you wish to be a true, honest, and fair researcher, however, to prove this piece of evidence as true and valid, versus incorrect, you could do as I have suggested.

TAM:)
 
While I personally know the source at AA credit goes to PFT and DRG for working with him to obtain the document and release the info.

I will fully admit that I was not a part of the process.

I trust the source and the info so I ran with it here when I saw the story broke this morning.

I already told you that the mechanic said he was frustrated because they had to put inoperable phones back in so they wouldn't leave a hole in the seat. So the "removing" the phones does not indicate how inoperable phones were put back in.


Again......we see this as EVIDENCE.

If proven incorrect so be it.

So get your evidence to counter this evidence our you have nothing.

I thought you were part of the "Citizens Investigation Team"? Why have you come here to ask to be debunked? Why are you asking for counter-evidence?

Where's the rest of the section regarding the airfones?
Have you contacted anyone from AA?

How come the folks here have to tell you how to do your job?
 
Kudos for the admission.

Billdave2 is quite correct.



Uhhh, I don't think you quite understand. Noone here is arguing that the phones were never deactivated/removed - the question is when. The manual was very likely revised in Jan 2007, which means it's not clear when the system was removed from the 757 fleet; all we know is that they were removed as of the revision date.

What you need is:

Engineering Authorization(EA)/ Engineering Order(EO) documents. EO/EA compliance reports saying when individual aircraft (ship 644) were complete, or even logbook history documents. All of the above should be available to your source.
 
Looking at it again I am even more convinced that the date at the bottom was originally 1/28/2007. The 1 in the 2001 is either smudged or a differint font than the 1 at the front of the date. This would make sense if the system is set to print the rev date automatically at the bottom of everypage to match the header on page one. I think the probablity that he two dates were both January 28 is astronomical.


Good catch!!!
 
Because his reply only states that effective the date of his reply there were no phones on the 757's. The email reply does not indicate anything about the airfone status on 9/11.

Lyte, watch your tone, or I'll be forced to report every single infraction you make on this site.

TAM:)

Do you ever do any research of your own?

He is in "Customer Relations".

Why don't you try contacting him?
 
Uhhh, I don't think you quite understand. Noone here is arguing that the phones were never deactivated/removed - the question is when. The manual was very likely revised in Jan 2007, which means it's not clear when the system was removed from the 757 fleet; all we know is that they were removed as of the revision date.

What you need is:

Engineering Authorization(EA)/ Engineering Order(EO) documents. EO/EA compliance reports saying when individual aircraft (ship 644) were complete, or even logbook history documents. All of the above should be available to your source.

exactly...

To recap...

What the truthers have....

1. An anonymous unverified (to us at least) page out of a 2001 Boeing 757 maintenance manual, that was revised in 2007.
2. an email response from a Chad Kinder, with PR in AA, who states, that as of the date of his reply (not given here on this thread) there are no airfones on the AA 757's

Anything else? Am I missing anything?

TAM:)
 
Looking at it again I am even more convinced that the date at the bottom was originally 1/28/2007. The 1 in the 2001 is either smudged or a differint font than the 1 at the front of the date. This would make sense if the system is set to print the rev date automatically at the bottom of everypage to match the header on page one.

The '1' in '2001' is certainly shorter than the '1' in '01'. It also is thicker.
 
Last edited:
Do you ever do any research of your own?

He is in "Customer Relations".

Why don't you try contacting him?

So is acting like a child your last resort, or can we expect even worse behaviour than this from you?

TAM:)
 
I thought you were part of the "Citizens Investigation Team"? Why have you come here to ask to be debunked? Why are you asking for counter-evidence?

Where's the rest of the section regarding the airfones?
Have you contacted anyone from AA?

How come the folks here have to tell you how to do your job?

This is evidence that was obtained by an organization we support with a little help from us.

I believe it is significant.

You can choose not to but we have provided evidence and you have not.
 
I have asked you a question four times now, you now not answered. The question required a simple yes/no answer. It is in response to this post, you hate pseudo-sceptics and you people who simply say everything is fake.

All you can do is cry IT'S FAKE!

Just like all you can say about the citgo witnesses are THEY HALLUCINATED!

Get out there, make some phone calls, do some research and back up your claims with evidence.

Pseudo-skeptics bug me.

Are you claiming the phone calls from the victims to their families were not real yes or no?

Phone calls, fake or real ?
 
The document also states that any maintenance to the system would need to be done by Claircom employees and not AA employees. If the system was rendered inactive and the phones themselves did not work...why would any maintenance be needed. Perhaps this document outlines the deactivation of one system and the installation of another one perhaps?
 
exactly...

To recap...

What the truthers have....

1. An anonymous unverified (to us at least) page out of a 2001 Boeing 757 maintenance manual, that was revised in 2007.
2. an email response from a Chad Kinder, with PR in AA, who states, that as of the date of his reply (not given here on this thread) there are no airfones on the AA 757's

Anything else? Am I missing anything?
TAM:)
The follow up call: After reading the two letters to Kinder, RB asked if he had indeed written the reply. Kinder answered that he could not specifically recall having written it---he writes so many letters, he explained, and this one would have been written over a year earlier. But, he added: “That sounds like an accurate statement.” Kinder indicated, in other words, that it was a letter he might well have written, because what it said---that AA 757s in 2001 did not have onboard phones, so the passengers on AA 77 had to use cell phones---was, to the best of his present knowledge, accurate.

Sorry, the date of the email exchange was February 17, 2006.
I hope this doesn't hamper any follow up investigation that might take place.;)
 
The '1' in '2001' is certainly shorter than the '1' in '01'. It also is thicker.

though I would love to call fake on this, and there is a good chance it is, I am sure one must look at the original form, not the scanned image, to determine if any fakery to the original had occured.

Of course, without the original proven to be authentic, all we have is a scanned image that we are to TRUST hasnt been altered in photoshop etc...

TAM:)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom