On Again Off Again Airfones

Why do you come to JREF? What do you hope to accomplish here, at this board? The outsider observer could suppose that you are engaging in a game of virtual one-upmanship instead of focusing on real, important issues in the REAL world.


Well, indeed. I suspect it’s partly because he’s humiliated himself on this forum so many times before. Combine that with the fact that, at the moment, he’s got some yet-to-be-debunked evidence, and he just can’t resist gloating. It’ll probably be a very different story this time next week, so he might as well make the most of it.
 
Seems to me, rather than take the word of an anonymous mechanic, that one could take this accusation, or "evidence" and bring it to American Airlines. I am sure they would provide a response/answer to it.

I wonder how long it will take for that to happen...

TAM:)

I think they have as the email and follow up call to Mr. Kinder shows.
 
There are a number of scenarios that could explain the cell phone call reports.

I do not have specific evidence in this regard so I will let you speculate on your own the various ways outside of the official story that these reports could come to existence.

Are you claiming the phone calls from the victims to their families were not real?

Yes or no.
 
Here's what I gather from what I've read:

1. In an article published September 30, 2002 titled "What ever happened to Seat-Back phones", there were two types of phones. One was Claircom, a division of AT&T and the other was Airfone by Verizon. It seems that the Airfone's were on AA planes from TWA.

http://www.businessweek.com/magazine/content/02_39/c3801015.htm

2. Here's another article that discusses Claircom telling Delta that it will discontinue service as of June 14th, 2002. 12 of Delta's 757s were affected among other planes. It also stated that Delta's 403 other domestic flights have Airfone's, which service will continue to be provided. Also, below the article, is some forum comments. One of which is "On an AA flight I noticed all the phones had stickers stating their service ended March 22, 2002."

http://www.flyertalk.com/forum/showthread.php?t=54695

My question is, how do we know that the 757 in question wasn't a TWA plane that had an Airfone, which sounds like they were still operable. The document provided talks only of Claircom.
 
Last edited:
I don't know and have never claimed to.

Perhaps some were made before or after the plane swap.

"After the plane swap?"

Please elaborate. I don't think we've had the privilege of hearing your complete theory.
 
Do you have a family, James? He may. Perhaps job security, James, to feed himself and his family. Maybe passing along documents from AA aircraft manuals is a violation of company policy. Maybe he doesn't want any public spotlight shinning on him. Perhaps he doesn't want the FBI investigating him?
His motive doesn't change the fact, James.
And you have added zip with that post. Explain how the American Airlines annotate their changes in their manuals? If you can not you have failed to add to the thread as usual. Why are all truthers challenged with research and facts?

This is funny stuff, blind led by the blind and spewing junk. How truthy.
 
Sorry I don't think I was very clear in my first post. I am a ASQ Certfied Quality Engineer my profession and used to work in the aerospace industry. I was trying to say that the date at the top under "Software Release:" was probably the revision number for the document and that the redacted area next to the term "Software Release:" is probably the actual software release number. It would make more sense as a standard format for a controled document.


Ahh, gotcha. That may be the case. I have to take these manual system computer training modules every year and I usually sleep or daydream through them(seriously, watching paint dry is more exciting).

It could be very likely that the REV 62 Jan 28/2007 is the date the manual was revised and the date on the bottom could be the original manual publication date..
 
Seems to me, rather than take the word of an anonymous mechanic, that one could take this accusation, or "evidence" and bring it to American Airlines. I am sure they would provide a response/answer to it.

I wonder how long it will take for that to happen...

TAM:)

Anyone from here written to AA yet?

/S
 
A couple of (perhaps off-topic) technical questions:
1) What does "Pace" mean on the document, as in "Pace: 1" (just above the document's date)?
2) What kind of printer do they use to print out these documents so that the two 0's in both 2001 and 2007 are different sizes?
 
My question is, how do we know that the 757 in question wasn't a TWA plane that had an Airfone, which sounds like they were still operable. The document provided talks only of Claircom.


The ex-TWA AA 757s had P&W 2000 series engines, besides, didn't the merger take place after 2001?:confused:
 
Lyte will never do that. Lyte will never question his claims. He is more than happy with one single page of a manual. More of this manual might clear things up. A call to AA might clear things up. Lyte won't seek out either.

He completely avoids anything and everything that contradicts his fairytale. Just look at the beginning of this thread. He claimed the phones weren't removed, but the second sentence of the page that he posted, contradicts him. It's apparent that Lyte read the 1st sentence of this page and stopped right there. He has no need for additional information, or a phone call; he's got all he needs.

While I personally know the source at AA credit goes to PFT and DRG for working with him to obtain the document and release the info.

I will fully admit that I was not a part of the process.

I trust the source and the info so I ran with it here when I saw the story broke this morning.

I already told you that the mechanic said he was frustrated because they had to put inoperable phones back in so they wouldn't leave a hole in the seat. So the "removing" the phones does not indicate how inoperable phones were put back in.


Again......we see this as EVIDENCE.

If proven incorrect so be it.

So get your evidence to counter this evidence our you have nothing.
 
so I am sure there were documents indicating what was installed and not installed on the two 9/11 flights in question....I am not an expert, but I would imagine each airplane had some sort of equipment list...don't wanna remove something, even an airfone, without ticking it off on a list for other important people to see...track down those docs and you have your answer.

So is this Chad Hilder fellow on the record as saying that no 757's had airfones on 9/11/2001. If so, what title does he hold at AA?

TAM:)
 
Ahh, gotcha. That may be the case. I have to take these manual system computer training modules every year and I usually sleep or daydream through them(seriously, watching paint dry is more exciting).

It could be very likely that the REV 62 Jan 28/2007 is the date the manual was revised and the date on the bottom could be the original manual publication date..

Kudos for the admission.

Billdave2 is quite correct.
 
Again......we see this as EVIDENCE.

If proven incorrect so be it.

So get your evidence to counter this evidence our you have nothing.

Why? If we provide a statement from AA, you will call foul...shills.

If we provide a copy of the check list for the plane's equipment, from the FBI, who probably have it, you will cry foul...shills.

So what difference does it make...we call your evidence fake, you call our evidence fake...

TAM:)
 
A couple of (perhaps off-topic) technical questions:
1) What does "Pace" mean on the document, as in "Pace: 1" (just above the document's date)?
2) What kind of printer do they use to print out these documents so that the two 0's in both 2001 and 2007 are different sizes?


That says Page 1

;)
 
Ahh, gotcha. That may be the case. I have to take these manual system computer training modules every year and I usually sleep or daydream through them(seriously, watching paint dry is more exciting).

It could be very likely that the REV 62 Jan 28/2007 is the date the manual was revised and the date on the bottom could be the original manual publication date..

Looking at it again I am even more convinced that the date at the bottom was originally 1/28/2007. The 1 in the 2001 is either smudged or a differint font than the 1 at the front of the date. This would make sense if the system is set to print the rev date automatically at the bottom of everypage to match the header on page one. I think the probablity that he two dates were both January 28 is astronomical.
 
so I am sure there were documents indicating what was installed and not installed on the two 9/11 flights in question....I am not an expert, but I would imagine each airplane had some sort of equipment list...don't wanna remove something, even an airfone, without ticking it off on a list for other important people to see...track down those docs and you have your answer.

So is this Chad Hilder fellow on the record as saying that no 757's had airfones on 9/11/2001. If so, what title does he hold at AA?

TAM:)

Do you ever do any research of your own?

He is in "Customer Relations".

Why don't you try contacting him?
 
Looking at it again I am even more convinced that the date at the bottom was originally 1/28/2007. The 1 in the 2001 is either smudged or a differint font than the 1 at the front of the date. This would make sense if the system is set to print the rev date automatically at the bottom of everypage to match the header on page one. I think the probablity that he two dates were both January 28 is astronomical.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/member.php?u=17572Billdave2 is no longer correct.

The chances are 1 out of 365.

Hardly "astronomical".
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom